Chapter 43

	Let such pure hate still underprop
	Our love …
	HENRY THOREAU

Mary was still hoarse from shouting at Mrs. Bewley. She cleared her throat. “Why don’t we sort them for her?” she said. She was watching Patrolman Vine and Sergeant Ordway turn over mountains of trash, spreading them out neatly on the floor of the firing range on six of Isabelle Flower’s clean white sheets. “Maybe she’d like all the Choko-wrappers in one bag and all the popsicle sticks in another.”

“No,” said Homer. “She may have some profound system of classification all her own. Let them alone. Mrs. Bewley knows best.”

It took them two hours to go through the entire collection. Some of the pieces were sticky and had to be soaked apart. Luther Ordway picked up the last of these from a towel in the darkroom and brought it out into the light to look at it. He was whistling, but then he stopped whistling, and read it through again. Then he brought it to Chief Flower. Jimmy read it a couple of times, looking sober and brought it over to Homer’s desk.

“Oh, good,” said Mary. “Did you find something else?”

Jimmy glanced at her, looking troubled, then shifted his glance away. Homer read the scrap of paper through twice, then slowly lifted his small sharp eyes to look at her.

“Well, what is it?” said Mary. She walked around behind him and he held the piece of wrinkled paper so that she could see. It was a short typewritten note.

Dearest Philip,

I have something to tell you that I hope will make you happy. Can you meet me at Nicholson’s Barn between 12:30 and 1:30? Please don’t say anything to anyone—and destroy this.

It was signed in ink. The signature had run, but it had a homely look, and it jumped out at Mary from the page. It was her own.

Homer looked up at her. His face was still with an arctic calm, his eyes buckets of nails. Mary couldn’t speak. She didn’t say anything at all. She stared at the signature. That was her M, her closed A and careless R, and her Y that was just a bump and a straight line without any loop.

Then Jimmy snatched the paper suddenly. “I’m going to tear it up,” he said.

“What do you want to do,” said Homer, “lose your badge? That’s evidence.”

Jimmy glared at him. “It don’t mean anything and you know it.”

“Oh, but it does,” said Homer. He stood up and reached out, gripping Jimmy’s wrist. He squeezed the wrist in his large hand until Jimmy’s fingers went limp and dropped the paper. “Thank you,” said Homer. He picked it up. “This note calls Philip away from the place where he was surrounded by witnesses who could furnish him with an alibi for the time of the murder, to a lonely spot where no one would see him coming or going. He could walk to the barn from the Gun Club right across a dry field.” Homer looked at Mary coldly. “Did you meet him there?”

Mary dumbly shook her head.

Homer started walking around the room. “Philip Goss received this note some time during the morning of the murder. Expecting a declaration of love he walked eagerly across the field to the barn, arriving around 12:30. Impatiently he waited there for Mary for a full hour, maybe longer, before giving up. Then he tossed the note aside in disgust, returned to the Rod and Gun Club and started to drink himself under the table. Afterwards, when asked about his whereabouts, Philip was gallant. He refused to name the reason he was missing, for fear of getting into trouble the girl he loved. A gentleman of the old school.”

“That’s more than you are, I see,” said Jimmy, his voice rising. “Listen here, Homer Kelly, if you say a word, just one word, that harms a hair on the head of my Mary, I’ll …”

Homer interrupted roughly. “Oh, so she’s your Mary now, is she?” Jimmy made an angry lunge for the piece of paper, but Homer snatched it away and held it behind his back. He looked at Mary and spoke softly. “Split the lark, and you’ll find the music. Mary, did you write this?”

Mary hugged her arms and shivered. She found herself noticing the way Homer’s head was arranged on his neck, the way his neck grew out of his collar. His head was different from the bald knob that rested on Jimmy’s shoulders like a friendly turnip. It was erect like a dog’s, furry and cocked and alert. Cocked. Cocked like a gun. “No,” she said. “I don’t think I did. I mean, of course I didn’t. I know I didn’t.”

Homer blinked. He lowered his eyes to her desk and touched her typewriter. “We can find out what machine it was typed on, probably. I’ll bet it was Charley’s. And anybody could have traced your signature. Charley had letters from you?”

Then he wasn’t—it was all right. Mary nodded without speaking.

Homer glanced at the note again. “Elite type. Small portable, most likely. Is that what yours is? I mean the one you use at home?” Mary nodded again, and looked at the piece of paper. Even with its soaking it looked grubby, and she was reminded of the dirty typed sheets of plagiarized scholarship turned out by Roland Granville-Galsworthy.

“Jimmy,” said Homer, “have you got some typewriter experts up your sleeve?”

Jimmy was still glowering. He shook himself and spoke grudgingly. “We’ll look into it.”

Mary took Jimmy’s phone call in her library office. “Well,” said Jimmy, “his lordship had to admit that it couldn’t have been your typewriter that wrote that note. The expert identified it as Charley’s, all right. The A tended to skip, the type needed cleaning, the E was tipped off-axis to the right, and so on and so on. But of course the Great Kelly hastened to add that you or anybody else could have used Charley’s typewriter. But what this really amounts to is one more little piece of evidence that doesn’t do Charley Goss any good.”

“But why would Charley forge a note from me to Philip?”

“It’s like Homer said. To get Philip away from witnesses, to take away from him the alibi he would have had for the time of the murder.”

“But if Charley was planning to kill his father and pin the murder on Philip, why did he wear the Sam Prescott outfit and do it in a public place?”

“Just so that you would ask that very question.”

“Oh. Well, did you ask Charley about it?”

“Oh, he denied it. Categorically. Then we talked to Philip, and he admitted receiving the note. He said he found it on his pillow before the parade. Said it got him all excited. (You sure have a powerful effect on us men.) But then he got very angry when you didn’t show up. He didn’t remember dropping the note, but he supposes he probably did. And it could have blown into the road where Mrs. B. could have found it. And, say, we found the letter that your signature was traced from. It was one of the letters you wrote to Charley from Amherst, that summer when you were working on that female poet. What’s her name?”

“Emily Dickinson. What did my letter say?”

“Oh, you needn’t worry. It sure wasn’t any smoldering billy doo, it didn’t even smell pretty. Say, Mary, listen here, were those boys jealous of each other over you?”

“I told you,” said Mary. “I turned them down, both of them, a year ago. They weren’t really serious about me any more. I just came in handy to take out.”

“Is that so? Did they have any other girl friends?”

“Well, no, not that I know of.”

“Do you think they still hoped to win you over, either of them?”

“Oh, maybe, but I did everything I could to discourage it.”

“Well, I just wonder if one of them could have been all worked up with jealousy on your account, and tried to eliminate the opposition by getting it accused of murder.”

“Oh, no, no, I’m sure not.” That was absurd. Mary hung up and turned away from the telephone, looking troubled. She folded her arms on the sash of the window and stared out at the rain that had been coming down obstinately for a week now. But she didn’t see the lowering sky and the sodden leaves. She was aware only of a heavy feeling of increasing guilt—the more she took part in the investigation of Ernest Goss’s murder, the more deeply entangled in suspicion Charley became. Whether you loved someone or not, if they loved you, you had a certain responsibility not to hurt …

Alice Herpitude was looking at her, questioning her, picking at her sleeve. Mary had to say it out loud, and admit it to herself as well as to Alice. “Things look pretty bad for Charley Goss.”

Then Miss Herpitude did an odd thing. She started trembling all over. Her pale old lips looked thin and tight. “Are you sure?” she said. “Do you think they’ll accuse him of—of—?”

“I just don’t know,” said Mary.