An hour before sunset and the commencement of the Jewish Sabbath, Phasael and Hyrcanus walked out of the citadel. They were immediately arrested and taken before Prince Antigonus. Phasael offered to open the gates of the citadel at sunset next day, which marked the Sabbath’s end. In exchange he asked immunity for his mercenary soldiers and for the lives of the women and children in his party. He made no bargain for the lives of the others. Believing my cavalry had abandoned the citadel, Prince Antigonus had no reason to doubt Phasael’s sincerity. Nor could he see any advantage in refusing the offer. So the sun set, and the Sabbath began with the promise of a twenty-four-hour truce.
Since the departure of my cavalry Herod had rearranged his sentries. They stood along the citadel ramparts close to towers and pillars. They did not move either at night or during the day. Once darkness fell over the city on the Sabbath eve, these sentries were replaced by uniforms stuffed with straw. They were held in place by ropes and timbers, exactly as the living sentries had stood. Herod then ordered everyone to gather in the sewers. He hoped the ruse of the sentries might last through the night.
At the third hour of the night, Herod began sending his infantry through the tunnels. These were followed by the families, the servants – including my secretary – and all the nobility. Herod and his Guard came last. The way was narrow and required the party to proceed in single file. The first ones out of the tunnel waited nearly an hour for the last. They could not be seen from the city walls, the night was pitch black, but neither could they see where they stepped.
I met Herod’s party in the fourth hour of the night, just as the last of his party escaped the sewers. I brought with me the wagons, carts, litters, and carriages my scouting parties had been able to collect. The vehicles had seemed quite satisfactory on the roads, but on uneven ground they creaked and groaned incessantly. Nor were there enough for those who needed to ride. The ground was stony and uneven and great numbers went down as they tried to walk. After that they were unable to continue without assistance. Herod ordered the men in his Guard to help those who could no longer walk. But the cost was time. It took more than an hour to cross the plain.
Young mothers held the mouths of the youngest children. They whispered and prayed: ‘Be good, child. Be still; on your life, be still!’ Sensing the fear in everyone around them, some of the very youngest cried out in terror. These shrieks were soon muffled, but no one knew if they had been heard in the city. If riders came to investigate, all would be lost.
With only his infantry to command, Herod might have counted his escape complete once safely beyond the city walls. Fighting men could have run thirty miles before dawn. With so many elderly and children in his train, his work was only beginning.
A child shrieked and then fought the hand that muffled the cry. A wagon wheel hit a stone with an awful crack. Horse hooves clapped against the hardpan. And every time some awful sound erupted we all turned into cowards. I cannot count the times I looked at the city wall. I could see nothing beyond the dark silhouettes of its towers cutting into the night sky, but for all that I could not stop myself looking back.
Having no road, the carts and wagons actually slowed our progress. And the longer we went the more people needed them. At some point an axle broke on the biggest wagon, for it was terribly overloaded. In the face of such disaster any sensible commander would have abandoned his plan. Almost three hours after the escape we had yet to travel three miles. Herod’s resolve, however, never wavered. In this party he had his wife and son and mother and sister. With assorted nephews and nieces, old friends of his father, their wives and children and even their grandchildren, he could not bear to abandon the civilians, even if it cost him his own life.
Phasael was the wiser of the two brothers. He ought surely to have made the better king, for he was a creature of court life and knew to kill the weakest when necessary; but only Herod could have forced his will on us that night and by doing so saved everyone, from the most ancient to the very youngest.
When we could no longer carry the injured or fit them all on the wagons, I ordered our cavalry to let those who needed to ride take their horses. This meant most of my men walked at the side of their animals for the sake of one whose strength had given out. I meant to stay mounted so that I might supervise the column with Herod, but I soon discovered a young woman limping and in obvious pain. As it happened this was Salome, Herod’s sister, though I did not realise it until she was atop Hannibal and we had begun talking.
Salome was my age, a decade younger than Herod, and naturally already married, though yet without children. I expect Salome thought we had only a few hours more to live; I know I did. This escape was moving too slowly for us to have any hope of getting clear of Jerusalem. Knowing our lives had likely come to an end, we spoke of anything but that. I would have thought I had nothing in common with this girl from the orient, but Salome was quite well travelled and thoroughly acquainted with a number of the great cities I had seen. So we talked about architecture, of all things. Throughout our exchange Salome betrayed no fear of what might come next, though as a young woman of high station she had to know what happens to women before they are killed. ‘I do not care for the gigantic proportions of it,’ she said, ‘but there is no temple in all the world as perfectly made as the one dedicated to Serapis in Alexandria.’
‘Not even in Ephesus?’ I asked. I did not like the simple lines and massive stones of the temple dedicated to Serapis, but I had been overawed by the Temple of Artemis at Ephesus.
‘There is no art in Ephesus,’ Salome answered. ‘It is all a grand mishmash of columns and porches put together over centuries. There is no order to any of it. I prefer the tiny Temple of Vesta in Rome. I know it is not the popular opinion, but a thing perfectly proportioned is far grander than a heap of stones covering acres of ground.’
Talking so earnestly about the wonders of our world, I kept recalling with a jolt of dread that I was likely going to be dead in a few hours, but before I could dwell on such matters, the young woman drew me back from my despair. It was one of those peculiar nights that makes for a lifelong friendship, for though I might not marry Salome without first submitting to circumcision, nothing at all prevented us in later years from an intimate friendship that served us both. All because of a bruised heel.
At dawn we found a road, and Herod ordered us to march at double-time. The carts and wagons rumbled more quickly. The riders, often two per horse, bumped along uncomfortably as the animals were pushed into a trot; the cavalrymen jogged beside their mounts. I sent scouts to look for the cavalry coming from Masada. I ordered others back to watch for the enemy coming from Jerusalem. We passed Bethlehem, some eight miles from Jerusalem. We needed to cover another twelve miles before we could hope for the Masada cavalry to relieve us of our party of civilians.
Of course in Bethlehem there were partisans of the rebels who would send word to Prince Antigonus that we were fleeing Jerusalem. Eight miles by road to the city on foot would give us two hours. If someone went by horseback we might see the first Parthian archers within the hour.
Three miles more passed without incident, but at that point a great many of us had begun looking to our horizons: rescue from the south, attack from the north. Herod, on horseback, moved from the front of our line to the back, calling to everyone on foot to keep pace. He feared we might need to form our defences quite suddenly. And then finally one of my scouts came from the north. The Parthians, he reported, had not yet left Jerusalem.
Herod called a halt. We ate and drank our fill, resting a full hour. Those departing from the city had been moving for over twelve hours. My cavalry and I had been travelling for eighteen. I rested like the others, but I did so in the company of my officers, that we might arrange our forces for the coming fight.
Back to our feet, sated and sore. Hard work even persuading the horses to move. Two, three, four miles slipping by.
Finally we came to the base of the hill Herod intended to use for his camp. Infantry and civilians alike began digging a trench along the edge of the plain. Behind the trench others brought stones down the mountain to build a low wall. To the back of the camp the mountain rose up steeply enough that very little was needed in the way of defensive works; our wagons and carts and carriages created enough of a barrier.
While the camp was still being fortified, my scouts returned from the road to the south. The Masada rescuers had not yet left the mountain. If they were coming they were still more than two hours away.
At that point I ordered seven hundred of my Spartan cavalry behind the crest of the mountain. The others remained at Herod’s camp. I put scouts high on the mountaintop to watch for the enemy’s approach. At their signal I came forward to see what we faced. Because it was a Sabbath, the Jewish regiments under the command of Antigonus had remained in Jerusalem. That meant we were fighting only the Parthians, a thousand cataphracts and some three or four hundred mounted archers, those same archers we had decimated at Jerusalem.
Our numbers and position gave us a slight advantage, but cataphracts are ultra-heavy cavalry, impervious to light missiles and even swords. They cover themselves and their horses with chainmail; they encase both their heads and the heads of their horses with iron masks. In our only fight against these faceless iron monsters some weeks earlier we had suffered heavy losses. Afterwards, I did everything I could to avoid engaging with them. But this time, like it or not, we had to fight them.
As per their custom, the archers came forward while the cataphracts waited a furlong behind them. My tribunes at Herod’s camp ordered our cavalry to attack the archers, two hundred Spartan lancers against twice that number of archers. We were practiced at this game and knew to use tight formations so that one rider might cover another. In that manner we chased them down, breaking our phalanxes apart as they scattered and tried to regroup at our flanks.
As soon as we began winning this fight the cataphracts came forward. On pre-arranged orders, our riders refused to engage and fell back to either side of Herod’s defensive works. With cataphracts now holding a position close to Herod’s camp, the archers returned. For Herod’s makeshift wall to provide any shelter, his infantry were obliged to stay down. As for the civilians, they found cover under the wagons and carts. For the moment no one cared about harming them. Some of the Parthian archers tried to flank our camp; most contented themselves with lofting their arrows high overhead, letting the missiles rain down on the camp. A few of Herod’s men were wounded, but most kept themselves covered with their shields.
The moment the Parthian attack commenced, I sent my forces to either side of the mountain. At the beginning we were unseen by the enemy. Once we broke from cover we formed into six long columns and pushed the horses into a gallop as we swept around the enemy and came toward the backs of the cataphracts.
Each column was comprised of one hundred twenty riders, four abreast and thirty deep. The idea, in the abstract, was to drive eight columns into the midst of the cataphracts, our six columns plus the cavalry at either wing of Herod’s line. Hitting all sides simultaneously, we hoped to break through the outer perimeter and drive toward the centre.
This was not utterly suicidal. By the concentration of force a few dozen men can soon crash through any line. It is an especially effective technique against cavalry, where animals under the stress of assault quite naturally panic and give ground. Once in the midst of the enemy, I hoped our superior quickness would neutralise the advantage of the enemy’s heavier armour. The trailing riders in each of the eight columns had orders to close down the perimeter, that we might keep the fight contained.
Before we hit the cataphracts, the archers came for us. Every man leaned close to his mount, covering himself with his shield. Because of our formation, the archers had some play at only one-in-four riders. Men and horses were hit but very few went down. An arrow scorched my thigh early in the charge. I had been intercepting another with my shield and simply did not see it coming. With a screaming curse I pulled the dart free. I saw blood seeping from the wound, but there was no spurt, which is the real danger. No matter. There was nothing to be done for it. I had either to fight or get trampled by my own men.
Foam gathered at Hannibal’s bit; the pure white froth of a racing horse covered his neck. I hugged down close and tried to ignore the searing pain in my thigh. I was in the vanguard of my column, first to crash into the enemy. The man I came against pierced my shield with his lance. The force of the impact ripped the thing from my grip. My own spear slipped under his shield as I had intended but accidentally caught the pommel of his saddle. At impact, the shaft of my spear shattered.
We passed by one another, he to receive the fury of the men in my column, I to greet another iron mask charging me. I drew one of my swords and turned Hannibal into the flank of another rider, the way ships ram into one another. As we crashed into this animal, I swung my sword down across the rider’s arm. I could not cut flesh through Parthian chainmail, but bone was still vulnerable and the rider dropped his spear.
I pulled my second sword and spun Hannibal, looking for another fight. The enemy was everywhere, but so too were those who had ridden in my column. I hooked an arm about the head of a man in a fight with one of my Spartan auxiliaries. As easily as that, I pulled him from his mount. At my own flank a rider came closing in and swung his sword at Hannibal’s neck. I parried the stroke, then turned Hannibal into him, letting Hannibal’s superior strength drive him back. As we fought, swords clashing, I heard Hannibal’s scream. He reared above the smaller horse, striking with both hooves and biting the chainmail covering the enemy’s mount.
One of my men closed behind the fellow and knocked him to the ground. I spun Hannibal about and charged another rider, ramming into the smaller horse. The other horse cried out and shied away, leaving its rider struggling to keep his seat. I had no chance to grab this rider’s head, so I hacked at his wrist instead. His sword dropped, and I spun Hannibal on his haunches, looking for the next fight.
We lunged into another rider but were also hit by a man coming behind us. Hannibal gave another scream of rage and kicked at the animal with both back legs. The enemy’s mount shied from this attack and I was saved from a sword swung at my head.
There was no line, no order to any of it; the fight was everywhere. A melee of swords and shields. Horses rammed into one another, reared up or gave vicious kicks, fighting like the men on their backs, and for a long time it seemed that neither side could gain an advantage.
Then suddenly we saw Herod’s infantry wade into the fight. After that, melee turned to massacre.
The men on the ground came in pairs. One carried a shield and sword; the other a sword and dagger. These weapons slipped under the chainmail skirts of the Parthian mounts. Once a horse went down, the rider generally fell to the ground too. If by chance he landed on his feet, Herod’s infantry tackled him. In any event, after he was on his back, killing him as he struggled to get up was as simple as giving his head a hard kick or a quick turn.
Our cavalry continued to engage the enemy, knocking them from their horses if possible, but Herod’s infantry did most of the killing. I was turning, looking for another fight, when a wounded horse came backing away from a sword thrust and bowled broadside into Hannibal. Both animals went down with a scream of pain, but I was able to step free.
I was naturally worried for Hannibal but had no time to look for him. A Parthian rider came over me the moment I touched earth, swinging his long sword down toward my head. I parried the blow and then took his leg before he could swing at me a second time. Turning my back to his horse I pulled him from his saddle and down he crashed, nothing more than a heap of steel.
I kicked his head, breaking his neck, but when I turned from him, I saw another rider coming for me at a gallop. His sword was lifted, but he seemed determined to run me over. Caught between fights at either side, I had no chance to evade his attack. A stride before he struck me one of my own men collided with his mount. Both animals tumbled, but the Parthian himself came hurdling over the neck of his horse.
He struck me with his shield as he landed and sent me reeling back. I tripped over the legs of a corpse and went down. Sword lifted for a killing blow, the Parthian stepped over me. A horse came in behind him, the rider leaving his saddle and tackling my assailant. Only as the two men hit the ground did I recognise Herod.
Herod took the iron mask of the Parthian into the crook of his arm and gave it a hard twist. He then took my hand and pulled me to my feet. We turned now as an infantry team, playing out the remainder of the fight from the ground.
Plunge a blade into a horse’s belly or break its leg with a slashing wound. Catch hold of an iron man’s ankle. Pull and turn it. Get them on the ground and they were helpless: slow to rise, half blind, staggering like drunks.
The dust was so thick we were fighting shapes not colours. Everywhere came the shouts of men, the grunts and screams of horses colliding, the strident song of steel. And then suddenly our cavalry from Masada arrived. With fresh forces coming into the fray against them, the cataphracts abandoned the fight and sought only to break free of our circle. And breaking free, they raced back the way they had come, along with their archers. We let them go with only the Masada riders giving chase.
Looking about, I saw some five hundred horses had been brought down. Almost all of them still struggled. Of the cataphracts left behind, all were quiet, every man with a broken neck. I limped out of the centre of the fight, sore and worn out, but anxious to know how the battle had gone at the perimeter. My cavalry had taken the worst of it there. They had been the only targets the archers could shoot at. Most of the men in that position were wounded; some forty were dead or dying.
I found Hannibal standing off in the distance. I checked him for wounds, but he was fine, only very close to exhaustion, like every man and horse under that mountain. I led him back into Herod’s camp and passed him to the care of my secretary, who had waited out the fight with the civilians. Only then did I seek medical treatment.