EXHIBIT I

Text messages between Sara Donoghue and Becca Donoghue

Sara | Becca

7/6/16

I know you aren’t there, but I’m going to pretend you’re going to read these someday.

I miss you. We all miss you.

7/28/16

Where did you go? Did you mean to leave? Why didn’t you take me?

Are you alive? Are you hurt?

I love you.

8/9/16

I’ve been having these dreams.

You’re in them sometimes.

We’re walking somewhere. On a road. An old footpath. We’re in the woods.

Except I’m not me, and you’re not you.

9/2/16

More dreams. There’s a girl in them.

9/5/16

It’s Lucy Gallows. The girl I dream about on the road.

Ridiculous, right? Getting obsessed with old ghost stories.

Except it doesn’t feel ridiculous. It feels real.

11/7/16

Tttt[]ttt[]

Becca?

Ahcr.p-apsrchusrchu[][]

[Photo: Blurred, dark. Barely distinguishable as a road.]

[Photo: The same road. Clearer. A figure, shadowed. Female.]

Becca?

11/9/16

Lucy?