EXHIBIT S

Emails recovered from the drafts folder of Rebecca Donoghue

To: Sara Donoghue

From: Rebecca Donoghue

Subject: (none)

Help I

To: Sara Donoghue

From: Rebecca Donoghue

Subject: (none)

i need help i

To: Sara Donoghue

From: Rebecca Donoghue

Subject: gone

She’s gone, but she’s not gone. Only for a few minutes, maybe. I can already feel her trying to take control again. It’s

To: Sara Donoghue

From: Rebecca Donoghue

Subject: wake

Lucy did something to me only she’s not Lucy at all and now I keep waking up and it’s another day and I’m in another place and I don’t understand what happened.

To: Sara Donoghue

From: Rebecca Donoghue

Subject: listen

A moment ago I was with you and I tried to tell you something was wrong, but I think she messed with you too. She spent so long whispering to me it was like she could just step inside me and she already owned me but I think she couldn’t control you and I think that’s why she left. Why she picked me instead. I think she had to do something to you to make you forget instead. But you need to remember.

What happened to Anthony? What did I do?

To: Sara Donoghue

From: Rebecca Donoghue

Subject: Mel

Mel called and I didn’t understand what she was talking about. But I sent that man an email. Ashford? I told him I needed help, but I don’t know if I made any sense. I sent him a bunch of photos. That was easier than writing. They were already on the computer. I hope he

To: Sara Donoghue

From: Rebecca Donoghue

Subject: (none)

I haven’t sent any of these why can’t I send them I can’t even make myself push the mouse over

To: Sara Donoghue

From: Rebecca Donoghue

Subject: (none)

I’m waking up less and less

To: Sara Donoghue

From: Rebecca Donoghue

Subject: (none)

I love you.

To: Sara Donoghue

From: Rebecca Donoghue

Subject: goodbye

[no message text]