APPENDIX
APPLICATION OF BAYES’S RULE

Bayes’s rule can be expressed as follows:

P(A | B) =

P(B | A) x P(A)

P(B)

For the current problem, let’s use the notation that G refers to the prior probability that the suspect is guilty (before we know anything about the lab report) and E refers to the evidence of a blood match. We want to know P(G|E). Substituting in the above, we put in G for A and E for B to obtain:

P(G | E) =

(P(E | G)×P(G))

(P(E))

To compute Bayes’s rule and solve for P(G | E), it may be helpful to use a table. The values here are the same as those used in the fourfold table here.

COMPUTATION OF BAYES’S RULE

Hypothesis (H)

(1)

Prior Probability

P(G)

(2)

Evidence Probability

P(E | G)

(3)

Product

(4) = (2)(3)

Posterior Probabilities

P(G | E)

(6) = (4)/Sum

Guilty

.02

.85

.017 

.104

Innocent

.98

.15

.147 

.896

Sum = .164 

= P(D)

Then, rounding, P(Guilty | Evidence ) = .10
P(Innocent | Evidence) = .90