“This is your plan?" said Quincy. "It's a joke."
"There's more to it," said Hannahlee. "You'll have to trust me."
"I lust after you," said Quincy, "but I don't know if I frust you."
While the two of them talked in the front seat of the Hummer rent-a-car, Dunne listened from the back...and watched the bathroom door of the gas station in Crockett, Texas. War had gone through it two minutes ago, giving his prisoners a rare chance to talk without him hearing every word.
Not that they had much time. After all, it was only a bathroom break.
"What's the good of getting to New Justice, if War just blows it up?" said Quincy. "Including Cyrus Gowdy, if he's there?"
Hannahlee sighed. "The bomb might not even be real."
"The only way we can know for sure is if he tries to blow us up," said Quincy. "Great fidea!"
"I still think we can bring him around," said Hannahlee. "Make him realize we're not the enemy."
"You really think you're fooling him?" Quincy shook his head. "Are you sure you're not the crazy one?"
"I think I'm getting under his skin," said Hannahlee. "I'm working on it."
"You think Scott Savage got under his skin?" Quincy ticked off names on his fingers. "Or Luanne Diego? Or Baine Sherwood? You really want to be Number Four on the call sheet?"
Hannahlee jabbed a finger at the map of Texas and New Mexico unfolded on the dashboard. "This is our only alternative right now. Head for New Justice."
"Wrong," said Quincy. "Here's an alternative. We trap him in the bathroom and amscray. Or how about we just kill him? It's three against one."
Dunne, who was still in a perpetual state of shellshock, wanted to tell him it was more like two against one. He liked the first choice better, making a run for it...but even that idea filled him with dread. With the guns and the bomb in play, he was afraid to do anything.
"Who's your favorite Willow, Quincy?" Hannahlee's fiery gaze swung around to lock in on him.
"Free," said Quincy.
"Did Free Willow ever fire a gun?" said Hannahlee. "Did he ever kill a man?"
"No." Quincy's voice was low and defeated. "He was a pacifist."
"Well, you might have to be a killer anyway." Hannahlee touched Quincy's shoulder. "But not yet." She glanced at Dunne in the back seat. "Wait for my signal. Then you move. Both of you."
Dunne winced.
Hannahlee caught the wince and turned around. "Especially you," she said. "He won't be expecting you."
"How?" Dunne gaped at her in disbelief. "How exactly are we supposed to kill the gun-toting human bomb lunatic...without getting shot or blown up?"
"Figure it out while you wait for my signal," said Hannahlee.
"Which will be what, exactly?" said Quincy.
"Here he comes!" Dunne said it as soon as he saw the bathroom door pop open. Without waiting for War to emerge, he flopped back against the seat and stared out the window on the opposite side of the Hummer.
"'War Willow is dead,'" said Hannahlee. "That's the signal."
"'War is dead?'" said Quincy. "You mean this War? Our War?"
"'War Willow is dead,'" said Hannahlee. "Don't forget."
"Dunne Willow is dead," said War. "If he tells me a lie."
Somewhere between San Angelo and Midland, Texas, War pulled out one of his guns—the six-shooter. Flipping open the cylinder, he showed Dunne that all six chambers were loaded.
Then, War flipped the cylinder back into place and pressed the barrel against Dunne's head.
"Truth or Death," said War. "That's the name of the game. Answer my questions truthfully, one Willow to another, or I will shoot you dead where you sit."
Dunne closed his eyes as War cocked the gun. He prayed Quincy wouldn't hit a pothole.
"You don't need to do that, War," said Hannahlee. "We're all family, aren't we?"
"Therefore, brother Dunne would never lie to me," said War. "Therefore, I will never pull the trigger."
"Of course he'd never lie," said Hannahlee. "But how would you know if he did?"
"I'd know." War nodded gravely. "My Ninja and Apache mentors taught me well."
Dunne's pulse roared in his ears. He did his best to remain perfectly still, though his body shivered with rising intensity. Sweat ran down his face and his sides.
His mind burned with the knowledge that he could die at any second. That all it would take was the flick of a trigger.
And he would get what he deserved.
"Let's begin," said War. "You've said your family was shot to death by an intruder. First question: who was this intruder?"
Dunne swallowed hard. He closed his eyes and slowly opened them.
His mouth felt like it was stuffed with cotton when he spoke. "I don't know. I'd never seen him before, and I've never seen him since."
War raised an eyebrow. "He got away?"
Dunne did not want to keep answering questions...but the barrel of the six-shooter was still pressed to the side of his head. "Yes."
"The police never arrested him?" said War.
"No," said Dunne.
"I see." War paused. "Did he kill them in front of you?"
"That's enough." Hannahlee turned and looked back. "The War I know isn't sadistic enough to torture his own brother."
"Let me rephrase the question." War pushed the six-shooter tighter against Dunne's head. "Did you watch the intruder kill your family?"
"Yes." Dunne thought of that terrible moment again...though in truth, he never stopped thinking of it.
Vicky, his wife, on her knees on the living room floor. Holding on to Ella for dear life. One shotgun blast was enough for the both of them.
Blood everywhere. So much blood. The smell of a slaughterhouse. Acrid smell of gunsmoke. The killer's laughter.
Vicky's eyes, not quite dead, staring up at him across the room. Beseeching.
Not beseeching. Betrayed.
"Next question." War leaned closer. "Why are you still alive?"
It was as if War had a sixth sense for personal trauma. He had already zeroed in on Dunne's most painful memory. Now, he was quickly closing in on Dunne's darkest secret.
Dunne couldn't stand the thought of revealing that secret...but the latest question would drive him to the verge of doing just that. He didn't want to answer...but the gun was still there, against his head.
Insisting.
Maybe if he said as little as possible. "He didn't shoot me."
War clucked and rolled his eyes. "More information, please. The name of the game isn't 'Truth or Vagueness.'"
Dunne shut his eyes, as if that would be enough to block out the danger. As if that would make the threat go away—the threat to his life and the threat of exposure.
Even as he shivered and cringed, he knew the truth shouldn't matter. What did he care what Quincy and Hannahlee thought—especially Quincy? He barely knew them. After they finished the job—if they didn't die first—he might never see them again.
But he still didn't want them to know. He didn't want anyone to know. The secret was too painful to bear and too ugly to show the world.
The question was, would Dunne give his life to keep it? Because it looked like that was what it was going to take.
The answer was "no." "I'm not sure why he left me alive," said Dunne. "I didn't ask."
"So this stranger intruded in your home," said War. "He shot and killed your family but left you alive for unknown reasons. Then he just left."
Dunne started to nod, then remembered the gun at his head and stopped. "Yes," he said.
"He didn't pistol whip you," said War. "He didn't kick your ass."
"No," said Dunne.
War narrowed his eyes and locked his gaze with Dunne's. "Not a bruise on you. Not a scratch."
"No." Dunne's heart was beating so fast, he thought it would shatter his skeleton. He thought about leaping out of the Hummer and running for his life...but if a gunshot didn't kill him first, the pavement speeding underneath the Hummer would pulp him on impact.
War nodded slowly. His voice was almost a whisper. "I know the truth."
Dunne did not answer.
"Tell me," said War. "We need to hear you say it."
Dunne's head spun. His stomach ached and twisted.
War had worked his way to the awful truth. He had hunted it down like a bloodhound and flushed it out.
Now, Dunne would have to confess it. Either that, or he'd be shot to death in the back seat.
"War, please," said Hannahlee. "That's enough."
"Say it," said War. "Tell us the truth."
Dunne tried. As War pushed the gun barrel further, Dunne opened his mouth, intending to speak.
But he couldn't do it. The truth was too terrible.
He'd never told anyone. He felt as if saying it out loud would make it worse. As if everyone would be ashamed and hate him instead of feeling sorry for him.
"Tell us!" said War. "Do it or I'll shoot you!"
Dunne tried again. Tried to save his life.
And he couldn't. Seized by fear, he couldn't stand up in a life-or-death situation.
Just like when he'd failed Vicky and Ella.
So maybe the secret wouldn't come out after all. Maybe he could take comfort in that. When he was dead, at least, no one would know the full story.
No one would know that Dunne hadn't fought for his wife and daughter's lives. That he'd been too afraid to take on the gunman.
Or to sacrifice his own life for the lives of his loved ones.
No one would know...unless War told the story himself. "Do I have to say it? You can't even tell your own secret?"
"Stop it." said Hannahlee. "No more."
Dunne felt like he was about to pass out. He wanted to say something that would end the torture, but he seemed to have no control over his voice.
All he could do was sit there in a daze, waiting for the bullet. Remembering Vicky's eyes. The look of betrayal in the moment before her death.
The realization that he was not the man she'd thought he was.
"I'll say it, then!" said War. "I'll give away your vile secret!"
"Cut it out!" said Quincy. "I'll run this thing into a tree, I swear to God!"
Dunne braced himself for War's next words. For the full revelation of his cowardice.
He closed his eyes, held his breath, and waited for his life to change.
War asked the question. "Did you kill your family?"
Dunne opened his eyes. It was not the question he'd expected.
Neither was the next one. "Are you a Poison Oak?"
Finally, Dunne regained his voice. He answered both questions truthfully. "No."
War's eyes were steely as he searched Dunne's gaze. Finally, he shook his head. "Liars die in this game."
"I'm not lying," said Dunne.
"Game over," said War.
"No!" The Hummer swerved as Quincy reached back for the gun.
"Stop it!" said Hannahlee. "War would never kill his own brother."
War grabbed Quincy's hand and twisted it hard, making Quincy howl in pain. The Hummer jolted into the left lane, face to face with an oncoming tractor trailer.
War let go, and Quincy jerked the wheel hard to the right. The Hummer bucked out of the tractor trailer's path with barely a second to spare.
The whole time, the six-shooter never left the side of Dunne's head.
Hannahlee looked back, emerald eyes glinting. "No more nonsense, War. You are not going to shoot Dunne."
"There's only one way for him not to die," said War. "According to the rules of Truth or Death, someone else can save his life by telling a true secret in his place. A big true secret."
Hannahlee hesitated only a moment. She looked at Dunne, then swiveled her fiery gaze to fix upon War.
"Years ago," said Hannahlee, "I got pregnant." Her voice was calm and even. "I gave the child up for adoption."
The Hummer was silent except for the rumble of the motor. War, Dunne, and Quincy hung on every word from Hannahlee's mouth.
"I've done nothing but suffer ever since," she said. "My career, my relationships, my whole life have gone straight to hell. Not a day goes by that I don't seriously consider killing myself."
That was the end of it. For a long moment, no one said a word.
Finally, Hannahlee spoke. "Do you believe me?"
"Yes," said War. "I know that was true."
"Was it a big enough secret for you?" said Hannahlee.
"Yes." War pulled the six-shooter away from Dunne's head.
"Good." Hannahlee turned around to face front. "Now why don't you give it a rest for a while?"
"Will do," said War, and then he slumped in his seat, staring out the window.