CHAPTER ONE
New Chapel, Indiana
April
Monday 7 p.m.
The sun was beginning to set behind the beautiful tan brick-and-stucco mansion as I drove my bright green BLOOMERS FLOWER SHOP minivan up the curving brick driveway. I parked near the front doors and took in the magnificent view. The oversized landscaping around the house and driveway was perfectly groomed. The second story was centered around a grand, half-oval window. Off to my left was a three-car garage, and inside the bay closest to the house sat a shimmering silver BMW with a vanity plate that said Paige Me.
This was my last delivery and I was uncharacteristically late because of a stopped freight train that had blocked traffic for over ten minutes, but I had taken that time to wolf down a snack bar, momentarily silencing my grumbling belly. I took the long white box out of the back of the van and straightened the bow. It was full of multi-colored tulips that Slade Rafferty, the owner of a successful realty firm in town, was sending to his wife Paige for their first anniversary. I shut the van door and carried the box up the brick driveway and across the wide cement porch to the front door. And there I came to a startled stop.
The glass window on the side of the door was shattered as though someone had put a fist through it, and the door was slightly ajar. With my heart revving, I stepped carefully around the glass shards that lay scattered on the cement below and called in softly at first, “Mrs. Rafferty?” and then tried again louder. No answer either time.
From behind the house I heard a car’s engine starting and then the sound of wheels squealing on pavement. Alarmed, I fumbled with the long flower box, pulled out my phone, and called 911. After speaking with the dispatch operator, I took the box of tulips back to the cooler in the van, then paced up and down the driveway in front of the mansion, desperately wishing I could go inside to see if Mrs. Rafferty was all right. But having worked with my husband, Marco Salvare, a private detective, for nearly two years, I knew not to touch anything. It was driving me crazy.
Within minutes I heard sirens and then saw three squad cars race up Sandy Creek Court, pulling into the opposite side of the curving driveway. Sgt. Sean Reilly and his partner, Officer Bill Martin, emerged from the first car and immediately headed toward me. Sean stood at least two heads taller than me, trim in his tan uniform, with sandy brown hair parted at the side and deep blue eyes, and was never without a smoldering, inquisitive look on his face, especially when interacting with me.
Reilly had come to my rescue on more than several occasions, had pleaded with me to stop getting myself involved in harrowing, inescapable situations, and had even forced Marco and I to stop investigating our most recent case, to which we responded by solving it. But still, Sgt. Reilly had moved up the ranks of the New Chapel PD alongside my father, offering Marco and me the same respect and comradery. We had grown very close to Sean, and I was proud to call him my friend.
“You again?” Reilly asked sarcastically as he strode up beside me. “There’s a surprise. What’s going on?”
“I stopped to make a delivery and found the side light glass broken and the door open. I tried calling inside but no one answered.” I pointed to the car parked in the open garage bay. “That’s Paige Rafferty’s BMW. She should be home.”
“Okay, stay back,” Reilly commanded. “We’ll take it from here.”
Officer Martin stepped onto the cement porch and sidled up to the front door. Reilly signaled for two of the officers to circle around the left side of the house, and the other two the right side, then used his elbow to open the front door wider.
“Mrs. Rafferty?” Reilly called. “New Chapel PD.” Hearing no response, he tried again and finally said, “We’re coming in.”
He and his partner moved cautiously inside, hands on their readied holsters. I stayed back for a moment craning to see over their shoulders, then curiosity got the better of me and I crept across the porch, stopping just outside the doorway as Reilly scanned the enormous, high-ceilinged foyer and wide curving staircase, then proceeded cautiously into the living room on his left.
“Mrs. Rafferty?” Reilly called again. “New Chapel Police.”
I stepped further into the house, keeping quiet and following at a safe distance as they made their way through the house and met in the massive kitchen at the back, where white countertops and black cabinets filled three walls, and a gigantic island sat in the middle of the room.
The aroma of coffee filled the air, as though it had been recently brewed. I caught a glimpse of a black marble kitchen table with white chairs in a large bay area in front of a bank of windows and that’s when I saw Paige, her blonde head down on the table, a black and white coffee mug near her right hand.
Reilly used his shoulder radio to call for an ambulance, then slipped on latex gloves and went to examine her. He put his fingers on her neck and shook his head. “She’s gone,” he said to his partner. “Call the detectives and the coroner.”
I had to turn away. Paige Rafferty, a beautiful woman who had once worked as a real estate agent at her husband’s firm, was dead on the eve of her anniversary, her first anniversary, according to the note attached to the bouquet of tulips. I couldn’t wrap my mind around it. Marco and I had been married just a year-and-a-half, and I didn’t even want to imagine life without him. I had to quickly shake that thought from my head and stay focused.
When the other officers came through the back door, the first officer said, “The backyard is clear, Sergeant. No footprints anywhere but we found the back gate open and
fresh tire treads on the street behind the house.”
Officer Martin stepped into view. “The sliding glass door here was unlocked and wide open. Looks like a quick escape out the back.”
I couldn’t keep quiet any longer. “Reilly, he’s right. I heard a motor gun and tires squealing behind the house. I must have scared the killer away after he murdered Mrs. Rafferty and before he had a chance to finish robbing the place.”
Reilly swiveled to give me glare. “Didn’t I tell you to stay back? The house hasn’t been cleared yet.”
“First of all, I am back.” Which I was, several feet at least. “And if you’ll look over there you’ll see what I’m talking about.”
I pointed to a built-in desk area on the far-right side of the kitchen, where drawers had been pulled out and emptied onto the floor and a computer cord lay under the desk, still attached to the wall outlet, the computer missing. Paige’s purse lay near the desk, the contents scattered, her wallet open, a tube of lipstick lying beneath the chair.
“I must have scared the killer away before he had a chance to finish,” I repeated, as the thought really hit home. “And if I hadn’t been stuck at a railroad crossing, I might have arrived in time to stop her murder.”
As I said it and my words sank deeper, I felt sick to my stomach. But for that ten minutes, Paige Rafferty might still be alive.
Reilly must have noticed my distress because he came over and put his hands on my shoulders. “Abby, I appreciate your keen eye, but you’ve still got to get out of the way.”
He turned back to his men. “Clear the house. McConnell, check upstairs to see if anything appears to be taken. Smith, take the main floor. Beck, the basement. Keep your eye out for a cell phone.”
“Are we looking for a weapon?” one of the officers asked.
“It looks like she was strangled,” Reilly said, “and there’s no blood that I can see without moving her, but let’s not take any chances. Bill, start cordoning off the outside of the house.”
Time for me to go.
As I headed toward the opened front door, with Officer Bill Martin right behind me, I caught sight of Detective Arno getting out of his car. I stopped immediately and feigned patting my pocket. “I must’ve dropped my keys,” I said to the officer. “I’ll be out in a minute.”
As soon as Officer Martin had stepped outside to begin his task, I immediately ducked into an alcove off the huge foyer and waited for Arno to make his way to the kitchen.
In his early forties, Richard “Dutch” Arno was a senior detective known as the best closer on the force. He was an athletically built, tall, brute of a man whom I’d had the displeasure of meeting before. His hair was dark and slightly receding, combed back, just brushing the thick, upturned lapel of his long overcoat. He had a prominent forehead and dark eyes that could cut a person in half. I didn’t like or trust him because of his narrow-minded attitude. Once he had a suspect in his sights, he went after that person with a vengeance even if there was evidence that pointed elsewhere.
It had happened to several people I knew, including my best friend Nikki, whom Marco and I’d had to prove innocent before she was charged as an accomplice in a murder case, so I was always on guard where Arno was concerned. Unfortunately, Arno solved cases fast, making the district attorney look good, and therefore he’d gained the trust of the DA as well as the Chief of Police.
As Arno approached Reilly, I moved quickly behind a pillar and then into a short hallway off the kitchen to listen.
“What do we have?” Arno asked.
“I’ll wait until my officers finish outside and then fill you in,” Reilly replied.
“Go ahead and round them up,” Arno said. “I’ll take a look around while we’re waiting.”
At that point the crime scene photographer, a forensic team, and the coroner arrived, so as soon as Arno left the kitchen, I took advantage of his absence, and a house full of people, to blend in with them and take some photos of my own.
When I caught sight of Arno coming back into the kitchen, I quickly tucked my phone away and inched back into my hiding place. Detective Arno joined Reilly and his men, gathered around Paige’s body.
“By all indications,” Reilly began, “someone broke into the house to rob the Rafferty’s and murdered—,”
“Excuse me, Sergeant,” Arno interrupted in his usual blunt, condescending manner, “but from everything I’ve seen, it’s the exact opposite, a murder staged to look like a robbery. I’ll pick up the husband and take him down to the station for questioning.”
There it was, Arno’s snap decision.
And here came mine.