Ivory Tower
Brother Benton died in the wee hours of a Sunday morning two weeks after classes started. Though the reports were somewhat inconsistent, the gist of the story was this: Brother was in the middle of the KN initiation weekend when he refused to walk across the quadrangle in nothing but an NBU baseball cap. For his insubordination, he was ordered to drink a pint of whiskey, after which he stumbled home arm in arm with Frankie, where they both collapsed in their respective dorm rooms on the third floor.
Brother got sick sometime in the night, and like the rock stars you hear about on the VH1 specials, he choked on his own puke without a soul between the stone walls of Tully knowing his struggle.
For a month I felt what was like a brick in my gut, and I sat from time to time in the library, weeping over the waste of Brother Benton’s life as the campus slowly cranked back up again (though the KN house was under investigation). I had driven with Frankie down to Alabama and watched as they lowered Brother’s mahogany casket into the earth behind the First Presbyterian Church of Tuscaloosa while his daddy held his mama, who sobbed and sobbed through the service. Mostly I looked away from the hole in the patch of soil he had wanted to escape and instead watched his seven-year-old sister, whose hair was pulled back in a bun outlined with purple pansies. She blew dandelion fluff into the damp grass and looked at the weepy adults around her as though they were strangers.
I wrote this in the margin of the church bulletin as Frankie drove us back up into the mountains:
Alabama air
thicker
than kudzu vines.
Your mama’s
graveside cry
shriller
than a wren.
You
my potential
suitor
whose shirt
still holds
your scent
gone
(for what?)
at eighteen.
Yates, the KN president, was waiting in the dorm lobby when we returned from Tuscaloosa. Frankie held up his arm and said, “I’m not joining your godforsaken fraternity or any other. Brother’s gone, and I think KN is partly responsible for his death.”
To that Yates held up his arms, shook his head in a kind of solemn frustration, and turned toward the door.
I didn’t hear from Peter Carpenter again, though I had tried to call him a few times. I ran into him once on the colonnade. His eyes were bloodshot, and while he balanced a biology book on his hip, he seemed to have no idea where he was going.
“Peter, you okay?”
“Adelaide,” he said. “I’m sorry I haven’t called. It’s been a rough time.”
“I’m sure,” I said, and we stood there, silent, as the chapel bell tolled for Seventeenth-Century Poetry.
“Can’t be late for class,” I said, patting his shoulder. He didn’t move a muscle as I scurried into the humanities building.
In my heart, I didn’t know if the KNs were responsible for Brother’s death. It was rumored that Peter had given the order to drink at Yates’s command, but I wondered why Brother didn’t refuse it.
As the leaves on campus turned a ruddy orange and I fought to keep my grades high so that McSweeney would sign off on a creative writing course for the spring, I filed Brother’s death away in my mind as a sad, horrible, freak event, and I didn’t expect anything like it to happen again.
But I had a bird’s-eye view from my Expository Writing class that October when the Troutville County police pulled Peter Carpenter out of the Burroway Science Building and charged him with manslaughter right there on the front quad beneath Nathaniel Buxton’s statue as a handful of nervous students gathered around the outlying columns and patches of emerald landscaping.
They handcuffed him on the spot and read him his rights, and he dropped to his knees and began to bawl.
As they led him to the police car, a surge of nausea crept up my throat, and I bolted out of my classroom, where my professor was in midsentence, and ran to a weeping willow tree to get sick. How I wished Mama or Juliabelle were there to hold my hair back and wipe my eyes. There was a sour churning like lava in the pit of my stomach, and before I knew it I was running to the chapel to see if I could ice it down with a prayer.
When I walked into the arched doors of the sanctuary, I remembered the convocation speech in which President Schaeffer had told us we were on a mission to cultivate intellectual growth in a setting that stressed the importance of individual honor and integrity. And then there was his bit about our responsibility to serve humanity through the productive use of our education. Humph.
“How will you take advantage of this opportunity, scholars?” he had said right into my eyes.
I had toiled to get here. I had kicked and scratched my way up through Williamstown High and put my daddy’s dreams on hold. And for what?
I didn’t realize how loud I was weeping, but before I knew it, the stout and elderly man who ran the chapel bookstore came up, offered me a tissue, and sat beside me as I blew my nose.
I flung myself into his soft little chest and cried. I didn’t even know who he was, but he was nice enough to bring me a tissue, and he patted my back and told me not to worry. Not to worry.
He smelled like mothballs and Tic Tacs, and by the time I pulled away from him, the pocket of his starched oxford shirt was soaked.
A tourist interested in purchasing a postcard of the chapel had come in the middle of the outburst, and when she cleared her throat, he had to excuse himself to ring her up.
Mostly, I felt alone. It was only autumn, and it was colder than any winter Williamstown had known, and the two young men who had remotely noticed me were gone—one in a graveyard in Tuscaloosa and the other handcuffed and headed for the Roanoke County Jail. What was going on?
The tissue the sweet man had given me was shredded now, and when I reached in my backpack for another, I felt something smaller than a coin and pulled it out to find that it was the St. Christopher medal Juliabelle had given me on my graduation day. It was oval, and on the outer rim it said, “Behold St. Christopher—And Go Your Way in Safety.” In the center was the hulking saint leaning on a cane and looking back at the sacred passenger on his shoulder.
I rubbed the medal and thought about my commencement speech and the “out to sea” adventure that I proclaimed would make up our post–high school life. I thought about Juliabelle’s promise, “You know I’ll make the prayer for you, my Adelaide. I’ll be here making it every time you come to mind.”
The “Go” in “Go Your Way” was in my mind now, and I mouthed it more than once as the little man came back and asked me if I’d like him to walk me to the counselor’s office.
“I’m okay,” I said to him, and he smiled a dear and sympathetic smile at me.
“You’re welcome here anytime, miss.”
“Thank you,” I said.
Go my way. I mean, I couldn’t give up now. Okay, two freak things had happened—Brother Benton was gone and Peter was in trouble— but I still had to hold my future by the scruff and not let go. That fury rose inside me like the day on the beach when Daddy wanted me to swim. I could hear him say, “C’mon, sister!”
I inhaled, buttoned my coat, and walked out onto the great hill as a flutter of the fiery-colored leaves loosened from their hinges and fell onto the green grass.
On the quadrangle I could see Dean Atwood pacing the colonnade with President Schaeffer as two media trucks from Roanoke and one from Richmond raised their large antennae for a press conference in response to the arrest. I walked right toward them on my way to Tully, and I gave President Schaeffer the mean eye for the crock of dung he had spewed at us at the convocation. Heck, this wasn’t the ivory tower, set apart from reality. Rather, it was its own little warped world tucked in the mountains.
A thought was coming to me. Maybe a title for a poem. I was trying to remember the name of that book I’d read in tenth-grade English class in which a group of young and well-bred boarding-school children devolve from civilized to barbaric after they are stranded on an island.
Before I knew it, a lady in a red suit with gold buttons approached me.
“What year are you, ma’am?” She spoke into a black microphone that had “WKIV-ABC News” sealed across it.
“Freshman,” I said as a camera wheeled around to my left.
“What do you think about the arrest that just took place here?”
“I think it’s sad,” I said. “I know the boy from home, and he is a good boy.”
“Oh, so you know Mr. Carpenter?”
Dean Atwood was racing toward me with her finger making a mock slash across her mouth as if to instruct me to button up. The reporter, sensing the urgency, shoved the microphone closer to my lips. “Give me your reaction of the events that have transpired here over the last few weeks.”
“I can’t make heads or tails of it, miss. I worked my whole life to get into a school like NBU”—I nodded toward the colonnade—“and now the highest-caliber person I know is on his way to jail.”
Then the thought came to me! The title of the book was on the tip of my tongue, and I had to spout it out.
“The Lord of the Flies meets Animal House is how I’d describe it here so far. And this ivory tower is beginning to look more and more like the pig’s head on a stick.”
Dean Atwood furrowed her brow, then narrowed her eyes at me. She pinched her fingers over her lips in her own version of “Pipe down, Piper!”
But I was too riled up not to finish my thought. I looked away from her and into the camera. “How are we supposed to thrive in an environment like this?”