Sean’s schedule was so tight during the next month that he didn’t even realize his last session with Lily was looming ahead until his assistant pointed out a correction on his calendar. He stared at it, his stomach doing a strange flip, sort of like one he gets right before a major presentation.
He and Lily had kept themselves busy every night engaging in every sex act he could convince her to try out. He was surprised by how little experience she had beyond the basic, vanilla sort of sex that didn’t really count in his eyes. But he also found her innocence something of a challenge. And it was kind of hot, teaching her all these new things, knowing she’d never done them with anyone before him.
The only thing bugging him about their encounters was how much convincing it often took to get her to come home with him. He knew she had pretty good reasons not to sleep with him, and it wasn’t like it was that tough to seduce her into bed all over again. But he was also aware that the only reason she could never say no firmly enough was that he kept popping up. Every week, she had no choice but to see him.
Now that their sessions were drawing to an end, would she finally reject him permanently?
He couldn’t stop thinking about it, and a frown etched between his forehead as he walked into the parlor shop. The bright smile she gave him helped to tamper down his worry, but he couldn’t seem to relax, even when she found every excuse to touch him as she went through the usual procedure. When they were finished, she held a mirror up to his arm. The skin was red and slightly indented where the tattoo used to be, but otherwise almost new.
“Cool.” He knew he didn’t sound like he meant it, but she didn’t seem to care. Instead, she pressed her body up against his, her breasts practically shoved against his face. She tilted his head back and leaned down to kiss him.
“We’ll have to go to your apartment tonight,” she said. “Mine’s getting fumigated.”
“Okay.” His cock was instantly hard at her words, his body responding, knowing what was coming next. All doubts about her not wanting him anymore were banished from his head, at least momentarily. He rubbed his hand up and down the side of her leg, tempted to toss her onto the chair and fuck her right then and there. They had fucked so often in this room that he already knew exactly what positions would give him the most leverage as he thrust his cock inside her. But his toys were waiting for them back at his apartment, and it would be worth the wait.
The drive home was torture, not that he was complaining. She couldn’t seem to keep her hands off him, touching his chest, his shoulders. Rubbing his raging boner, jerking him off through his jeans. He found it extremely difficult to concentrate on the traffic with her doing that. His eyes kept rolling back in his head, and it was impossible to keep his lids from drooping. After he almost side-swept a car, he finally had to grab her wrist to stop her. When she gave him a disappointed pout, he chuckled, then reached between her legs and found her wet and ready. He almost crashed into a truck in front of them.
At the red light, he rubbed her clit with two fingers, squeezing the small nub lightly between his knuckles and letting his hand slide down so the tips of his fingers could slip inside her. She squeezed her eyes shut and let out an agonized moan. He continued to stroke her until the light turned green, and kept his hand there for the rest of the ride. Pre-cum moistened the front of his boxers, and if the drive was going to take any longer, he was going to drag her onto his lap and fuck her the rest of the way home.
He exhaled in relief when he pulled up to the driveway and didn’t see Patrick’s car. He’d met a girl the other week or something and had been spending most of his nights at her house.
“That’s odd,” Sean said, glancing up.
“What?”
“The apartment light is on, but Patrick isn’t home.”
“Maybe he forgot to turn it off.”
“Maybe.” But he felt a strange sensation on the back of his neck, his hairs rising like some sort of red flag. It wasn’t like Patrick though, who was pretty good about things like that. Sean tried to shrug it off and opened the door to let Lily in.
Once inside the elevator, they were on each other instantly and he forgot about the light in his apartment. It was ridiculous, how horny he was. You would think he hadn’t had sex in months, when he and Lily had been screwing their minds out for most of the night practically every night. Their mouths devoured one another. Hands under clothing, as far as they could reach, body pressed against body. Rubbing wherever they connected, getting as close as possible. He shoved her hard against the elevator wall, keeping her in place so he could press his hard cock against her body, relieve some of the pressure and tension building up inside of him. He was desperate to be inside her, to feel her body around him. If they didn’t get somewhere soon, he’d have to fuck her then and there. Thankfully, the elevator was fast and he only lived on the fourth floor.
When the elevator reached his floor, she almost tripped in her heels. He caught her against him, then reached down and lifted her in his arms. Usually, he was patient when girls had to walk in five-inch stilettos--hell, he wouldn’t be able to stand in those shoes. But today, his patience was low, and he was determined to get to his apartment fast. She gasped in delight, but used her free hands to touch his chest and neck, kissing him everywhere she could reach.
Inside the apartment, he put her back on the floor and ripped off her clothes, pausing briefly to suck on the tips of her breasts before yanking her bra straps off her arms and pulling her shorts down past her hips. He urged her back until she was leaning against the wall, and then he lowered to his knees. His mouth watered at the scent of her, clean and flowery and sweet. He bent her knee and placed one foot on his shoulder. He was about to lean in and taste her when the room was suddenly flooded with light.
Lily gasped and slammed her foot onto the floor. He got to his feet, covering her with his body as much as possible. It took a moment for his eyes to adjust, but as he blinked, he could make out the familiar, lithe walk of his ex-girlfriend Mandy. His heart pounded heavily inside his chest.
“What are you doing here?” he asked. He took off his jacket as fast as possible and wrapped it around Lily’s shoulders.
“Aww,” Mandy cooed. “Isn’t that sweet? You’re so protective of her.”
He ignored her. “How did you get in?”
“Through the door, silly.”
He groaned inwardly. “You still have my key.” How had he forgotten?
Mandy continued walking toward them until she was only an inch away. She looked from his face to Lily’s, who stared blankly back. Her expression was confident, though not exactly challenging. She merely looked amused. She observed Lily’s naked form, her eyes moving up and down despite Sean’s obvious dismay at their situation. She ignored him.
“You’re pretty,” Mandy admitted, tossing her hair over her shoulder. “I can see why he likes you.”
Lily licked her lips. “Thank you,” she said hesitantly. “So are you.”
“You did a good job with his tattoo. And with removing it too. Maybe you can do one for me.”
Lily looked at Sean, who could think of nothing to say. He raised his brows at her.
“What are you thinking of getting?” she asked Mandy.
“A little rose.” She reached for the hem of her blouse and took it off all of a sudden, revealing plump, perky breasts. She was tall and slim, her stomach flat with the small indents where her abs were slightly toned. Lily’s mouth fell open, and neither she or Sean could stop staring. Sometimes he forgot just how hot Mandy was, and she always enjoyed reminding him what he was missing out on. “Right here.” Mandy grabbed her right breasts with one hand and pulled it to the side, pointing at the underside of her boob. “What do you think?”
Lily’s mouth opened and closed. She swallowed hard. “That...would be...cute,” she stammered.
Mandy let her hands drop to her side. “Do you have any tattoos?”
“I have a small one on my shoulder.”
“What is it?”
“A butterfly.”
“Can I see?”
“Um--”
But before Lily could answer one way or another, Mandy reached up and pushed Sean’s jacket off her shoulders, leaving her completely naked. Lily gasped, her mouth opened in a shocked O, but she didn’t stop Mandy as the girl wrapped one arm around Lily’s waist and spun her around. Lily braced one hand on the wall, her body angled out in the sexiest position that made Sean’s cock rise by a couple inches. Mandy’s traced over the tattoo on Lily’s smooth, pale skin with her palm, and she made a breathy sound.
“So pretty,” she whispered.
Lily didn’t seem to know how to react. Her mouth was slightly open, her eyes wide. And Sean, standing there watching the two girls, became increasingly aware of the heat pooling at his crotch, the almost painful rise of his erection. Damn, that was hot, and they weren’t even doing anything. Mandy topless, her nipples already hard, standing an inch away from Lily, who was naked and blushing and seemed to have trouble breathing.
Mandy’s hand continued to smooth over Lily’s skin. At first she was just examining the tattoo, but then she didn’t stop, making circuitous motions along Lily’s shoulders and back. “You’re so soft,” she commented. “What kind of lotion do you use?”
“Wh-what?” Lily turned around, guided by Mandy’s fingers. Sean watched as Mandy rubbed her hands over her stomach and hips. Her hands were feminine and elegant, like she was sculpting clay. Her fingers moved around Lily’s arms, avoiding her breasts deliberately. Both girls looked mesmerized with each other, lips parted and breathing deeply.
What kind of game was Mandy playing? She was so insane that their relationship had always been a roller coaster. It used to excite him, distract him from the stressful frenzy of his work. Gave him an escape from the rest of his life, which had always been organized and controlled. But now it just made him feel panicked. He hoped she wasn’t planning on doing anything to hurt Lily.
“You have nice breasts,” Mandy said. “Nice and big.” She reached up, surprised them both by pressing her thumb against a nipple, and flicking it lightly. Lily let out a small yelp. “Did you like that?” She didn’t wait for a response, cupping Lily’s breasts with her hands and massaging them. Lily’s body gave a jerk. Sean reached into his pocket and tried to move his erection discreetly, wondering if either girl had noticed how turned on he was watching them.
Mandy was staring down at Lily’s breasts while she massaged them between her fingers. “May I?” she asked.
Lily didn’t answer, but she didn’t say no or push away either. Mandy dipped her head, cupped one breast up, and closed her mouth over the nipple. Her lips pursed around the areola, looking like she was just enjoying a delicious piece of candy. Sean managed to keep the groan from escaping his mouth.
“Oh!” Lily gasped. One hand braced the wall, her knee threatening to give out. Sean moved to her side, wrapped an arm around her waist to hold her steady. Or maybe he was just using it as an excuse not to be left out of the fun. She gave him a surprised, frightened look, and he gave her waist a gentle squeeze to let her know it was okay. More than okay. They had never talked about having a threesome seriously before, though she did mention once that she’d always been curious.
“How does it feel?” Mandy asked.
“Different.” Lily looked up at Sean questioningly. He gave her a reassuring smile. There was no way he was going to stop them from continuing. He wasn’t exactly sure what Mandy was up to, but whatever it was, he hoped she finished it.
“How different?” Mandy asked. She moved to her other breast and kissed that one too, giving Sean a nice view of her tongue tracing around the nipple before she sucked it into her mouth. He groaned, pressed his hips against Lily so she could feel how hard he was.
“Softer,” Lily said. “It’s...more delicate.”
“Oh.” Mandy seemed thrilled by the answer. She touched Lily’s face. “Let’s see how different it is, kissing.” Lily looked like she might have protested, but her curiosity got the better of her. Sean’s breath caught as he watched their lips move closer together. For one increasingly torturous moment before they kissed, he thought Lily would back out. But he wasn’t to be disappointed. The girls’ mouths touched, gently at first, tentatively. He could see their tongues dart out, dance around each other. Sean was happy to watch, but he couldn’t help but touch at the same time. He fondled Lily’s breasts while his gaze fixed on their mouths, their tongues playing together, the shift of their lips. He heard Lily’s breath quickening, knew she was probably getting super wet. He wanted a taste of her for himself.
When they pulled away, he held Lily’s chin, tilted her head back, and leaned down and kissed her. She was sweet and delicious and soft, and she strained up against him. Next to him, he felt Mandy bend down to play with Lily’s other breast with her mouth. He reached down between Lily’s legs the same time Mandy did, their fingers joining for a moment to fondle the moisture and heat of her cunt. She was dripping wet, and he slid his fingers inside her while Mandy touched her clit. Ironically, it was the most intimate thing they’d ever done together, pleasuring another woman.
Lily’s chest was moving in and out quickly as she struggled for breath. When Sean broke the kiss finally, her eyes were dazed and half-lidded. Mandy knelt in front of her, and he moved behind Lily, wrapping an arm around her waist to support her. Mandy resumed the same position that he’d been in just moments ago, kneeling down, lifting one of Lily’s feet onto her shoulder.
“I wonder how different it would feel, getting eaten out by a girl,” Mandy said, looking up at Lily. “Are you curious?”
Lily gave a small whimper. Mandy flashed a grin at her, winked at Sean, and then leaned forward. She pressed an open mouth against Lily’s cunt, and he could only imagine what her tongue was doing to Lily’s clit. Lily’s body went as tense as a tight wire. Her fists clenched and she gritted her teeth, throwing her head back.
“Ssh,” Sean whispered. “It’s okay. Just let go. Enjoy it.” He palmed the curve of her waist in reassuring motions. The muscles in her abs were tightening and loosening as she tried to contain the sensations. He could see her expression go from confusion to pleasure to surprise.
She didn’t relax of course, instead straining against the pleasure. He could only imagine what was going through her body, and he added to it, cupping her breasts and playing with her nipples. He bent his head and pressed kisses against the side of her neck, sucking gently on a sensitive spot. This made her wild, and she thrashed about. She probably would have thrown Mandy off if Sean weren't there to hold her steady.
The sight of his ex’s head moving between Lily’s legs, bobbing her mouth over her cunt, was so hot, he could have come just by rubbing his cock against Lily’s ass. But he watched his breath caught in his throat, his ears nearly deafened by Lily’s moans. He was hot and tense all over, and couldn’t wait to get inside Lily’s hot, wet cunt. But he wanted her nice and ready, and he was willing to wait.
Besides, they had never done anything like this before. He liked that he was the first one to introduce her to her first threesome.
She went even stiffer than before, practically parallel to the floor as her body tensed. Her breasts grew firmer, her nipples hardened, and she suddenly gave out a loud, surprised cry. A muscle in her ab twitched. She was so hot. Her mouth opening and closing in delighted shock as she came. Mandy’s tongue continued to circle her clit, and that seemed to draw the orgasm out longer. Lily moaned repeatedly, her body jerking and twitching between them until finally, she went completely limp. She molded against Sean’s body, her breath escaping her in abrupt gasps.
Mandy stood and grinned. “How was that?” she asked.
Lily didn’t answer her, still coming down from her climax. He was so hard, so fucking horny that he could feel pre-cum wetting the front of his boxers. With shaking fingers, he unbuckled his belt, his fingers fumbling so bad that he could barely get his jeans unzipped. Mandy chuckled and helped him, the back of her hand rubbing against his cock as she did. He groaned, grabbed her wrist to prevent her from getting any ideas. Yeah, this was hot, and he’d enjoyed watching her eat out his girl. He wasn’t going to say no to any further physical explorations either. But he didn’t want to give her any ideas. He was with Lily now.
Mandy gave a little pout and, to his surprise, leaned forward and kissed him. Their mouths met with shocking familiarity, and she deepened the kiss, he pushed her away; this was not going to happen.
Suddenly, she broke the kiss and stepped back to give him a full view of her body. She bent down and slipped out of her skirt to reveal a naked pussy. She didn’t like hair. Said it felt a lot better when she was bare and completely exposed. She was still as hot as ever, her breasts smaller than Lily’s but firm and full. Lily was gaping up at her. Her legs seemed steadier now, and when he was sure she wasn’t going to fall, he released her to roll a condom on his dick.
“Lily,” he said, feeling ridiculously jealous as all her attention was focused on Mandy at the moment. He felt strangely possessive of her, and wished Mandy would leave now so he could have Lily to himself. Then again, he also liked the surprise on her face, liked that he was pushing her innocent boundaries, that she trusted him enough to let him.
She turned to him and wrapped her arms around his neck before kissing him. Sean took control of the kiss--he needed to feel like he had control of something, at least. She went pliant against him almost immediately, and that drove him insane. It always had. The way she was so naturally submissive and shy and innocent. His hips were already thrusting as if on their own, and his cock rubbed against her naked pelvis, searching for some sort of release.
Behind Lily, Mandy approached, completely naked now. She touched Lily, hugged her from behind, and reached around to play with her breasts. Lily broke the kiss with a gasp, looking down at the feminine, nail polished fingers tugging on her nipples. Over her shoulder, Mandy made eye contact with Sean, and the moment was so full of tension that he felt as if he was going to explode.
“Kiss me,” Mandy said. She reached up and grabbed his head, pulling him down until their mouths met before he could stop her. Lily was sandwiched between them, and he wondered momentarily if she would be offended that he was kissing another woman. But she didn’t seem to mind, not judging from the way she reached down and wrapped her fingers around his cock. He moaned as he broke Mandy’s kiss. A sense of nostalgia tugged at him, reminding him of nights when he and Mandy would explore each other, find new, adventurous things to do.
He couldn’t take much more of the foreplay. Watching the girls had been more than enough of a tease, and he had to find some sort of release before things ended on an embarrassing note. He wrapped an arm around both girls and guided them to the floor. He knelt down and Lily straddled his lap, her legs wide open and inviting, her back flat against the floor. Mandy knelt above her, gazing down at the girl’s face as Sean positioned himself at her pussy. He couldn’t wait any longer, and pushed himself inside.
The feeling was glorious. He closed his eyes and groaned, enjoying the sensation of her pussy stretching over him, her wetness consuming him. Her muscles clamped onto him, squeezing and releasing. She could have milked an orgasm out of him if she kept going.
When he opened his eyes again, he was surprised to see the two girls making out like crazy. It was extremely erotic, holding himself hilt-deep inside one girl while another kissed her like the world was ending. Mandy continued to play with Lily’s breasts as he began to move in and out of her. Damn she was tight. And hot.
Mandy moved down the length of Lily’s body, stopping to lick at her nipples before moving further. She squatted over Lily’s face, making it obvious what she wanted the other girl to do. Lily hesitated for a brief second, looking up at Sean as if for approval. He smiled down at her, giving her leg a reassuring squeeze. With that, she parted her lips and gave an experimental lick at Mandy’s slit. The girl squealed in delight.
“That feels good,” she cooed, in a sort of over-dramatic way. A porn star trying too hard to earn her keep. But Lily didn’t seem to notice, taking it as encouragement instead. He watched as her tongue darted in and out of Mandy’s cunt, then circled her clit. She used her fingers to stroke inside, and Mandy gave a genuine moan, buckling over her mouth.
Sean was thrusting inside of Lily harder now, unable to help himself. He wanted to last until the girls were done, but it seemed impossible. He couldn’t quite believe this was happening. It was all so amazing, his senses completely conquered, his body gripped with extreme pleasure.
Mandy reached down and touched Lily’s clit with her palm, wrapping two fingers around his cock. He grunted in surprise as she pleasured both of them while his cock continued to move in and out of Lily’s pussy. The result was an intense combination of sensations, of having his cock jerked off while he fucked Lily at the same time.
“Fuck,” he burst out. “I’m not going to last.” He reached out and grabbed Lily’s breasts, pinching them hard how he knew she liked it.
“Neither am I,” Mandy said. She was squirming and giving Sean pleading looks as if he could do something to help her. She squeezed her eyes shut and threw her head back. “Don’t stop. Don’t stop.”
“I’m going to come pretty soon,” she warned.
They looked down at Lily, who was busy twirling her tongue on Mandy’s clit.
“Eat her,” Sean said.
“What?”
“While I’m fucking her. Eat her at the same time.”
Mandy’s eyes widened in confusion. Frustrated, Sean palmed the back of her head and gently guided her down. The girls were essentially in a sixty-nine position, except he had his dick inside one of them at the same time. Mandy got what he meant, and he knew the moment she went at it on Lily’s clit, because her cunt began to squeeze him so hard, he almost came right away. He gritted his teeth and hung on, trying to distract himself with boring thoughts. But it was impossible. It felt way too good not to keep himself in the moment.
Suddenly Mandy cried out, her moan muffled as she stuffed her face against Lily’s cunt. Her body twitched in that way it did whenever she orgasmed. She looked like she was doing some sort of dance, her hips swaying, her curvy body moving to a silent rhythm. He reached down and stroked his fingers through her hair affectionately. She’d always been adventurous, surprising him with new things to try, and he especially missed this part about her.
As her cries died out, she redoubled her efforts on Lily’s clit, sucking and licking the girl to completion. Sean knew the moment Lily orgasmed--not because her cries nearly deafened them both, but because her pussy gripped him so hard that he couldn’t have stopped from climaxing if someone hit him in the stomach this very moment. Actually, it was so intense that it felt like someone had punched him. His heart nearly burst out of his chest, and he came so hard that his teeth went numb. He wasn’t aware of screaming until he heard himself and gritted his teeth in order to stop. He shot a massive load into the condom, and it never seemed to stop, each convulsion wracking his body with almost embarrassing twitches.
When it was over, they untangled themselves and lay together in a heap with him in the middle of both girls. Lily was pressed against his side, nuzzling his neck and kissing him while Mandy simply lay there catching her breath.
After a long moment, Mandy got up and began dressing herself. They watched her for a moment in silence.
“Where are you going?” Lily asked her eventually. She sounded almost concerned and disappointed that she wasn’t staying.
“I’ve got a date tonight,” she said.
“Oh.” She looked bewildered. “Well, that sounds nice.”
Sean shook his head and shrugged. “Have a good time,” he said, watching Lily as she stood up and walked to the bathroom.
“This was fun,” Mandy said. “If you ever feel up to round two, call me.”
He got unsteadily to his feet and walked her to the door. “Mandy,” he said. “I don’t know what game you’re playing… You know it’s over between us, don’t you?”
“I’m not playing a game, when have you ever know me to play games.” She touched his face. “I just wanted to see what sort of girl she was.”
He sighed. “And?”
Mandy shrugged. “I guess she’s pretty cool. I don’t mind losing you to someone like her and besides after tonight, neither of you will be able to enjoy sex together again without thinking of me.”
“So that is your game then?”
She waved a hand dismissively. “I don’t feel like arguing, Sean. I need to go, Bye.”
And then she was gone.
He stood there for a moment, feeling completely taken advantage of, and not quite able to wrap his mind around what had just happened.