After breakfast one Saturday, Mama told Lily that she was going to town with Aunt Mary. “I’ll take baby Paul with me,” Mama said. “Hannah, Levi, and Davy will stay here until we come back. I’m sure Levi and Joseph will be fine, but you and Hannah should keep an eye on Dannie and Davy. You can have all day to play. Papa will be in the shop, if you need anything.”
Lily was nervous, but excited. Hannah hadn’t come over to play in weeks. At school, Hannah acted a little stiff and uncomfortable around Lily—as if she just wasn’t sure if Lily was or wasn’t a sandwich thief. Maybe a whole day to play together, without anyone else around from school, would set things right between them.
Aunt Mary drove the buggy up to the house and waited while her children climbed out and Mama and baby Paul climbed in. “Be good, and have fun,” Aunt Mary and Mama said at the exact same time. Lily thought it was funny that they were so much alike. They looked alike, they sounded alike, they even talked alike. Why couldn’t Lily have a sister? It seemed like so much fun.
Hannah had run alongside the buggy to wave goodbye to her mother, then she turned and walked up to join Lily on the porch. In the quiet, things grew awkward again. “What do you want to do today?” Hannah asked.
“Anything you’d like to do,” Lily said. She wanted Hannah to have a good time.
Hannah tilted her head, as if something was whirling in her mind. Lily grinned. She knew Hannah was thinking up something fun and interesting. A little dangerous, but not too dangerous. Hannah had good ideas.
“Hmmm . . . I wish,” Hannah started, tapping her chin, “I wish we could have another campfire like we had for Joseph’s birthday.”
Lily’s gaze shifted to the kitchen window. “We still have a whole bag of marshmallows left over.”
“Let’s toast them!” Hannah said.
Lily rolled that over in her mind. Too risky. “We can’t make a campfire.”
“Maybe we can come up with a solution . . . if we think hard enough.”
A wonderful idea popped into Lily’s head. “I have just the thing! We could light the kitchen oil lamp and put a marshmallow on a fork and hold it above the chimney to toast it.”
“Great idea!” Hannah said as they both ran to the house.
In the kitchen, Lily carefully removed the glass chimney of the oil lamp. She struck a match and lit the wick, then replaced the chimney and adjusted the wick until it was burning just right: a nice flame but no smoke.
She ran into the pantry to fetch the bag of marshmallows while Hannah found forks in a kitchen drawer. She let Hannah toast the first marshmallow. It took a long time until she was satisfied that it was a golden brown. Hannah popped it into her mouth. “Perfect!” she said, opening a mouthful of chewy marshmallow.
Now it was Lily’s turn. She held the fork with the marshmallow above the chimney. She kept turning it to make sure the marshmallow would toast nicely on all sides. This was taking so long. The marshmallow wasn’t even turning a color yet. She was hungry for a toasted marshmallow right now! If she could only get the marshmallow closer to the heat, then it could toast on all sides.
Holding the fork, she poked the marshmallow down inside the chimney. It didn’t take long at all before the marshmallow was beautifully golden brown and puffy. As Lily tried to pull it back out, it got stuck against the sides of the chimney. She pulled a little harder. Her fork flew out but the marshmallow stayed stuck. Then it turned black. Lily tried to blow the flame out, but the marshmallow was blocking it. A horrible smell filled the air. Hannah screamed.
Think quick, Lily! She ran to get a pot holder. Then she removed the chimney and blew out the flame. Problem solved! She carried the chimney over to the sink to clean out the sticky marshmallow that was stuck inside. She opened the faucet and let water run over it. There was a loud cracking noise and the chimney broke into pieces.
Hannah and Lily stared at the mess. How would she explain this to Mama? She and Hannah were supposed to keep an eye on Dannie and Davy. Mama assumed those little boys were the ones who might get into trouble. Instead, it was Lily.
“Let’s hide it,” Hannah whispered. She found a paper bag in the pantry and started to pluck pieces of glass from the kitchen sink and drop them into the bag.
“But where?” Lily said. “Dannie finds everything.” She picked up a shard of sticky, marshmallowy broken glass.
Hannah’s eyebrows knit together in a frown. “Where is a place Dannie wouldn’t go exploring?”
Lily rinsed the last slivers of broken glass down the drain, reviewing her hiding places in her mind. Her bedroom was out. Dannie often poked around in her room while she was in school. She thought of hiding the paper bag in the basement, but he would find it while he was supposed to be helping Mama with the laundry. Papa’s workshop wouldn’t work. Then her face broke into a smile. “My old attic bedroom! No one goes up there.”
The girls took the stairs two at a time, threw open the red door, and went up the last stairwell, a little out of breath. Lily opened the attic door and peeked her head in. She wanted to be sure no bats were swooshing around. She took a few steps inside and turned in a circle, gazing at her lovely room with the purple painted floor. She hadn’t realized how much she missed it—the little window at the far end where she could see over the tops of trees. The quiet—so quiet! No sounds of little brothers galloping by.
Hannah was hunting for a place to hide the broken chimney. The room was mostly empty, except for a few pieces of furniture. She spied an old dresser in the corner and opened drawers, then closed them. “Too obvious.” Then she dropped to her knees and tucked the paper bag under the dresser. She pushed it far up against the wall, jumped to her feet, stepped back to look at it carefully, then patted her palms together as if she were dusting flour from her hands. “I think we found the perfect spot. No one would ever think to look here.”
“But what do we do about replacing the chimney?” Lily asked. She wasn’t as quick a thinker as Hannah about these types of things.
Hannah bit her lip, thinking hard. “You can use the chimney from the lamp in your room. Then, next time you go to town, you’ll have to buy a new one at the hardware store and sneak it home.”
That sounded expensive. How much did a glass chimney cost, anyway? She had only two dollars and fifty-three cents left in her piggy bank. And how would she read at night without her oil lamp? It also sounded like a plan in which, very likely, she would get caught. But then they heard Jim’s familiar clip-clop as he turned the buggy into the driveway and they didn’t have time for more brainstorming. Mama was home.
The girls hurried back down the stairs before Jim reached the barn. On the second floor, Hannah grabbed the chimney from the lamp in Lily’s room. In the kitchen, she placed it on the oil lamp on the kitchen table. Lily glanced around the kitchen, making sure all traces of marshmallow were gone and everything looked normal.
Then she had a happy thought. Today, everything was normal. Being with Hannah felt easy and natural again! The strain of the sandwich switch was over. Lily smiled. Life was good again.