ON TUESDAY MORNING, ROSE RUSHED THROUGH HER before-breakfast chores, lingering only for prayer. Wilhelm and Andrew wouldn’t return until late that evening. Rose ran a broom over the floor of Wilhelm’s retiring room and smoothed the sheets over his unused bed. He hadn’t lived in the room for two days, but it collected dust all the same.
Rose itched to know more about the hostel guests—their backgrounds, jobs, anything at all—and she couldn’t sit around and wait for Andrew to return and dig out his records for her. She felt some compunction about rummaging through his desk in the Trustees’ Office, but it was the best way to begin. She hurried over to the building before the bell rang for breakfast.
For ten years, Rose had been the community’s trustee, and she still missed it. She’d loved the excitement of starting new business ventures, buying and selling land, and watching over the daily work life of the community. Her practical nature had fit beautifully with the demands of the position. Becoming eldress had required more adjustment. She now felt at peace with the change and grateful for the challenges, but it had been a slow process. If she thought too much about it—and she tried not to—she suspected that some of her most satisfying experiences as eldress were those times when the world threatened the village’s reputation and sometimes its very survival. This was one of those times. While she had come to embrace her role as spiritual guide for her Children, she had to admit that the call to action always invigorated her. And worried her.
Rose sat at the double desk that had once been hers. She’d always loved its golden patina and economic design. Two trustees could work comfortably side by side without getting in each other’s way. Cubbyholes provided organization for smaller items, and generous bookshelves fit on top of the cubbyholes. She ran her hand over the clean surface, remembering its well-used smoothness.
This was no time for sentiment. She sifted through papers, looking for anything Andrew might have written about the Shaker Hostel. Andrew was both creative and well-organized, bless him. He had crammed both sides of the bookcases to the brim with ledger books and journals. Some he’d identified with carefully printed labels on the spines, some were plain. She skimmed over the titles and grabbed one that said “Shaker Hostel.” She turned the pages quickly. Numerous pages outlined Andrew’s plans for renovating the West Dwelling House. He’d listed sources within the village for furniture, plates, cutlery, kitchen equipment—they’d had to purchase little from the world to complete the project.
Finally she came to his notes about the first set of guests. Andrew had said there wasn’t much information about them, and he’d been right. However, he’d scratched some notes that might be helpful. All the guests had approached him by telephone, and he’d jotted down bits of the conversation. Andrew’s handwriting was clear and legible. She took some blank paper and began to copy.
Horace von Oswald had been the first to call, early in February. Andrew had noted that his call arrived the very day the first advertisement had appeared in the major Kentucky papers; therefore, Horace might have been staying somewhere nearby. Andrew’s notes said: Well-to-do, no permanent job, likes to experience new places. Sounds well-educated. Asked about transport to Languor. Mentions plain living, wholesome food. Asked if worship service public. Knows about us??
No one else called until early March, when the second set of advertisements hit the newspapers, this time in Ohio and Indiana, as well as Kentucky. Saul Halvardson was next to inquire about a room. Andrew had written: Salesman, ladies’ personal garments. Travels often through Kentucky and points south. Wants a place to rest between sales trips. He asked if women would be allowed to the share the building. Asked if furniture authentic—odd.
Mina Dunmore had called next, followed closely by Beatrice Berg. According to Andrew, Mrs. Dunmore had asked several questions about the community. He had written: Widow, small inheritance. Needs inexpensive but safe place to stay for a time. Asked who was elder, eldress? How many buildings? Location? Beatrice Berg had been brief: Needs job, place to live. I said we needed housekeeper who can cook, send refs. Andrew had noted to the side that she’d never sent references, but she’d arrived early and demonstrated that she could handle the old kitchen equipment. Andrew’s final cryptic note about Beatrice said: Asked—isolated?
Daisy Prescott had been the last to call, just two days before the hostel opened. She’d said little. Andrew had written: Wants vacation. Concerned safety. Soft-spoken.
Rose turned the page and discovered that Andrew had listed questions for each guest to answer upon arrival. He’d requested a home or last address; telephone number, if available; and source of income, to ensure payment. He’d noted that each had paid for a two-week stay, in advance. She copied down all the information. Horace had given an address in the village of Birdhill, in southern Ohio. Beatrice listed a boardinghouse in Languor; Rose knew the proprietor. Saul and Mina gave Lexington addresses, and Daisy cited Indianapolis as her last address. Everyone except Saul had listed phone numbers; she’d start with those.
She tidied the desk and gathered up her papers. Breakfast would be ending soon, and she was hungry. She missed the days when she could slip into the Trustees’ Office kitchen and grab some bread and cheese. She’d swing by the Center Family Dwelling House kitchen and beg some leftovers from Sister Gertrude, then sequester herself in the now empty Ministry House library. The phone hadn’t yet been disconnected, so she could make her calls in private.
“Landsakes, you’re just going to waste away if you keep missing meals like this,” said Sister Gertrude, as she hacked off a thick slice of bread and wrapped it in a towel with a hunk of cheese.
“I expect I’ll survive,” Rose said, laughing. “I can’t stay away from your recipes for long. That dill potato soup I tasted the other night at the hostel was superb.”
Gertrude beamed. “Tonight I’m using basil and some of our canned tomatoes to make soup.”
“Sounds delicious.” Rose stowed the bundle of food in her apron pocket and hurried out the kitchen door to avoid an extended conversation, Gertrude’s specialty. Careful to avoid bruising the young oregano plants, Rose cut through the kitchen garden and between the Infirmary and Laundry. She had almost reached the Ministry House when she heard her name called by a high, frantic voice. She turned and saw Nora, Mairin’s best friend, running toward her.
“Sister Rose, please, you’ve got to come right away.” Nora ran right up to her and clamped her small hands on Rose’s wrist. “Please, now.”
“What’s wrong, Nora?”
“It’s Mairin. You’ve got to come. I can’t—oh, just follow me, please. It’s really important.” Her voice squeaked with frustration and fear. Rose didn’t ask any more questions until they’d reached the Children’s Dwelling House.
“Aren’t you both supposed to be in school?” Rose asked.
Nora ran into the dwelling house without responding or even waiting for Rose to catch up. By the time Rose got through the door, Nora was halfway up the staircase to the second floor, where the children’s retiring rooms were located. Rose followed as fast as she could. She reached the second floor, but Nora was already heading for the third floor, where no one lived. Rose had given Mairin permission to keep her kitten in one of the empty third-floor rooms, to keep it warm and safe but away from the rest of the children. One of the girls being raised by the Shakers had breathing problems, and cats seemed to make them worse.
Nora scurried down the hallway, and, to Rose’s surprise, passed right by the room Mairin had been given for her kitten. At the far end of the hall was a narrow staircase that led to a small attic, where the children’s out-of-season clothing was stored. Nora turned and beckoned to Rose to hurry. She clambered up the attic stairs and disappeared. Rose climbed the stairs more sedately, having worn herself out.
At the top of the staircase, Nora paused and waited for Rose. Nora took her hand and led her into the attic room. A high window provided minimal light, since it hadn’t been cleaned in some time. As they approached a dark corner, Rose heard a tiny cry, which she now recognized as the mew of a kitten.
“Mairin?” Rose asked. “Is that you? What on earth are you doing up here? Are you all right?”
A gasp and a sob joined the kitten’s mew. Rose pushed aside a row of winter dresses hung on a horizontal pole. Mairin crouched in the corner, curled against the wall as tightly as a ball of yarn. She held the calico kitten against her shoulder, one hand on its back to keep it from escaping.
“Dear one, what has happened?” Rose knelt on the dusty floor and reached toward Mairin. She expected to be rebuffed. In all the troubled times she and Mairin had shared, she had never heard the child cry with such anguish. In fact, she rarely showed emotion at all. But this time she scrabbled to her knees and threw herself into Rose’s arms, wedging the panicked kitten between them.
Rose extracted the kitten and handed her to Nora, then folded Mairin in her arms. She murmured soothing words and stroked the girl’s disheveled curls. Mairin sobbed until she began to hiccup. Rose tried to ease Mairin away a few inches, to see her face, but the child clung to her.
Rose gave up and whispered in Mairin’s ear, “Can you tell me what has happened?”
For several moments, Mairin’s small body remained rigid. Then she pulled back and looked at Rose. Her eyes were red and puffy, and she had the exhausted look of a child at the end of her endurance. She hiccupped and said, “I have to show you.”
“All right, then. Can you do it now, or do you need to wait awhile longer?”
“We can’t wait.” Mairin cast a worried glance in Nora’s direction. “I’ve got to keep Angel safe,” she said. “I’m afraid she’ll get hurt.” She squirmed out of Rose’s grip and reached for the kitten. “She’s got to stay with me. I have to protect her.”
“What if you and I take Nora and Angel to Sister Agatha’s retiring room. Will that be safe enough?”
Mairin bit her lower lip. “Okay, but they have to stay there until I get back.”
“Agreed,” said Rose.
By the time they’d left Nora and the kitten in Agatha’s care, Mairin seemed her old self again, though subdued. Rose’s heart was pumping with anxiety. Mairin was not a child who allowed much to penetrate her outer reserve. Mairin stared straight ahead, her face set in grim lines, as she led the way across the lawn toward the abandoned South Family Dwelling House. She paused at the cellar door, then seemed to change her mind and led Rose around the side of the building. They arrived at the sisters’ entrance. Mairin took Rose’s hand and stood in front of the door.
“Should we go in?” Rose asked.
Mairin nodded, but still held back. Fear clamped down on Rose’s throat, constricting her breathing. The child seemed terrified.
“Couldn’t you just tell me what to look for?” Rose asked. “Then you could stay out here and wait for me.”
“Nay,” Mairin said, “I’ll take you.”
Rose had the distinct impression that Mairin was protecting her. She held the girl’s hand more tightly and pushed the door open. Mairin stepped in first. When Rose pulled the door shut behind her, the hallway seemed alive with eerie movement. But it was only swirling dust caught in the sunlight. She was allowing her imagination far too much freedom. It was entirely possible that someone was playing at haunting the village, for some unknown reason, and Mairin had found some evidence of the deception. That would surely upset the girl, who had come to believe the ghost was her guardian angel.
Rose followed Mairin through the hallway and downstairs to the kitchen. From the kitchen, another short stairway led down to the root cellar, where Mairin had spent so much secret time—and where she had hidden her kitten. The dank, earthen smell had become familiar to Rose, but she didn’t find it pleasant. She couldn’t understand why Mairin was so drawn to the place.
A narrow dirt passageway led all the way to the cellar door. Small storage rooms branched out on either side of the hallway. Mairin stopped at the first entrance on their left, across from the room in which she’d hidden her kitten. She stood in the opening, still and silent. The cavelike room was in near total darkness, so Rose took a step inside. Mairin squeezed her hand as if to stop her, then let go. Rose entered without her. The room’s packed earth walls were lined with strong, wide shelves that once had been filled with canned goods. As Rose’s eyes adjusted to the dimness, she saw a bundle of clothing on one of the lower shelves at the far end of the room. So she’d been right—this was the ghost’s dressing room.
Eagerly, she approached the bundle and knelt on the dirt floor. She reached out to grab it, but the fabric did not give. With instant certainty, she knew what she had touched. Someone was inside those clothes. Someone who did not respond to noise or to touch. No skin was visible because a wool jacket had been draped over the body’s head and arms. Behind Rose, Mairin whimpered. For her sake, Rose kept her own reactions under firm control. Though she wanted to leap back, she forced herself to lift the jacket and look underneath.
Open eyes stared back at her. They did not see her, of course. They would never see again. She had found Brother Linus Eckhoff.
Rose dropped the jacket back over his face and stood. She kept her back to Mairin for several moments while she tried to compose herself. Then she scooped Mairin into her arms and didn’t put her down until they were out in the sunshine.
“I’m so very sorry you had to see that, little one,” Rose said, as they put some distance between themselves and the dwelling house. “I’m going to take you right to Agatha’s retiring room. I want you to tell her everything, okay? Will you promise me that?”
“Okay, I promise.” Mairin pulled ahead, clearly eager to get to the comfort of Agatha’s presence.
“I have to call the police, so I must leave you with Agatha.”
“Okay.”
Rose wished that she, too, could curl up at Agatha’s feet, but her duty lay elsewhere. One of her Children had been murdered.