CHAPTER 63
Manhattan, NY Sunday, July 11, 2021
THE TWO FEDERAL AGENTS PULLED TO THE CURB IN FRONT OF THE judge’s residence early Sunday morning and climbed from the car. The female agent wore slacks and a blazer, and just like when the two hiked through the mountains of Lake Placid earlier in the week, she was in charge. Her partner, wearing a crisp gray suit, followed her to the front door. He limped slightly from his blisters. Sunday mornings, the agents knew, were a time for coffee and newspapers before the judge headed to church with his family. Their presence would not be well received, but there was simply no more time to wait.
The female agent knocked on the front door and a moment later Judge Marcus Harris opened it. The judge was wearing a T-shirt and work-out shorts. Open-toed slippers covered his feet, and a look of annoyance covered his face.
“Good morning, sir. I’m special agent Mary Sullivan. This is my partner, James Martin.”
“Is this really necessary on a Sunday morning?” the judge asked.
“I’m afraid it is, sir.”
The Federal Bureau of Investigation had a bead on one of its most wanted white-collar criminals, and years of searching had finally produced his whereabouts. Waiting for Monday morning and office hours and chambers time was not an option.
Judge Harris waved them both through the door. “Come on. Let’s see what you have. I’m leaving for church in an hour.”
Ten minutes later, the judge’s kitchen island was covered with the surveillance photos the agents had taken of the Lake Placid cabin, including a couple of long-range shots through the windows that captured the hazy figure inside. For thirty minutes the agents presented their evidence to the judge, who sipped coffee as he listened. They took him through the operation and brought the judge up to speed on the Bureau’s hunt for Garth Montgomery, and how they had, just this week, turned over the most damning evidence yet that convinced them the fugitive was hiding in the cabin featured in the photographs.
“Listen, Agent Sullivan,” Judge Harris said, “it’s a compelling case, and the Bureau should be applauded for the hard work it’s put in on this. But in order for me to sign off on a warrant, I’m going to need more than hazy photos of an unrecognizable figure in that cabin. I’ll need proof that it’s Garth Montgomery before I permit a SWAT team to crash through the front door.”
“We have it, sir,” Agent Sullivan said. “These”—she gestured at the photos on the kitchen island—“were just to show you that we’ve put in the legwork. This is our proof.”
Agent Sullivan removed her phone.
“Jim Oliver met with Claire Montgomery, Garth Montgomery’s daughter, on Friday afternoon. She provided us with proof that her father had attempted to contact her with a postcard that revealed his location. This was confirmed by a phone call she made to her father at the Lake Placid cabin. A call that she recorded herself and then delivered to the Bureau, on her own and without coercion.”
Agent Sullivan tapped her phone and Avery’s voice was heard.
Hello?
Dad? It’s me.
Claire?
Yes, it’s me.
You got the card. I knew you’d know what to do.
I have to see you, Dad. I don’t have a lot of time.
I’d love that. Where?
I’ll come to you. To the Lake Placid cabin. It’s safest that way.
When?
Sunday.
Okay.
Claire, I wanted to tell you—
Not over the phone, Dad. Get off the landline. I’ll see you Sunday.
Okay.
Agent Sullivan stopped the recording. “We know Garth Montgomery is at that cabin, and we know he’s there today. Tomorrow, he might not be.”
Judge Harris put his coffee down and flicked his index finger at her.
“Give me the warrant. I’ll sign it.”