On Saturday morning, Jim came back, and he was much more friendly this time than he had been the night before. In fact, over the course of the next few days we became like old friends. It is strange how quickly you bond with people in incredibly difficult circumstances.
The police issued us with a password, in case the press or anyone else got hold of the story and tried to get more information out of us over the phone. Bizarrely, our password was Wonga – apparently, it was the first thing Jim and his ‘guvnor’ had seen in the newspaper that morning. Soon after, I got a call from Detective Chief Inspector Jason Tingley but I refused to talk to him until I heard the magic password. I knew he was probably who he said he was, but I needed to make sure …
DCI Tingley, now armed with the right password, called us back and later came over with a colleague, Detective Inspector Andy Harbour. They arrived at about 8pm and I sat in the kitchen with Paul, Max and my eldest sister Annette as the officers recounted what they knew. They explained that the CCTV images that P&O Ferries had provided were now with the police and a European arrest warrant was being prepared. Trouble was, it would need to be put before a senior judge in order for it to be authorised, and that couldn’t happen until Monday morning at the earliest. That meant that if Gemma and Forrest didn’t return on the Sunday night, they wouldn’t be able to arrest him in France until Monday at the earliest.
They also explained to me how MI5 and the Serious Organised Crime Unit were advising Sussex Police, and how Interpol, the International Criminal Police Organisation, would assist with the investigation, acting as a go-between for the police forces in the UK and Europe. To be honest, I don’t think I took it all in: all I wanted to know was how long it was going to take to bring my daughter back.
Annette and Max then started going on and on about the lack of support that the school had given us. It was then that I was broken out of my trance. I remember sitting there in utter disbelief at the conversation they were having.
Suddenly, I snapped. ‘Will you two shut up! I don’t care what your thoughts or views are, this is not helping. The only person I want to hear speak is Chief Inspector Tingley!’ Having a debate about it wasn’t going to get Gemma back.
At that point I didn’t care what the school did or didn’t do. I was just hanging on every word that Jason Tingley had to say. It wasn’t until the next day, when it actually dawned on me what I had done, that I apologised for my outburst. I was ashamed about how I had reacted.
Jason explained that if Gemma and Forrest arrived back on the 10pm ferry, the police would be waiting there to arrest him on suspicion of abduction. They could do this as soon as they were back in the UK, but they couldn’t do anything in France without the European arrest warrant. Once they had arrested Forrest, Gemma would then be taken into protective custody. She wouldn’t be under arrest herself, as she had done nothing wrong.
Until then, he said, we just had to be patient …
The next call I got was from the Sussex Police media department. With all the text messages and tweets that our family and friends had been putting out, our local newspaper, the Eastbourne Herald, had got hold of the story. To make matters worse, some other children at school had obviously put two and two together, and there were some Facebook messages going round, saying that Gemma had run off with Forrest.
The media department wanted to issue an official statement and take control of the situation. Max gave them a quote and, before we knew it, a story about Gemma appeared on the BBC News website …
Missing schoolgirl XXXX XXXX thought to be in France The parents of a 15-year-old East Sussex girl who is believed to have gone to France with a man she knows have urged her to contact them.
XXXX XXXX, from Eastbourne, was reported missing when she failed to turn up for school on Friday.
Sussex Police said she was spotted later using a Dover to Calais ferry.
Detectives named the man thought to be with XXXX as Jeremy Forrest, 30, from Ringmer, near Lewes, who was driving a Ford Fiesta, registration GJ08 RJO.
The teenager’s father, XXXX, said: ‘We just want XXXX to make contact with us. We are worried and miss her terribly – please get in touch XXXX.’
Det Insp Andy Harbour from Sussex Police said: ‘We do not believe XXXX to be at risk but we are appealing for her to make contact with her family, who are very worried and miss her.
‘We know that she crossed from Dover to Calais at around 21:20 BST [on Friday]. We believe she is still in France and we are in contact with the French authorities.’
He urged anyone with information about her disappearance to contact the police.
XXXX is said to be 5ft 6ins, slim and has long dark brown hair. She was last seen wearing a white vest top and a silver necklace.
Once the story was out there, it spread like wildfire. I was quite naïve when it came to social media; I had only ever used Facebook for sharing pictures with my friends and family and had never used Twitter before. Max was much more techie, however, and by Sunday morning social media was going crazy with the story. Paul worked out how to set up a Twitter account and Lee and Maddie kept us up to date with everything they saw on Facebook.
Someone put up a post saying that Gemma had been abducted and I remember feeling sick to my stomach. That word had never been used before and seeing it written down made the situation even more frightening.
At some point I remember Lee telling us he had found a song that Forrest had posted on his blog under the name Jeremy Ayre and that people on social media were saying he had written it for Gemma. Lee wanted us to listen to it, but I couldn’t face it. I just hoped that the press wouldn’t pick up on it and make a story out of it.
Max had been looking after Alfie, but Monday was going to be his first day at school, so he brought him back to the house in the afternoon. I was determined that Alfie wasn’t going to know what was happening. We told him that his big sister had gone to stay at her nan’s, which wasn’t unusual, as she often did.
Once I had tucked Alfie up in bed and settled Lilly, it was strange and eerily quiet in the house. Paul, Jim and I sat in the kitchen, drinking tea and watching the clock. Every so often, I would catch someone glancing up at the clock: we were all waiting for 10pm to come around.
It was the longest evening ever, but there really was nothing to do but wait. And wait. The clock was moving more slowly than ever. At one point, I even thought it was going backwards. It was unbearable.
Jim tried his best to keep our spirits up, reassuring us that the police would notify us the minute that the passenger lists had been checked on the ferry.
Ten pm came. No call. 10.05pm. No call. Then at 10.15pm, the phone rang. Jim walked into the hall and pulled the door behind him as Paul and I held each other and waited for him to come back in with good news.
A few minutes later, he walked back in, shaking his head: they weren’t on the ferry. They were missing. At that point I allowed myself to cry. I completely broke down and fell into Paul’s arms, sobbing. My heart had literally been broken and every shred of emotion that I’d been holding back started flooding out.
I began blaming myself for everything that had happened. If only I’d listened to Gemma more … If only I hadn’t screamed and shouted at her because of that phone call from Forrest … If only I hadn’t said she could stay at Louise’s … It was all my fault. I have lived with that guilt ever since and I’ve had counselling to try and come to terms with it, but no amount of sessions will ever shed the guilt.
I was inconsolable. Paul and Jim tried to comfort me and insisted that I was not to blame in any shape or form, but it was all too much. I felt physically sick and sobbed my heart out. Then anger took over. I was filled with fury for that bastard. How dare Forrest do this to her? How could he ruin her life like this? What right did he have to take my daughter, to even be near her?
It was around this time that we discovered that the national papers were also interested in the story and had been trying to get more information out of Sussex Police. I was later to discover that the newspapers scour local websites for any stories that they can pick up on. In this case, The Sun was the first on the case.
We knew that the story was likely to be all over the papers the following day. My friend Chloe was due back from holiday in the early hours, so we sent her a text message asking her to pick up the first editions of all the newspapers at the airport when she arrived. My heart sank when she called me a few hours later: ‘You’re in all of the papers!’ I insisted she read out every single story that had been written about Gemma. She said it was bizarre standing in the middle of Gatwick, reading out stories about a person she knew, but then nothing about this situation was exactly normal.
Each of the papers had put their own spin on the story, but basically they repeated what had been on the BBC News website. Luckily, the police hadn’t revealed that Forrest was a teacher at Gemma’s school, so that crucial piece of information was missing from those early stories.
By the time the later editions came out, though, they had unearthed more details. Suddenly we were faced with headlines such as MARRIED TEACHER ON RUN WITH PUPIL and YOU HIT ME LIKE HEROIN, which we later discovered was a line from the song that Forrest had apparently written for Gemma. There were pictures of Gemma in her school uniform, pictures of Forrest and his wife on their wedding day, pictures of the school …
My private life had suddenly become very public.