It had been almost a week since the arrests of Joseph, Simeon, and Samuel. Caleb had not seen Judah again. According to Judah’s sister, he had left Jerusalem on an urgent family matter, and it was uncertain when he would return. Caleb knew this was untrue, though he did not know if Judah’s sister knew this or if Judah had actually left the city. As far as Caleb knew, there had been no additional arrests, and he had not heard any rumors of soldiers looking around for additional conspirators. The people expected Roman authorities to punish these men soon, though most believed they would not do so until after the Passover.
The arrests had increased the tension in the city. People claimed that such seemingly insignificant men with no history of violence could not actually be responsible for the deaths of five Roman soldiers. Most believed that these men were peripheral at best to the attack, and that Roman authorities had arrested them in an attempt to find the true culprits.
Since the day of the arrests, Caleb’s soul had been conflicted. At times he felt extreme guilt, but at other times he was able to justify his actions and assuage his conscience. Today—at least for this moment—he was living in the latter. No doubt this first day of the Passover week, a beautiful spring day, helped. The city streets were bustling with activity, and excitement was in the air. While some pilgrims had arrived earlier, this was generally the day of arrival for most traveling to the city to celebrate the festival. The city with a population of approximately sixty thousand people would swell to almost three hundred thousand. While this influx of people certainly caused headaches for the city rulers and officials, it brought great energy and excitement for the common people. A majority of those making pilgrimage had family and friends in the city, and therefore this was a time of reunion and celebration.
Caleb himself had many friends arriving whom he was eager to see again. He also had family that he would be hosting in his own home: his aunt, Elizabeth, along with her son, Jacob, and daughter, Mary. Jacob was a year older than Caleb, and Mary was a year younger than his sister Miriam. Their families had been extremely close, but Elizabeth and her children moved to Damascus when she remarried after the death of her first husband. They always returned to Jerusalem for the Passover and stayed through the Feast of Weeks, a celebration of firstfruits and the giving of the Torah, held fifty days later. Because of his responsibilities in Damascus, Elizabeth’s second husband rarely made the trip with them.
Jacob and Caleb had grown up like brothers and were inseparable throughout their youth. They both worked in the pottery shop, and Caleb’s father took care of his sister’s family up until her remarriage. When they moved it was hard on Caleb, who lost his closest friend. It also made the death of Caleb’s father, only one year later, much harder. Though the distance had been difficult, the two regularly corresponded and usually saw each other at least twice a year. Their relationship was one on which time and distance seemed to have no effect. With this reunion in front of him, he couldn’t allow himself to be mired in guilt.
He closed the shop at noon. After a quick lunch with Miriam, they headed out to greet their family. The march of pilgrims into the city was exciting. Many pilgrims would sing and dance, and those at the gates waiting for family usually joined in as a group approached the city entrance—whether they knew them or not! Even for those who did not join in, the sight of family and friends reuniting was a joyous one.
As was their tradition, Caleb would meet Jacob and his family at the Shushan Gate on the eastern side of the city, across from the Mount of Olives. Travelers from the north would usually come south along the Jordan River to Jericho before turning west toward Jerusalem. They would pass through the village of Bethany, come down the Mount of Olives into the Kidron Valley, and then ascend Mount Zion, where Jerusalem’s glorious temple sat.
The current temple was the result of a massive remodeling of the one originally built by the Jewish leader Zerubbabel after the return from Babylonian exile five hundred years earlier. The remodel was undertaken by the late Roman client king, Herod “the Great,” whose sons, Herod Antipas and Philip, still ruled on Rome’s behalf in northern Israel. While he was a paranoid despot, Herod’s acumen for building was undeniable. The remodeling of the Jerusalem temple was, without question, his magnum opus. Before Rome granted Herod power in the region, Zerubbabel’s temple was nothing special to behold. It was a shell of the earlier temple built by King Solomon on the same site, Mount Zion (at times called Mount Moriah). Both had occupied only a fraction of the mountaintop. But in order to gain favor with the people and recognition for himself, Herod began a massive building program, turning the entire mountain into a platform for the temple to stand on.
While the people of Jerusalem hated Herod, they loved the temple he had built them. Every Jew in the city knew its dimensions. The enormous retaining wall around the Temple Mount was 1600 feet north to south and 900 feet east to west. The walls were a hundred feet at their highest point and sixteen feet thick. And its stones—oh, those great stones of the retaining wall! Caleb could hear the words of his father when he was just a young boy: “Five hundred tons, my son! Nothing could shake a foundation stone that size!”
The retaining wall was impressive, but the true beauty was the temple that sat within it. It was made of marble that glistened beautifully in the sunlight, as did the ornate golden overlays that adorned it. At times the beauty was almost blinding—as if the glory of Israel’s God was emanating from within. It was not quite centered on the Temple Mount but sat a bit to the north. It ran 480 feet east to west and 200 feet north to south, standing fifty feet at its highest point.
Most of the Temple Mount consisted of a massive open courtyard that was not technically a part of the temple itself. This courtyard was named the “court of the Gentiles” because it was open to anyone, Jews as well as Gentiles. Separating the court of the Gentiles from the temple proper was a fifteen-foot wall with multiple gates. Only Jews who had undergone proper purification could pass through these gates. The wall was engraved with warnings in both Greek and Aramaic that any Gentile or unclean Jew who passed through the gates would be sentenced to death. For this crime—and this crime alone— did the Roman governor grant Jews the power over life and death.
The Shushan Gate, where Caleb and Miriam were headed, was named after the capital city of Persia. This name honored the nation that allowed the Jews to return to their ancestral home and rebuild their temple. The gate depicted, ever so ornately, the royal palace of that great city. For this reason, it was often referred to as the “Beautiful Gate.” Through this gate one would enter directly into the outer courtyard of the temple, the court of the Gentiles. Consequently, to reach this gate from inside the city, one had to enter the western side of the Temple Mount and cross the entire courtyard.
As Caleb expected, the outer courtyard and its beautiful porticoes were bustling with activity. Newly arrived pilgrims were exchanging their Greek and Roman currency for that which was acceptable for use in the temple. That currency was then used to buy animals for sacrifice, food from local vendors, souvenirs from local artisans, and even payment for guided tours of the temple grounds. Some complained that the exchange rate was unfair, a complaint that Caleb knew on occasion had merit. But he was also a businessman and knew that the temple had expenses beyond what most could likely imagine. While some complained, most understood this to be the business of the temple. Priests of varying ranks were also moving about the area directing traffic, answering questions, and facilitating regular temple tasks. The increased number of people meant a need for additional priests.
Making their way through the hustle and bustle took a while. They declined at least five offers for a guided tour of either the temple or city. Twice Miriam stopped to admire the work of another potter and ask about sculpting techniques, both times causing Caleb to think he had lost her in the crowd. After the second time he snapped at her, saying they didn’t want to miss their family’s arrival. To this she simply smiled, told him to relax, and that they had plenty of time. This response only frustrated him more. He hated when she pointed out how uptight he could be—more often than not, she was right. And she turned out to be right again. They arrived at the gate at least an hour before their family arrived. Thankfully, Miriam didn’t rub it in.
The early arrival gave them a chance to enjoy watching the pilgrims coming up the road singing and dancing. They knew each song, and they sang them with all gathered there—songs of God’s faithfulness, his holy dwelling, and his deliverance. While Caleb’s faith had waned of late, he couldn’t help but sing these songs he had known since he was a child. Watching the reunion of family and friends was good for his soul: the kisses and embraces, the old jokes followed by laughter, the grandparents meeting grandchildren for the first time, and the tears of joy that accompanied it all. He loved his people, and he loved how much they loved each other. Caleb even joined some of these reunions as he recognized friends arriving to the city.
While caught up in one of these reunions, Caleb noticed a commotion brewing around him. Many people were speaking excitedly and moving to the front of the gate. Miriam pulled on his arm. “Come on Caleb, we need to see this. The prophet from Galilee is coming!” He suddenly understood, and together they worked their way to the front of the gate—not an easy task.
At first, Caleb saw a large crowd of people on the road moving across the Kidron Valley toward the city. The crowd was at least a hundred, maybe more. It grew as he watched, with some people running down from the city to join it and others catching up with it from behind. They were singing and shouting, but from this distance Caleb couldn’t make out what the people were saying.
As the crowd drew closer, he made out a man at the center who was riding what looked to be a horse. The people near him were taking off their coats and laying them down in front of him. Others were waving what looked like palm branches and laying them down along with the cloaks. The striking scene reminded Caleb of the stories he had heard about the great deliverer, Simeon Maccabeus, entering the city of Jerusalem. Was this really happening?
As the crowd drew closer, it became clear that the man was riding not a horse but a donkey. He could finally hear what the crowd was saying. The most dominant sound was the chanting of “Hosanna”—a declaration of coming salvation! But others were shouting, “Hail the Son of David,” “Blessed be the coming kingdom of David,” and “Blessed is the king who comes in the name of the Lord!” He couldn’t believe what was happening! This prophet was entering the city as a king, as a conquering messiah and deliverer of Jerusalem!
While others were rushing to join the crowd, Caleb slowly stepped back. Dread filled him. He looked around and saw four Roman soldiers stationed at the gate, frantically talking with each other. As he watched them, two remained at the gate while two ran in the direction of the Antonia fortress, which was adjacent to the northern retaining wall of the Temple Mount. It was the headquarters of Roman military power in Jerusalem. The remaining two soldiers made no movement but stood tensely, watching the crowd move closer. A number of others looked shocked and afraid, with some deciding to leave the scene altogether.
Caleb’s mind was racing. What did this mean? What would be the consequence? He expected at any moment to see more Roman soldiers storming to the gate to bring this display to an end and arrest Jesus. But none came.
The crowd was a mere thirty feet away now, and he could see Jesus clearly. He was smiling and touching the hands of those who reached out to greet him. He wore the common robes of a peasant. He bore no special decoration, nor did he appear to be carrying any sort of weapon. His face was weathered, but not old in appearance. He had an unkempt beard that could not conceal a warm smile. His eyes were kind and his face warm and sincere. He seemed unconcerned about the political gravity of the situation that surrounded him. When he was about ten feet from the gate, he signaled two men to help him dismount from the donkey. They led the animal back down the road away from the city. The crowd pressed in on him and swallowed him up as it moved through the gate into the outer courtyard of the temple.
Caleb was startled by someone grabbing his shoulders and shouting his name over the noise of the crowd. The sight of his cousin Jacob jolted him out of his concern for the Galilean prophet, reminding him of the reason he was at the Shushan Gate. The joy and excitement of seeing Jacob overcame the dread in his heart. They embraced, kissed each other on the cheek, and exchanged warm words of greeting. As they were doing so, Miriam suddenly appeared with Aunt Elizabeth and Cousin Mary. It was a joyful and happy reunion.
“When did you arrive?” asked Caleb. “I didn’t see you coming up the road.”
“We were in the crowd with the prophet Jesus!” Cousin Mary replied.
“You likely saw us coming, then, even if you didn’t!” said Jacob with a smile, followed by a laugh.
The fact that his family was a part of this dramatic entrance quickly sobered Caleb, though he tried not to let his face reveal his concern. It was awkward to suddenly realize that those he loved most dearly held a surprisingly different perspective than his own. Trying to hide his concern and surprise, Caleb replied, “Ah, so you were a part of the dramatic entrance? No wonder I didn’t see you in all that commotion!”
“Wasn’t it all so exciting?!” asked Mary.
“It most certainly was!” replied Miriam—a response that surprised Caleb, but he wasn’t sure why. “Did you travel with him all the way from the north?” his sister asked excitedly.
“Oh, no,” said Jacob. “We first saw him with his followers in Jericho four days ago. As you know, we always stay there a day or two with my father’s kin. When we arrived, we heard rumors that the prophet Jesus had arrived in Jericho that same day and would be teaching in the synagogue the following morning. We had heard of him even in Damascus, yet he had never been there. We were eager to hear him, so we decided to get up early to go to the synagogue. And it is a good thing we arrived early, as it seemed the entire town had the same idea. The synagogue was filled to capacity with an overflow surrounding it!”
“But it was worth it!” said Mary. “He was wonderful! His words were kind and gracious and spoken with such charisma. He spoke passionately of a new age about to dawn for God’s people and a new work that God would soon be doing in this world—work that would bring justice and peace to the poor and the longsuffering. The kingdom of God is near, he said, and people need to prepare their hearts for it by forgiving one another, sharing with those in need, and extending compassion to those on the margins of our community. The kingdom of God is open to all who embrace it, he said!”
“It was truly powerful, my cousin,” said Jacob with deep sincerity. “I was not sure what to expect, as I had heard so many different rumors. But the way he spoke and the things he said moved my spirit deeply. He never openly claimed to be the one God had sent, but the way he spoke seemed to claim it with every word. Many who heard him felt the same way, though there were some prominent Pharisees who were deeply offended by him. Apparently, the night before he had celebrated a dinner at the home of a chief tax collector, which must have put them off. If I am honest, to hear that he was the guest of such a person was off-putting to me at first. But when I heard him the following morning, it all seemed to make sense.”
Caleb’s mind was trying to take all this in. “So, did you stay with him from that point on?”
“No,” his aunt replied. “Apparently, he left the city the next day, early in the morning. We heard he wanted to reach Bethany before the Sabbath—”
“But we were able to join him and his group when we went through Bethany this morning,” Mary interrupted. “Jacob asked one of his disciples if we could travel with them the short distance to Jerusalem, and he welcomed us. And as you saw, we were not the only ones! Many others wanted to join us as we were leaving. The group got larger and larger as we got closer to the city gate!”
“Did he ride on the donkey all the way from Bethany?” Caleb asked.
“Yes,” Jacob replied. “Two men brought it to him right before he left. I think they were from among his closest disciples.”
“So he arranged to enter the city on a donkey?” asked Caleb, incredulity in his voice.
“Yes!” both Mary and Jacob replied.
“Did he also instruct people to wave branches and place their cloaks in front of him?”
“Of course not!” replied his aunt. “That just, well . . . well it just started to happen, I guess. Why so many questions, Caleb?”
“I . . . well . . .” Caleb stammered. “I am just curious, I guess. It was quite a spectacle, and I guess . . . well, I guess I am just trying to understand it all. What does it mean? This man entered the city like one of the great Maccabean conquerors to shouts of ‘salvation’ and declarations that he is God’s appointed deliverer.” They all looked back at him, nodding and affirming what he had just said. He stared blankly, stunned they were not more worried about what they had just taken part in.
“Isn’t it all so exciting?” exclaimed Mary.
“Exciting?” Caleb asked. “Well, it certainly created a lot of excitement yes, but . . . but . . .”
“But what?” asked Elizabeth with a look of confusion on her face.
“But it is also dangerous, isn’t it?” Caleb asked cautiously. “As he was coming near the gate, two Roman soldiers ran off toward the Antonia. I half expected them to return with two hundred more, arrest the prophet, and disband the crowd.”
There was a moment’s pause as his family thought about what he had just said. Jacob broke the silence. “Yes, I guess in the back of my mind I knew that what we were doing, and what he was doing, was dangerous in a way. But in the moment, it just didn’t seem to matter. After I heard him teach and watched him, escorting him into the city in that way just seemed right, and so . . . so I joined in.”
“Yes, I think that says it all quite well,” said Elizabeth. “We will do what we must, and the Romans will do what they must!” she added defiantly.
Those words sent a chill through Caleb, who couldn’t hide his surprise at his aunt’s response. “I am not sure you are thinking this through to its likely conclusion. I fear what the presence of this prophet will do to our city.”
Jacob took him by his shoulders and looked him in the eye. “My cousin, have faith. If he is God’s anointed, all will be well. If he is not, God will make that clear. Do not fear—rely on your faith!”
Caleb caught a quick glance from his sister, who was aware that he had not yet expressed his recent doubts to his cousin and closest friend. Now was certainly not the time. Caleb sought a way to end this awkward exchange, thinking that perhaps with this visit it would be harder to pick things up where they last left off. “Yes. Yes, of course you are right, Jacob. My curiosity and worry got the best of me. Our God must be trusted,” he forced himself to say. He wanted to get them out of temple grounds as quickly as he could. “Now let’s get you and your things back to the house. It is time to settle in and take some refreshment. There is much to catch up on!”
As they began to exit the gate, they saw a large crowd gathered and a great commotion in the direction he and his sister had initially come from. Wanting to stay away from any more excitement caused by the prophet, Caleb turned in the opposite direction, saying, “It’s less crowded this way. It will make for a quicker route home.” The others followed, though they found themselves going against the flow of traffic moving toward the great commotion behind them.
Caleb couldn’t get off the Temple Mount fast enough. He would now have plenty of information to share with his contact, though he rightly guessed that the public nature of these events undermined his chance of presenting anything new.
Cheers went up behind him as he and his family finally reached an exit from the Temple Mount. While the others looked back, he did not want to know what had happened and urged them forward.
Eleazar was in the temple scheduling priestly duties for the coming week when he was interrupted by loud knocking on the door of his private chambers. Startled and annoyed, he opened the door to see a wide-eyed and frantic young Levite named Malachi standing before him, saying nothing. “Is something the matter, Malachi? Why have you come? What is wrong?”
“It, it’s . . .” he stammered.
“What is it, boy? Loosen your tongue!”
“The . . . the . . . the prophet Jesus, sir, he . . . he has arrived!” said Malachi nervously.
“He is here in the city? When did he arrive?” Eleazar was surprised by this news.
“Just now, sir. He hadn’t even made it to the gate before I ran to tell you.” Malachi still could not seem to catch his breath or gather his wits.
“All right, thank you for informing me, Malachi. Though I am not sure his mere arrival is worth bothering me in my private chambers. If his presence brings about any urgent news, let me know immediately.” Eleazar started to turn around, but to his surprise, Malachi grabbed his shoulder. This was not something a Levite would do a high-ranking priest, and it brought a flash of anger from Eleazar.
Malachi recoiled slightly but continued. “But . . . but, it already has, sir! His arrival itself, sir, and how he arrived, sir!”
“What do you mean? In what manner did he arrive?” It began to dawn on Eleazar that something serious might have already happened.
“As . . . as a king, sir! His entrance into the city was like that of a king, sir.” Fearing another flash of anger, Malachi flinched as he said these last words.
But his words did not bring anger—merely confusion. Eleazar was having a hard time wrapping his mind around what the Levite was saying. “What?! What do you mean he arrived as a king? I don’t understand.”
Malachi began to calm down. He took a moment to gather himself and then began to explain what he had witnessed. “He approached the city from Bethany, sir, intending to enter through the Beautiful Gate. But he approached the city riding on a donkey, sir, with a great crowd of people—hundreds of people—escorting him into the city. They placed cloaks and palm branches on the ground in front of him, and they were waving palm branches, as they were all shouting and cheering.”
The news was stunning. “What were they shouting, Malachi? Tell me!”
“They were crying out ‘Hosanna,’ sir, and calling this prophet a king, a son of David who would bring the kingdom of David. It reminded me of the stories I have heard about the Maccabees, sir. Jesus entered the city like the great conqueror Simeon, and the people acted like he was one.” It was obvious that the event had made quite an impression on Malachi, who remained wide-eyed in his recounting of it.
Apart from an outbreak of violence, this news was indeed as bad as Eleazar could imagine. His mind was racing. How would Pilate respond to this? Did he already know? Was he already preparing a violent response? He would have to get this news to his father, and quickly.
“Where is the prophet now, Malachi?”
“I don’t know sir,” Malachi replied. “I left the gate before he even entered the city, but I am sure he has entered by now. He may be in the temple courtyard, or he may have gone into the city itself.”
Eleazar realized that there was no time to lose; he must inform his father of this news immediately. “Go quickly and take this news to my father! He is at his home. Do it now, and don’t let anything delay you. Do you understand?”
“Yes, of course, sir!” Malachi replied.
He turned to leave, then turned back when Eleazar called his name. “You have done well to bring this to me immediately Malachi. I will not forget it.”
The Levite gave a nervous smile. “Yes, sir, thank you, sir.” He ran to tell Caiaphas.
Eleazar quickly left his private chambers and made his way out of the temple proper to the courtyard of the Gentiles. If the prophet was still here, he wanted to witness him with his own eyes and see what he was doing. As he exited the south side of the temple, he heard a great commotion and a roar of cheers. The source of the noise was a large crowd to his left, maybe fifty feet away. He moved in that direction, staying close to the dividing wall between the temple and the outer courtyard. Although he wanted to see what was happening, he did not want to draw attention to himself.
He saw a stirring in the middle of the crowd. Men were shouting, “Make room! Move back!” Slowly the people responded and the crowd began to part. Then from the crowd a man emerged, and Eleazar recognized him as the man he had seen a year or two before, teaching a small group of people near the pools of Bethesda—it was the prophet Jesus. He was of average height, about that of Eleazar himself. He had on the simple garments of a peasant. His hair was dark and curly, and he had a dark unkempt beard. He was altogether quite plain looking, with nothing in his physical appearance that seemed impressive or would set him apart from any other man in the crowd. How could such a simple-looking man be such a threat to the peace of this great city? Eleazar thought.
Jesus walked through the crowd into an open area in the courtyard. He appeared to be surveying the money changers, those selling animals, and those selling souvenirs. It seemed all eyes in the courtyard were upon him. Would he do something? Say something?
Suddenly he moved to the tables where people were exchanging Roman or Greek coins for Jewish or Tyrian coins. The people in line waiting to make their exchange watched Jesus closely, as did the money changers themselves. In one quick movement, he grabbed one of the tables and violently turned it over. Papers and coins went flying! All stared at the prophet in stunned silence, mouths gaping open. Without a moment’s hesitation, he turned to his right and flipped over another table.
Eleazar noticed that the local temple guards had gathered nearby and were looking at the scene in shock, not knowing what to do. He hoped they would have the wisdom to do nothing, as any sort of resistance toward the prophet at this point could easily turn this excited crowd into an angry mob. Jesus then turned in the direction of those selling animals. Seeing what had just happened, men stepped in front of their booths to protect them. Jesus stopped in front of them and did not move for what felt like an eternity but was no more than a minute. The crowd stared in stunned silence.
Then Jesus stepped back into the middle of the courtyard, looked around at everyone, and said loudly, “The leadership of this most holy place has failed us and the God they claim to serve!”
He paused as murmurs spread through the crowd, then continued. “Pagans have appointed our leading priests, and they use their appointment to increase their own wealth!”
Eleazar had heard such critiques before, and as such the words themselves bothered him little. The people often complained about the wealth of his family and other leading priests. The envy of the masses was not surprising. But this time the growing crowd and the pall of anger that rested over it was a different matter. His anxiety was rising.
The prophet continued his rant. “They grow fat, eating fine foods and living in luxury while the people of the city, their own people, struggle to survive!”
Now cries of full-throated support broke forth, and a deep fear seized Eleazar. Would this prophet light the spark of rebellion here and now?
He raised his hand, and slowly the din of the crowd faded. Then he looked specifically in the direction of Eleazar and continued speaking:
“As in the days of Jeremiah, these priests are bandits. They hide in this temple, thinking it will protect them from God’s judgment. But the kingdom of God is coming, and it will be no respecter of this place!”
The crowd erupted with cheers at these final words. He moved toward them, and the crowd parted to let him pass through. A smaller group, perhaps his disciples, fell in behind him. Eleazar kept on watching them as they made their way back to the Shushan Gate and exited the city.
The entire horrifying scene took no more than five or ten minutes, but it seemed like an eternity to Eleazar. While stunned at what had unfolded before him, Eleazar was also relieved that the crowd had not been turned into a rioting mob.
In his twenty years as a priest, he had never witnessed such a direct affront to the temple and its leadership or a more imminent threat of violence in the city. His mind was racing as he tried to wrap his mind around the political ramifications of the prophet’s actions. He had entered the city as a victorious king, an act that both challenged the authority of Rome and jeopardized the peace of the city. Additionally, he had entered the temple courtyards, caused a violent disruption, and not only challenged the authority of the temple and its leadership but also almost brought the people to the point of violence. King Herod had burned men alive for such a disturbance in the temple! In less than an hour this man had, in the eyes of Rome, committed two capital crimes. The peace of the city was indeed at great risk.
Jesus’ intentions now seemed quite clear, and these were the very intentions Pilate had feared. They were the reason the governor had wanted to arrest Jesus before he reached the city, but Caiaphas had convinced him not to. Eleazar shook his head at this thought. Pilate would be furious. It was looking like his father had made a rare and tragic mistake in judgment. He could only hope it was not a fatal one.
Pilate sat at his private desk, fuming. A messenger from the Antonia fortress had just delivered news about the prophet Jesus’ dramatic entry into the city and his defiant act of protest in the temple courtyard. It was a complete and utter disaster—the very thing Pilate wanted to avoid! But this was far worse than he could have even imagined. He thought this prophet might slowly rally the people to his cause, stir them up throughout the week, and finally attempt to lead them in some demonstration against Rome’s power. But this man took a completely different approach. He flaunted his ambitions from the very beginning and did so in one of the boldest ways imaginable. At least secrecy and the element of surprise will not be weapons to fear with this messianic aspirant, Pilate mused sarcastically.
In a way, the strategy was quite brilliant. In openly proclaiming his ambitions, this prophet put Pilate in a bind. Pilate would obviously need to remove the threat to keep the peace, but how would he do it and still keep the peace? From the report he had received, the masses had eagerly supported the prophet’s actions in the temple courtyard. The people loved him! Any attempt to arrest him openly might spark a riot and jeopardize peace. Pilate was damned if he did and damned if he didn’t! Well played, prophet, he thought. Perhaps he was even hoping to force Pilate’s hand, inciting a violent military response to his entrance. The manner he went about entering the city certainly seemed like he had a death wish.
But if that was Jesus’ plan, no one took the bait. Brutus, the commander of the Jerusalem cohort, had not sent soldiers onto the Temple Mount to arrest him. Brutus had received a report of the disturbance from the soldiers at the Shushan Gate, where Jesus had entered the city. In response, he had quickly organized three hundred soldiers to be ready to storm the court of the Gentiles if things began to turn violent; one hundred of them were archers who could rain down arrows on an unruly mob from the top of the courtyard porticos. From the fortress towers, he could observe the situation easily enough, but it never escalated to the point of mob violence, so he stayed his hand. Pilate was proud of the prudent way Brutus had handled the situation and would have to comment on it in his next letter to the legate of Syria, the supreme commander of Roman military forces in the region.
Why had he not arrested the prophet in Jericho?! Why did he listen to Caiaphas? All his best instincts told him to eliminate the threat before it became unmanageable, but he didn’t listen to them. He wouldn’t ignore those instincts again. Caiaphas was certainly correct that in not arresting Jesus, Pilate would ensure his own peaceful entry into the city. Just three days prior, Pilate had marched into the city with three hundred soldiers, and it didn’t elicit a single peep from the onlooking crowds. But Pilate would have gladly traded such an entry for one with angry jeers and rotten figs to avoid the situation he found himself in now.
What would he do about this Jesus? It seemed the prophet clearly wanted a confrontation, and Pilate knew a confrontation must come. The open flouting of Roman power and claims of messianic deliverance could not go unchecked. But Pilate determined then and there that any confrontation would be on his terms and not the prophet’s. This was a latrones match in which both parties were aware that Pilate had the advantage. But if Pilate was not careful, a victory could quickly become a loss. He needed to play out this game, and he knew that Roman power alone could not solve the problem. He was going to need the help of Jewish authorities to succeed. As much as the thought sickened him, he was going to need Caiaphas’s help.
He was not only angry at Caiaphas but also saddened the priest had made the wrong call; perhaps he was even sorrowful at his own anger toward Caiaphas. But perhaps the priest who got him into this mess would prove useful in getting him out of it. As grave a mistake as it was, Pilate told himself that it was not beyond the possibility of redemption. All was not lost, and there must still be a way to both successfully eliminate the prophet Jesus and keep the peace. If both goals could be accomplished and Caiaphas was able to help him accomplish them, the high priest’s error in judgment could be forgiven.
The thought of finding a new high priest certainly didn’t appeal to Pilate. He worked well with Caiaphas. He liked Caiaphas. He did not like his alternatives, most of whom were either related to or in some way aligned with Annas, a former high priest. Pilate neither liked nor trusted Annas. He seemed disingenuous, always plotting ways to enhance the wealth and power of his own family.
Pilate did not look forward to his scheduled meeting with Annas the following day. Apparently, Annas had concerns about the way the city was being run by its current leadership, concerns Pilate might not be aware of. No doubt this would be another attempt to undermine Annas’s son-in-law. While Pilate was angry at Caiaphas, he was not interested in whatever chicanery Annas might be up to.
On the other hand, a meeting with Caiaphas was both crucial and urgent. They needed to meet that very night. Thoughts of how to deal with this prophet were beginning to form in his mind, but the developing plot would require Caiaphas’s help. He would no doubt dislike Pilate’s proposal, but he would have little choice. It was Caiaphas’s fault they were in this mess, and that gave the priest little leverage regarding how things would move from this point forward. The latrones match was on, and Caiaphas was going to be one of Pilate’s most valuable pieces.