Chapter 2
IN THIS CHAPTER
Leaving your assets to your heirs
Planning your estate after remarriage
Keeping your business from failing
Choosing a dependable personal representative and trustee
Giving away your assets is easy, right? You just make a list of the people in your life who are closest to you, divide your assets between them, and you’re done. Well, maybe not. You have to consider many other factors to be sure that your estate plan is carried out as you intend and that your beneficiaries receive the full benefit of your gifts.
This chapter helps you identify the people, institutions, charities, and other beneficiaries to whom you wish to leave bequests. It also helps you recognize special circumstances that may affect your estate plan, such as the effect of blended marriages and business succession planning. You also discover how to select a trustee or personal representative, when you should get help from an estate planning professional, and how to find and choose a lawyer, accountant, or institutional trustee.
You need to figure out what assets you have and how you want to leave them to your heirs. You inventory your various assets, including your savings, investments, retirement accounts, real estate, personal property, cars, boats, jewelry, collections, and anything else you own. You consider your debts, including asset-related debts, such as mortgages and car loans. You also consider how your property is held and whether jointly held property will pass to the joint title holder without going through probate (see Book 5, Chapter 3 for a lot more on probate).
For the most part, your estate plan is written on paper and isn’t etched in stone. You may change your will or revocable trusts at any time you choose. Similarly, you may change the beneficiaries on your life insurance policies, annuities, and retirement accounts. If you use irrevocable trusts in your estate plan, once you transfer assets into those trusts, you can’t change your mind about your gifts.
After you create a list of assets and heirs, you can decide how to divide those assets. Consider your family, including your parents, spouse, children, grandchildren, siblings, and perhaps also aunts and uncles, cousins, nieces and nephews, or more distant relatives. Think about whether you want to make gifts to friends or other nonrelatives. You may also decide to leave bequests to charities, schools, churches, or other organizations.
Even with this list in hand, you’re not quite done. You need to think about how your heirs may change over time, through birth, death, adoption, divorce, remarriage, or anything else that may happen in the future. You don’t have to write your estate plan to cover every contingency, but your forethought can help you create an estate plan that needs less frequent amendment. You will also have a better picture of what types of changes in your life will necessitate the revision of your estate plan.
After you figure out who your heirs are, you need to figure what you want to leave to them. Ask yourself these questions:
If you intend to leave specific assets to your heirs, you need to remember that the value of your assets may change over time. In some cases, the asset may be sold, lost, or destroyed before your will or trust is administered. You may include language in your trust that equalizes the value of specific gifts, such that a child receiving a less valuable gift will also receive a sum of cash. You can also give heirs a percentage of your estate instead of specific dollar values to help preserve your intentions in the event that your estate grows or shrinks in size.
If you want to keep an asset in the family, you should designate an alternate beneficiary just in case your primary beneficiary dies. For example, if you leave your daughter your grandmother’s engagement ring, do you want it to go to your son-in-law if she dies before you? Or would you prefer that it go to another child or to one of your grandchildren?
You may leave your household furnishings or other personal property to your heir without making an exhaustive list of everything you own. For example, you can leave your clothes to a specific heir or charity. Another option is to describe a mechanism by which your heirs will inherit personal property — for example, you could leave your children your furniture, but provide that they take turns selecting a piece of furniture until all of it has been distributed between them. If you provide for them to take turns selecting items, you should also either indicate who picks first or describe a technique, such as drawing a high card from a deck of cards, to determine who will be randomly selected to pick first.
To make sure that some heirs benefit from your request, you must engage in some extra estate planning. For example, your minor children will require somebody to manage their assets. One of your children may be bad with money, so you may want to create a spendthrift trust to prevent them from squandering an inheritance or having it taken by creditors. If you have a child or grandchild with special needs, you may need to create a special needs trust to allow him to benefit from your gift instead of the state taking it as reimbursement for the cost of public assistance.
You’re not limited to describing your heirs by name. You may also describe your heirs by class, such as “to my children” or “to my grandchildren.” Such language may help ensure that children or grandchildren born after you complete your estate plan share in an inheritance. Or, if you prefer, you can expressly exclude after-born children. You may also state whether you want adopted children or stepchildren to be treated as your children or provide for them separately.
You may want to leave part or all of your estate to an organization that advances the public good or supports a cause you believe in. Subject to state law restrictions on disinheriting your heirs, discussed in the previous section, you are free to do so. Many charities and educational institutions offer model documents you can use to leave bequests to them.
Charitable giving may also help you avoid estate taxes. A bequest to a tax-exempt organization may provide your estate with a tax deduction.
You may also consider using a charitable remainder trust to reduce the size of your taxable estate or to help you avoid capital gains taxes. Typically, the trust is set up to provide an income for yourself while eventually making a gift to charity. The trust may also be reversed, providing an income to a charity from an asset that will pass to your heirs upon your death.
It’s your money, so for the most part, you can leave it to whomever you want. You can set up scholarships or memorial funds, support a public garden, or engage in other creative gifting.
You can also create a trust to benefit your pet. Yes, really. Pet trusts are not universally recognized as valid, although a growing number of states have passed laws making them enforceable. In states where they’re not formally recognized, try to choose a trustee who will carry out your wishes even though they’re not legally binding.
Generally speaking, the complexity of your estate plan increases with the size of your family. It’s pretty easy to plan your estate when you’re single. Getting married doesn’t add much complication. But then you have kids, divorce, remarry, have a blended family… . Each new development may complicate your plans and wishes.
If neither you nor your spouse has children, estate planning for your second marriage is pretty simple. You simply execute new estate planning documents designating your spouse as your beneficiary. In some cases, you may want a more complicated estate plan, leaving some of your premarital assets to other friends, relatives, or charities instead of your spouse.
But if you or your spouse have children from prior relationships, things become a lot more complicated. And the complications compound if you later have children together. Here are some questions to think about:
You may feel 100 percent certain that your spouse “will take care of” your children and be comfortable leaving your entire estate to your spouse. Most of the time, your instincts will be correct, and your spouse will respect your wishes. But if your spouse chooses not to leave money to your children from the prior marriage or dies intestate, your children are effectively disinherited.
Start thinking about estate planning before you marry. You may find that you need a prenuptial agreement to keep some of your premarital assets from becoming part of your marital estate or subject to your spouse’s elective share of your estate. The elective share is the amount your spouse may choose to inherit under state law, and your spouse may exercise that right if your will provides for a lesser inheritance.
A common tool used in estate planning for second marriages is the life estate. If you own your marital home as separate property, you can make your spouse a life tenant. Your children receive title to the home upon your spouse’s death. But a life estate may prove to be an imperfect tool:
Your living trust can be beneficial in directing your separate property to your children. You can also place some of your assets in an irrevocable trust for the benefit of your children before you remarry, but you need to be aware of gift tax consequences. (Estate taxes are discussed in Book 5, Chapter 5.)
A common estate planning tool for second marriages is the bypass trust, in which you leave a substantial bequest to your children. This gift takes advantage of your gift tax exemption, by keeping the gift out of your spouse’s taxable estate. It also permits you to provide income for the support of your spouse, while directing the principal of the trust to your children.
Another common estate planning tool for second marriages is the Qualified Terminable Interest Property (QTIP) trust, which is often used in conjunction with a bypass trust. You can use the bypass trust up to the amount of your estate tax exemption and then use a QTIP trust for other assets, which will be treated as part of your spouse’s estate, but which you may still direct to your children upon your spouse’s death.
Some states permit contract wills, which can’t be changed after the death of the first spouse. However, this type of will can be unduly limiting, particularly if the surviving spouse remarries or has more children, and may complicate probate. Before considering a contract will, be sure you fully understand how the joint estate plan would affect you as the surviving spouse.
A more complicated estate planning tool that may be useful in second marriages is the Family Limited Partnership (FLP). You control the assets in your FLP while your children are limited partners who have an ownership share but no control over the assets. The FLP is often costly to create and comparatively burdensome to maintain.
If you own your own business or a share of a family business, your estate plan should include a business succession plan. A will isn’t enough, and your living trust is probably inadequate. Business succession is a complicated process and is usually best implemented over a course of years. If you’re a business owner:
Sometimes you will want to transfer business ownership or management to another family member, perhaps a child. Other times, you will want to sell the business to somebody outside of your family. Remember that it can take a long time to find a buyer for your business, and the buyer may expect training and support. If you intend for your business to be sold after your death, you should still implement a plan for its operation and management pending sale and for support of the new owner.
When you’re the sole owner of your business and you want to leave it to your heirs, you need to consider many factors:
The FLP may be a useful tool in leaving your business to your heirs, while also possibly reducing its value for the calculation of estate tax. In a FLP, you retain control of your business as the managing partner, while transferring ownership of shares to your children. Your children are limited partners and thus do not have any say in your management decisions. You can use the annual gift tax exemption, presently $14,000 (in 2017), to gradually transfer ownership to your children while reducing your taxable estate.
Even if you choose not to implement a FLP, perhaps due to its cost or complexity, you may nonetheless use an annual gifting strategy to transfer shares of your business to your children. Annual gifts have an additional benefit, in that as your business grows in value so do the shares you have already transferred. If you wait until you die, today’s $14,000 gift may represent a six-figure increase in your taxable estate. Although your children will face increased capital gains tax if they sell the gifted shares, as opposed to getting a step up in basis when inheriting them at your death, the potential tax savings remain substantial. For more on estate taxes, see Book 5, Chapter 5.
You can also sell shares to your children during your lifetime, financing the sale with a low-interest promissory note. Similar to a gift, your children receive the shares at a much lower value than they’re likely to be worth at the time of your death. You may still implement a gifting strategy, using your annual gift tax exclusion to forgive part of the debt owed on the note.
Every small business with more than one owner should have a buy-sell agreement addressing the right to purchase shares from a partner who wants to leave the business, or from a partner who becomes incapacitated or dies. You probably don’t want a stranger buying or inheriting your partner’s interest, or exercising the proxy rights of an incapacitated partner and then trying to assert a say in how your business is operated. Without a buy-sell agreement, you may get exactly that or may give that “gift” to your partners.
If you own a share of a business, whether it’s a family business or a business you run with partners or investors, you face many of the same issues as with a sole proprietorship (see previous section). If you manage the business or have a significant management role, you and your partners need to plan for a successor manager.
A key difference is that your partners have an interest in how your shares are distributed. Some businesses have buy-sell agreements, detailing how shares are to be valued and when your shares may be purchased by the other partners. Depending upon what you and your partners decide:
The buy-sell agreement may be triggered upon a partner’s death or incapacity, giving your partners the opportunity to purchase your shares from your estate rather than having them inherited by somebody they would prefer not be involved in the business. You, of course, get the same benefit should misfortune fall upon one of your partners.
You may be used to taking charge of every detail of your life. But no matter how independent you are, you can’t administer your own estate. You have to get help from somebody else. So what do you do?
You seek out helpers who are trustworthy, responsible, and financially stable and who are young and healthy enough that they’re likely to remain both willing and able to manage your affairs after your death or incapacity. Your choice will usually be a person, but at times you may choose an institutional trustee or lawyer to administer your trust or will. The following sections help you make the right choices and choose helpers who will protect your estate and respect your wishes.
Your personal representative, also called an executor, is the person who manages your estate during the probate process. Your trustee manages the assets held by your trust. During the administration of your trust or estate, your trustee and personal representatives will be the primary target of anybody who is unhappy with your estate plan or the way it is being administered.
Whenever you choose somebody to assist with your estate plan, you should talk to her before adding her to your will or trust. This discussion isn’t a sales pitch where you’re trying to convince somebody to become your trustee. It’s more like a job interview, where you try to be absolutely certain that your candidate is trustworthy, reliable, and willing to perform a difficult job. Find out the answers to the following questions:
Although it’s reasonable for your trustee or personal representative to hire professionals to assist with these tasks, you need to choose somebody who is comfortable working with numbers. Her math skills increase the quality of oversight of your assets and reduce the chance that your estate will unnecessarily incur expenses for professional services.
It takes two, baby. Or more. Your first choice as personal representative or trustee may not be able to fulfill that role for many reasons:
By designating a successor (or more than one successor), your trust or estate will continue to be managed by somebody you choose.
After you have chosen your trustee, personal representative, and successors, you need to make sure they understand your wishes. You should sit down with them and have a conversation about your estate plan and goals.
Go over your will or trust and explain what each provision means. Encourage your helper to ask questions.
The more complicated your estate plan, the more likely it is that you will require assistance when preparing and implementing your plan. Common situations in which professional assistance is recommended include
Your first task in getting help from a lawyer is finding a responsible estate planning lawyer. Your ideal lawyer will be experienced not only with planning estates but also with planning estates that are similar to yours. Similarity goes beyond size and extends to similarity of assets. If you have a small business, you need a lawyer familiar with business succession issues. If you’re on your second marriage, need to create a special needs trust for a disabled child, or want to disinherit an heir, seek a lawyer who is experienced with those issues. You may want a lawyer who has probate experience and whose estate planning documents have stood up in probate court.
Easier said than done? Certainly. You won’t find that type of detail from a Yellow Pages ad, and if you call a law office and ask, you’re almost certain to hear that the lawyer you have contacted has qualifications that far exceed your needs (whether or not that is true). So what do you do? Try to get referrals from people you know who have hired estate planning lawyers. If you have an accountant you trust, request a referral. You can also interview members of the American College of Trust and Estate Counsel (ACTEC), using its online directory (available at www.actec.org
).
Just as when you hire a lawyer, referrals are very useful when you need to hire an accountant. Your friends, family, business associates, and your lawyer may have suggestions. You can also consult your state’s CPA Association. You can find a directory of CPA Associations on The American Institute of Certified Public Accountants website at www.aicpa.org/states/stmap.htm
.
When you have selected some possible CPAs, you should interview them. Questions to ask include
When you choose an accountant, consider the condition of the accountant’s offices. Are they neat and organized? That’s what you should expect. You can also rely on your instincts. Do you trust the accountant and feel comfortable with the idea of working with the accountant? If not, it’s a big world. You have a lot of other accountants to choose from.
Your first thought upon hearing the words institutional trustee is probably, “that sounds expensive.” The most common institutional trustees are banks, brokerages, lawyers, and trust companies. They typically charge annual fees between 1 and 3 percent of the value of the trust.
An institutional trustee is thus likely to charge more than a friend or relative who serves as trustee, and you can’t expect that an institutional trustee will waive its fees. Unless your trust is valued at $400,000 or more, using an institutional trustee is probably not financially prudent. In fact, many institutional trustees will decline to service smaller estates.
Using an institutional trustee provides the benefit that your trustee is likely to be in operation for the entire life of the trust. At the same time, responsibility for your trust may be handed off from employee to employee, due to staffing changes or employee turnover. You should inquire about continuity issues when you interview potential trustees.
You should consider having the trust periodically reviewed by a third party, to make sure that assets are being properly invested and maintained. This review adds an additional cost to your trust but helps protect your heirs from mistakes or misconduct. Your institutional trustee should carry insurance to protect you from losses resulting from any such problems.
An institutional trustee is likely to be objective when managing your estate. Except as clearly authorized by the trust, pleas from your children for the extra disbursement of funds will probably fall on deaf ears. An individual may be swayed by a family relationship or feelings of friendship. Similarly, while your children may decide that it makes no difference whether they spend the money that they’re supposed to hold in trust for your grandchildren, your institutional trustee will do exactly what you instructed and make sure that your grandchildren receive your gift. Your institutional trustee will also not go through a period of grieving after your death or shy away from recovering trust assets from your friends or relatives.
Institutional trustees are readily able to consult other professionals. While your individual trustee may struggle to find a lawyer or accountant who can give her advice on a minor problem, your institutional trustee can easily obtain advise from lawyers, accountants, investment professionals, and other experts. Also, even with staff turnover, the institutional trustee’s experience with trusts avoids the learning curve of an individual trustee who has little or no prior experience managing a trust.