I decided to try my luck with the newspaper the next day. They had run small pieces on both Les and Ruth's death but only on inside pages. I knew D'Onofrio's involvement meant the police were treating both deaths as suspicious, but no one except Carol had publicly uttered the word “murder.”
I had sent a short email to the City Editor, proposing a freelance article. Now I followed that up with a phone call.
“Yeah, Rebecca, good to hear from you. How's it goin'?” was his gruff reply when he heard my voice. “Got your email,” he went on. “Any other time I might be interested. But, hey, we're facing another round of layoffs. Advertising revenue is down apparently. We're hoping it'll pick up soon, now that it's close to Christmas. But I sure don't have much of a freelance budget, and I don't think I could commission you to write anything without the union going after my head.”
I tried to sound confident as I outlined the possible connection to the death twenty years ago.
“You mean kids are in danger? That might be an angle. I thought it was just the staff who died? And no one's said anything about murder.”
I backed off a little. “I'm not sure the two things are related,” I said. “And the police are just saying the deaths are suspicious right now. They haven't gone any further, but—”
“Well, I might be able to sell a personal angle,” he interrupted me. “Sort of a 'My life in the co-op of death: residents live in fear' kind of thing. Let me think about that. I'll get back to you.
He hung up before I was able to protest that wasn't at all the angle I was aiming for. Enough co-op members seemed to resent me already. I didn't want to add to the number by portraying their home as a death trap.
I guess, in my eagerness to get an assignment and work my way back into the paper, I'd acted too soon. At least Dave didn't have to worry about telling the paper about a story they might find interesting.
But I needed to find out if there really was a connection between the deaths.
I remembered Jeremy said he had keys to the office and the storage area. Maybe I could start searching through more boxes of materials. Even if I didn't find out any more about the deaths in the co-op, I'd at least be further ahead on the co-op history. But I only got voicemail when I dialed his number. And the same when I tried to reach Gwen.
I had just put the phone down in frustration when it startled me by ringing.
“Is this Rebecca Butler?” a hesitant voice greeted me. “It's Carol, Ruth's mother.”
Her voice choked a little. “I've found some papers in Ruth's room. I think they belong to the co-op. I thought I should let someone know. I mean, if she brought work home, it's probably important, right.” She took a long, shuddering breath. “I'm sorry. I just thought I should start clearing out her room, maybe giving away some of her things other people could use. But I guess I'm just not ready.”
“No, of course not,” I agreed. “It is a hard job.” I remembered trying to sort through my mother's things after she died. Dad had wanted to do the same thing, hoping someone else might get some use and enjoyment out of things she would no longer need. But neither of us could face it for months.
She rushed on. “Anyway, I found these papers, and I thought the co-op would want them back. But when I called the co-op office, of course there was no one there. And Ruthie's voice was still on the voicemail . . .” She started to sob openly, then checked herself.
“I remembered your name from the funeral. I wondered if you wanted to come and pick them up. Or I could send them by courier I guess.”
The papers Ruth had been working on before she died? That she had thought important enough to take home? It might have been nothing, of course. Maybe just some bookkeeping she needed to catch up on.
But I was going to find out. “Of course, I can come and get them,” I said. “When would it be convenient for me to pick them up?”
Her address wasn't too far away, but I checked with my father to see if I could use his car. Carol hadn't said how much material there was, but it would certainly be faster to use the car. And I was impatient.
She greeted me at the door of a neat bungalow a few blocks east of Commercial Drive. The house wasn't as old as some of the Victorian and Edwardian houses in this neighborhood, and lacked the gingerbread trim and stained glass some of those houses had, but it had a cozy charm. It dated perhaps from the late 1920s or early 1930s. The house was nestled in a pretty garden, with a winding path to the front door. A location on a hill gave it a stunning view of the North Shore mountains. The rainstorm we'd had a few days earlier had turned to snow at that elevation, and the mountains were covered with a light dusting of white that shone in the sunlight.
Carol's eyes were red but she smiled at me. “Thanks for coming,” she said. “I hadn't noticed when I talked to you but there appear to be three boxes of stuff. You'd think I'd have noticed that Ruth was bringing masses of work home.”
She frowned. “You know, maybe Les had them. Ruth and I cleaned up his apartment after he died, and I think she brought some stuff home from there. I think she did say something about things missing from the office and wondering if Les had them. But she didn't tell me she'd found anything. I thought maybe she was bringing home a few things to remember him by—he was always good to her when she was little—or maybe just some household stuff she thought she could use when she got her own place.”
Her eyes filled with tears. “She was planning on moving out, you know, talking about getting her own apartment, now that she was working. I was worried about her, but girls have to grow up. Of course, she won't now.”
I hugged her as she sobbed on my shoulder. “Could I make you some tea?” I asked. I knew tea wouldn't soften her grief, but that's what people did. “Or I could call someone to stay with you. A friend? Someone from your church?'
“No, I'll be all right, thank you. I just have to get used to her not being around. Let me show you the boxes. I can help you carry them to your car. You do have a car, don't you? The boxes are quite heavy.”
I assured her I did. I was glad I had brought the car. I couldn't imagine trying to walk home carrying even one awkward cardboard box. Even taking the bus would be difficult. And carrying all three would have been impossible.
I thought about Carol as I drove home. Both Les and Ruth had been part of the co-op. Surely, there was something we could do to help her. I thought I could drop off a casserole and a salad for her, so she could eat well without worrying about cooking. And maybe Mariana and Gwen could make something for her. Then I remembered that Ruth had likely been poisoned in the co-op. Maybe food wasn't a good idea.
Carol had mentioned something about Ruth's weak heart, and a suspicion of autism. Perhaps we could make a donation in Les and Ruth's name to the heart and stroke foundation or a group that worked to help autistic kids. Maybe we could donate to an organization that developed affordable housing, either in Canada or the developing world. Or maybe we could hold some sort of memorial in the co-op, or even rename the building after them. I'd have to talk to Gwen and Jeremy about it. Maybe the board could come up with an appropriate tribute. I could certainly mention them in the history of the co-op I was working on. That would be one way to recognize their contributions.
Although I could have used help carrying the heavy boxes, I was glad no one was around when I pulled into the parking garage. I really didn't want anyone in the co-op to know I had found some more information, at least until I had a chance to go through it. I realized that I might have brought back nothing more than the receipts needed for the financial statements for last month. Or even last year. The boxes might contain nothing of interest at all. But I could feel a growing excitement.
I managed to carry all three boxes to my apartment without running into anyone. As I was carrying the last box home, I thought I heard a door open. I thought it was from Naomi's side of the hall, but I wasn't sure. I looked over my shoulder, but all the doors in the hall were closed.
I shrugged and carried the last box to my bedroom office.
I tore them open eagerly. The first was a disappointment. As I'd feared, it was filled with invoices and copies of cancelled checks from this month and the two previous months. Obviously Ruth had been working on the current quarter's financial statements for the next board meeting.
I was thrilled when I opened the next box. It was from the year Amy and Jessie had disappeared. But it seemed to contain nothing more than the usual meeting minutes and old pictures I had come to expect. There was a brief mention in one of the board minutes after the girls had disappeared, wondering if the co-op could do something to help the families. But I couldn't find any further mention after the date that Jessica's body had been found.
I looked at the boxes in bemusement. Was this how other organizations handled their filing? There might have been extra copies of the minutes in neat binders in the office but somehow, remembering what the office always looked like, I doubted it. Maybe that was something I could do after I'd sorted the materials for the co-op history. Or maybe the new staff person could organize the files. I knew the board had advertised the position but there had been few applicants. I could guess why.
It was in the last box that I found the only interesting information. It was a piece of paper in Les's handwriting attached to a complaint form on the co-op's letterhead. The ink was faded, but I gathered that Cara's mother had filed a complaint to the co-op against Eddie Cole under the co-op by-laws, and was asking that Mariana and Eddie be evicted.
I shuffled through the rest of the papers but couldn't find anything else about the complaint. There was nothing in the board minutes to show that the complaint had ever been dealt with, let alone resolved. I knew from experience that conflicts could arise among co-op members. But an eviction was a serious action.
Maybe it had been nothing. Mariana was still living in the co-op, and Eddie was planning to move back. But I was still curious.
Dave and Jeremy had both suggested I talk to Cara about the co-op history. I had been reluctant, but now it seemed like a good idea. I had no idea if she would be home. I knew she worked different shifts at the restaurant. But I thought it might be easier to just turn up at her door, rather than call and get put off.
I checked the co-op members' list to confirm her unit number and took the elevator down to her floor. Cara looked a little nervous when she answered her door, but I tried to look friendly.
“Hi, Cara,” I said, smiling. “Do you mind if I talk to you for a few minutes?”
“Um, sure,” she said, hesitantly. “Do you want to come in?”
Her unit was similar to mine but smaller. I could see only two bedroom doors leading off the hall and the living/dining area was smaller than in my unit. She didn't have the light our apartment got on the top floor. I was beginning to see why some co-op members resented the fact that we had moved into that unit.
I knew the co-op kept an internal waiting list of members wanting to move to a larger, smaller, or more desirable unit. But I also knew Les would have made sure a unit adapted for people in wheelchairs would have gone to someone who needed it.
“Is this about Dave?” Cara asked nervously. “You know he told me his marriage was over when we first met. I had no idea you were still together.”
Aha, so Dave had started dating Cara while we were still married.
“No, nothing like that,” I assured her. “Water under the bridge. Although you might want to consider that if you're serious about a relationship with him. If he cheated on me, well . . .
“But no, it's about the co-op. Both Dave and Jeremy told me you grew up here. I thought it might be interesting to talk to you about growing up in the co-op, and what it's like to raise your own family here as an adult.”
“Oh, sure. Well, I've never lived anywhere but the co-op, so I don't really have anything to compare it to. But it was a nice place to live as a kid. I mean, you must know that with your son. All the kids in the playground have a great time together. I know you've been going through some of the files from the co-op, but I think I have some old pictures in my mom's things you might be interested in. I could get them out for you to look at.”
She was smiling at the memories. “We did have some great times here,” she said. “We always had a big Christmas party and Santa came. I was always so excited. I remember one year when I was really little and all I wanted was a tricycle. And then Santa came to the co-op party and brought me this brand-new pink trike, with sparkly streamers on the handles. I was so thrilled I was almost afraid to ride it in case I damaged it or got it dirty.
“I didn't realize until years later that Santa was really Les dressed up in a costume. And my mom told me that year my family had hardly any money. My dad had been really sick and wasn't working. And the co-op and some of the members chipped in to get me the tricycle I had my heart set on. Because I kept saying that Santa was going to bring me a trike for Christmas, and they didn't want me to be disappointed.
“That was really sweet, wasn't it? I haven't thought about that Christmas in years. I guess that's a good story to put in the co-op's history, isn't it?”
“That's exactly the kind of story I'm looking for. But I guess things aren't always perfect around here. I heard that your family had filed a complaint against Eddie Cole and were asking for Mariana and Eddie to be evicted. I guess there are stories of conflict to go along with the wonderful times, aren't there?”
I'd asked the question out of overwhelming curiosity. But I was shocked by Cara's reaction. She went dead white, and I thought for a moment she was going to faint. She started to shudder as she looked at me.
“Oh, Eddie Cole. Mariana keeps saying he's coming home. But he won't if I have anything to do with it. When Mariana started saying she couldn't move to a smaller unit because Eddie and her grandson were coming home, I told Les he better tell her to move. Because Eddie Cole is moving back to this housing co-op over my dead body.”