Independence and Nationalist Movements

Throughout the twentieth century, independence movements and nationalism have risen in response to the decline or defeat of colonial powers. The primary mission of these movements has been to resist and expel foreign occupiers. In some cases, the new nations have been able to negotiate their independence with a relative lack of violence, depending on their economic, social, and historical relationship to the colonial power. Factors in the outbreak of colonial warfare included the size of European settler populations, the perceived importance of the colony to the ruling country’s economy and national prestige, and the radicalism of the independence movement’s ideology. 

Negotiated Independence

India

India’s nationalist movement under the British Empire, originating in the late nineteenth century, was led by the upper-class members of the Indian National Congress. From the beginning, India’s nationalists were divided between Hindu and Muslim factions. The Muslim population was in the minority, over all, and its leaders often deviated from Congress’ insistence that British India was destined to be a single independent federated nation. After World War I, Britain’s Government of India Act of 1919 granted some domestic power to the Congress but left far more power in British hands compared to the “white” dominions of Canada and Australia, which were also agitating for more independence at this time. Britain balanced its reform effort with increased prosecutions for sedition, arousing popular resentment. At Amritsar, a British general ordered troops to fire on a protest rally, killing many hundreds of unarmed civilians. This shocking episode, and the British public’s approval of it, began to push Indian opinion away from Dominion status (domestic self-rule within the Empire) and towards complete independence.

At this time, Mohandas Gandhi emerged. Gandhi focused on the peasant roots and spiritual traditions of India and helped turn the Congress Party from an elite debating society into a disciplined mass movement. His methods of satyagraha, civil disobedience against unjust laws, and ahimsa, nonviolence in the face of police action, highlighted the injustice of British rule. In the 1930s, Britain proposed a federal structure for India to protect minority Muslim rights, but the Muslim League, under Muhammad Ali Jinnah, countered with a demand that India be divided into two separate states, Muslim and Hindu.

When World War II began, the British offered domestic rule in return for cooperation against Germany and Japan. Despite Gandhi’s “Quit India” resistance campaign and Japan’s attempts to recruit an Indian liberation army as it approached the Bengali border, the Indian people again generally supported Britain in the war. After the war, the British realized they could no longer count on the Indian bureaucracy for governing and policing, but they could not afford a military campaign of suppression and conquest. On August 15, 1947, independence was granted to India.

However, increasing violence between Hindus and Muslims had persuaded the British to agree to an India/Pakistan Partition, which led to the creation of Hindu India and Muslim Pakistan. This division led to a mass cross-migration of Muslim and Hindu refugees amid terrible civil slaughter. Hundreds of thousands were killed, which poisoned relations between India and Pakistan going forward. The two nations fought four wars over the next fifty years. Pakistan itself was composed of western and eastern provinces, separated by India. The populations, of different ethnic groups and ancestral history, shared only their Muslim religion. In 1971, East Pakistan fought for its national independence and became Bangladesh.

Africa

By 1914, almost all of Africa had been carved up by European powers. Economically, it had been transformed by the development of monoculture plantations of cash crops for export and mines of precious materials such as gold and diamonds. The ownership of these properties was exclusively in the hands of European merchants. In the period after World War II, the largely left-wing popular European governments had little interest in subsidizing imperial enterprises. In addition, many of the African colonies saw a rise in a democratically-minded elite class, eager for independence.         


As in India, Africans mobilized urban residents into mass-movement independence parties, with labor organizations, social clubs, literary circles, and youth movements all becoming vehicles for protest. These movements grew steadily in the decade after the war, with early liberation in North Africa: Morocco, Libya, Egypt, Tunisia, and Sudan. The Gold Coast, taking the name Ghana and led by Kwame Nkrumah, was the first sub-Saharan nation to achieve its independence in 1957. As Britain and France accepted their inability to maintain worldwide empires and faced pressure by the U.N., a flood of new African nations sprang up in the next ten years. Almost thirty new nations gained independence in relatively peaceful transfers of power. This was only less than a century after the infamous “Scramble for Africa” of the late nineteenth century. 

The arbitrary political borders drawn by the European colonial powers created many nations that were comprised of unrelated ethnic groups. These often had a history of conflict that began long before the colonial era, and in the new states they became rivals competing for power. For example, the Republic of the Congo exploded in a five-year civil war in 1960, when Belgium abruptly withdrew in the face of nationalist demands. Secessionist movements, such as Biafra in Nigeria and Shafta in Kenya, and civil conflict, such as in Chad and the Hutu genocide in Burundi, were not uncommon in post-colonial Africa. There were also structural difficulties in development, as the colonial powers had modernized the local economies and societies solely to exploit and export national resources. More broad-based modernization efforts often stumbled over tensions between unequally developed regions and sectors, and dictatorships and military rule were characteristic aspects of Africa’s political culture in the 1960s and 70s.

Zionism and Palestinian Nationalism

Following World War I, the British ruled Palestine under a League of Nations mandate, replacing the Ottoman Empire. In the Balfour Declaration of 1917, the British government supported a homeland for Jews in Palestine, in line with the European Zionist movement for Jewish nationalism. However, Arab Palestinians saw both British rule and Jewish settlements as forms of western and non-Islamic imperial control, and the British tried to control the violence between communities as the Jewish minority slowly grew in numbers and wealth. 


At the end of World War II, the regional Pan-Arab movement joined the Palestinians in opposing the creation of a Jewish state, but the Holocaust had motivated the Jewish people to find a secure homeland. By 1947, the weakened British Empire turned the question over to the United Nations, which planned to divide the area into two states. Paralleling India, in that a negotiated end to colonial rule led to violence and mass migrations between rival groups, a war ensued. Jewish victories over the neighboring Arab nations led to the creation of the state of Israel on May 14, 1948. As Jews were expelled from newly independent Arab states in the region and relocated to Israel, Palestinian refugees from Israel resettled in cities and camps in neighboring Jordan and adjacent lands. 

Both sides claim the ancient Holy Land as their national homeland, and fighting continues to plague this region. Israel fought three subsequent wars with its Arab neighbors, including the Six Day War in 1967, which expanded its territory into the Jordanian West Bank and Egypt’s Sinai. Since then, Israel and the Arab states gradually established a local “Cold War” kind of stability in the 1970s and 80s, and the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) has used terrorism to press for a Palestinian state to replace Israel in the region.

Island States

Islands have been important for expanding European empires since the Age of Exploration, either as plantation colonies or for their strategic position on the sea lanes. In the twentieth century a large number of island colonies achieved independence as national movements confronted weakened or restructured empires. The first was Cuba, which rebelled from Spain in 1898, only to come under effective political domination by the United States; it would take another sixty years for a Communist revolution to expel U.S. influence. Ireland, long dominated by nearby Great Britain, waged a guerrilla war after World War I to achieve home rule as the Irish Free State, a Dominion like Canada and Australia. Complete independence as the Irish Republic followed soon after in 1937. Britain’s rule in Protestant Northern Ireland remained a source of conflict and terrorist violence for decades to come.

After the Second World War, the United States conceded independence to island colonies that were unprofitable, strategically unnecessary, or unsustainable in the face of nationalist resistance. The Philippines, Papua-New Guinea, and many Polynesian island groups in the Pacific; Jamaica and a number of smaller islands in the Caribbean; Cyprus in the Mediterranean; and Madagascar and Sri Lanka in the Indian Ocean all negotiated their national freedom in the postwar period. As with their continental counterparts, these countries were often consumed by factional or ethnic strife that had been suppressed by the colonial powers.

Armed Struggles for Independence

Africa

Several European colonies in Africa had developed relatively large settler communities. These groups, supported by the colonial governments, resisted independence movements by the native majorities, leading to armed conflicts and full-fledged wars. In Kenya, the violent Mau Mau rebellion was suppressed by the British Army, but this accelerated the movement towards full independence in 1963. Similarly, since 1848 coastal Algeria had been part of metropolitan France, and a large white settler community had lived there for many generations as a privileged class over the native Algerians. In the 1950s, the National Liberation Front (FLN) began a terrorist campaign to drive out the French. A large French army waged counterinsurgency war for years, and the local French government collapsed as the conflict proved unwinnable. After Algerian independence in 1962, large numbers of colonial whites departed; Algeria has since been torn between Islamic and modernizing socialist currents, leading to civil war in the 1990s.

Southeast Asia

The peninsulas and archipelagos of Southeast Asia were occupied by Japan during the war. The defeat of the Europeans by an Asian army, as well as the harsher policies of the Japanese themselves, helped rouse a generation of nationalist movements to evict the ruling empires. 


In the Dutch East Indies, Sukarno declared independence for Indonesia in 1945, and the Netherlands fought a four-year colonial war before admitting defeat and withdrawing from its 350-year old possessions. Britain was challenged by a communist insurgency in Malaya in the 1950s, which it successfully defeated while preparing the colony for independence. While not directly comparable, the Malayan experience contrasts remarkably with Vietnam. Among other factors, many Malayans knew and trusted the British and were willing to fight with them against the guerrillas, and the British emphasized small-unit jungle tactics rather than massive firepower. 

Vietnam

French Indochina was evacuated by Japan in 1945, and immediately a group of Vietnamese nationalists under the leadership of Ho Chi Minh began a guerrilla campaign against the returning French. The French-Indochina War lasted nine years before defeat at Dien Bien Phu forced France to quit. Indochina was divided into Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia. Reflecting the communist ideology of the fighters in the north, Vietnam was split into a communist North and a nationalist South. Cold War dynamics led the United States to support South Vietnam in the name of resisting communist China's regional aggression. After 1965, the United States committed a massive army to defend South Vietnam, but the North’s determination, roots in ancient Vietnamese patriotism, and greater willingness to take casualties eventually won them the war. A negotiated peace preceded full Communist victory in 1975, after thirty years of war. Vietnam was devastated by intensive combat and took years to recover. Laos and Cambodia also suffered destruction from civil conflicts, including the Cambodian revolutionary genocide of the 1970s. The nationalist character of Vietnamese communism was revealed a few years later when Vietnam fought a war to repel Chinese influence in postwar Indochina.

Failed Struggles

The story of nationalism in the twentieth century would be incomplete without reviewing the many instances of regions or peoples who failed to achieve independence. Some struggles involved violence, terrorism, and guerrilla warfare; others were tied to regional or superpower politics; and others still were expressed more through art and mobilization. Just a few of the most prominent examples were: the Basque region, Catalonia, Northern Ireland, and Turkish Cyprus in Europe; Chiapas, Quebec, and Puerto Rico in the Americas; Biafra and Darfur in Africa; Tibet, Taiwan, Okinawa, Mindanao, East Timor, Kashmir, West Papua, Kurdistan, Palestine, Tamil Sri Lanka, and Chechnya in Asia.