Marco
Millie’s eyes were closed as I ran the soap across her body, the hot water pouring down on us. I stared at the love bites I’d left on her neck and smiled to myself before pushing myself up against her. Her eyes popped open as I dropped the soap and lightly grazed her nipples with my fingertips.
“Marco.” She shook her head. “We can’t. My roommate’s bedroom is connected to the bathroom. She’ll hear us.”
“I don’t care if she hears us.” I cupped her sex and kissed her. “Maybe I want her to hear us. Maybe she’s lying there right now, jealous that her roommate is getting the fucking of her life and she’s getting nothing.”
“Marco, no,” Millie moaned as I slipped two fingers inside of her. Her legs buckled slightly, and I grinned. The effect I had on her and her body was amazing. She was so responsive to me, and my own body was loving hers.
Even though I had sex a lot, it was never like this. I was insatiable with her. I didn’t need to take the women I fucked over and over again. Not like I did with Millie. I never even kissed the other women I fucked. Kissing was too intimate an act for a quick fuck, but I loved the feel and taste of Millie’s lips against me.
“I want you to scream my name and wake your roommate up, and then I’ll bring you to orgasm,” I whispered in her ear as her body trembled next to me. Her eyes opened and stared up at me, dazed and tired.
“Marco …” she moaned my name again then I silenced her with a kiss. I was about to lift her up and press her against the wall when the door to the bathroom opened.
“Millie, are you okay?” a woman’s voice said.
I pulled the glass shower door aside. A woman with long black hair and big brown eyes looked back at me. She was completely naked and didn’t look remotely embarrassed about it.
She licked her lips and smiled slowly. “What’s going on in here?”
“Talia,” Millie groaned from behind me. “Sorry, I have company.” Millie pulled me back, but I wasn’t to be moved.
“I can see that.” Talia looked me up and down and grinned as her eyes rested on my hard cock. “Looks like you’ve been holding out on me. Who is this big boy?”
“I’m Marco.” I walked out of the shower dripping wet and reached out my hand to her. “You must be Millie’s roommate.”
“I am.” She shook it and then she pressed herself against me and wrapped her arms around my shoulders. “I prefer to hug.”
“No worries.” I grinned as her breasts pressed against my chest, my cock twitching at her stomach. “What are you up to right now?”
“Well, I was sleeping, unless you two have other plans for me?” She flicked her hair back.
I looked back at Millie in the shower, wondering if I could talk her into having a threesome, but the sparks of anger shooting from her eyes told me that idea was dead in the water.
“Talia, you need to leave!” Millie almost shouted.
I looked over at Talia to see how she would react. She just smiled lazily, winked at me, and then walked back to the doorway.
“If that’s what you want.” She bit down on her lower lip as she looked over her shoulder and slapped her ass. “I was hoping we could have had some fun, but c’est la vie.”
“Damn.” I stared at her ass as she exited the bathroom and then turned to Millie. “Come here, sexy.”
“Excuse me!” She glared at me as I walked over to her and made to touch her stomach. “If you think I’m going to let you touch me after that little display, you’re crazy.”
“You’re mad?” Obviously, I’d sized up the situation incorrectly. “Sorry, I thought you might be down for some X-rated fun.”
“We just had X-rated fun.”
“I meant double X-rated.” I laughed, but she just glared at me. “Look, sorry, your roommate walks in on us naked, presses herself against me and hints that she’s down for a threesome—I thought maybe this was something you girls did.”
“Really? You thought I’d be cool with having a threesome? Even though I told you that I didn’t want to wake my roommate up?”
“I don’t know. I know girls love to play games.” I shrugged. “I figured one of you wanted to be on my cock and one of you wanted to be on my face.”
“You’re nasty.”
“How is that nasty?” I licked my lips. “I just had a foursome the other day, and it was amazing. None of the girls thought it was nasty.”
“You had a foursome the other day?” She looked shocked. “You told me that you hadn’t had sex in so long that you couldn’t remember the last time.”
“Maybe that was a bit of an exaggeration.”
“Maybe?” She just stared at me with contempt. “When’s the last time you had sex?”
“Ten minutes ago?” I cocked a grin, but she just pushed past me and grabbed a towel.
“Not with me.” She opened the door and headed to her bedroom. I followed behind her, dripping water on the hardwood floors.
“The day before I came to San Francisco.”
“Oh my God, are you kidding me?” She looked at me in disgust. “Are you even clean?”
“I always use protection.” I pursed my lips. “And I get tested every sixty days.”
“I cannot believe I let you touch me. You’re nasty!”
She wrapped her towel around herself and sat on her bed. I stared at her for a few seconds, not knowing what to say. I knew she wasn’t super experienced, but her reaction right now was unexpected.
“Sex isn’t nasty. It’s a beautiful thing.” I sat next to her on the bed. “I had fun. Didn’t you?”
“It was okay.” She glared at me.
“I’m sorry you’re upset your roommate was flirting with me, but you can’t be upset because I have a healthy sexual appetite. I never told you this was anything more …”
My voice trailed off. I didn’t want to make her feel cheap or regret what we’d done. She looked at me, disgusted, and I felt sad knowing that she was pissed off at me.
“You’re the sexiest woman I’ve been with in a long time.” I kissed the side of her neck. “I could touch you and kiss you all night long, and I don’t ever normally kiss.”
“Wow, aren’t I special?” She pulled away from me. “You need to leave now, Marco.”
“I don’t want to go.” I reached to grab her hand, and she pulled away from me. “Millie, please, look at me.”
I stared at her and something inside of me tensed. She was really pissed off at me. And it wasn’t as if I’d never been around a pissed off woman before; I’d just never really cared. This feeling was new to me. Regret, worry, and nerves filled my stomach. All of a sudden, everything didn’t feel light and playful the way it had before.
“I’m sorry.” I leaned back on the bed. “I didn’t mean to hurt you.”
“You didn’t hurt me. You’re just tacky. Who has sex with a girl and then tries to make a threesome happen with her roommate?”
“Well, I didn’t try to make it happen. She tried to make it happen.”
“You would have gone along with it.”
“I’m a man, Millie.” I stared into her eyes. “Look, I was surrounded by two hot, naked women, and I’m a man who loves sex. I wouldn’t have said no, but I didn’t need it. I didn’t want to be with her. Being with you was enough.”
“I don’t know what to think right now.” She sighed and yawned. “I’m tired, and I need to sleep.”
“Can I take you to lunch tomorrow?” I stood up and started pulling my clothes on.
“Why?”
The truth was, I wasn’t sure. I should just leave and move on. I didn’t need this drama in my life, and I didn’t need to see her. I’d had her more than once tonight; I didn’t need her again. But as I stared at her naked body and felt a stirring in my chest, I knew that was a lie. I did need her again. Maybe one more time would get her out of my system.
“Because I’d like to see you again.” I smiled. “Please?”
“We’ll see. You need to leave now, though.”
She pulled a sheet down and slipped under the covers. More than anything, I wanted to pull her into my arms and stay the night with her. I wanted to wake her up with a kiss and pull her on top of me in the morning for some morning sex that would have her walking crooked when she got to work. I wanted everyone to know that she’d been taken by a man who knew what he was doing. I didn’t care if Jane got upset. I wanted everyone in her office to know that I’d fucked her and she was mine. Even if she wasn’t.
I got dressed quickly, then leaned down and kissed her forehead gently. I closed her bedroom door softly before heading downstairs, pulling out my phone to call a car as I went. As I reached the bottom of the stairs, Talia strode up to me from the living room, still naked.
“I had a feeling you’d be slipping out in the middle of the night,” she said.
“Oh, yeah?”
“Yeah.” She leaned forward and kissed the side of my ear. “Your type always does.”
“Really?” I stared into her brown eyes and frowned. Was Millie’s roommate really going to try and sleep with me, knowing I’d just fucked Millie?
“Yeah … Why don’t you show me what you’re working with again.” She ran her fingers down her neck and started playing with her breasts. “I’m feeling horny.”
“Are you now?”
She ran her right hand all the way down to her neatly trimmed pussy and rubbed herself.
“Yes.” She grabbed my hand and placed it next to her clit. “Can’t you feel how wet I am?” She rubbed them back and forth against her clit, and yes, she was very wet.
I yanked my fingers away from her, completely soft. Talia, for her all her wanton beauty and sexiness, was doing nothing for me. I pictured Millie, all red curly hair and innocent smiles upstairs, and then focused again on Talia. I had absolutely no interest in being with this woman. Even the thought of a threesome didn’t appeal; I only wanted to be with Millie.
I frowned at the thought and reached down to rub her again. She moaned as my fingers found her slit and she pulled me against her for a kiss. I shuddered in disgust and pushed her off.
“Sorry, this isn’t going to happen.” I pulled my fingers away from her and wiped her juices off on her back. “I’m not interested.” She stared at me in shock and reached down to rub my cock, but she hadn’t turned me on at all and I was still soft. “I’ve got to go.”
“You don’t know what you’re missing …” She licked her lips seductively, but I just chuckled as I surveyed her body.
“I really do, but I’m going anyway.”
I opened the front door and hurried down the stairs to the street. I looked up to the stars as the cool night air hit my face. What the fuck had just happened and why had I walked away? Talia had been asking for me to fuck her. Given how brazen she was, I knew she would have been open to anything I’d wanted. Shit, if I’d told her I wanted to fuck her in the ass, she would have spread her cheeks for me herself.
My heart warmed as I thought about Millie and how perfect our night had been … until I’d ruined it. As I walked down the street, I thought back to our day and dinner and how she’d asked me questions about me and my family. How she’d wanted to get to know me as a person, not just as a hunk or a baseball player. I thought back to how she’d surprised me by being a dirty talker in bed and how she’d been so confident in her body. Fuck, when she’d told me she wanted me to come on her, it had taken everything in me to not blow my load on top of her pussy. More than anything, though, I’d wanted to see her pussy wet with her juices and my cum. I growled as I continued walking. I was getting hard again just thinking about her. She was something special. I knew that now.
There were only two problems. The first being that I didn’t know exactly what I wanted from her, and the second being that I was pretty sure I’d ruined any chance of having her take me seriously at all.