17

The last time Rosemary was in Seattle, it was to board the cruise ship headed for Alaska. As far as she knows, that’s the last time Veronique was in Seattle, too.

They were there with Melinda. And Walter. The four of them flew up, back in the days when flying was still fun, when you didn’t have to get to the airport two hours early and take your shoes off in front of strangers, back when planes had leg room and airlines served real food. Rosemary seems to remember that there was free wine, even, but perhaps her nostalgia’s casting an overly rosy glow over the memories. And flying didn’t cost a fortune back then, either; there were inexpensive commuter tickets even at the last minute, and no charges for luggage.

Rosemary and Walter often reminisced about that trip, when he could still remember anything. She wonders what Melinda told Jeremy about it.

She’s pretty sure that Jeremy’s never been to Seattle. He and Amy are poring over a guidebook in the backseat of the van. It’s a shiny rental van reeking of New Car, a scent Rosemary has never liked, but one she hears the rental agencies dispense from spray cans into the innards of every vehicle, old or new. Hen’s driving, with Tom riding shotgun.

“I’m so psyched about the science-fiction museum!” Amy says happily. The child speaks exclusively in exclamation marks; just listening to her makes Rosemary feel old and tired. “Can we go twice? Once for the CC exhibit and once to see everything else?”

“I dunno, Amy.” Jeremy sounds as sick of this drive as Rosemary feels. Flying to Seattle is so much easier. “We’re going there for a funeral. We have to see what happens.”

“Yeah, sure, I’m sorry.” Although Amy’s sitting behind Rosemary, Rosemary can hear the blush in her voice. “I didn’t mean to be insensitive. It was awfully nice of Mrs. Clark to say we could come.”

Rosemary’s curious to meet this woman, so trusting of strangers who have every reason to hate her dead son. “No reporters,” Hen said. “That was her only stipulation. She doesn’t want this to turn into a media circus.” If Vera had her way, Rosemary knows, they’d show up with a full press corps and a mob of strangers hurling eggs, tomatoes, and curses at Percy’s urn, if not at Percy’s parents.

The funeral’s on Saturday, but they won’t drive back until Monday. Jeremy’s taken a week’s vacation from the café, and Hen’s arranged for an associate priest to preach and celebrate the Eucharist on Sunday. When Veronique fretted about paying a professional pet-sitter to feed her cats, Rosemary got one of the youth group kids to do it. She’s paying him, although she hasn’t told Vera that.

Airfare for all of them would have been prohibitive even with plenty of notice, so Hen, Tom, and Rosemary chipped in to rent the minivan. Veronique refused. “I only agreed to this damn fool trip because you insisted, Rosemary. If you can’t afford to pay my way, I’m not going.” Rosemary’s chosen not to tell anyone else about that.

Veronique did pay for their first gas stop, though; maybe it’s her way of apologizing.

Hen limited everyone to one suitcase and a small personal item. “Like airline carry-on,” she told them. Well, Rosemary thought, at least we don’t have to go through an X-ray machine and take our shoes off to get into the van.

Amy responded to the limitation with typical exuberance. “Cool! It’s like Survivor! We only get one luxury item!” Her luxury item is her laptop, although Hen could have allowed her two: improbably, given her age and gender, her other piece of luggage is a small rucksack.

Driving’s less expensive than flying, but only marginally more comfortable, and it takes a lot longer. They’ve been on the road for four and a half hours, passing up and down darkly furred slopes bordered with wildflowers. The van’s flickered through sunlight and shade, an alternation that should be pleasant, but instead has given Rosemary a headache. They’ve just stopped in Klamath Falls for lunch, piling with groans out of the van. Rosemary’s amazed she managed to hold her bladder for that long, although everyone else in the van makes a beeline for the restrooms, too.

Rosemary hates highway rest stops. Like airports, they’re all alike: bright lighting and shiny tile, anonymous and depressing despite cheerful displays of artwork or tourist information. The people there always seem distracted, their minds already on wherever they’re going next. Time on the road is lost time, a waste of a commodity already infinitely precious. Whoever said that the point was the journey and not the destination wasn’t taking planes or driving on highways.

They have eight more hours to go. After they all pee, Tom will replace Hen in the driver’s seat. In another four hours, roughly, she’ll take it back again, and finish the trip. They’ll stop overnight in Portland if they have to, but Hen wants to do the trip in one day, both to save money and to give them more time in Seattle itself.

Greg, Hen’s seminary buddy in Seattle, has invited all of them to stay at his house. He has in-law quarters originally built for a recently deceased mother-in-law, three extra bedrooms—two belonging to children away at college, one a dedicated guest room—a living room and family room, both with sleeper couches, and a finished basement. Hen, Tom, Jeremy, and Amy have brought sleeping bags. “Oh, we’ll work it out,” Hen said cheerfully of the sleeping arrangements.

Rosemary wonders how a priest can afford a house that size in Seattle. It’s like those TV shows where New York City editorial assistants live in Park Avenue penthouse apartments. Well, maybe he inherited money, or married it.

Dibs on the in-law quarters, Rosemary thinks. She hasn’t said it yet. She knows that Vera probably wants them, too. Maybe she and Vera can share them, although at this point, Vera would rebel against that. Once it might have seemed like a slumber party; now, even after Rosemary’s confession, Vera’s likely to believe that she’s under surveillance.

*   *   *

Jeremy hates riding in backseats; they make him claustrophobic. He knows the others would let him sit in front if he asked, and maybe he will at the next stop, but back here, at least he can sit with Amy, who wouldn’t be making the trip if it weren’t for him. And right now, he couldn’t move if he wanted to. Amy’s dozing, her head pillowed against his shoulder, which has gone to sleep in apparent sympathy. He likes Amy a lot, but this isn’t helping his claustrophobia any.

“Jeremy,” VB says, “you doing okay back there?”

“Sure.” She’s been extra solicitous the whole trip, as if she’s trying to take care of him. He doesn’t even know why she’s here. She’s told everybody often enough that she has no sympathy for Percy or his family. There’s a weird vibe between her and Aunt Rosie, and he wonders if Rosie somehow made VB come to keep tabs on her. He can’t imagine VB doing anything she doesn’t want to, though, and he doesn’t know how Rosie could force her.

He still doesn’t like VB, but he has to hand it to her for pulling off that Planet X caper. The potter told Jeremy about that when he and Rosie showed up to check on her: how when the police arrived at the guesthouse, VB came to the door wrapped in a blanket and informed them regally that she was fine, thank you, and that Rosemary Watkins should mind her own damn business. VB sent the two of them away, too, just as Jeremy had predicted. Good for her.

This new VB, the one who speaks her mind even when other people don’t like it, is a lot more interesting than the old one, who just sat and glared at you like she had a stick up her ass. The old VB always made Jeremy feel like he’d done something wrong that she wasn’t going to tell him about, just to make him feel stupid for not already knowing it. Now she lets people know what’s bothering her. She shouldn’t have lost it in class like that, but Jeremy still respects her a lot more than he used to.

“All right,” she says. “But listen, Jeremy, if you decide you don’t want to go to the funeral, you don’t have to. I’m not going, that’s for sure. We can sit it out together.”

“If I change my mind, I’ll let you know. I don’t think I will.” He wants to go. He needs some sense of Percy beyond what they’ve all seen in the papers: the handsome, smiling photos, the popular and privileged honors student who somehow stumbled sideways into insanity. Jeremy thinks he’d go crazy if he didn’t know who killed Mom, because he’d keep imagining different people, keep wondering if anyone he passed on the street could be the murderer. Having a name is a relief. Now he wants more than that. He wants—

He doesn’t know what he wants, exactly, except that he’s pretty sure it isn’t revenge, which wouldn’t work anyway, because Percy’s already dead. He isn’t glad that Percy’s dead, exactly, not that he’s sorry either. He doesn’t know what he feels. Everything about Percy evokes a numb horror in him, and the numbness is threatening to spread out and infect the rest of his life, as if EE has injected some mad-scientist virus into his bloodstream. He wants to go to the funeral to meet people who aren’t numb about Percy. He wants to plug Percy into some earth-normal context: family, friends.

He doesn’t know if this is the right thing to do. He can’t be sure he won’t start screaming halfway through the service, although he’s made a promise to himself that he’ll leave instead of making a scene. He doesn’t need to pull a VB.

Looking down, he realizes that he has a more immediate problem. Amy’s begun to snore softly, and a shining slug’s trail of saliva descends from her lower lip onto his T-shirt. If he wakes her up to tell her she’s drooling, she’ll be embarrassed. If he doesn’t wake her up, she’ll be more embarrassed when she finally wakes up on her own, and he’ll be wetter. He shifts to get more comfortable, hoping the movement will waken her. It doesn’t.

Stuck, Jeremy thinks, and for the first time in weeks feels an overpowering urge to cry. Crazy, he thinks, blinking back a tsunami. After everything else, why should this trigger tears?

And then he remembers. When he was still very small, five or six maybe, his mother took him to a small zoo north of Reno, a place that nursed injured wildlife back to health and kept the animals if they weren’t fit or strong enough to be released back into the wild. There were coyotes there, and once a month in warm weather, the zoo welcomed guests after dark for a coyote howl. When the coyotes howled, the humans howled along with them. Melinda brought Jeremy, bundled in a fleece jacket against the chill of the desert evening, cool even in summer. For once, he was alone with Mom: neither of the auntie-grannies came. He’d been anticipating the event for what felt like forever, although she’d probably only told him about it the day before. Being alone with his mom made him feel like a big boy.

Howling was fun for a little while, but then he fell asleep. When he woke up, his mother was carrying him back to the car, and his face was stuck to her shirt in a puddle of drool. He can still feel the ripping sensation against his skin as he lifted his head.

“Want to howl more,” he said.

“I’m sorry, sweetie. It’s over. No more howling tonight.”

“But they’re still howling!” Behind him, the wavering song of the coyotes was already fading, mournful and haunting.

“Yes, they are, but they’re howling by themselves now. The people, like us, have to go home and go to bed.”

“They sound lonely, Mommy.”

“They aren’t lonely, Jer. They have each other. They’re singing together.”

“They sound sad. They sound like they’re crying. Maybe they miss their mommies.” The naturalist who led the howl had explained that these coyotes had been taken in as pups after someone killed their mother.

“They have a safe home,” Melinda said firmly, giving Jeremy a squeeze, “and I’m right here.” Had her voice truly caught, or is he just inventing that now, knowing what he knows now that he’s older? His birthmother, the one in Guatemala who’s dead, whom he’ll never be able to remember. Had Mom been thinking about her? How could she not have been?

“I want to help them howl.”

“We’ll come back sometime, I promise. I didn’t know you were so tired!”

They never went back. The promised expedition was put off in favor of other outings—movies, trips to Lake Tahoe, swimming lessons—and finally forgotten altogether. Jeremy hasn’t thought about the incident in years, hadn’t even known he remembered it. His cheeks are slick. He lifts his free arm to dry his face, and Amy stirs.

“Are we there yet?”

“Nope. Hours to go. I was just shifting. Go back to sleep.”

“Unh.” She lifts her head—does he hear a faint ripping sound?—and says, “Oh, God, Jeremy, I drooled all over you! Crap!”

“It’s okay.”

He hears a sigh and sees VB bend in front of them, hears her rummaging through the overstuffed Lands’ End canvas tote she brought as her luxury item. After a minute, she passes back a pale, moist rectangle. Amy takes it.

“Baby wipe,” VB says briskly. “I figured they might come in handy. There you go, kids. Don’t say I never gave you anything.”

Jeremy hoots. “Like Archipelago with her baby wipes!” Come to think of it, Archipelago and VB have somewhat similar personalities, although VB has cats, not a scorpion.

VB gives him a blank look, but he knows Amy will understand the reference. She doesn’t say anything, though. She’s scrubbing at his shirt. The wipe smells like baby powder, a scent Jeremy has always found nauseating; he feels his nose wrinkling. “Aim, it’s okay. You can leave it, really.”

“Jeremy?” VB says. “What’s wrong?”

He closes his eyes, willing them to stop leaking. The walk to the car, coyotes mourning behind them, the faintly shining slug-trail of Jeremy’s spit on his mother’s shirt. Small as he was, he tried to wipe it with his hand, and Mom laughed. “It’s okay, Jer. I’ll put it in the laundry when we get home. But that’s nice of you, to try to clean it for me.”

He was so upset. He started crying again. Melinda thought he was tired, but Jeremy, remembering the story after so many years, thinks that was only part of it. He was grieving for and with the motherless coyotes, and he was grieving because he’d wasted in sleep some of this precious time alone with his mother, away from the other women with their constant chatter.

He’s the only person in the car who remembers the coyotes. He understands for the first time that the auntie-grannies are a memory bank: so much of his life has happened with one or more of them there. He’s always resented that, but now it means that some of Melinda is preserved outside of him, that other people can bear the burden of memory for him. The coyotes, though, are his alone.

What would it be like not to be able to remember? What would it be like to be Walter?

He squints, blinks. “Memory,” he said, and nudges Amy with his elbow. “Hey, Amy, that’s the third element! In the game. Order. Entropy. Memory.”

She frowns, chewing her lower lip in a way he’s come to see as charming. “Yeah? I’m not sure I follow.”

“I’m not sure I do, either, exactly. Okay: Order trumps Entropy and Entropy destroys Order—”

“That’s your seesaw.”

“Yeah. That’s the seesaw. But Memory: that’s what lets us rebuild.” He blinks, his lashes still wet, sticky now, like his face against his mother’s clothing or Amy’s against his own. “It feels right. I can’t explain it yet, but I think it’s right.”

Amy squirms and brings her knees up onto the seat so she can hug them. It’s her thinking position. VB and Rosie both half-turn, now. Rosie says, “What’s this, kids?”

“Um,” Jeremy says, balking. It seems too complicated to explain to the auntie-grannies. But when Amy gives them a quick summary, both Rosie and VB seem to understand what they’re talking about. Well, sure. VB’s a professor, isn’t she? And Rosie’s probably thought about memory a lot, because of what’s happened to Uncle Walter.

Trees whoosh past outside. The two women are quiet for a moment, thinking. VB has the furrow between her eyes she gets during class when she’s trying to teach something difficult, which means at least she’s taking this seriously. “Memory tips the seesaw,” she says after a second, and Rosie gives a soft grunt of approval.

“Right. That’s it, Vera.”

Amy’s nodding now, although Jeremy hasn’t gotten it yet. “What?”

Amy laughs. “Order trumps Entropy and Entropy destroys Order. That’s the seesaw, evenly balanced. But memory’s what people use to restore order, because they remember how things are supposed to be. So memory’s CC’s secret weapon.”

“Memory and hope,” Rosie says, “because sometimes people build things that haven’t existed before. Memory, hope, imagination. Your CC has a lot of secret weapons.”

“Entropy’s outgunned,” Amy says, sounding almost giddy. “EE’s toast, J.”

He looks out the window, at the passing trees. What he remembers most clearly now, what he’ll never be able to forget, is that his mother is dead, murdered. “Memory fuels revenge, too,” he says.

“Anything can be misused,” Aunt Rosie tells him. She reaches across the top of the seat between them to squeeze his hand. Her fingers are cool and very soft. “And entropy—time—it softens memory and makes it easier to bear. Maybe only a little bit, but still. We find out we can still breathe. That’s something.”

*   *   *

On the Alaska cruise, Melinda is restless, distracted. She’s just started the process of trying to adopt, and every time she sees a child on board, she stares: smitten or alarmed, the others can’t quite tell, but anyway fascinated.

“Mel,” Rosemary says over dinner one evening, when Melinda keeps craning her head to peer at two twin toddler girls—who brings kids that small on cruises, anyway?—“you have to stop ogling kids. You’re going to scare their parents.”

“Sorry.” Melinda reddens and turns to face the others again. “I’m being goofy, I know.”

“You’re being creepy,” Veronique says, and Melinda rolls her eyes.

“None of us has kids. Doesn’t that seem weird to you?”

“No,” says Veronique. “Lots of people don’t have kids. It’s something we have in common, that’s all.”

Melinda bites into her roll. “But why? Did all of you want to be childless? I mean, okay, I know it’s none of my business, and I guess I’m turning into one of those horrible people who act like anyone who doesn’t have kids is a mutant who deserves to be interrogated about it in public, but—”

“Mel,” Walter says mildly. “We’re friends. It’s okay.” He glances at Rosemary, who shrugs.

“I don’t mind talking about it. We tried. It didn’t work. We didn’t feel strongly enough about it to adopt. A kid would have made our lives too complicated.” She shakes her head. “Our parents were upset. They wanted grandchildren. My mother gave me a lecture about how selfish I was being, only living for myself. On the other hand, my mother’s most of the reason I spent twenty years in therapy, so I took anything she said with a grain of salt.”

“And we’ll all help you,” Walter says, smiling. “So, see? We’re all having a kid after all.”

Veronique snorts. “Well, fine. But I don’t like children. Oh, don’t stare at me like that! I’m sure I’ll like yours, Mel. I like the idea of them well enough, and I know they’re important, but in practice they’re loud and annoying. I wouldn’t have patience with a child.”

Melinda squints. “Vera, you teach.”

“College students. Who technically aren’t kids anymore, although sometimes I wonder, but even when they act like children, they’re children who can dress and feed and bathe themselves. I’m not responsible for their welfare. I’m just responsible for trying to teach them to think, which Lord knows is difficult enough.”

Someone at the next table yells, pointing out the window. “Whale! Whale! I just saw a breach!” Everyone in the dining room leaps from their seats, abandoning tableware and cutlery in a loud clanking rush to press against the windows, even though—as the ship’s naturalist explained to cruisers gawking on the deck that afternoon—breaching means that the whale has dived, and might not resurface for a long time.

While everyone else peers through the window, pointing hopefully at any splash or ripple on the water, Melinda sneaks a furtive glance at the twin girls, sitting piggyback on their parents’ shoulders so they can see over the crowd. One child gazes out the window with everyone else, asking in a piercing whine, “Where whale?” The other, oblivious, happily plays with her mother’s barrette. She isn’t loud or annoying at all.

*   *   *

The in-law quarters are small, but they have their own bathroom and even a tiny kitchenette. The most important factor, though, is a door. Veronique closes it to block out the din from the others. Too much chatter. Since the meltdown, she’s lost whatever tolerance for strangers she had. She knows it’s lovely of this priest—Greg, that’s his name, Hen’s friend—to put them all up, but her head’s still buzzing from the road. All she wants to do is nap.

They got here an hour ago. It’s a large, airy house, and Greg and his wife Linda had dinner waiting for them, a buffet with salad, lasagna in a warming pan, mixed vegetables, garlic bread, cookies. Iced tea, lemonade, soda. Veronique thought that eating real food in a stationary chair would make her feel better, ground her again, but it didn’t work. Hen and Rosie promptly got into church gossip with Greg and Linda while Jeremy and Amy chattered about the museum they want to see.

Veronique couldn’t follow any of the conversations, but they weren’t meant to include her, anyway. She sat and ate her lasagna, feeling like the kid without friends in the junior high cafeteria. Then she got up and started browsing the bookshelves, which contain a pretty respectable selection of literary fiction and chewy theological tomes. The others were still eating, still chattering. Although she knew it was childish, she found herself wishing they’d notice her absence and call her back to the table. They didn’t, of course.

So she excused herself, pleading headache. She’d ruthlessly claimed the in-law quarters the moment they got there, although she could tell Rosie wanted them. Tough. Rosie dragged her along on this ridiculous expedition. Veronique’s the one who doesn’t want to be here, which in her mind entitles her to extra consideration. Rosie can have the guest bedroom, even if it means she’ll have to share a bathroom.

Veronique opens her suitcase—Tom carried it in her for her—and extracts a light sweater. She’s chilly, even though it’s summer. She misses her Planet X pot, its weight and solidity, the fierceness of its uncompromising ridges against her skin. She wishes she’d brought it as her one luxury item. She could have packed it in a box with foam peanuts, or just held it unprotected on her lap. She suspects it’s stronger than she is right now, and it’s a link to home, to Melinda.

The luxury item she did bring was her own pillow, now on the bed with the suitcase. It has cat hair on it. Everything in Veronique’s house has cat hair on it. Greg’s in-law quarters will now have cat hair, too. She supposes she should warn him, in case anyone else likely to stay here is allergic, but she’ll do that later, or tomorrow, or before she leaves. She’s too tired now. And, anyway, the entire house is immaculate, which means that Greg and his wife either clean like crazy or, more likely, pay someone else to do it. The cat hair will be history.

Veronique drags her suitcase off the bed—light as it is, it hits the carpet with an audible thump—and lies down, hugging her pillow. The bed’s comfortable, a really good mattress, not one of those saggy sofa cushion things. She feels herself relaxing for the first time since leaving Reno.

Tomorrow the others will do their sightseeing, since they’ve arrived a day earlier than Hen thought they might. Veronique doesn’t know what she’ll do. Maybe she’ll go shopping and try to find another pot. Right now, though, she needs to sleep.

*   *   *

“You need to get some rest,” William says.

“After the service.” Anna just blew up at the caterers over the price of salmon canapés. She knows she’s being unreasonable. She doesn’t care. She’s been using this company for years; they always cater the gallery openings. The last time Anna worked with them, the salmon canapés were reasonable. Now they’re outrageous, and Anna suspects the caterers don’t want to be associated with Percy’s memorial service. She thinks they’re trying to get fired. She thinks they could at least have been nicer about the price of the canapés. This is her son’s funeral.

Is she being paranoid? She doesn’t care about that, either.

Standing in the kitchen, looking out at the deck, she rubs her forehead irritably. A few months ago, she craved sunlight. Now it’s making her eyes hurt, and she yearns for clouds.

“If you act like that at the service, no one will stay.” William’s voice is bland, but kind enough; she gives him a sharp look anyway. He’s been completely silent on the subject of the memorial, giving her total creative control, and this is the first hint she’s gotten that he may share her anxiety about the social aspects of the event, about the importance of the service as a way to restore or maintain their reputation in the community. This is, Anna knows, a completely selfish motivation, but right now she feels entitled to behave selfishly.

It’s not like it matters. Nobody’s going to come, except immediate family and the people from Reno. Anna’s anxious to meet them, but they can’t help with the local situation, and they can’t eat more than a bit of the food she’s ordered. Most of the salmon canapés will go uneaten. The flowers will wilt and die. The family reputation will remain ruined.

Entropy will conquer all.

“Take an Ambien,” William says. Some small part of her brain knows he’s right; she hasn’t slept for two days.

“I’m afraid of Ambien.” She’s begun to have obsessive dreams about Clarke Beach, dreams in which she’s the one wading into the water, Bart straining against his lead to try to save her. “People sleepwalk on that stuff. They open the fridge and eat everything inside, and then get into the car and drive to the supermarket and buy every pint of ice cream in the place.”

William lets out a long, dramatic sigh. He’s mocking her. “Okay, so take a Valium. Drink some scotch. Jesus, Anna! This thing was your idea, and it’s too late to cancel now.”

“I don’t want to cancel.”

“Then try to hold it together, all right?”

She walks to the kitchen table and sits down. She knows she needs to sleep, but she isn’t tired. She’s never felt less sleepy in her life. There’s too much to do. This is too important.

“What are we going to do with Percy’s ashes? Afterwards? We haven’t talked about that.”

“I have no idea. Let’s talk about it then.”

“Do you have any ideas? I thought maybe the Cascades—”

“I said let’s talk about it then.” William’s voice has gone quiet with warning. “After the memorial, all right? One thing at a time.”

She swallows bile. “He’s your son.”

“Do you think I don’t know that?”

Anna puts her hands flat on the table and presses, as if this will keep her voice from rising to a shriek. “Don’t you care?”

“About his ashes?” William’s standing in the kitchen doorway, his face a mask of controlled fury. “No. I don’t care about his ashes. His ashes are dirt. They aren’t him. They don’t mean anything. I cared about him when he was alive. If he were still alive, in prison, I’d be doing everything I could to help him, whatever horrors he committed. He was my son. But he’s not alive. He’s gone. The ashes don’t matter.”

She swallows again. “Do you care about the memorial?”

“It’s the right thing to do.”

Which doesn’t answer the question. She closes her eyes and sees Percy with Bart, sees Percy helping her over the tree roots. Images from photos. It occurs to her that of all the photos she’s looked at, she’s found none of the three of them together. William doesn’t approve of family portraits. He thinks they’re tacky. She believes his parents may have, must have, some photos of all three of them, but they haven’t given her copies.

Marjorie and David will be arriving at Sea-Tac in a few hours. If Anna had thought of this earlier, she’d have called and asked. It’s too late now. What they’ve brought with them is fixed now, unalterable, unless a neighbor could FedEx—

No. Too complicated. And maybe not important.

The last time she was at the airport was to pick up Percy. When he came home from Mexico.

Anna takes a breath, feels a shiver of premonition down her back. When she speaks, she hears her voice break. “William. Do you care about me?”

If this were a movie, a book, a graphic novel, even, he’d come and knead the knotted muscles in her neck, speak loving words of reassurance, promise her that together, they’ll get through this. But they’re in real life, in uncharted territory.

“Anna, please.” His own voice is frayed now. “I’m almost as tired as you are. Can’t we talk about all this after the service?”

He doesn’t wait for her answer. He turns, whistling for the dog, the old escape route. She hears the rattle of the leash, hears the front door open and close. He could so easily have said, “Of course I do,” even if he didn’t mean it, even if she wouldn’t have believed it. How hard would it have been for him to mouth any of the conventional phrases, to say the Right Things? How hard would it have been for him to throw her the smallest of bones?

Too hard, apparently. She can’t imagine what all of this is like for him: can’t even begin to, because he hasn’t told her, hasn’t let her in. She realizes with a sliding sensation in her bones that her marriage is over, another casualty of Percy’s violence. It’s been over for months, maybe even since before Melinda Soto died, but that brutality broke it irrevocably, and made the wreckage visible.

For a moment rage sweeps through her. If only Percy hadn’t gone to the bar that evening. If only he hadn’t met Melinda Soto. If only he hadn’t lost his mind. If if if.

But he did.

July 24 will be his twenty-third birthday. That morning, she decides, she’ll get up and have a private birthday moment, before the fiasco of the memorial service. She’ll take her coffee and a bran muffin out onto the deck, and she’ll put a candle in the bran muffin, and she’ll sing “Happy Birthday.” Not to the killer, no. To the sweet child she knew before that, the sweet child Percy would somehow still have been, or could have become again, if he were still alive now.

The rage is gone, and for the first time in days, she feels bone-heavy fatigue, aches with it. William’s right; she needs sleep. She doesn’t think she’ll have to take drugs to achieve it.