My mum lasted a few days at Toby’s over that Christmas (‘She was just prowling around after the booze’) before she went back to the London flat on her own. I couldn’t tell if she wanted my dad back for good or not. She’d take a taxi from the rank outside her flat to the care home, then afterwards catch a bus straight back down the road on the way home. The journey became puzzling in spite of its direct simplicity. Twice she overshot the bus stop and once ended up disorientated at Baker Street, where she had to ask a newspaper vendor the way back – although not before confusing him by being unable to resist pointing out she used to write for the very evening paper he was selling.
It reminded me of the last time they ever tried travelling abroad together. It was 1993. I was performing in Brussels with Tracey and – with some covert help from our tour manager – they had arranged to secretly fly over and surprise us, but they had nearly missed the flight. After collecting their boarding passes, my mum – then sixty-nine, and a little rusty at travelling – had crisply asked the check-in staff for directions, not to Departures or Passport Control, but Customs. As a result, they had been sent to a small remote office in the far corner of the terminal that dealt with all those things we all know there is no point ever trying to take with us on an aeroplane, like snails or soil or exotic plants. It was a good half a mile from where they should have been going. By the time they finally got back near the flight’s actual departure gate, hot and exhausted and out of breath, they weren’t speaking to each other, and my dad – hearing their names for the third time over the public address system – saw red and encamped himself sulkily in the duty-free shop, refusing to budge another inch, while my mum pressed on and stoically got on the plane without him. A search party was sent by the ground crew to collect him and they had to talk him into boarding the flight.
I tried to picture my mum on her own at the flat. I saw her restive and ill at ease, spending the first forty-eight hours moving photo frames around, smoothing and re-smoothing a shawl across the back of the sofa, squinting at a Final Reminder, huffing and sighing and looking out of a window, absent-mindedly waiting for the sound of my dad to clear his throat in another room, but I couldn’t picture her cooking for herself or listening contentedly to Radio 4 or taking her tablets every day at the right time or even enjoying her own company for very long – doing anything that might actually qualify as ‘independent living’.
When I think of her eating on her own it is always cold food – half a quiche, cottage cheese on Ryvita, a bowl of Alpen, a banana, a biscuit. A kind of deprivation. She drank half-cups of sweetened black coffee, but she used sweetener (Hermesetas) not sugar, even though she hated the aftertaste. She had always been conflicted about food: disgusted by waste; never indulgent. Cold scraps were put in the fridge after every meal, covered by a side plate. Even cold vegetables. They would stay in there for a couple of days until it was clear no one in the family in their right mind would touch them, and then she would finish them off in a show of dreadful self-sacrifice. As a child, I once saw her open the fridge at seven in the morning in her dressing gown, and bitterly eat a coagulated spoonful of cold Brussels sprouts and cheese sauce before throwing the remainder in the bin with disapproval and revulsion. ‘I grew up in a manse,’ she said, mid-mouthful. ‘What do you expect?’
It was true. She was born in Carlisle in 1924, the daughter of an itinerant Methodist minister. Her mother was a Welsh Wesleyan too. After a brief stop in Huddersfield, she was five when they moved for most of her childhood to Halifax, where the first manse they occupied was set in the grounds of a cemetery on Skircoat Moor. ‘It was like a dark barn,’ she said, ‘and funeral processions regularly pulled up outside our front door.’ The graveyard didn’t bother her as a child. She played hide-and-seek around the tombstones with her best friend, Joan, collecting discarded flowers left by the visitors. ‘We ran our own imaginary florist just for ourselves,’ she said. ‘A little table with all the wilting posies on it.’
On the edge of the cemetery – now overgrown – was a vast deserted octagonal brick tower, two hundred and fifty feet high, that still stands imperiously and incongruously over the Calderdale countryside. It used to creak in the howling wind at night. Sparrow hawks nested in its empty abandoned galleries. Her mother hated it. It was built as a chimney in the 1870s to take fumes from the old abandoned Washer Lane dye-works factory using an underground pipe, but in the end was never used. The owner, a rich Victorian magnate – John Wainhouse – had paid for it. Determined that it shouldn’t be an eyesore, he had spent a fortune on its design, including its four hundred and three interior steps and double viewing platforms. Wainhouse’s Folly, the locals called it. A colossus in the countryside. At night my mum sometimes thought it would fall on the house if she’d been bad.
When she was eight they moved to a new house on Rothwell Road with outhouses and a croft and a paddock, where her mother felt less oppressed by the surroundings. She went to a local school on the moor for a couple of years before being sent to a Methodist boarding school in Arnside, near Grange-over-Sands, and from there she went to another – Hunmanby Hall near Filey. ‘Life was very spartan,’ she told me, ‘bordering on the puritanical.’
Her father was not only a minister, but Romany on his mother’s side. Born in Hull, a nephew to the celebrated Christian evangelist Rodney ‘Gipsy’ Smith, he grew up with a consuming love of wildlife and the countryside, and for eleven years of my mum’s childhood the family spent summer holidays touring the country lanes around Whitby in a reconditioned horse-drawn vardo – the Romany name for a caravan. It was a proper barrel-roofed wooden wagon with casement windows, locker seats and a split door, bought from Brough Hill Fair in the Eden Valley for seventy-five pounds by her father three years before she was born. It sounds romantic but it was tough for a child: living frugally and walking the hedgerows for hours during the day, always in regimented single file with her older brother, much of it in silence in case they should disturb their father’s self-absorbed bird-watching or charcoal sketching; camping out under leaky canvas at night, spooked by the ants and the moths. If they weren’t out in the countryside they’d be parked up for weeks on end on the edge of windswept Eskdaleside in a farmyard near Hard Struggle Cottages with little to do except run races and swing on gates.
I dropped round one afternoon in the new year to see her at the flat. She’d left a short message on my voicemail: Could you bring me some cheese? When I arrived she was in the lobby with her coat on.
‘Oh, I thought you weren’t coming,’ she said. ‘I’m just stumbling out to the shops.’
‘I came as quickly as I could. If you still want to go, I’ll come with you.’
She smiled as if to say that would be lovely.
We pushed open the glass swing door. Outside, with her on my arm, life seemed to speed up suddenly. A motorbike courier was remonstrating with a cyclist. A group of tourists blocked the pavement, herding round an A-Z street map and pointing the wrong way towards Abbey Road. She gripped my arm and we walked gingerly down the steps. That same oaky sweet smell was on her breath.
‘The air is nice, darling,’ she said. ‘So stuffy in that flat some days.’
‘You should open a window.’
‘They’re all sealed up.’
‘No, they’re not. They’re double-glazed but they all slide open.’
‘Do they? You’ll have to show me.’
‘Again,’ I teased.
We walked along the pavement to the corner and turned and walked to the end of the block. The supermarket was on the opposite side.
‘What kind of cheese, Mum?’
‘Oh, forget it. I’ve got plenty really.’
‘Really?’
‘Yes, you know me. I’ll eat any old leftovers.’
‘If you’re sure.’
‘Let’s just go once round the block. It’s nice like this.’
She squeezed my arm.
I remembered being with her in a wheat field in Sussex near the Walberton cottage where we used to stay in the late sixties. I was almost seven. I could see her edging through a thicket and an iron kissing gate, and suddenly we were out the other side and the sky above our heads was streaked with tattered white clouds. The path cut down the side of the field. We ran our fingers through the outermost line of the blond crop – rough and smooth, rough and smooth – the heads craning and stretching away to the rise in the field, the leaf blades and stems nicking at my fingers. And then she was calling up ahead, ‘Come and look, come and look! Cow parsley and yarrow.’ I loved to hear the names – convolvulus, knapweed, lords and ladies, rosebay willow-herb. The sleeves of her smock were pulled high over her elbows, her crow-black hair pushed back over her forehead, her skin tanned. And at the end of the field we scuttled down the steep slope and over the sedge to the brook. She held my hand across the little wooden bridge. The clear water was puckered like seersucker by the rushes in the shallows, the pebbles on the bottom shining like toffees.
‘Why is it called the rife?’ I asked.
‘It’s an old word for river. A country word. It may look small now, but in the olden days, it was a big river and the tide would sweep right up here carrying boats with food and people on board.’
‘Where is the river now?’
‘It’s gone back to the sea.’
We started to climb up the other side.
‘Let’s recite a poem to get us to the top,’ she said, pushing on ahead. And I could hear her voice, strong and articulate:
‘I went out to the a hazel wood,
Because a fire was in my head,
And cut and peeled a hazel wand,
And hooked a berry to a thread;
And when white moths were on the wing,
And moth-like stars were flickering out,
I dropped the berry in a stream . . .’
‘ “And caught a little silver TROUT”!’ I shouted.
‘Yeats!’ she shouted back.
I loved the rich evocative words and was frightened of the white moths and the dark hazel wood, and then we were at the top of the hill and we stopped and sat down and looked back to the brook below and the wheat field beyond. A breeze disturbed the hedgerow. The leaves shivered. A cluster of finches darted down the track.
‘Finches love the hedgerow and the crops,’ she said. ‘We might see linnets and buntings this week too.’
The old small church was at the top of the rise. I half looked at it, half hid my eyes. It was frightening and beautiful. We’d walked there once in winter when the track was as hard as bones, flecked with snow, and the fields were empty, in a huffling wind, and I wouldn’t look up. The bell-tower was black in my imagination. And then my mum had taken me to the graveyard wall and made me look, and when I opened my eyes the ground was a carpet of glistening frosted snowdrops and it was like something from a fairy story.
The cottage where we stayed smelled of woodsmoke and books. The front door opened directly into the small living room. There was no central heating. The downstairs was heated only by a small open fire. The staircase to the two bedrooms above and the short passage to the kitchen had latched doors to stop the draughts. When they creaked it made me want to hide my head under the bedclothes. The passage to the kitchen was piled high with old newspapers. Dried mud clung to the coir matting. At mealtimes we huddled round the kitchen table under a huge poster of a snowy owl with yellow shining eyes with yet more newspapers piled up beside us. Often it was so cold the steam from the food looked like smoke.
Two steps down from the kitchen was a bedroom with more books and pictures of clowns on the wall, and I wasn’t allowed to play in there, as the man who lived in the cottage most of the time had ‘his things’ in there.
Upstairs there was a bedroom for grown-ups above the sitting room with a double bed, and another room with bunk beds and orange nylon sleeping bags, where I slept beside a smelly paraffin heater. The cold bathroom had a dark cupboard full of cobwebs and a tank full of water that spluttered and groaned. I used to scare myself by opening it and leaning inside.
Outside the back door there were three small gardens, interlinked by high hedges with fat shiny leaves. It was all unkempt and overgrown and gave me itchy legs. There was a knotted and crinkly fruit tree that hurt my knees if I tried to climb it, and tall grasses grew at the back. (‘Don’t go in there. There are tigers.’)
If you scraped away the undergrowth you could find big iron rings embedded in the ground. My dad told me they were ‘Sinbad’s buried treasure’ and that he had landed at Climping and dragged his haul of jewels to the garden and buried it, but no one had had the strength to prise it out, and I tried not to believe him, but I wanted to, and it was only when my mum told me the place used to be a blacksmith’s forge and the rings were for the horses that I stopped looking at them, and was annoyed at my dad for lying to me.
In the furthest garden was an outbuilding, a small barn. Downstairs had been made into two bedrooms and my half-brothers sometimes slept in there. My eldest half-brother, Simon, was eighteen by then and had one of the rooms to himself and burned sandalwood joss sticks and played Roy Harper and Beach Boys records. He had cut out the face and shoulders of Roy Orbison from the front of a vinyl record sleeve and pinned it to the window ledge, and made a small hole where his mouth was and would dangle a lit joss stick from Roy Orbison’s lips. I thought it was a dangerous thing to do but also strange and lovely – like the altar at the end of a church where the cross stands. Simon used to walk across the fields on his own to the church some days and play songs on the organ when no one was there.
Above the bedrooms was a huge dark loft full of long strips and sheets of polystyrene; I never knew why they were up there. A rusted iron ladder was propped up outside against the gabled end, half hidden in an unruly thorny pyracantha bush. It scratched my legs, but I could get to the top and swing the loft door open, and turn round and sit in the doorway, and look out over the wheat field where I walked with my mum.
‘Who owns this cottage?’ I would say to her. I often asked the same question several times if I felt the answer I got the first time didn’t make sense, or to test whether I would get the same answer twice, and therefore it was more likely to be true.
‘Uncle Ken rents it from a nice man in the village.’
‘And who is “Uncle Ken” again?’
‘He is your brothers’ and sister’s father. And I was married to him once.’
‘Why aren’t you married to him now?’
‘Because I am married to your father.’
‘Is he your brother?’
‘No.’
‘Then why is he called Uncle Ken?’
‘We just call him that, darling.’
‘Why does Simon light joss sticks?’
‘It’s his room and he can do what he likes. Now run along.’
I think being unsure of Ken’s identity made the cottage even more special and secret.
We walked on slowly. The pavement was uneven. Padlocked to a lamp-post was a bicycle frame with no wheels. A police siren wailed near by and I felt my mum flinch. I filled the moments with chatter about the kids.
At the traffic lights she said suddenly, ‘Do you think I could have him back?’
I watched a plane disappear behind a cloud. For a moment I couldn’t think what she was talking about and then realised she meant my dad. ‘What makes you say that?’ I said.
‘He makes such a fuss now when I leave. I can’t bear it.’
I thought of them without me there at the care home: just a couple; still the little shifts in dominance; moments of beseeching; the things we do and the roles we play when we are sure no one is watching. ‘And how will you cope?’
‘Like I always have done, dear.’
We stood at the crossroads. I watched a car slow down, climb up on to the raised speed-table, then ease itself down the other side. I wondered how it was having to ask your children for help, knowing that some things can no longer be done without them – lifting things, organising things. Was it a little degrading, having to wait on the authorisation of someone who once relied on you so completely? As the traffic lights changed I asked myself if all this was easier in other people’s lives – these people, the ones in front of me in their cars criss-crossing in a matrix of dropping off, picking up, going home, leaving town. Was it the same for everyone? Life as a slow journey of negotiations. Back and forth. I pictured my mum and dad back at the flat. It was not much more than a year since they’d first moved in. I saw myself unpacking their things, making it nice, mapping it out, feeling I could make a difference. And suddenly I was conscious that I might make no difference, that I could help them do something but not influence its outcome, as if I had simply been invited in to view it all at close quarters, made to witness something, and it was going to unfold inexorably, whether I liked it or not, whatever I said, and it was something I just had to get through.