III:4. Struggling Together with God

  1.       Genesis 31:30.

  2.       Genesis 32:4–33.

  3.       Genesis 33:4–9.

  4.       Genesis 46:29.

  5.       AVK—to wrestle or struggle. HBK—to embrace. Compare va-ye’avek (Genesis 32:25) with va-yehabbek(ehu) (Genesis 33:4). Some commentators associate Jacob’s nighttime wrestling partner with Esau.

  6.       Or the “Lonely Man of Faith” of Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik, Tradition 7:2 (Summer 1965), to whom Greenberg was subtly alluding.

  7.       Yes, I have in mind Wittgenstein’s argument against private language. See Ludwig Wittgenstein, Philosophical Investigations, 2nd ed. (Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1958, 1992), sec. 269 et seq.

  8.       Genesis 2:18.

  9.       Hosea 3:1.

  10.     Exodus 9:3.