Solution—Kill Crazy

1. The knife-carrier is not the killer as Sheriff Flynn was shot.

2. Hunt is not the knife-carrier or the killer.

3. Moxie Moggs is not the knife-carrier. Jake Barron is not the knife-carrier or the murderer.

4. The knife-carrier and killer are friends. Hence, as Barron and Hunt are neither knife-carrier or murderer, and as Moggs is not the knife-carrier, Moxie Moggs is the murderer.

Therefore, Mike Cleary is the knife-carrier.

* * * *

MURDER MAY PASS UNPUNISHED FOR A TIME, BUT TARDY JUSTICE WILL OVERTAKE THE CRIME.

—Dryden