Chapter Twelve

Emma

The following morning, the yard is quiet and still. All the hustle and bustle has completely disappeared. The workers aren’t working. The cooks in the cook shack shuffle about with as few movements as necessary. Even the wind has died, leaving the tall grasses surrounding the backyard motionless.

Only one sound permeates the yard—the high, mournful keening of Mrs. Potter’s surviving dogs.

I ache to join them. To stand by Benjamin, to tell Mrs. Potter I’m sorry, to do something. But a rock sits in the pit of my stomach, anchoring me in place. So I hang back, sticking to the edges of the crowd drifting toward Mrs. Potter’s trailer.

I find Sidney lounging against one of the nearby trailers, watching the scene from beneath his dark hair. I want to tell him what I saw. Or maybe let these hiccup-y sobs trying to rattle their way out of me do just that. But what right do I have to these emotions when I’ve barely been with the carnival a week? So I pull my spine up straight and act as though it’s a regular day and my heart isn’t breaking for Ben, Mrs. Potter, and the little white dog who comforted me when I needed it the most.

Sidney gives me a grunt by way of greeting. It’s before eight, so I nod toward the paper cup full of milky coffee and ask, “What cup are you on? Two? Three?”

“Two,” he says, never taking his eyes from the trailer before us. “And please keep all questions that are harder than that one until after I get another cup in me. I’m useless until I’m on cup number three.”

“So you must have been useless the whole time you were in the box, huh?”

That bit of smart-assery earns a mildly amused glare in return but that’s it. When he doesn’t say anything, I add, “You’re up early for someone who doesn’t have to be.”

“Can’t seem to sleep longer than four hours,” Sidney says. “And I don’t dream.” He frowns, a sharp line settling in between his brows. “At least, I don’t remember them if I do.”

I don’t know what to say to that, so I say nothing and turn back to the funeral and the churn of feelings in my belly.

After Leslie calms Mrs. Potter down, Lars picks up the small, cloth-wrapped body, and they bury the dog several feet away from the edge of the yard.

The reedy grasses brush up against my legs, the touch so soft I only register it’s happening because I can hear the dry rasp it makes. Mrs. Potter, who had seemed as immutable as her blazing-purple hair, is shaking, her shoulders heaving with ragged breaths. I want to do something but I don’t know what. It feels like anything I might say would be insincere. I knew her terrier better than I knew her. But the dogs’ howling has plucked at some cord deep inside me, and it reverberates with the ache of loss.

Ben had been shocked. Everyone had, but Ben had seemed particularly fond of the dog. The fuzzy white terrier had slipped off a ramp and didn’t get up. The moment after the fall hung in the air like a bead of water about to drop from a leaf, fat and heavy with promise. Then everyone sprang into action.

The customers were quickly ushered into another tent by one of the clowns. Everyone else—Benjamin, Mrs. Potter, a grizzled-looking clown who had stayed back—all hovered over the dog, waiting. I don’t think they were expecting a zombie dog resurrection, but it was more like they couldn’t believe a dog could die in the first place.

Even now, a sense of disbelief pervades the carnival. It’s in the way people slowly shake their heads and let their sentences trail off before completion. It’s in the blank stares into nothingness, the startled faces when someone tries to catch another’s attention. A few nervous glances are thrown my way, but I can’t tell if it’s because they think the accident was my fault or if they still hadn’t gotten a good look at me. Common sense tells me it isn’t the former. Self-doubt tried to convince me it is.

“I feel like I’m still missing something,” I say, watching Sidney as he sips from his cup. Sometimes I think I miss food so much that I’ll go crazy if I can’t eat. But this body doesn’t get hungry. And when I tried to sneak a bit of cotton candy, it stuck to my desert-dry tongue like cobwebs. Other times I feel so detached that it almost scares me that I’ve changed so much in such a short period of time.

Sidney looks in my direction but not at me, like he’s occupied with something else. “You know those signs some places have that say something like ‘Ten days since our last accident’?”

I nod.

“Okay. Well, imagine the carnival has one of those. Except instead of a number of days, try the word ‘never.’ All right, ‘never’ may be an exaggeration, but we’ve gone years and years and years without something like this happening.” He stares off at Leslie leading Mrs. Potter away, with Lars and Ben herding the pack of howling dogs. “Years.”

“Bullshit,” I say, already sick of Sidney’s hyperbole for the day.

Sidney gestures to the crowd, coffee spilling from his cup in a pale arc. Some of it spatters on the bare legs of one of the bright redheads who work the cotton candy booths, but Sidney ignores her glare. “Do you really think there’d be this much fuss otherwise?”

There were a lot of people gathered here. “Okay, fine. Let’s say I believe you, and this never happens. Why did it happen now? And to that poor dog? Everyone keeps going on about the charm and how it protects everyone, but this doesn’t seem very protected.”

“That is an excellent question, Emma,” Sidney says as he stares at me. I don’t like it. It’s not predatory, like the night he tricked me, but there is more to it than I can parse out at the moment. But like the showman he is, his expression switches, going from lost in thought to jovial carnival performer in a heartbeat. “But I thought I told you to hold all hard questions until I had more coffee.”

We’re silent as Mrs. Potter passes us, her gentle sobbing the only sound. I reach out and grab her hand as she goes by, giving her fingers a quick squeeze. Her smile is watery, barely more than her hot-pink lips pressing together, but at least I offered some comfort for the poor woman.

“So,” Sidney says as he pushes off the trailer. “I hear you and Benjamin had a run-in with the Fabulous Moretti Brothers.”

Sidney walks deeper into the yard, and, since I don’t have anything better to do, I follow. I wish it was warmer, and that my shudder didn’t look like I did it out of fear from hearing their name. “Yeah. Assholes.”

Sidney runs his hands over his face and through his hair. “I’m going about this all wrong. You need to take a few nights off from the box.” I start to protest, but he holds up a hand to stop me. “Look, I know, okay? I know that all you want is to get out of there. But taking a couple of days to acclimate to the carnival isn’t going to hurt you. If anything, it’ll make you better, smarter. Seeming like you fit in is part of the illusion that makes it easier to trick someone. Trust me.”

“‘Trust me,’ says the guy who pushed me from a Ferris wheel.”

A half scowl twists up his mouth while he tries to find the right thing to say, though I don’t know that there is a right thing to say in an instance like this. But ultimately, he just shrugs. “I’m only staying on to help. If you don’t want me to help you, tell me, and I’ll leave.”

I stop walking and look at him. He jams his hands into his pockets and stops beside me. I can’t tell if he means it or not. If he really stayed on because of me. Do real human feelings lurk beneath the shallow surface that only seems to be concerned with eating every meal he missed out on in the time he was trapped by the curse? But then his gaze is caught by something past my shoulder. It’s Benjamin and a blond woman who looks incredibly like him, walking away from Mrs. Potter’s trailer.

Oh.

Oh.

“Are you really staying for me, or does it have something to do with her?”

That snaps him out of it. “Huh? Wait, what? Ben’s mom? Audrey? No. No, I’m staying to help. It’s part of the deal. Even if you did pass on the curse tonight, you wouldn’t get to leave. You have to help your successor. It’s not a real rule, but it’s more of an honor code kind of thing, so stop looking for a double meaning behind this”—he waves his arms emphatically around himself—“and just let me help you.”

But there’s something in his tone, in the way his eyes won’t meet mine. He’s lying. Again.

We leave the yard and near the carnival grounds. Mrs. Potter won’t perform tonight, but the show must go on. As the performers and workers drift away from the little funeral, the carnival slowly comes back to life. Two women running games next to each other hose the grass and mud off the fronts of their booths. Leslie and Lars pass us on the path, the big man bent over nearly double in order to better hear the tiny ringmaster. We stop where Gin and Whiskey are stretching, getting ready to run through their paces. A man who must be their father leads a white horse with speckled-gray haunches around a circle.

“Listen,” Sidney says, eyes firmly locked on the horse making its way around the ring. “Some people think that the curse is just transferred with a kiss. Don’t correct them.”

I nearly stumble I stop so fast. “Why wouldn’t I—”

“Because,” Sidney says, his words sharper than I’ve ever heard them. “You can use it. To protect yourself.” He drapes his arms over the metal tubing of the makeshift fence and watches the girls run through their act.

“Why would I need to protect myself by threatening people with the curse?”

“You never know, Em. Never know.”

Sidney doesn’t seem to have anything to add, and I don’t feel like pressing him. The next time the girls’ dad leads the horse around the circle, the girls run up a brightly painted ramp and jump onto the moving horse’s back. They wobble for a second and I’m sure that one of them is going to fall. But then, with a smooth bend of her arm, Gin has Whiskey balanced while making it look like it was part of the act in the first place.

As the girls ride off to the far side of the ring, Audrey and Ben walk into view, and I take a better look at them. So Audrey is Benjamin’s mother? The more I study them, the more apparent it seems. Ben has a narrower nose, a different line to his mouth. Their hair is the same, and so are their eyes, but then Ben has those charming glasses where Audrey seems fine without.

Sidney can’t stop staring at Audrey, even though Whiskey is now balancing on one leg on the back of the trotting horse. Her balance never wavers, and neither does Sidney’s gaze.