data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/27a13/27a13065129e8ac270f712158a32d2cddca475bd" alt=""
PROFESSIONAL SPORTS AUTHENTICATORS
THE TRADING CARD
★ ★ ★
Like its American cousin, the baseball card, the hockey card had its beginnings in tobacco products. The first full-out sets appeared in 1910–11, produced by Imperial Tobacco. Unlike baseball cards, however, hockey cards were hard to come by before 1910. Baseball stars were often part of multi-sport series like Allen & Ginter’s cards; hockey players, meanwhile, weren’t often subjects in these products. Those early Imperials, three sets in total, were classified as “C” by American Card Catalog author Jefferson Burdick. Modern manufacturers Topps and In The Game would pay tribute to these first series by using their design to showcase modern players. The floodgates opened soon after World War I ended, as more cigarette series were produced. The turn to kid-friendly products followed as companies like Paulin’s Candy entered the growing fray.
The first products that teased hockey’s soon-to-come “modern era” in hockey cards was a short run by O-Pee-Chee in the 1930s, including oversized and undersized (by today’s standards) cards, as well as a unique pop-up product. Companies like Sweet Caporal and World Wide Gum also produced series, while European issues began to pop out of cigarette and confectionary packs the same way they did in North America. With the onset of World War II, however, cards were again shelved, as O-Pee-Chee ceased production.
In 1951, the hockey card market changed forever when confectioner Parkhurst issued its first set. Amid this era, the focus turned from the cards helping to sell gum to gum helping to sell cards. Boys and girls hunted for the series that, at first, still featured art renditions. The company would later be joined by American card king Topps, soon after it had disposed of baseball rival Bowman (ironically, the cards were actually manufactured by O-Pee-Chee). After Topps’s arrival, a split occurred, whereby Parkhurst produced cards of the Canadian teams and Topps took on the U.S. squads. There would be a slight shift a couple years into the structure as Parkhurst would also begin producing cards of the Detroit Red Wings. The split between the two companies lasted through the 1963–64 season, when Parkhurst folded after issuing its perhaps most iconic design, with the pre-maple leaf Canadian flag or American flag in the background of primarily posed shots. With the closure, Topps had the hockey market cornered until the 1968–69 season, when O-Pee-Chee produced its first series under its own brand name. O-Pee-Chee mirrored the Topps sets, except for two differences: O-Pee-Chee had more cards and included French text on the reverse.
The O-Pee-Chee–Topps split continued through the 1970s and 1980s, with the only major difference being that O-Pee-Chee had the market cornered on World Hockey Association (WHA) products. Occasionally, the two companies would experiment — O-Pee-Chee did a “big” series in 1980–81 and produced “mini” series in 1987–88 and 1988–89. Topps, for its part, broke its 1981–82 series into regional series, and later brought its “Tiffany” premium boxed sets into the market. The only true interruption during this time was a two-year layoff for Topps (1982–83 and 1983–84) when they didn’t produce any cards for American fans. But the monopolistic bubble for the O-Pee-Chee–Topps tandem burst for the 1990–91 season when three new manufacturers entered the market and hockey cards went from being bicycle and flip game fodder to stock market desirables.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4a59c/4a59c7a50de0d3b375bb62a7dbafb8445f4542cb" alt=""
JON WALDMAN
The rest of hockey card history breaks down as follows:
1990–91
- Pro Set, Score, and Upper Deck, three companies who had entries in other sports, join the hockey market. Each comes loaded with its own specialty — Upper Deck has, arguably, the most premium feel (and inarguably premium pricing), along with a French parallel series and exclusive rights to the Canadian World Junior team; Score hits the ground with an exclusive for Eric Lindros cards and split editions for Canadian and American audiences; and Pro Set … well, it had lots of errors.
- While Topps rests on its laurels for the most part, O-Pee-Chee introduces Russian stars like Sergei Fedorov and Arturs Irbe in its main set and later issues its own premium series, O-Pee-Chee Premier. The set did so well that demand pushed pack prices to the $10 mark.
1991–92
- All five companies return with guns blazing. Pro Set, Score, and Upper Deck introduce the hockey market to in-pack certified autographs with Patrick Roy, Bobby Orr, and Brett Hull signatures respectively.
- Pro Set also reintroduces Parkhurst to the hockey market in conjunction with brand rights holder Dr. Brian Price.
- Upper Deck expands on the World Junior success, first by getting the rights to Canada Cup cards and later expanding its World Junior line to include all participating teams (while also producing an exclusive series for issue in Czechoslovakia).
- Upper Deck partners with McDonald’s for the first of many series issued through the fast-food chain.
- Topps and Score push the premium brand further with the introduction of Stadium Club and Pinnacle, respectively. O-Pee-Chee tries to keep up with Premier, but the lustre is already gone.
- Draft pick sets become all the rage as overnight companies Ultimate and Arena join card veterans Star Pics and Classic. Ultimate also issues the first mainstream retro series with Original Six (which also included autographs).
- The first true Summit Series retro product is issued by Future Trends. The company would release one more series the following year, commemorating the 1976 Canada Cup.
1992–93
- The hockey card market reaches its true boom. Baseball magnate Fleer joins the hockey market, while most of the other brands soldier on.
- O-Pee-Chee issues its sole base brand series that is completely different from Topps.
- Topps and Pro Set (via the Parkhurst brand) introduce the hockey market to parallel cards – pieces that are similar to a ‘base’ card save for a different feature, usually added foil.
- Pro Set, one year after filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in the U.S., issues its final series.
- Classic, the last draft set standing, signs Manon Rheaume to an exclusive contract, making her the first woman to appear in a mainstream hockey series.
1993–94
- With Pro Set gone, baseball veteran Leaf/Donruss gains a hockey licence.
- The NHL and NHLPA limit the number of hockey card series that can be issued, effectively ending the boom era in the process.
- An O-Pee-Chee series is not released for the first time in decades, as both Topps and its Canadian cousin issue Premier series in its place. Topps continues Stadium Club and teases the arrival of Finest one year later.
- Score signs Alexandre Daigle to an exclusive and in doing so creates the first redemption card (a card that offers a replacement upon notification by mail or online registration) in modern hockey card history.
- The World Junior licence is burst open and available to all card manufacturers; only Score cashes in on the opportunity, while others like Fleer and O-Pee-Chee and Topps concentrate on the 1994 Olympic squads.
- Upper Deck gains the rights to produce Parkhurst cards, including a “Missing Link” set that fills in the gap year of 1956–57 when no hockey card sets were produced (the reason for this is unknown to this day).
1994–95
- The autographed card market is blown wide open as Upper Deck teams with the NHL Players’ Association (NHLPA) to issue the first Be A Player series, which includes one autograph per pack. The set is an immediate hit, and packs can be seen hitting the $20 mark.
- O-Pee-Chee issues its final series as a company.
- The NHL lockout plays havoc with intended redemption programs, including the You Crash the Game set in Parkhurst. The program “officially” launches successfully one year later.
- Upper Deck releases the first “SP” pack series, a brand that would splinter into several sets in subsequent years.
1995–96
- Topps issues its supposed last sets in hockey (in actuality, they teamed with Fleer for a set called Picks one year later and a sticker set the year following). The Topps series includes an O-Pee-Chee parallel (as it would for the Picks series), keeping the brand name alive in hockey.
- All licencees combine for a set titled NHL Cool Trade. Each company also has redemption programs for parallel versions of their respective entries.
- After splitting with Upper Deck, Dr. Price opens Parkhurst Products Inc., with a European-only distribution chain. Naturally, some product makes its way to North American shores.
1996–97
- One year after acquiring the McDonald’s licence, Score (now known as Pinnacle Brands) gains the Be A Player licence from the NHLPA and produces the series for the first time with NHL licensing in tow.
- Pinnacle also purchases Donruss/Leaf, expanding its stronghold in the hobby.
- Upper Deck issues hockey’s first memorabilia cards — cards with swatches from game-worn jerseys.
- Fleer produces its final sets (at least for the short-term).
1997–98
- Pacific Trading Cards joins the hockey card market in a flurry of series.
- The Upper Deck’s experiment with jersey cards continues, and Pinnacle joins in the growing craze.
- Topps gains a licence with the Canadian Hockey League (CHL). It’s the first time a dedicated set for the league has been issued since 7th Inning Sketch (yes, they were a hockey card company) folded after the 1991–92 season.
- Pinnacle issues printing plates in its series, a first for hockey.
1998–99
- Mere weeks after issuing promotional cards for an intended Donruss series, Pinnacle closes up shop suddenly.
- Be A Player is launched as its own trading card company and carries on the one-autographed-card-per-pack tradition.
- Topps returns to the NHL market officially. O-Pee-Chee cards continue to be part of its programs as the company issues O-Pee-Chee Chrome. The CHL licence is imported to the NHL series for the first time since the early 1990s.
- Upper Deck regains the McDonald’s licence in the wake of Pinnacle’s downfall.
- Upper Deck issues the first retro jersey cards, cutting up a Winnipeg Jets jersey of Bobby Hull.
2000–01
- Pacific blows up the memorabilia card concept, issuing three products that promise one jersey card per pack. Upper Deck and Be A Player follow suit in subsequent years.
- Be A Player gives hockey its first ultra-premium series, Ultimate Memorabilia. Packs for this set hit the three-figure mark.
- Be A Player causes a major stir in the hobby as it announces it is cutting the only known set of goalie pads worn by Georges Vezina. As a result, the cards themselves hit four–figure values.
- After a couple years layoff, Be A Player reintroduces the Parkhurst line via an insert series. One year later, the set is once again a standalone.
- Upper Deck gains the CHL licence.
2001–02
- The NHL and NHLPA announce that players must appear in an NHL game before one of their cards can be featured in a licensed product.
- Topps officially reintroduces O-Pee-Chee as a base brand series.
- Fleer gains a limited NHL licence, allowing it to only produce cards of retired players.
- Pacific and Upper Deck cross into the bobblehead world with Heads Up and Playmakers, respectively, as box toppers on products.
- Upper Deck brings mini masks to NHL products with Mask Collection.
2002–03
- As quickly as they re-enter, Fleer re-exits the NHL market, having produced only three series in its short tenure.
2003–04
- Topps issues its final full-out series in hockey. One year later, their last true hockey card is issued, in the Chronicles set, commemorating the lost season of the NHL lockout.
- Be A Player changes its name to In The Game. Among the premiums offered for box buyers is a series of miniature Stanley Cups with its Memorabilia series.
- Pacific issues its first (and only) American Hockey League (AHL) series.
2004–05
- Upper Deck gains an exclusive agreement with the NHLPA, ending the tenures of most of its competitors.
- Pacific issues its final NHL series. In anticipation of the resurrection of the WHA, it signs a licensing deal for the new league. Only two promotional cards are issued before Pacific shuts down and is sold to Donruss/Playoff Inc. (then primarily a football card company).
- In The Game retains an NHL licence and also signs on with the Professional Hockey Players’ Association (PHPA), CHL, and AHL (along with limited licensing with international licensors). As a result, it produces the first mainstream cards of Sidney Crosby and Alexander Ovechkin.
2005–06
- Upper Deck signs a five-year contract with the NHL and NHLPA for full exclusivity, effectively pushing In The Game out of the major hockey card market. It also gains the coveted licences for McDonald’s and the Be A Player brand (both of which were shut down during the lockout) and Parkhurst.
- Sidney Crosby, Alexander Ovechkin, and their rookie brethren push hockey card collecting into an echo era.
- Upper Deck buys out Fleer and brings its brands back to the NHL.
- Upper Deck releases The Cup, an ultra-premium series that only the most affluent (and risk-taking) of collectors can indulge in.
- In The Game continues its CHL and AHL contracts, as well as signing current and former NHL players on an individual basis.
2006–07
- Upper Deck gains the O-Pee-Chee licence, reviving the popular brand while also issuing the last Parkhurst set that will be seen until the 2011–12 NHL season.
- In The Game produces its first cards with Hockey Canada licensing. The contract lasts for two years.
2009–10
- Topps issues the Puck Attax game card set, fuelling rumours it will return to the NHL market in full when the exclusivity contract with Upper Deck expires at season’s end. It doesn’t.
- The final full-out McDonald’s series is released.
- The final Be A Player series is released.
2010–11
- Sticker magnate Panini, who the year prior purchased Donruss/Playoff Inc., gains an NHL licence and immediately makes an impact, bringing in favourites from the Score/Pinnacle, Donruss/Leaf, and Pacific eras.
2012–13
- With the NHL lockout slicing the season, the NHLPA makes the unique decision to hold any debuting players over for the 2013–14 trading card year.
2013–14
- Upper Deck regains exclusive license for NHLPA trading cards at season’s end.
Needless to say, it’s been an interesting few years since the boom era, and those days aren’t going to end soon.