It was an idea that never failed to entrance Beth Harper, the notion that a simple object – well, two actually – could be so utterly transformative. Just ask Dorothy Gale.
Positioning a pair of sequined red heels onto the black-and-white-striped-clad ‘legs’ she’d fashioned from a couple of cardboard tubes, Beth stood back and evaluated her work.
The famed ruby-red slippers were of course unmistakable, but perhaps the polystyrene farmhouse looked a little off? No, Beth figured most shoppers would get the theme. The Yellow Brick Road (hand-painted at home in her apartment the night before) was a giveaway.
Anyway, it wasn’t as though she could call on Hollywood resources for her displays – nope, all Beth had at her disposal were basic craft supplies, her own imagination and, of course, some of the world’s most beautiful shoes.
Thankfully she also had her boss’s blessing, especially when the management of Carlisle’s – the popular Lexington Avenue department store in which she worked – realised that Beth’s movie-themed shoe displays not only delighted shoppers, but attracted tourists to the shoe room in droves, during the holidays especially. Her in-store displays weren’t quite as popular a tourist attraction as Saks’ Christmas windows, but they were getting there.
For Beth, the opportunity to utilise her greatest passion – the movies – in her day-to-day work was a dream come true, and she loved delighting Carlisle’s customers and staff all year long by using beautiful shoes to help recreate some of Hollywood’s greatest movie moments.
Satisfied that her latest masterpiece was complete, she made a final check that everything was in place in the shoe department, before the store opened its doors to the public that morning. December was a time when people from all over flocked to the city for Christmas shopping, Broadway shows, outdoor ice-skating and the many other festive activities that made New York great.
Irish by birth, Beth had lived in Manhattan for the better part of ten years, and over that time had learned to appreciate the ramped-up energy of the city during the busy holiday season. Even though the accompanying chill wind played havoc with her hair … That thought made Beth double-check that her medium-length blond ponytail was still in one piece after all her creative endeavours. It wouldn’t do for her own appearance to let her down when the whole shop was decked in finery.
Christmas cheer exploded throughout Carlisle’s, almost as though Santa’s elves had come to do the décor. Delicate tree branches dusted with snow lined the ceiling, and fairy-lit pine cone garlands danced around the beams. Elegantly decorated fir trees twinkled on every floor, and beneath them were selections of the best Christmas fare the world’s most famous luxury brands had to offer. The holiday merchandising team had even hung random bunches of mistletoe in different spots around the store, encouraging customers to join in the fun.
But while she loved this time of year in the city, just then Beth couldn’t help but think about warmer climes. She and Danny, her boyfriend of seven years, had planned to leave for a long weekend with friends in South Florida today, but due to a pressing work issue on his part, they’d had to make a last-minute cancellation. Which was why Beth found herself on the sales floor in the first week of December, busying herself with a festive Wizard of Oz theme, and covering a shift for one of the part-timers in the department.
The distraction of setting up the new display was working wonders in helping keep her spirits up, but deep down she was a little disappointed. She had really been looking forward to a relaxing break away before the Christmas retail rush kicked off in earnest, but more importantly, she’d wanted some time alone with Danny. They lived together – had done so for the past five years – but there was something extra romantic about a break away with the one you loved, far from humdrum day-to-day habits and responsibilities.
Still, she thought, straightening a crystal and satin Kate Spade pump (which worked brilliantly as one of Glinda’s Silver Shoes) on the central display, it was no great hardship to be here surrounded by such prettiness.
While her love affair with the movies had been inspired by her grandmother Bridie – who had introduced Beth to all the Hollywood classics at a young age – she guessed her appreciation of shoes had also begun with the first glimpse of her grandmother’s vintage Mary Janes when she was a child.
She and her mother had found the wedding shoes amongst Nana’s things after she died, and 12-year-old Beth, who had never known Bridie to wear anything other than comfortable lace-up brogues, had been entranced by this completely unexpected glimpse into her grandmother’s past.
White satin, adorned with white fluffy ostrich feathers and tiny jewelled roses on the vamp, and in the low-heeled Mary Jane style that was the fashion of the time, they were impossibly glamorous and Beth had fallen in love almost immediately. And she listened captivated as her mother told her what little she knew about her own parents’ wedding day, other than that Bridie and James had married just before the Second World War, and James had died in battle a year later while Bridie was pregnant with Beth’s mother.
There were no photographs of the event, so no clue as to what her grandmother’s wedding dress had been like. Beth’s mum recalled Bridie talking about having to pawn her wedding ring to keep them afloat after James died, leaving the shoes as the only memento of that special day.
From there on in Beth had spent countless hours trying to imagine the wedding and how her grandmother had managed to hold on to those shoes when other, more valuable possessions had been lost. They must have been particularly precious to Bridie.
She realised then that her grandmother’s great passion for 1920s Hollywood glamour wasn’t just restricted to the silver screen, and that the romantic classics so beloved by her – and readily shared with Beth – had been an escape of sorts, a vicarious glimpse into the kind of romantic life Bridie had imagined for herself before her marriage was so cruelly cut short.
Beth remembered wonderful nights at home in Galway at her grandmother’s house, tucked up under a blanket on the sofa in the darkness, she and Bridie watching rapt while Humphrey Bogart proclaimed his love for Lauren Bacall, and swooning as Spencer Tracy and Katharine Hepburn played out their great passion onscreen.
Her grandmother had been a huge influence on Beth, but had died when she was twelve, and she guessed evoking the movies was her way of holding on to those memories of her beloved nana so many years on, and especially now when she was so far away from home.
Thankfully, Beth’s mum had let her hold on to Bridie’s shoes, and to this day they remained in her New York wardrobe; in the original worn box, wrapped in the old delicate tissue paper. They were about her size, and Beth promised herself that as a tribute to Bridie, when (or if) she ever walked down the aisle to marry the love of her life, she would be wearing her grandmother’s beloved Mary Janes.
Now, standing in front of the display shelves, she gently ran her fingers along the various shoe designs, caressing the soft silky material. As was her habit, she tried to imagine where each pair would end up, the kind of women that would wear them and the adventures they might have.
The sparkling silver and gold sandals were easy to place: these were ideally suited to glamorous, sophisticated events, a night at the opera or a gala ball at the Met. While the easily identifiable red-soled slingbacks were sexy and fun, perfect for a cocktail party or a girls’ night out, the glorious satin crystal-encrusted creations were so exquisite that they were surely destined for a romantic encounter worthy of one of Bridie’s beloved silver-screen classics.
Beth looked at her own feet and smiled as she imagined herself as a movie heroine wearing the shoes; her blond curls pulled up in a sophisticated chignon à la Grace Kelly, her petite figure dressed in a gorgeous flowing gown (Oscar de la Renta, maybe?) and in Danny’s arms, dancing to Sinatra in some beautifully picturesque location … under the Eiffel Tower or at the base of the Spanish Steps in Rome, beneath a sky awash with stars.
Her face broke into a grin as she allowed her imagination free rein, and heard the accompanying film soundtrack swell in a spectacular crescendo in her mind as she pictured Danny wearing a tux, his dark hair slicked back Clark Gable-style, and his aquamarine eyes shining as he leaned forward and softly placed his lips on hers …
Her idyllic Hollywood daydream was interrupted when a couple meandered into the department.
Ah – her first customers of the day.
Glancing around, the woman immediately made a beeline for Beth’s Wizard of Oz display and, stopping in front of it, she smiled and gleefully clapped her hands. The man pulled her close and planted a kiss on her cheek.
Buoyed by this obvious show of appreciation, Beth smiled and, smoothing down her red knee-length woollen dress, moved to greet the couple. ‘Hello there – is there anything I can help you with?’ she asked cheerfully, her green eyes sparkling with warmth.
The young woman turned her attention to Beth and beamed. ‘I just love the holiday displays in here – this one is so wonderful, and Oz is one of my favourite movies!’
‘Thank you. I love that movie too.’
The customer reached out and picked up one of the silver heels. ‘But much as I love them, I don’t think sparkling ruby slippers will quite work for what I need,’ she giggled. Her face flushed happily, and she looked ready to burst with excitement.
Beth recognised that look. ‘Ah, so you’re planning a wedding then?’ she ventured coyly, before the younger woman could say anything more.
She burst out laughing, and glanced at her companion. ‘Well, yes, I suppose I am – we are. Though I didn’t realise it until a couple of hours ago … we’ve just got engaged!’ She offered her left hand, which, sure enough, was home to a gorgeous princess-cut diamond.
‘How wonderful. Congratulations.’ Beth looked back and forth between them. ‘Nice job on the ring,’ she added, offering the guy a wink. ‘It’s beautiful.’
He ran a hand through his dark hair and a blush crept up his neck, finding a home on his cheeks. ‘Thanks.’
His fiancée grinned. ‘I still can’t believe it! We just arrived in the city yesterday for some holiday shopping. We were taking a stroll in Central Park this morning, and when we reached the Bow Bridge, it started to snow, and then out of the blue, Josh…’ she giggled, indicating her companion, ‘got down on one knee, and it was like … time just froze. It was surreal. I mean, we have been together for ages now – three whole years – and of course we’ve talked about it … but I mean, wow. So unexpected. And right there, with the snow falling all around us, it was so romantic it almost felt like something out of a—’
‘Movie,’ she and Beth finished in unison and they both laughed. The bride-to-be (clearly a kindred spirit) who introduced herself as Katie, was overjoyed and Beth was only too happy to be taken up in the excitement. She came across many would-be brides in this line of work, and she loved meeting couples at this newly engaged point, when everything was still fresh and romantic, before all the wedding preparations became overwhelming.
She also knew that such a time was strictly for browsing, with a heavy dose of wish-fulfilment thrown in.
Well, she could understand that.
‘I’m so happy for you both. What a lovely time to get engaged. Have you set a date?’
‘We’re thinking this time next year. A Christmas wedding maybe?’
‘Perfect. Well once you start planning, and find your dress, I’d be delighted to help you with shoes and accessories, if you want. I see you like those Kate Spades.’
‘They’re so beautiful. And thank you; that would be great. I know it’s too early to be looking now. It’s strange, though, because as soon as he asked me, I could almost envision the whole day in my head … what Josh would look like as I walked down the aisle … and I have this vision of me too, of what I will look like on the day, the dress I’ll wear, and the shoes on my feet. Especially the shoes. Is that weird?’ She glanced from her fiancé back to Beth.
Beth threw a quick look of reassurance to the guy, who had a perplexed look on his face. Understandable; everyone knew men didn’t share the shoe – or indeed the ‘Big Day’ – gene.
‘Oh, I’d say that’s pretty normal,’ she said. ‘I think most women, myself included, have a pretty good idea of what they want their day to be like.’
Katie was shaking her head sagely. ‘Exactly. And did yours turn out the way you envisioned it? Your wedding day, I mean,’ she added when Beth looked blank.
‘Oh…’ She opened and closed her mouth in quick succession, understanding at once that her words had been taken out of context. ‘Well, I’m not married, actually,’ she mumbled pleasantly.
Katie looked uncomfortable. ‘I’m sorry, it just sounded like you knew so much about what I was talking about … I was sure you’d gone through it too.’
Beth shrugged, keeping a smile on her face. This wasn’t the first time she had gone down the ‘gosh, you’re not married?’ route. At thirty-four years old and possibly a good ten years on the girl in front of her, she guessed she should have expected it. ‘No, I’m not married. I mean, not yet, and I’m not sure if we ever will,’ she added, laughing a little. ‘My boyfriend and I have been together seven years and—’
‘Seven years and no ring?’ Katie gasped, cutting her off. Then spotting Beth’s reaction, she immediately began to backpedal. ‘I mean, sorry. It’s not like … it’s just … I thought three was long to wait…’ She trailed off and shook her head. ‘But of course, every couple is different, right? Some people have things figured out, without all that stuff. It sounds like you do, anyway. I mean, some people never get married at all.’
At this point the guy nudged her, as if trying to signal to his beloved to take her foot out of her mouth. Beth remained calm and unaffected. After all, Katie wasn’t insinuating anything; she just had a different perspective. Anyway, Beth was sort of used to it. This wasn’t the first time someone had reacted with surprise when they realised just how long Beth and Danny had been together, yet seemed to have no intention of tying the knot.
‘Anyway, I’m sorry. I’m blabbering now,’ Katie blushed.
‘It’s no problem. Like you say, everyone’s different. My boyfriend and I always joke that if we got married, all the romance in our relationship would just wither and die,’ Beth chuckled, trying to keep the mood light, before backtracking herself when she spotted the expression on her audience’s faces. ‘I mean, not that the romance is going to be dead for you two when you get married.’ She gulped. ‘It’s just a silly in-joke of ours. In any case, best of luck to you both and congratulations again. I’m Beth and here’s my card. Feel free to give me a call when you’re back in town and ready to choose your wedding shoes.’ She extracted a card from her pocket and handed it to the girl. ‘And Merry Christmas.’
‘Thanks, and same to you…’ The young couple hurriedly took their leave, the bride-to-be regaining her sunny disposition, and her fiancé looking mildly relieved.
Beth smiled after them as they walked away and put the conversation out of her mind. It made no sense to think too deeply about it. That sort of exchange had happened before, and just like she did at other times when faced with the question of why exactly she and Danny weren’t married, she decided to sidestep the issue in favour of cheerier thoughts.
‘Let me guess, yet another bride-to-be salivating over the satin Manolos?’ Beth jumped in surprise as Jodi Cartwright, her longtime co-worker in the shoe rooms, sidled up to her.
Beth laughed. ‘The Kate Spades, actually. They just got engaged. Down on one knee on the Bow Bridge in the snow. The park is such a perfect backdrop for a marriage proposal at this time of year, isn’t it? So romantic.’
Jodi snorted. Ever cynical, the forty-something divorcee didn’t share Beth’s optimism about love and romance, and least of all about marriage.
‘Yeah, it’s romantic until one day you catch him with his mistress in the same place making his own romantic moment. And you know what’s even more full of hearts and roses and unicorns that poop rainbows?’ she added archly. ‘Serving him with divorce papers at his mistress’s house after he said he was away at a Vegas cop convention. That’s my romantic moment.’
Beth blanched. She loved Jodi, but guessed she should have remembered who she was talking to. Her friend certainly wasn’t one to be first in line with ticket in hand for the latest Nicholas Sparks movie. She should have remembered that Central Park was indeed the place Jodi had caught her now ex-husband Frank with this mistress. A million miles from romantic. She guessed Katie’s foot-in-mouth syndrome was catching.
‘Sorry, Jodi. I didn’t mean…’
Her friend patted her shoulder. ‘It’s OK, honey. Easy for you to romanticise marriage; you haven’t been there. And I say that not as a criticism but a commendation. Don’t go there, Beth. Single life wins out every time.’
Beth wasn’t completely sold on that, even though she and Danny regularly downplayed any considerations of marriage where their relationship was concerned. But she wasn’t about to start another dialogue about the pros and cons.
‘Anyway,’ Jodi continued, ‘what are you doing here this morning? I thought you and lover boy were heading south this weekend?’
Beth picked up some boxes and turned back towards the stockroom. ‘Danny had something come up last minute. He encouraged me to go ahead anyway, maybe meet up with some of the others, but it would be no fun without him. I might as well stay here and do something productive.’
Ever suspicious, Jodi narrowed her eyes. ‘And what came up that he felt you should still go?’
Beth smiled good-naturedly. As far as Jodi was concerned, there wasn’t a decent man in all of Manhattan – hell, in all of the world. But Beth knew different.
‘It’s just a work thing. His firm has a new client starting a big PR campaign in January, and the entire office has been put into lockdown over something last minute. And that’s fine by me. Especially since the company has been looking shaky as of late.’ She frowned. ‘He’s had a lot of hours cut recently, so it’s good that things are looking better. I don’t want him getting laid off, so he needs to put in the time if they ask him. Simple as that. We can always do the Sunshine State some other time.’
‘Hmm.’ Jodi regarded her sceptically.
Beth swatted at her friend with a playful hand. ‘Oh, stop it. Danny’s a good guy, you know that.’
Jodi snorted again. ‘Well, I’m glad that while you may be a hopeless romantic and always only a heartbeat away from re-enacting the best of Meg Ryan, at least you aren’t caught up in that obsession most women over thirty in this town have about marriage. At least you’re sane in that aspect. Because if you weren’t we just couldn’t be friends,’ she added wickedly. ‘I’m going to go put those boxes away, OK? Man the floor and I’ll be back in no time.’
Jodi disappeared into the stockroom and Beth smiled after her older, cynical friend. It was true that she might be a hopeless romantic, but also that she didn’t obsess about marriage – at least, not until faced with the question in the form of a happily engaged couple with a look of pity on their faces, she thought wryly. She and Danny worked well together, and Beth knew without a doubt in her mind that he was the one for her. They were in love, and dedicated and committed to each other for the long haul. She didn’t need a white dress, a piece of paper (or fairy-tale slippers) to tell her that.
But still, she couldn’t deny that things had changed since the early days. OK, so she didn’t get as many butterflies in her stomach at the sight of him as she used to, but their relationship wasn’t what you would call stale, not by a long shot. It was just different.
Though maybe that was simply what happened when time passed and familiarity grew. In romantic movies, nobody ever got to see what happened to the hero and heroine after the credits rolled. Possibly for good reason, as after happily ever after didn’t necessarily make for an interesting story.
Still, Beth couldn’t deny that she wished her and Danny’s once-passionate kisses occurred a bit more often, and that these days unexpected romantic moments weren’t so few and far between.
But, she told herself, she still had the memories: the romance that was part of her and Danny’s story over the years. And that was it, Beth thought: it was their story that made them special together, that made them dedicated to each other. That was the foundation of their love. She and Danny Bishop had been writing their own particular romantic movie all throughout their relationship.
She remembered a moment, very early in the relationship, long before they had moved in together, before they’d even said, ‘I love you’ (though Beth had known it at the time). It was one of her favourite memories.
It was summertime, and they had just been out for dinner in Little Italy, she was still in her little black dress and Danny had thrown his jacket over her shoulders. They had found themselves at the foot of 58th Street, in a spot just overlooking the East River and the Queensboro Bridge, which was lit up with what seemed like a million little sparkling fairy lights.
And it was there that they’d sat and talked about everything and anything, until eventually the sun had started to peek out over the horizon. Beth remembered just how badly she wanted to tell dawn to wait a while longer, that she wasn’t finished with the night yet – that she needed a few more hours of darkness as she learned about this wonderful man who was sitting next to her.
It had been magical. And though Beth didn’t realise it until later, it had also been a scene – quite literally – from out of a movie. Woody Allen and Diane Keaton had filmed a famous piece from Manhattan in that exact spot, sitting on the very same bench. But she had never seen the movie until one night months later at her old apartment, when Danny was flipping through TV channels, and the iconic clip appeared onscreen.
As she watched, she felt as if stars had been trickling down upon her from heaven. It was a sign, a sign from the romantic movie gods – or perhaps even her beloved grandmother – that she and Danny were meant to be together.
Instantly hooked, she had insisted on watching Manhattan from the very beginning, and while the more unconventional production wasn’t usually her style, the film immediately took on a very special meaning.
Smiling at the memory, Beth realised that despite Jodi’s misgivings, sometimes romance could indeed be like something from the movies – and in her and Danny’s case it was even better.