Josephine didn’t know a thing about Caroline Reagan’s crusade. Broadway babies don’t sleep tight until the dawn, and in the shaded bedrooms of number 2259, nobody stirred.
There are dozens of stories about how Mrs. Reagan took Josephine back to Paris. Josephine’s own recollections were, as always, fanciful. An impresario had offered her a part in an overseas tour, and the French waiters at the Plantation encouraged her to take it. “ ‘Go,’ they said, ‘you will feel better, you will be understood.’ So I left.”
Some variations on the theme:
U. S. Thompson: “The lady came to the Plantation lookin’ for talent and right away, she could see Josephine had the makin’s of a big star, all she need was a chance.”
Ralph Cooper: “When she got the proposition to go to France, we talked a lot about it. She said, ‘I don’t know where it is, I don’t speak the language, and you are not coming. I don’t want to go.’ I told her it was a good opportunity, and if she liked it, then she could arrange for me to come over; I guess that helped her decision.”
Paul Bass: “This woman from the Folies-Bergère, she wanted Joe to go back and teach the Folies-Bergère chorus girls the Charleston. And Josephine told me, ‘Well, I don’t want to leave Ralph,’ so I said, ‘Look, Joe, this is an opportunity, you can go over to Paris and make the money and send back for Ralph,’ and she laughed and said, ‘Well, okay.’ Then she went over and met this count, and she forgot about Ralph.”
Dorothy Rhodes: “Our producers tried to scare Josephine from going to Europe, they were telling her they were gonna take her off the boat, and you know, if she go, they wouldn’t let her into France, all that stuff. Well, she was a little leery, but the other girls got with her and we said, ‘Go, don’t let this chance pass you by.’ ”
Claude Hopkins: “Josephine was the end girl, last to leave the stage, she was doing some bits going off, and the house was coming down, hollerin’ and whistlin’. And Mrs. Reagan noticed that. She wanted Ethel Waters, but Ethel wouldn’t have been the star that Josephine was.”
Ethel Waters: “I said I preferred to see America first. . . . Josephine ended up with a château, an Italian count and all Paris at her feet permanently . . . Sacrebleu!”
Few people ever got the story straight. Most of the ones I talked to called Mrs. Reagan the “little French woman.”
She was actually a little American woman from Chicago. She had been the youngest of five children, four sisters and a brother, she the tiniest, “good to repair the electric wires under the dining room table.” Her father, Emilius Clark Dudley, was a famous gynecologist. (At the age of seventy-one, he went to China to teach at the Hunan-Yale Medical College—known as Yale-in-China—and was “absent from home during most of 1922 and 1923.”)
His daughters grew up interesting: One painted, one wrote, one was loved by Bertrand Russell. And Caroline, during the First World War, went to France and served coffee and doughnuts to soldiers.
She married Daniel Joseph Reagan, who would later be sent to Paris as a foreign service officer. The couple had one child, a girl they named Sophie, but Caroline did not settle easily into domesticity. She wanted to produce—in France—an all-black musical revue. The notion had come to her while she and her husband were still living in Washington, D.C., and she’d gone to a rehearsal at the Douglas, a small theater in a black neighborhood.
“Eight black girls in black tights, one more superb than the next, dancing, dancing, dancing. It was the Charleston. . . . I was overwhelmed, drawn by the invisible magnet, to produce a company, to show such artists, to amaze, flabbergast, dumbfound Paris . . . the elite, the masses, the artists from Picasso to the hippie painters of the streets . . . and there is where the seed for this Revue Nègre sprouted. The germ possessed me and began to grow.”
Possessed as well of a certain sexual ambiguity—Gertrude Stein told her, “You are neither fish nor flesh nor fowl”—Caroline Reagan says she asked herself, “Was I a woman? A man? A spirit in every sense?” and decided it didn’t matter. At the age of thirty, she had become obsessed with the élan vital of the American black.
In her efforts to bring a black revue to Paris, she solicited cooperation from the directors of all the big theaters, the Casino de Paris, the Folies-Bergère, the Odéon. The directors were respectful but firm. “Madame, we cannot,” they said politely. Then the painter, Fernand Léger, came to her rescue. “Go see Rolf de Maré. He’s got a white elephant of a theatre. Just the other day I told him, ‘Get Negroes, they’re dynamite, they’re the only ones who will wake up your theatre. . . .’ ”
Rolf de Maré, a rich, Swedish-born patron of the arts who had brought Pavlova, Paderewski, Paul Robeson, Les Ballets Suédois—even Will Marion Cook and his Syncopated Orchestra—to Paris, listened to this possibly crazy woman. “I propose a black revue,” she said. “Authentic, racial, the blacks so sure of themselves, it is their soul that sings, that dances without end.”
De Maré gave her money to go to New York and put a show together. “That was the best day of my life. . . . I was flying. . . . I came home blinded by happiness.”
Next stop, Harlem.
“Harlem,” she writes, “a silken word. Harlem, land of banjos, piano and the mechanical victrola, gramophone, radio morning noon and night. . . . I got off the bus at Lenox Avenue.”
She asked directions to the theater in which Will Marion Cook maintained a small office. “Young laughing boys led me, each holding slices of red watermelon, the seeds as black as their eyes . . . it was hot. I was happy.”
Mrs. Reagan had been told Cook could help her choose the talent for her show, and he obliged. As male star and choreographer, he suggested his son-in-law, Louis Douglas. Douglas was famous in Europe; at the age of six, he’d been taken abroad by Belle Davis with a group called The Little Pickaninnies. (In 1898, Davis, a comedienne and singer, had starred in Clorindy, or the Origin of the Cakewalk, the first show written by Will Marion Cook.) Louis Douglas was newly returned to the United States after twenty-nine years away.
He came in and danced for Caroline. He had conquered Russia, Caroline said, and “he conquered me that morning.”
He then proposed his wife Marion (daughter of Will Marion Cook) for the chorus. The casting had begun.
Florence Mills was Caroline’s star of choice, and in fact, her picture appeared in the July 9 program of the Théâtre des Champs-Élysées as the fall’s coming attraction. But Florence was a big name, and earned big money; Caroline couldn’t afford her.
So Will Marion and Caroline still needed a female star, and a whole bunch of dancers. They couldn’t check out the Cotton Club; it was closed for alcohol violations, forty-four of them. They could and did go to the Lafayette Theatre. This is the way Lilly Yuen described what took place there:
“We all was working at the Lafayette, and that French woman that took Josephine to Paris, she came there, and we were supposed to go. Mr. Miller signed the contract, and then this little French woman and Mr. Miller had a big run-in and he tore the contract up. Then this woman wanted to take us herself, and we was kids, you know, and we said, we can’t leave Mr. Miller, he is like a father to us.”
Irving C. Miller’s company of forty had decided to dance with the guy what brung them, leaving Will Marion free to campaign for Tan Town Topics, the show he had doctored. He thought Mrs. Reagan should engage Ethel Waters.
Ethel Waters was marvelous, but she wanted $750 a week. Still, Reagan and Cook went back to the Plantation a second time to try to talk Ethel around, and that was one of the nights she was out. Watching Josephine clown, Caroline turned to Will Marion. “That’s our star,” she said.
The idea made Louis Douglas unhappy.
“He wanted no part of Josephine Baker,” says Bessie Taliaferro. “He said, ‘She’ll never go over in Paris, they won’t like her.’ But you see, they did.”
It was no easier to negotiate with Josephine than with Ethel Waters, Caroline discovered. She offered $150 a week and was rejected. “I was not Madame Ziegfeld, covered with jewels. (Even fake ones inspire confidence.) I was nobody important. I proposed, Josephine disposed. . . . She was happy where she was, free, the featured girl of eight girls.”
Caroline persisted. “ ‘With me, you’ll be the star of the Théâtre des Champs-Élysées.’ In the end, it was yes. Above all, because she knew exactly what she wanted to do. She wanted to sing sweet pretty songs. She assured me that she knew them. ‘All the better,’ I said. ‘That way, you won’t have to come to rehearsals, you can continue at the Plantation.’
“My contract with de Maré gave me three months in which to wire him the name of the show and the names of the stars. I was partial to Hotsy Totsy. A friend told me, ‘Stop, where is your tact?’ So, quite without thinking, I wired: LA REVUE NEGRE, STARRING JOSEPHINE BAKER AND LOUIS DOUGLAS. God help me, the die was cast.”
In Paris, Rolf de Maré had flyers printed, promising “Une Revue Nègre avec Josephine Baker et Louis Douglas,” not to mention “Les 8 Charleston Babies,” but two days after Josephine gave her word, she took it back again. Over the phone she told Caroline her bosses had doubled her pay. “I outbid them, saying, ‘Wait for me, I’m coming,’ ” Caroline recalled. “Then I grabbed my extraordinarily beautiful mandarin coat, embroidered in gold. My father had brought it to me from China, as though he knew that I was going to need it for her. . . . A taxi, and there I was again at Josephine’s. ‘Quick, quick, Josephine, the taxi’s waiting for us.’ The mandarin coat worked its spell, and she followed me. ‘We’re going to see the great designer, Tappe, who’s making a dress for you for Paris.’
“And here is how Tappe spoke to her, while draping her in the fabric beaded with pearls. ‘Mademoiselle, what luck you’ve been chosen by Madame Reagan . . . she will make you famous, she’s your lucky star.’
“Once she was put in her pearls, in that dress intended for the finale (later photographed in Paris by Man Ray), she kissed me. She was happy and beautiful, and she saw herself singing these sweet pretty songs. . . . I kept a hermetic silence, saying to myself, we shall see.”
To the end of her days, Caroline Reagan mourned the loss of the glittering coat. But she had her star. At $250 a week.
She still had to get a good jazz band. She and Will Marion Cook auditioned forty groups before they went down to the Smile-A-While Inn in Asbury Park to hear Claude Hopkins, who was twenty-two, handsome, talented, a pianist as well as a bandleader. “When I learned she was there,” Claude said, “I put up several novelty numbers that we used.” One of them was a long comedy version of “The St. Louis Blues” set in a Baptist church, and, Claude said, “The act put the audience in stitches. Mrs. Reagan . . . was almost hysterical.”
She had found her band. She also found several chorus girls, choosing them the way you choose ripe peaches, the ones with pretty color, the ones without bruise or blemish. Evelyn Anderson was eighteen years old, and working in the revue at the Smile-A-While. “After I did my Charleston for Mrs. Reagan, she asked me if I was interested in joining them to go to Europe. I said yes because I was likin’ Joe Hayman then. He was playing alto sax in Claude’s band.
“Claude’s wife, Mabel, was working in a different cabaret in Asbury Park, and that’s where Mrs. Reagan got her and Bea Foote and Marguerite Ricks. It was the end of August, and hot as hell when we came to New York.”
Satisfied with the results of her foraging along the Jersey shore, Caroline’s pleasure was capped when Sidney Bechet asked to join the band. Will Marion Cook told her the truth: Bechet drank, and maybe he’d miss a show once in a while, but every night he played, she would be grateful.
The real work began. Rehearsals for the Hopkins band in the Spiller basement, rehearsals for the chorus girls at Club Basha.
“My sister Dorothy’s house on Twelfth Street had become a sweat shop,” Caroline wrote. “It was hot, not work for the classic dressmakers of Broadway. . . . Dorothy had imagined corsets with red laces for the eight girls.”
The girls loathed the corsets (“You want to dress us like monkeys”) but liked the white organdy overcoats with real diamond buttons, and “the bras and panties, dyed separately to match their skin tones.”
Caroline rejected a set design by her friend, the novelist John Dos Passos (“It was very nice, but I found it was a little bit too much the way whites thought of blacks, a street in the south with houses of all colors”) and engaged Miguel Covarrubias to do the scenery. “I chose . . . sets from among the models. . . . My Mississippi steamboats, the Memphis and the Natchez . . . the skyscraper that leaned, while Bechet played. . . .”
In the midst of all this, a dispute broke out between Will Marion Cook and Louis Douglas. Variety of August 26 had carried the headline COLORED TAB FOR PARIS WITH WILL MARION COOK, along with the news that Cook would be leading the show’s orchestra, but it turned out to be a false report. Something had gone wrong.
It was Bessie Taliaferro’s view that quarreling with his son-in-law had soured Will Marion on the job. “He couldn’t stand Louis Douglas, because Louis married his daughter, I guess.” (Marion, in London with her father in 1919, had fallen in love with the young entertainer.) “And then Louis had been so nasty about Josephine, he had done everything he could to keep Will Marion from taking Josephine for the show. And then I think Mrs. Reagan and Will Marion fell out before she went across the seas.”
Variety had got everything else right, reporting that “a chorus of eight girls and an orchestra of six pieces (males) will be included in the company of 20. Among the principals are Josephine Baker, Maud de Forrest, and Louis Douglas.”
Will Marion was replaced by Spencer Williams (he would write the music, while Jack Palmer, a white man, did the lyrics), and Caroline signed Josephine as her star. “I needed a lawyer and a notary for each contract,” she said, “but everyone assured me I risked nothing with Josephine, that with or without a contract, she would never leave me.”
On September 10, the entire cast is milling around the passport office. It’s a mess. Some of them can’t read or write. Some who have never met before swear they are related because everyone needs a witness who has known him or her for ten years.
And you, Mother, you top them all. You deserve an award for your performance.
Six days before sailing, Mrs. Reagan has discovered you don’t have your birth certificate. “What to do?” she asks herself. “Go to St. Louis and find her mother, a laundress, and have her make an authorization? There’s no time.”
She uses her diplomat husband’s clout, and presto! the city of St. Louis sends her a copy of the missing document, and Booth Marshall drives you down to Wall and Nassau streets, along with your witness, Henry Sapan, a pianist. Caroline kisses you when you arrive, saying with relief, “My star is late.”
She produces your birth certificate, the first time you have seen it. It must be a bit of a shock to read that you were born Freda J. McDonald, and that a man identified only as Edw. was your father.
You sit down at a heavy wooden desk to fill out the application form. You write “Freda J. McDonald.” Then, on the line that gives you the choice of “father” or “husband,” you cross out “husband.” Your father, you declare, is named Edward McDonald. You don’t know any Edward McDonald, but then, you didn’t know the last father you invented—the Washington lawyer—either.
You’re an actress, you’re coming home in one year, you’re five feet eight inches tall, colored, with a large mouth, a short chin, and an oval face. You take the application back to the clerk. He, one William Marshall, notes that you are going to France, and asks to see your contract of employment.
You present it proudly. He shakes his head. “What’s this, Miss McDonald? The contract says Josephine Baker.”
“Baker is my married name.”
“But you wrote you are single.”
“A mistake. I’m married.”
McDonald is crossed out, Baker is written in; “single” is crossed out, “married” is written in. But there’s no pleasing this Mr. Marshall. He wants to know where your husband lives. You don’t have a clue to Billy’s whereabouts, so you make you another correction. “Married” is crossed out, and in its place you write, “Divorced, April 15, 1925, in Detroit.”
Mr. Marshall is showing definite signs of strain. He demands proof of your husband’s citizenship. No passport can be issued until you, Freda Josephine McDonald Baker, single, married, divorced, “present satisfactory evidence of husband’s American birth.”
Quick as a flash, you see what you have to do. Kill the guy off. Cross out “divorced,” write in “widowed.” Only thing is, you do solemnly swear that your husband died September 14, 1924. Good work, Mother. He dies in 1924, and you divorce him in 1925. It’s hard for Mr. Marshall to swallow your divorcing Billy Baker seven months after he’s dead.
“You are crazy!” cries Mr. Marshall. Fortunately, Mrs. Reagan, who has been choking with laughter, jumps in and saves you. Now I understand why you said in one of your books that you were running around in circles in the passport office, afraid you might be put in jail.
You are Carrie’s child, no question about it. When the census man came around, Carrie had the guts to look him in the eye, swear she’d been married to Arthur Martin for five years, and in one tidy sweep, legitimize all three of you children. You had the guts to go up against the passport man, daring him not to give you what you wanted. Your will be done. “Joe really got that clerk,” Booth Marshall told me. Even so, he said, she was not excited to be going abroad. “She didn’t know what was going to happen. She thought it was going to be like here, no future in it.”
A year before, Bricktop had thought the same thing. “It wasn’t unheard of for an entertainer to go to Europe,” she said, “but not many did, and hardly any blacks did. . . . I wasn’t excited. I wasn’t nervous. I barely knew where Paris was and didn’t know a word of French, but I’d traveled to a lot of cities in the United States, and it didn’t seem to me that Paris would be much different.”
On the eve of the Berengaria’s sailing, there was a farewell party for Josephine. Dorothy Rhodes was there. “It was at the Club Bamville on 129th Street and Lenox Avenue that was run by Broadway Jones, who had been in Chocolate Dandies with Josephine. And I can even tell you what Josephine had on. She had somebody to make her an outfit, pantaloons in gray, with suspenders. We had a good time.”
Booth Marshall had been paid fifty dollars to deliver Josephine to the boat, but all he could remember later was being too drunk to get out of bed. In the end, a whole bunch of people saw Josephine up the gangplank: Will Marion Cook, Paul Bass, Alice and Bessie Allison, Ralph Cooper (Bessie and Ralph had been her most recent lovers), and Mildred Smallwood (a lover from the past). There is a picture of Josephine clutching a small violin, a going-away present from Mildred.
Right up till the last minute, Josephine considered not going. “As far back as I can remember,” she wrote later, “I can only recall one single day of fear in my life. One day, which lasted only one hour, maybe one minute . . . one minute when fear grasped my brain, my heart, my guts with such force that everything seemed to come apart. It was September 15, 1925.”
On September 16, the Berengaria sailed. The last cast member to make it aboard was Sidney Bechet. “He didn’t show up for a long time,” Claude Hopkins said. “And we couldn’t move without him because Mrs. Reagan had his passport. He finally came. Later. Oh, he was something.”
“A quarter of Harlem was on the docks,” Caroline Reagan said. “ ‘Bon voyage, have a good time, come back.’ With little blue, white and red flags waving in the air. . . . On the boat, the orchestra played, and Harlem became farther and farther away.”
The adventure had begun. Half the troupe wasn’t sure where Paris was, and even the ship-to-shore phone was an astonishment. (On a different transatlantic voyage, Johnny Hudgins remembered getting a telegram from Louis Armstrong. “I said, ‘A telegram? How can a telegram get way out through all this water?’ I didn’t see no land.”)
Awake at last, Booth Marshall telephoned Josephine on the boat. She was summoned by a loudspeaker: “Miss Baker, Miss Josephine Baker, please come to the radio room.”
Miss Josephine Baker hugged herself with excitement. It didn’t matter that it was still mid-morning; true to form, she found reality too ordinary, and in one account of the sailing, she turned day into twilight. “The sea was calm, with a red glow from the setting sun. . . . Nobody paid any attention to me. Who would have looked at me? Who would have extended a hand or said a word? I was only a little girl, not even that, a little black girl.
“The Statue of Liberty disappeared on the horizon. It was over between America and me. . . . Goodbye, New York, goodbye, Philadelphia, goodbye, St. Louis. Goodbye the little girl with purple hands. Goodbye the rats of Bernard Street. Goodbye. . . .
“The secret in order to hold fast was not to move. . . . It was a game.”