DAY 59 Good Move, Better Time

A good move may have an expiration date, when it is no longer good. But it may also have an optimal date, when it is best.

F. Skripchenko White

Kaputin Black

Kaluga 1960

Sicilian Defense, Najdorf Variation B94

1 e4 c5 2 f3 d6 3 d4 cxd4 4 xd4 f6 5 c3 a6 6 g5 bd7 7 f4 b5?!

Question 64: Is Black threatening 8...b4 9 d5 xe4 ?

8 xf6

This sets traps. One arises after 8...xf6 9 e5 dxe5 10 fxe5.

Question 65: What happens after 10...d5 ?

8...gxf6 9 a4!

You’re right if you think d5 and e6 were good moves (9 e6 fxe6?? 10 h5 mate). But they are better if prepared by 9 a4!. For example, 9...bxa4 10 e6! a5 11 xa4!. Or 10...b6 11 d5! a5+ 12 b4!.

9...b4

Illustration

Now 10 e6 a5 11 xf8? bxc3 is bad and 11 d5 xd5 12 xd5 fxe6 13 c7+ d8 14 xe6+ is only a draw (14 xa8? b7).

Question 66: Is 10 c4 strong, in view of 10...bxc3 11 xf7+! xf7 12 h5+ g8 13 d5+ ?

10 d5

White’s threats include 11 c6. If Black plays 10...c5 White is way ahead after 11 c6 d7 12 cxb4. For instance, 12...xe4 13 e2 f5 14 c4! with the idea of c7+. On 14…a7! White is much better after 15 c6+! d8 16 b6+.

10...b7??

This stops 11 c6 and renders 11 xb4 relatively harmless (11...xe4).

11 e6! resigns.

In view of 11...-moves 12 dc7+.

Here’s a similar disaster:

Michael Redgrave White

John Steadman Black

Sydney 2007

1 e4 c5 2 f3 d6 3 d4 cxd4 4 xd4 f6 5 c3 a6 6 g5 bd7 7 f4 b5?! 8 xf6 gxf6 9 d5 b7?? 10 e6! a5+ 11 b4! and wins (But 9...c5 10 c4 wouldn’t be pleasant for Black).