CHAPTER 2

Detective Robert Fuller came to the house late in the afternoon. When he knocked on the door I was having my second vodka over ice, a ritual I have every afternoon. I knew Fuller from the accident. My daughter was coming home from an afternoon at Heart’s Desire Beach on the Point Reyes peninsula and when she came around a curve, there was the Ford Expedition, over the center line, cutting the corner and it struck her car a glancing blow. The huge SUV hardly wavered, but my daughter’s little car was airborne, sending it pinwheeling into the edge of Tomales Bay. Those were the words of the truck driver who saw the accident. “The car pinwheeled and landed on its roof in the edge of the bay,” he said. “I stopped, but the car that clipped her just kept going.”

Fuller was with the Marin County Sheriff’s Department and had been in charge of the investigation and he hadn’t found the car or the driver. All he had was her death. And that had destroyed my marriage. I was devastated by her death, a bright girl in her freshman year at SF State, on the way back from a Point Reyes beach after a day with friends, and some sonofabitch came around a corner and clipped her car, sending it pinwheeling into the bay. Pinwheeling. A Fourth of July verb. It was the verb that the truck driver who witnessed the accident used on the police report. She drowned in the upside down car. My whole life pinwheeled as well, and eventually my wife grew tired of my grief.

We tried counseling but there was this big hole in my life and I must confess that I was no good at the group sessions at the Catholic Social Services, couples arranged in a circle trying to deal with the deaths of their children. I was not good at it and Andrea gave up on me. I didn’t blame her. The sessions were designed so that each couple shared their story. There were couples whose child had overdosed on drugs. One couple described an automobile accident, a teenage driver going too fast over White’s Hill, lost control, plunged over the edge of the road and the car rolled until it was a crushed wreckage, the occupants dead.

The facilitator of the group was a middle aged woman with a ball point pen in the bun of hair that was tightly wound over her forehead, and she kept saying that it was good to talk things out. Put your grief into words, she said. But I could not put words to my daughter’s death. She had hung, trapped, upside down while her car sank in Tomales Bay, and the water rose until it enveloped her. I could imagine her lifting her head as the water rose and when I was asked how my daughter died, I could only say that she had drowned. My wife began to correct me, saying, No, it was not an ordinary drowning, but before she could explain, I rose and left the room.

I had nightmares in which I dove into the water to pry open the door of an upside down car, hearing my daughter’s voice bubbling through the water. My wife moved to the guest room. She said I shouted in my sleep, thrashed so much that I struck her.

Things came back to me in a rush at odd times of the day. I spent time in my garage making birdhouses. She loved birds and kept a log of birds that she had spotted. I still had that little black book with notations: A cardinal! So red that it was unreal. San Anselmo Park, October 16, 5:00 p.m. How wonderful!

I sometimes pictured her on the dock at Bodega Bay where I had taken her to fish for perch when she was not yet a teenager, her face lighting up when a wriggling perch came up to the railing. Soccer games. I took time off work to watch her run down the field, long-legged, a fluid movement and when she went off to SF State, I drove her to the dorm, carried her box of things up to her room, helped her to move in, met her roommate, a black girl from Compton. I bought her the Toyota and she brought her roommate to the house for dinner, a sweet girl who played soccer as well, but was not good enough to be on the SF State women’s soccer team.

I remembered times when she was out late in high school and I had met some of the friends who hung out with her, some boys that I had reservations about, and I waited up, listening for the front door that told me she had made it safely back to the house. My wife was asleep. She’ll be all right, she repeatedly told me.

Fuller shook my hand, and I asked if he wanted a coffee or a drink.

“What are you drinking?” he asked.

“Vodka over ice.”

“Not my style.”

“I’ve got some scotch.”

“That would be nice!”

“To what do I owe this visit?”

I poured him a scotch and he took a sip, then placed the glass on the coffee table.

“I’ve found the sonofabitch who clipped your kid.”

“You found him? You’re going to arrest him?”

“No. I know who he is, but I haven’t got enough evidence to arrest him.”

I was stunned.

Fuller took out a small notebook, laid it on the coffee table and opened it.

“That was three years ago,” I said. “I thought you gave up on it.”

“No. That’s a fault of mine. I struggle along, and some cases solve themselves and some of them drift along without a clue to help solve things, and I’m like some old dog chewing on a bone. I’ve been doing this twenty-five years. It doesn’t get easier, it gets harder.”

“So what happened this time?”

“You remember that we put out an alert to body shops about a Ford Expedition that might need body work on the right side?”

“But nothing came back.”

“That’s right. But last week there’s a guy doing an audit at Gotelli’s Body Work in San Rafael, a routine examination of the books for taxes, and he comes across our BOLO. And apparently nobody did anything with it. So here he is, with all these old records, and he’s curious, which is a stroke of luck for me, so he checks it out and sure enough there’s a black Ford Expedition that comes in two days after the accident date, and it gets fixed and the sonofabitch comes in and pays them in cash and drives off. There’s no insurance, the name he gives them turns out to be a phony and the address in Vallejo doesn’t exist. But of course the body shop takes down the VIN number of the car, that’s routine. And a check with the DMV tells us who bought the sucker. It’s only a year old when it gets fixed, so chances are that this is the original owner.” He traced something in his notebook with his index finger.

“Earl Anthony Winslow. 221 Carmel Drive, Ross, California.”

“That’s an expensive address.”

“Unless he lives in the chauffeur’s quarters over the garage.”

“So you go there and you arrest the sonofabitch.”

“No. What I have is a three-year old car repair. He’ll claim that he didn’t want the accident to go on his insurance, which is why he paid cash. I can’t connect that damage to your daughter’s car. The damaged parts are long gone. He’ll make up some cockamamie story about why he used a false name. There’s nothing there that I can use to make a direct connection to your daughter’s death.”

“But you think it’s him?”

“Two DUI convictions. A summer cottage in Inverness, not two miles from where he sideswiped the kid’s car.”

“Why are you telling me this?”

“I have two daughters. One of them is married, two grandkids. The other one is a doctor. She spends time in Third World countries fixing the bodies of poor kids. When they were growing up, I sweated out every Saturday might. They were both a bit on the wild side, parties and nights on beaches with a keg of beer and boys that I would just as soon have arrested and I lived in fear that something would happen to them. But nothing did. Sometimes I think it’s all just a matter of luck. What I know is this.” He paused, closed his notebook, picked up his glass and sipped at the scotch. “If some motherfucker sideswiped the car of one of my daughters, and pitched her into the bay and kept on going, I would have hunted down the asshole and I would have put a bullet into his head.”

“Are you saying I should find this prick and kill him?”

“I’m not saying anything of the kind. I’ll continue to work on the case, but it’s a cold case, and my boss won’t be happy if I spend too much time on it. I’ll find that truck driver, if he’s findable, and ask him some more questions. But it’s unlikely that I’ll find anything that concretely ties Earl Winslow to this. What you do is your own business.” He sipped at the scotch again.

“You’re sure it’s him?”

“I’m going to talk to him. Ask him about the repair to his car. Ask to see the car if he still has it. See how he reacts. It’s been three years. It will be interesting to see how he reacts when I show up with questions.”

“And you’ll let me know?”

“You’ll be the first person I talk to.”

I could feel the blood rising in my neck, feel a sudden agitation in my body. When I looked at my hands, I could see that I was clasping and unclasping them, forming fists.

“Maybe it’s all just coincidence. Maybe the damage to his car has nothing to do with that hit and run. But the truck driver, according to the field interview, was sure it was a black Expedition. Driven by a man. And two days later a black Expedition gets fixed, paid for with cash, a phony name and address. Rich bastard who has a house out at Inverness, and a record of driving under the influence. I don’t like coincidence. In all my years, I’ve never found one that held up.” He finished his scotch.

“Thanks for the drink. I’ll be in touch. Don’t do anything foolish.”

I stood, shook his hand. His face was lined and he looked at least fifteen years older than me. Which put him in his sixties. He looked tired.

“Thanks,” I said.

“I didn’t give you anything,” he said. “Maybe some grief. Like I said, don’t do anything foolish. Maybe I should amend that. Don’t do anything. I’ll be in touch.”

He left and I stood looking at the closed door. I would find 221 Carmel Drive in Ross. I would find Earl Anthony Winslow. I would see what he looks like. I would find out all I could about him. And if I were convinced that he was the one, then I would do something. Something foolish, no doubt. But I had spent the last three years during which there was never a day when I didn’t think about the death of my daughter. Fuller had no idea what his news had done to me. It had struck a match to the fuse.