When Natalie left the cramped space she’d shared with Wyatt and the kids, she was trembling. In the moment her gaze had locked with Wyatt’s, he’d told her without saying a word that he truly, deeply cared about the children in their charge. He’d told her that for all of his bluster, he did have a heart—more than he wanted anyone to know. Especially her.
In the kitchen, she made a cup of mint tea.
She wiped the counters free of the crumbs Luke and Kolt had missed.
Most of all, she waited. From upstairs came muffled sounds of laughter that made her wonder all the more at Wyatt’s sudden transformation. Why had he chosen tonight to fully engage in not only Esther’s care, but his other three nieces’, as well?
When Wyatt finally ambled down the back staircase, Natalie pounced. “What’s wrong with you?”
“Excuse me?”
With Luke and the big kids in the movie room with explosions blaring, she felt safe to say exactly what was on her mind. “You’re a walking contradiction. One minute, your actions—your whole demeanor—are in attack mode. The next, you’re this warm, loving uncle trying to do his best by these little girls. Which man are you? Because at the moment, I’m confused.”
“Look,” he said on his way to the fridge. “I’ll be first to admit I’m far from perfect, but then who is? All I can do is try to make up for past mistakes and, Nat, a lot of those include the way I’ve acted around you.”
Not sure what to say, she bowed her head.
“After Esther’s christening, you and I shared a connection—based on mutual frustration with our families, but still there.” He removed a beer only to set it on the counter. Now he stood behind her. Not touching her, but close enough for heat and awareness to shimmer as if their bodies were hot blacktop on an endless summer day. “I’m tired, Nat. I need—” He sharply exhaled. “Ever since I found out I could never father a child, I’ve worked hard to distance myself from damn near everyone I encounter. Not sure how or even why, but it dawned on me that the effort is exhausting. I’m tired of fighting. I just want to live, you know. Stop worrying about it.”
Though the counselor in Natalie longed to turn around and give Wyatt a hug, the woman Craig’s sweet words had destroyed was wary. How many times had Craig told her what she wanted to hear, only to get what he wanted, then, when it served him, walk away? She wasn’t sure what Wyatt could possibly want from her—surely not casual sex—but what? Could it be as simple as him needing a genuine friend?
If so, in her turbulent hormonal state, was there anything simple about the way she’d been feeling whenever the man was near?
While giving the girls their bath, she’d caught a glimpse of him she’d only dreamt about. She’d never denied his being handsome. Or the way her body hummed with awareness whenever he was around. Part of her wanted him to be aware of her, too. But not in superficial ways such as thinking she had great hair and eyes, but on a deeper level. She wanted him to appreciate the accomplished woman she’d become. But why? Because no matter how many signals her body sent to steal another kiss, her conscience knew he was wrong for her in every conceivable way.
“You’re too quiet.” Wyatt finally uncapped his beer to take a swig. Back to the fridge, he removed the leftover taco meat, took a spoon from the nearest drawer and proceeded to feast. “Makes me suspicious. Like you’re plotting my demise.”
Covering her face with her hands, she shook her head. “You make me crazy.”
“Trust me, the feeling’s mutual.” Setting his snack to the counter, he crossed to her, taking her hands in his. “Kissing you at Esther’s christening was a mistake. Huge.”
Heart racing, Natalie wanted to admit to feeling the same, but her brain was so focused on his nearness—the scent of tacos and beer on his warm breath—that her mouth no longer worked.
“Because ever since then, regardless of how many times a day we bicker, all I want to do is this…” Lowering his lips to hers, what this kiss lacked in showiness, it made up for in layer upon layer of emotion. The sweetness could’ve made her weep. The unmasked wanting made her incapable of denying how badly she wanted more. To know him skin to skin.
Dizzying, thrilling moments later, he drew back. The intensity in his eyes read as a challenge. As if he dared her to deny what they’d shared hadn’t been amazing.
She looked down only to realize she’d fisted his shirt and now clung to him for support. Her legs had long since gone rubbery and her lungs no longer seemed to work.
He kissed her again, and their bold sweep of tongues did nothing to help her return to reality long enough to push him away. “Damn, you taste good. Like candy I’ve been teased with for decades and only just now got to taste.”
“But this doesn’t change anything,” she reminded. “You and me are pals—nothing more.”
“Woman,” he brushed his lips against the base of her throat, in the process sending shimmering pleasure coursing through her body, “you talk too damned much.”
Agreed. But someone needed to be the voice of logic before they both ended up doing something they’d regret in the morning. Though, a long-buried part of her wondered if she woke in Wyatt’s arms would she crave doing it again and again?
“Eeeeeew!” Bonnie and Betsy cried in unison.
Bonnie took her protest a step further by asking, “Uncle Wyatt, why are your hands on Miss Natalie’s butt?”
LONG AFTER LUKE AND KOLT left, after the twins had finally drifted off to sleep, Wyatt tossed and turned in the guest room. He was too hot, and pushed back the covers. Then he was cold. His pillows were too flat. He grabbed extra from the bed’s empty side, but then they were too tall.
Growling in frustration, he sat up and scratched his chest.
Usually, he went right to sleep, so what was the problem?
A sassy brunette flashed before his mind’s eye. She wore her pregnancy beautifully. Some future moms were sick the whole time and complexions blotchy, but not Natalie. Her skin glowed. Her eyes were bright. Over the years, he’d been with many incredibly beautiful women. Natalie didn’t have conventional looks. She had an inner glow he found far more intriguing than the usual great rack.
But why? Not only was he on the verge of leaving the country, but she represented the one thing he was trying to escape. In acknowledging her magnetic pull, he’d become a walking contradiction. He said he wanted nothing more than to never see another pregnant woman, but in Natalie’s case, he couldn’t get enough.
Pushing to his feet, he adjusted the fly of his boxers, then opened his bedroom door, creeping down the hall to her room.
Once there, he should’ve knocked, but didn’t.
Feet soundless on thick carpet, he crawled in bed alongside her, bunching pillows beneath his head before giving her shoulder a gentle nudge. “Natalie? You awake?”
Dressed in an old-fashioned flannel nightgown, she bolted upright, hugging the sheet to her chest. “What are you doing, scaring me half to death? In case you haven’t noticed, I’m about a hundred months pregnant. At the worst I could have the baby right now, or at best, pee the bed.”
He laughed. “Sorry. Need me to change the sheets?”
“No,” she said with an outraged smack to his bare chest.
Under different circumstances, he would’ve trapped her hand with his, but Wyatt figured he was already in enough hot water.
“Get out. Seriously.”
“I will,” he promised, easing up onto his elbow. “Just give me a minute.”
“For what?”
“Truth? Your kiss has me all hot and bothered and—”
“My kiss?” She coughed. “I was ambushed.”
“Sugar,” he flashed his best cocky cowboy smile, “it’s a little late to plead innocence. You were just as into it.”
“Maybe I was, but that doesn’t give you the right to barge into my bed, expecting more.”
“Bit presumptuous, Miss Lewis. I’m solely here to talk.”
She pummeled him again.
Grabbing her wrists, he pulled her in for a replay of their dessert. Only this time, with fewer clothes between them, her breasts mounded soft and full against his chest, causing an erection that was both pleasure and pain.
“No,” she moaned, pushing him away only to pull him back.
“I agree.” Yet he couldn’t stop kissing her.
After a deep sigh, she pulled back. “Talk. Th-that’s why you’re here, right?”
“Yeah.” Heels of his hands to his forehead, he said, “Okay, so we’ve been fixtures in each other’s lives for so long we’re like furniture, right?”
“Way to make me feel special.”
“You know what I mean. I’ve always considered you a good-looking woman, but since kissing you at Esther’s christening, I can’t stop thinking of you in terms of someone I want to know better—only, that’s no good. You’re Natalie. You deserve to be treated like someone special. Only I’m in no position to give anything other than meaningless sex.” He wished for more lighting so he could see her expression.
“This the part where I confess that’s all I want, too? Just a quick tickle and poke?” After a sharp laugh, she said, “We have chemistry. Big deal. It doesn’t mean anything. We don’t mean anything.”
She was right. So how come deep inside he feared ignoring his growing fascination with her would be wrong?
“HE DIDN’T,” CAMI SAID over lunch in Natalie’s office later that week. While Esther slept in her carrier, Mabel rummaged through the toy chest Natalie kept on hand for times when visiting parents brought younger siblings. Though Natalie was on an indefinite leave of absence, she’d been cooped up at the ranch for so long with Wyatt that she’d desperately needed out. “What did you say?”
Natalie covered her flushed face with her hands. “I don’t remember. I was so mortified by his even being there, let alone kissing me, I couldn’t think straight. A few minutes later, he left, and I spent the rest of the night staring at the ceiling.”
Cami took a bite of her chicken salad. “Wonder what Josie would say about this development?”
“I’d love to know, but the last thing I want her worrying about is an event this irrelevant.”
“How is the best kiss you’ve ever had irrelevant?”
“Because,” Natalie said, stabbing her fork through a cherry tomato, “regardless of how much I enjoyed what happened between Wyatt and me, it will never happen again.”
“What if it does?” Cami’s eyebrows raised in challenge. “Are you strong enough to resist full-force Buckhorn charm?”
The question made Natalie’s pulse race, but did nothing to diminish her resolve. “Here’s the thing— Wyatt’s leaving. I’m having Craig’s baby alone because I stupidly believed our child would be the glue needed to bind us together. With Wyatt, even if I wanted something more than those few kisses, I’m smart enough to know there’s not even a question of whether or not he may one day leave. His flight’s already scheduled. Trust me, from now until the day he goes, this little flirtation we’ve been playing with is done.”
“LUKE TELLS ME YOU AND Nat have been hooking up.” Cash hefted a hay bale from the truck bed to the south pasture feeding area. Though the temperature was chilly, the sun packed enough heat to bring out a sweat.
“Where’d you hear that?” Wyatt slung his next bale with extra force. He was already tired from no sleep. Last thing he needed was for his business to be spread all over hell and creation.
“Bonnie told Kolt she found you two doing it. Kolt told his dad. His dad told me.”
“This family does love to gossip.” Removing his hat, Wyatt wiped his forehead with the sleeve of his denim shirt. “First, all we were doing is making out. And second, Bonnie needs her mouth washed out with soap.”
“No need to get defensive. I’m just making conversation.”
In the midst of snorting, mooing and chewing cattle, they unloaded the last remaining bales in silence, then used knives to slit the bailing twine, gathering it all before climbing back into the truck.
“You do know,” Cash said, removing his leather work gloves and slapping them to the dash, “since Nat’s practically family, you can’t use her for sex. Plus, she’s pregnant. I get the turn-on factor—Wren was seriously hot with my baby in her oven. But Nat’s baby isn’t even yours, which makes you dipping in that particular pond like poaching.”
To keep from punching his little brother, Wyatt gripped the wheel especially hard. The old road had enough dips and deep tire ruts to warrant his full attention. “Not that what I do is any of your business, but for the last time, there’s nothing going on between me and Nat.”
Cash snorted. “Then why were your hands all over Nat’s ass?”
“Bonnie needs a good old-fashioned spanking.”
“No doubt about it, but my question still stands.”
“All right, look, we’ve shared a few hot times, but that’s it. Call it an experiment gone bad. We’ve both made it plain it goes no further. End of story.”
“If you say so.” Cash’s sarcastic tone made it clear he wasn’t buying the line Wyatt was selling. “Just keep in mind Nat happens to be Josie’s best friend. You piss off Nat, you piss off your sister-in-law, which pisses off Dallas. Last thing you need is him breathing fire down your neck.”
“Stop,” Wyatt said with a narrowed-eyed, sideways glare. “I’m a grown man and will make out with whomever I please, whenever I please. Dallas can huff and puff all he wants, but I seriously don’t give a—”
“Watch out!”
Wyatt swerved to avoid hitting a winter calf, in the process ramming the right front tire onto a jagged stump. Freakin’ swell. Now, he not only had a busted tire to deal with, but more time with his little brother.
“If you’re as bad with women,” Cash noted, “as you are at driving, no wonder you can’t make lasting magic happen with Nat. Now, if you happened to be as good-looking as me, then—”
“Unless you want that pretty face of yours marred with a black eye, you really ought to shut up.”
“LET ME FEED MABEL,” Natalie was surprised to hear Wyatt say two nights later. “You handle the twins and yourself.”
Esther had already been fed her bottle and cooed at the mobile dangling over her carrier.
“I’m not a baby.” Bonnie shoveled mashed potatoes into her mouth. “I feed myself.”
Not to be outdone, Betsy said, “Me, too.”
“I know you two will be fine,” their uncle encouraged Mabel to use a spoon for her peas, “but you know how messy Miss Nat can be when she doesn’t concentrate.”
“Uh-huh.” Bonnie nodded.
“Gee, thanks.” Natalie helped herself to seconds of meat loaf, hoping nice, warm comfort food counteracted the cool look she cast Wyatt’s way. To the twins, she said, “You two talked to your mom a long time. What did she say?”
Betsy bounced on her seat. “Daddy and her are excited to see us and Mommy wants to know if we have our Christmas tree up yet, because it’s only two weeks until Santa comes and everyone knows he gets grumpy if you don’t have a tree.”
“Yeah, and Kolt’s been real bad,” Bonnie said, “so we’ll have to have an extra big and fancy tree.”
“Shouldn’t you spend more time worrying about your own behavior and less about your cousin’s?” Wyatt had cut Mabel’s meat into bite-size chunks. She pitched two at Kitty, who gobbled them up.
“Santa knows I’m perfect,” Bonnie said.
“Me, too.” Betsy tossed at least a dozen peas to the cat.
Accidentally catching the sparkle in Wyatt’s eyes caused Natalie’s pulse to quicken. Her body refused to get the memo that she wanted nothing to do with him. Still, it was fun to share a parental moment.
Wyatt asked, “Wouldn’t Santa want Kolt’s tree to be at Kolt’s house?”
The twins leaned together for a whispered conference, at the end of which Bonnie announced, “We think because Kolt’s bad and we’re good, we’ll help make Santa extra happy. If he has two trees, then that’d be even better.”
“Yeah,” Betsy said, “and we think if we have three or four trees here at our house, then that would even help the bad babies get a good Christmas.”
“I don’t know about having that many,” Wyatt said, “but if it’s all right with Miss Nat, how about when you two get home from school tomorrow, we head out to the tree patch for at least one?”
“Yay!” Both girls abandoned their meals to dance.
After dishes were done and the babies were bathed and sweetly sleeping, after the twins were supposedly asleep, but actually playing Barbies with flashlights under their covers, Natalie curled onto a corner of the sofa with Josie’s well-loved copy of What to Expect When You’re Expecting.
She’d just gotten engrossed on the horrors of gestational diabetes when she looked up to find Wyatt staring.
“Chilly in here,” he said. “Want me to make a fire?”
“That’d be nice. Thanks.”
While he worked, she tried settling back into her reading, but the view of his broad shoulders and strong back was too darned distracting.
Worse yet, once he’d finished, he sat on the opposite end of her sofa with what looked like an exhilarating geography tome.
Natalie had read on to preeclampsia when Wyatt asked, “Need popcorn?”
“No, thank you.”
“A drink?” he suggested. “Wine? Mom’s got the good stuff. She won’t notice if we share a bottle.”
“What are we? In junior high? And anyway, in case you forgot, I’m pregnant.”
He slapped his book to the sofa. “I’m trying here, okay?”
“To do what?” She rested her read on the sofa arm.
“For us to have a nice, normal night. In a little over a week, I’ll be gone, but until then, I want to experience what it’s like being a family.”
She frowned. “Why?”
“Because for the first time in forever, I’m excited about getting a Christmas tree. I can’t wait for all of us to trek into the woods. I know it sounds stupid, but—”
“No…” Turning to face him, she bowed her head. “I feel the same. But it’s pointless. You’re leaving. I’m staying. Our roles will never change. We’re wired differently. Maybe that’s what’s driving the attraction, but—”
“You’re feeling it, too?”
“To a maddening degree,” she admitted. “But I’m on the verge of becoming a mother. If I can’t resist temptation, how am I supposed to teach that skill to my child?”
“I see your point.”
“Good.” Gravitating closer, she managed, “We’re both rational adults. As such, I think we can manage to give the girls a special holiday without giving in to base urges.”
“Agreed.” So why were they slowly coming together until nothing but mutually hitched breaths stood between them? Why did their lips press together? Exquisitely soft and tender and sweet enough to feel the intensity clear to her toes. When sensation took over, all reason vanished. Sanity was replaced with the sweep of Wyatt’s tongue, stroking her into a sort of fevered madness she felt helpless to deny.
Once necessity caused her to pause for breath, Natalie put her hands on Wyatt’s chest, hoping she’d summon the strength to push him away. “No.”
“Sorry,” he said, also breathing heavy.
“Me, too.”
“So from here on out, we won’t do this anymore.”
“Definitely not.” She crushed him in a hug, resisting the urge to nip his earlobe. “We should do our best to get along in a strictly platonic manner.”
Skimming his hand under her flannel sweatshirt, her satin-smooth baby bump put him in a state of male distress.
“Mmm…” she moaned, “that feels nice.”
“No kidding.”
Her lips again landed on his, rendering him incapable of doing anything but easing his free hand to her neck to press her closer.
Suddenly, there was an alien-like movement beneath his palm. Drawing back, he asked, “Was that—him—or her? Inside you?”
Eyes wide, as if searching his expression to discover if he’d been put off or moved by the notion of making out with a woman pregnant with another man’s baby, she nodded. “I think he likes you.”
“He?” Wyatt barely managed to whisper past his tight throat. “You’re having a son?”
She nodded. “I found out at my latest ultrasound. I thought I wanted to be surprised, but at the last minute changed my mind. You’re the first person I’ve told.”
In Wyatt’s every fantasy about having a family, he’d always wanted a son. Which only made his current situation harder. “Thank you—for trusting me. I’m happy for you.”
Tears shone in her eyes. “Me, too. I mean, I’m happy. But then sometimes I’m really scared. Like what am I doing? Believing I’m smart enough to raise a child.”
Acting on instinct, he took her hand in his, giving her a squeeze. “Judging by the way you’ve cared for Dallas and Josie’s crew, you’re going to be fine. Perfect.”
“Think so?” Her voice had gone small. Like she truly didn’t know how impressive her mothering skills were.
“The first night we were charged with caring for the entire Buckhorn brood, and all the babies were screaming, I freaked out. You, however, acted as if you’d never met an infant you didn’t love. And they love you back. Your baby boy is going to believe the sun rises and sets in your arms.”
Her body fell limp against him. “You don’t know what a relief it is to hear from someone—anyone—that they think I can do this. My parents are freaking out about me not being married. Before the accident, even Josie told me I could move in here if I couldn’t manage raising a baby on my own.”
He couldn’t help but laugh. “Sure your parents haven’t conferred with my mom? Sounds like the same line she fed both my brothers and sister. I swear the woman won’t be happy until she’s married off the entire county.”
“Why does everyone think wedding rings are the only path to happiness? I’ve been fine on my own for years. Why wouldn’t I be just as fine with a child?”
“You will be.”
Natalie’s hug evoked an emotion deep inside him. Wyatt felt important and needed and as if his mere act of supporting her when no one else had made a genuine difference.
“Thank you,” she sniffled through tears.
“I didn’t do anything.”
“Yes, Wyatt, you did. I’ve been sitting here, reading this stupid book about everything that can go wrong with my pregnancy. You reminded me how right finally holding my son will be.”
Wyatt thought, Wish I’d be around to meet him.