At noon that same Saturday, Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office Detectives Peter Drummond and Richard S. Johnson were dispatched to a mansion on North Ocean Boulevard.
Detective Johnson was in his early thirties, a big athletic guy, ex-Marine, and a recent hire from Dade County. Detective Sergeant Drummond was in his sixties, a big, robust black man with a face almost devoid of expression due to nerve damage associated with a large burn scar that began beneath his right eye and spread over much of his cheek to his jaw.
Johnson knew he was lucky to have Drummond as his partner. The sergeant was a legend in the department, one of those men who had a knack for figuring out how criminals, especially murderers, thought.
Sergeant Drummond took a left off North Ocean Boulevard and pulled through open gates into an Italianate manor’s courtyard where two cruisers, a medical examiner’s van, and a midnight-blue Rolls-Royce were parked.
“Who the hell can afford to live like this?” Johnson asked.
“Around here,” Drummond said, “lots of folks. And definitely Dr. Stanley Abrams. He owns a big plastic-surgery clinic. They call him the Boob King.”
They climbed out of the unmarked cruiser into heat that was ungodly despite the proximity to the ocean.
“I thought most of the super-rich along Ocean Boulevard headed north for the summer,” the younger detective said.
“Most do,” the sergeant replied. “But guys like Abrams stay around no matter how hot it gets.”
One of the uniformed deputies showed them into the house—a castle, really, with so many hallways and rooms that Detective Johnson was soon lost. They climbed a grand staircase, passing an oil painting of a pretty woman in a ball gown, and heard the sound of a man crying.
They entered a bedroom suite and found a slight man in a hall off the bedroom sitting on a padded bench, head down.
“Dr. Abrams?” Drummond said.
The plastic surgeon looked up, revealing a smooth-featured face and a full head of hair that spoke to Johnson of multiple procedures, including hair plugs.
Drummond identified himself, told Abrams he was sorry for his loss.
“I don’t get it,” Abrams said, composing himself. “Ruth was the happiest person I know. Why would she do this to herself?”
“No inkling that she might have been thinking of suicide?” Drummond asked.
“None,” the doctor said.
“Nothing that had upset her lately?” Johnson asked.
The plastic surgeon started to shake his head, but then stopped. “Well, Lisa Martin’s death last week. They were close, ran in the same circles.”
Both detectives nodded. They’d caught that case too. But the death of Lisa Martin, another Ocean Boulevard resident, had been ruled accidental. She’d knocked a plugged-in Bose radio into the tub while she was taking a bath.
“So your wife was sad about Mrs. Martin’s death?” Drummond said.
“Yes, sad and upset,” Abrams said. “But not enough to…Ruth had everything to live for, and she loved life. My God, she’s the only person in this town, including me, who’s never been on antidepressants!”
“You found her, sir?” Johnson asked.
The surgeon’s eyes watered, and he nodded. “Ruth had given the staff the weekend off. I flew in overnight from Zurich.”
“We’re going to take a look,” Drummond said. “You touch anything?”
“I wanted to cut her down,” Abrams said, looking into his hands. “But I didn’t. I just…called you.”
He sounded lost and alone. Johnson said, “You got family, sir?”
Abrams nodded. “My daughters. Sara’s in London, and Judy’s in New York. They’re going to be…” He sighed and started to cry again.
Drummond went into the bedroom, Johnson trailing him. The detective sergeant stopped, studying the corpse in situ.
Ruth Abrams hung by a drapery cord that was suspended from a chandelier above the bed and cinched tight around her neck. She was a small-framed woman, no more than one hundred and ten pounds, and wore a black nightgown. Her face was swollen and mottled purple. Her legs and feet were a darker maroon because of the blood that had settled.
“You have a time of death?” Drummond asked the medical examiner, a young Asian woman who was making notes.
“Eighteen to twenty hours is the best I can do for now,” the ME said. “The air-conditioning throws things a bit, but it looks straightforward to me. She hung herself.”
Drummond nodded without comment, eyes on the body. He walked over to the bed and stopped about a foot away from it. Johnson did the same on the opposite side.
It looked straightforward to Johnson too. She’d apparently put an upside-down wastebasket on the bed to stand on while she got the noose around her neck and then she’d kicked it away. There it was, on the rug to the right of the bed. She’d hung herself. End of story.
But the sergeant had put on reading glasses and was studying the bedspread, which was bunched to the left side of the bed. He peered at the woman’s neck, livid and abraded from the cord, and then removed his glasses to study the knots that held the cord to the chandelier.
“Seal the house, Johnson,” Drummond said at last. “This was no suicide.”
“What?” the young detective said. “How can you tell that?”
The sergeant gestured to the bedspread and around the bed. “This looks like a struggle to me.”
“People struggle when they hang themselves.”
“True, but the sheets are all dragged to the left, meaning that the body was dragged up the right side, and the wastebasket was then placed on the right to suggest suicide,” Drummond said.
Johnson saw what the sergeant was talking about but wasn’t convinced. Drummond pointed to her hands.
“Broken and torn fingernails,” he said. “There’s a chip of the polish in the braids of the drapery cord. That and the vertical scratches above the neck suggests she was tearing at the cord during the initial struggle, which took place at ground level. And see how the livid lines are crisscrossed above and below the cord?”
Johnson frowned. “Yes.”
“They shouldn’t be there,” the sergeant said. “If she’d kicked the wastebasket, the cord would have caught all her weight almost immediately. There’d be one line behind and along the cord, and we might see some evidence of the cord abrading the skin as it slid into position.
“But these two clear lines suggest that the killer flipped the cord over Mrs. Abrams’s head from behind and throttled her. She fought, tore at her throat with her fingers, and maybe kicked at her killer. In any case, she created slack in the noose. The cord slipped, and the killer had to set it tight again, here. She was dead before she was hung up there. See the grooves along the cord where it’s tied to the chandelier? That’s from the killer hauling the body up.”
The young detective shook his head in admiration. Drummond’s legend was real, and the evidence was so clear once you heard him explain it.
“You want me to call in a full forensics team?” Johnson asked.
“I think that would be a very good idea.”