It was that next week that Roman began different tactics.
As soon as I sat down he said: ‘Now, Mrs Rutland, I think we’ve been making enough progress these last two weeks to pass on to the next stage. It’s very simple really, and really very much the same. But I shall stop asking you to tell me about your life and instead I just want you to talk. In the course of the hour I shall put one or two questions to you or perhaps even just one or two words – and I shall ask you to talk about whatever ideas come into your head as a result of that question or that word. I don’t want you to reason anything out, I just want you to say the first thing that comes to you, even if it’s nonsense – more than ever perhaps if it is nonsense. Do you understand?’
‘Yes, I think so.’
We sat in silence for a minute or two and then he said: ‘Are you happy coming here?’
‘Oh, yes . . . Yes, quite.’
‘Do you come by tube?’
‘Yes, usually.’
‘Rain. What does rain suggest?’
‘It’s always raining when I come here. Every time so far. My umbrella leaks a pool in your hatstand. The buses make noises with their tyres like kettles boiling. Hiss, hiss.’ I thought that was quite clever really on the spur of the moment.
‘Water,’ he said.
‘Isn’t that the same thing? Not quite, I suppose.’ I looked down at my ankle. That woman had caught my stocking in the tube with her crazy stick. Some women ought to be locked up, not looking where they were standing, and all the time telling this friend about Charles’s gallstones.
I thought I’d give Roman a run for his money. ‘Water? It rains a lot in Plymouth where I was born. And there’s water all round there. Why do they call it Plymouth Sound? The sound of kettles boiling. I love tea, don’t you? It’s the cosiest drink. They were always drinking tea at home. Come in, dear, and have a cup, it’s not five minutes since we made it. Sugar? No, I gave it up during the war. Wasn’t rationing awful?’
He waited a bit but I didn’t go on.
‘Baths.’
‘Baths?’
‘Yes.’
I didn’t speak for a long time but leaned back and shut my eyes. I thought, this isn’t bad. He just waits as long as I wait, and the hour ticks by.
‘Baths,’ I said. ‘Do you take baths, Dr Roman?’
He didn’t answer. I said: ‘Sometimes when I’m in the mood I have two and three a day. Not often, but sometimes. Mark says, What do I waste my time for, but I say, Well isn’t it better to take too many than not enough? People who don’t wash smell. You wouldn’t want me to smell, would you?’
He said: ‘What do you associate with baths? What are the first things that come into your mind?’
‘Soap, plugs, water, rain-water, Boers, Baptists, blood, tears, toil . . .’ I stopped, because my tongue really was getting ahead of me. What was I talking about?
‘Baptists,’ he said.
‘Blood of the Lamb,’ I said. ‘Made pure for me. And his tears shall wash away thy sins and make thee over again.’ I stopped and giggled slightly. ‘My mother used to take me to chapel three times every Sunday, and I suppose it’s coming out now.’
‘Did you learn that so young?’
‘And Lucy Nye too,’ I said in a hurry. ‘Lucy was just as bad after Mother died.’
The hour went on like this. Most of the time he seemed to keep on dodging around the same dreary subject of water. I don’t know what was biting him, but after a bit I didn’t enjoy it so much and thought, let him go and run after himself. Why should I work so hard? He was getting paid, not me.
So we stuck there for a long time, until he mentioned thunderstorms, and I thought, oh, well, this’ll colour his life, so I told him all about Lucy Nye and how she’d made me afraid of them. And even then I had this funny instinct that he wasn’t believing a word of it.
Anyway, when it was all over I came away with a feeling that for a non-talker I’d talked a lot too much . . .
So on the Friday I went all set to say nothing at all.
But it wasn’t so easy because almost the first thing he said was: ‘Tell me about your husband. Do you love him?’
I said: ‘But of course,’ in one of those light brittle voices, because keeping quiet here might tell more than talking.
‘What does the word love mean to you?’
I didn’t answer. About five minutes later I said: ‘Oh – affection, kissing . . . warmth, friendly arms . . . a kitchen with a fire burning, come in out of the rain, m’dear . . . God so loved the World that he gave His only Begotten Son . . . Forio knowing my step. Mother cat carrying her kitten away. Uncle Stephen walking down the street to meet me. That do?’
‘And sex?’
I yawned. ‘. . . Masculine and feminine. Adjectives end in euse, instead of eux. Male and female . . . Adam and Eve. And Pinch-me. Dirty boys. I’ll slap your bloody face if you come near me again . . .’ I stopped.
There was another long wait. OK. I thought, I can wait.
It must have been another five minutes. ‘Does sex suggest anything else?’ he asked.
‘Only dirty psychiatrists wanting to know,’ I said.
‘What does marriage suggest to you?’
‘Oh, what’s the good of all this?’ I said, getting hot. ‘I’m bored. See? Bored.’
It was so quiet I could hear my wrist-watch ticking away.
‘What does marriage suggest to you?’
‘Wedding bells. Champagne. Old boots. Smelly old boots. Something borrowed, something blue. Bridesmaids. Confetti.’
‘Isn’t that the wedding you’re thinking of, not marriage?’
‘You told me to say what came into my head!’ I was suddenly angry. ‘Well, I’ve flaming well said it! What else d’you expect! If that isn’t enough I – I . . .’
‘Don’t upset yourself. If it upsets you we can pass on to something else.’
So it went on. On the following Tuesday we had a real set-to. Then I clammed up and said practically nil for a complete half-hour. I pretended to go to sleep but he didn’t believe it. Then I started counting to myself. I counted up to one thousand seven hundred.
‘What does the word woman suggest to you?’
‘Woman? Well . . . just woman.’
I relaxed and dreamed about jumping a hurdle.
‘Woman,’ he said much later. ‘Doesn’t it suggest anything?’
‘Yes . . . Venus de Milo. Bitch. Cow. I once saw a dog run over in the street. I was the first one to get to it because it was still yelping and it bit through the arm of my winter coat and there was blood on the pavement, and the boy driving the baker’s van said it wasn’t his fault and I shouted at him yes it was, yes it was, you should take more bloody care, and the poor little perisher died in my arms and it was awful it suddenly going limp, just limp, like a heavy old rag; I didn’t know what to do so I left it there behind the dustbins meaning to go back for it, but when I got home I got in a screaming row for getting my arm and coat bitten . . . Queer; I’d forgotten all about that. Queer how you dig things up.’
He didn’t say anything. Each time I came he said less.
‘You want to know about sex,’ I said. ‘All this beating about the bush really comes down to that, don’t it? It’s the only thing any of your trade are interested in. Well, all I can tell you is I’m not. Mark wanted me to come to see you because I won’t sleep with him! That’s what he told you, isn’t it? Well, it’s the truth! But I don’t aim to be put in a glass case or stared at through a microscope – a sort of – of freak at a side-show – simply because I have my own likes and dislikes and choose to stick to them! See? Everything I’ve said you’ve tried to twist round to one meaning, haven’t you? I know your sort. Most men have pretty dirty minds, but psycho-analysts are in a class by themselves! God, I wouldn’t like to be your wife! Have you a wife?’
After a while he said: ‘Go on, say exactly what you think. But try to relax while you’re saying it. Don’t tense up. Remember you won’t shock me.’
Oh, won’t I, I thought. I could if I really got going. All those filthy rhymes that Louise taught me. Your kind don’t know the half.
He said: ‘Tell me one thing, Mrs Rutland. Apart from this question of – not wanting your husband, are you happy generally speaking, in other ways?’
I kept my mouth shut this time.
‘What I mean,’ he said, ‘is, do you feel you’re experiencing and enjoying life to the full?’
‘Why shouldn’t I be?’
‘Well, I’d be surprised if you do.’
‘That’s your opinion, isn’t it?’
‘I suspect that for a good deal of the time you live in a sort of glass case, not knowing real enthusiasm or genuine emotion; or feeling them perhaps at second hand, feeling them sometimes because you think you ought to, not because you really do.’
‘Thanks, I’m sure.’
‘Try not to be offended. I want to help. Don’t you sometimes slightly pride yourself on being withdrawn from life? Don’t you sometimes feel rather superior about people whose feelings get the better of them? – or ashamed when you give way to them yourself?’
I shrugged and looked at my watch.
‘And isn’t that pity or feeling of superiority an attempt to rationalize a deeper sensation, an overreaction if you like against a feeling of envy?’
‘D’you like hysterical people? I don’t.’
‘I wasn’t talking of hysteria but of genuine natural emotion, which is essential in a balanced liberated human being.’
I pulled up my shoulder strap, which hadn’t slipped after all.
He said: ‘But even hysteria is much easier to set right than your condition. You’ve grown a protective skin to defend yourself against feelings. Unless you try to come out of it the skin will harden until the real you inside shrivels and dies.’
‘And d’you think all this talking is going to help?’
‘It will, I promise you; but only on certain conditions. That’s why I’m breaking my general rule and trying to interpret your problems far too soon. So far, Mrs Rutland, except for one or two rare outbursts like today, you have been watching your step all the time. Whenever anything has seemed to come to your lips that represented the true Free Association I’m seeking you have bitten it off sharp. Well, that’s not uncommon at the beginning, especially in a woman of perception like yourself – but I have to differentiate between involuntary suppression and deliberate suppression. An analyst can only help a patient who tries to help herself.’
‘What d’you expect me to do?’ I said sulkily.
‘I want you to stop being frightened of what you’re going to say.’
It was that night we went to the concert at the Festival Hall. I went in the wrong mood to sit still for two hours while a lot of sad-looking men and women played prim classical music. The only thing that could have done me any good at all was perhaps jazz, which did at least set your blood moving, your arms and feet twinkling.
I yawned all through the first part of the concert – or at least half the time I struggled not to. The lights and the noise and the dressed-up audience made me sleepy and yet at the same time restless. The second half I thought I was never going to get through, except for the last piece. By then I’d soaked in some of the right mood, or perhaps it was the music. It was something by Brahms. I think it was his fourth symphony. But it might have been any of them.
Anyway, Mark saying it was different from when it was canned, I could see there was this difference. The horns and things showed you what ‘brassy’ meant, and the strings had a sort of reedy sound, like wind blowing through grass, like wheat stalks shivering, like the crying of trees. In the end it got me; it was like it had slid under my skin and was playing on exposed nerves. I forgot all the sad-looking people and Mark next to me and the gangway on the other side and the lights and the antique faces in the orchestra, and I felt as if I was alone on a peak of a mountain and what I’d done with my life so far was pretty much of a dream and only these few seconds were real.
But you couldn’t stay up there, it was too cold or the light was too bright or something, and suddenly the music had stopped and people were getting up and moving out. I wiped the sweat off my forehead and nodded to Mark and we followed the others down to the January wind and the waiting cars.
Afterwards we went to a night club. It was his idea not mine, but by then the want to jive had left me because something else had been there and taken its place. But the something else had gone and left an emptiness, and nothing much mattered any more. We got home about one. I don’t know if he thought the evening a success, but for me it had been too up and down; somehow except for just those few minutes I’d never been in step – and even those minutes I hadn’t so much been walking as flying.
When we got home I said I was tired and went quickly to bed and put the light out. I watched his light for a time, afraid because of something about him that evening.
Thought up two or three different excuses, including of course the most obvious one. I’d never used it even on the honeymoon because I was shy of speaking about it to a man. But I thought I might keep it as a sort of last resort tonight.
I heard him moving about for a long time. It must have been three before he put his light out. But he didn’t come in.
I’d missed two Saturdays at poker, but the next one I went again, and this time I gambled heavily. It was quite unlike me. I was losing my judgment. But I won twenty pounds. That’s the way it is sometimes; you get the luck when you don’t deserve it. That week I’d sent Mother a hundred pounds in two Money Orders, so I was within scraping distance of rock bottom.
On the Sunday morning Mark said: ‘These Saturday nights with Dawn Witherbie get later and later. What do you do, go dancing?’
‘No, we went to the pictures and then I went home with her, and her mother wasn’t well, so I stayed on until the doctor came . . . How did you know I was late?’
‘I thought I heard the car about two, so I waited and then went and looked in your bedroom and it obviously wasn’t.’
‘No, it must have been later than that.’
‘It was nearly four. I didn’t get to sleep again until after I had heard the car.’
I rubbed a small stain on my riding breeches.
He said: ‘Anyway you seem to come up bright and fresh every Sunday . . . How are you going on with Roman?’
‘Doesn’t he tell you?’
‘No, he hasn’t said anything yet.’
‘I’d like to give it up. It’s upsetting me.’
‘I’m sorry.’
‘I’ve done weeks and weeks now. It’s far beyond what I promised. I don’t want to go on. I come away feeling tired and depressed.’
‘Shall I ring him next week, and ask him what he thinks?’
‘Oh, I know what he’ll say. It’s only the beginning for him. He’s making a good thing out of it.’
‘He’s far too honest to go on only for that reason.’
I could see Mark wasn’t giving way, so I turned and went out into the garden.
For once Forio wouldn’t come to me. It was so out of character I could hardly believe it. He’d let me get nearly to touching distance and then he’d toss his head and trot off. It had been wet practically all week, so I suppose he hadn’t had enough exercise. After four or five times I gave up and walked back to the house. A piece of apple would fetch him.
As I got in I heard Mrs Leonard call out: ‘I don’t know where they are, Mr Rutland, not this week. I was out, and Mrs Rutland must have put them away.’
‘What is it?’ I said.
‘My new shirts,’ Mark said.
‘Oh, I put them in your wardrobe. Wait a minute.’ I ran upstairs and into his room. He was standing there in front of the mirror with a handkerchief in his hand. He was wearing a pair of old grey flannel trousers but he hadn’t anything on above that.
He said: ‘Sorry, I thought you’d gone.’
‘I had but I came back. I took the shirts out of the box and put them with your others.’ I went to the wardrobe. ‘Here they are.’
‘Thanks. I thought I’d just try one.’
I lifted the top one out and pulled the various clips and things out. On the table were his keys and his pocketbook and a diary and some loose change. He always put them there each night when he undressed. ‘I never knew before people ever did buy six shirts at a time.’
He laughed. ‘It’s not a sign of extravagance. They wear longer.’
When you saw him without his clothes you could see he wasn’t delicate, or even thin. His skin was pale and smooth, but the muscles lay under it; there when need be.
I said: ‘Forio’s being tiresome. I came in for some bait.’
He took the handkerchief away from his face. ‘As you’re here, d’you think you could get this eyelash out of my eye? I think I shoved it in with the towel.’
I went to him and he bent his head. I honestly believe this was the nearest we’d been to each other since we came home. And taking an eyelash out is very much of a close-up project. Your own eyes stare into the other eyes at nearer than love-making range. You see the pinkness under the lid and the tiny blood vessels; but even that doesn’t matter so much as the pupil, because that seems to stand for about the closest you can ever expect to get to the personality. It was harder still for me this time because I had to put my other hand somewhere when now and then it wasn’t wanted, so I had to put it on his warm shoulder, and of course my body was touching his.
I saw the eyelash and edged it towards the corner. Then with me standing there like this against him it was just as if my own body hadn’t any clothes on either. I got the feeling just like it was really happening.
Just about in time I got the eyelash out and shifted away, feeling sick and short of breath.
‘There you are. No charge at all.’
He took the handkerchief from me. ‘Oh, heaven, that there were but a mote in yours.’
‘What?’
‘Nothing. Only a quotation.’
I went to the door.
‘Marnie.’
‘Yes?’
He smiled at me. ‘Thanks.’
I went out and ran downstairs and went into the kitchen for a minute or two to try and get the thing out of my system. When I went to fetch Forio I realized I’d come out without his bit of apple. But it didn’t matter because this time he came to me like a lamb.
I rode till lunch-time and was late back for lunch, but I felt frightful all day. I felt so depressed I could have howled. I was becoming a melancholic. That’d be something fresh for Roman to unscramble.
I was depressed all week, and had dreams enough to keep all the psychiatrists in London on time and a half.
On the Wednesday I went down to see Mother. I found I could do it well enough in a day, so I made the excuse I had to settle up something with the Garrods.
Mother was looking much better. She was mixing in nicer company here, she said, and the house quite suited her. For once she jarred; I suppose because I was still feeling depressed. I thought, here she is having a good time on my money and not really caring where it comes from. Then I remembered how she’d been four years ago and what a difference the money had made.
She went into a sulk when I said I couldn’t even stay one night, but she only asked casually about Mr Pemberton and seemed to take it for granted things were going on as usual. Just after tea, while Lucy was washing up, I said: ‘Mam, when did Dad die?’
‘Die? He was killed, drowned. Nineteen-forty-three. Why?’
‘I was only wondering. I was thinking of it the other day. I don’t remember it. I mean I don’t remember who told me or what they said to break the news.’
‘Why should you indeed? You were only six at the time. Why should you remember anything about it?’
‘Well, I remember other things. After all six isn’t all that young. I remember Uncle Stephen coming when I was five and bringing me a pair of fur-lined gloves. I remember the girl next door—’
‘All right, you remember one thing and forget another. That’s the way of it. If you want the truth, I didn’t tell you for months after. I thought it’d upset you, like. I thought, Marnie mustn’t know. So in the end it just didn’t make an impression on you at all.’
I edged around on my seat. ‘What part of nineteen-forty-three was it? We were at Sangerford then, weren’t we? Did he visit us in Sangerford? I mean earlier. I mean one Christmas. I seem to remember he did. Didn’t he bring me a present of a box of chocolates? And some sugared almonds. I remember the sugared almonds . . .’
She said: ‘Wait,’ and got up with her stick and limped to this old stool we’ve had since the year one and lifted the top and took out her black bag. ‘I’ll show you,’ she said, and began to fumble among some papers. ‘I keep it here. I keep everything here.’ She passed me a yellow news-clipping.
It was from the Western Morning News, 14th June, 1943, under ‘Deaths on Active Service’: ‘Frank William Elmer, H.M.S. Cranbrook, on June 10th: Aged 41, late of 12, Mulberry Street, Keyham. Beloved husband of Edith and father of Margaret.’
I gave it back. ‘I don’t remember seeing it before. Thanks.’
Mother dabbed her nose. ‘It was Whit Monday that came out. It was a lovely day. People was on holiday, even in the wartime. I cut it out to keep. That’s all I had left.’
‘It’s years since I saw a photo of him,’ I said. ‘There used to be one in Plymouth on the mantelpiece. You know.’
‘There’s one here. Same one but not framed.’
I looked at that face. I’d come from that face. A stranger he was, because I only knew the photograph. Somehow I’d come from him. He wasn’t a bit like what I’d told Roman. His hair was fair and thick and cut short, his face was round, his eyes blue or light grey, small, and I should think twinkling. The oddest thing was he looked young. Mother had got older and he’d stayed young.
‘How old was he here?’
‘About thirty.’
‘Can I have this or is it the only one?’
‘You can have it if you take care of it.’
Old Lucy came in with some dishes then, so I put the photo in my bag before she saw. But later when she went out again I said: ‘Mam, what was the name of the doctor – you know, the one that let you down with the baby?’
‘Why?’ she said. ‘What’s it all about? Gascoigne was his name – may God have mercy upon him, for I can’t.’
‘Was I all right?’ I said. ‘I mean when I was born. No trouble then?’
‘Of course not! But that was before the war. You – why, you never gave me a minute’s worry. Not till you were ten, that was. And that was all because of the common company you had to mix with. What’s the matter with you today, Marnie? All these questions.’
‘I don’t know. I sometimes think I’m a bit queer.’
‘Queer. Well, be thankful you’re not like other girls. Trollops and flying after men. Painting their toe-nails. You’re worth three of any ordinary girl, Marnie, and don’t let anyone tell you different. You’re so clever – and so good.’
‘Were you a bit out of the ordinary when you were young?’
‘I was always one to want to get on – a wee bit proud perhaps – kept myself to myself. Your father used to say I was too good for him. But I was never as clever as you, dear.’
‘I’m not sure it’s wise to be too clever,’ I said. ‘Sometimes you overreach yourself.’
That Sunday at breakfast Mark said: ‘Are you never going to tire of your poker parties?’
I swallowed something that wasn’t food and said:
‘My what?’
‘The poker parties you go to at Terry’s.’
‘Have you been having me – followed?’
‘Not really. No.’
‘Then how did you . . .’
‘A few weeks ago I asked Dawn Witherbie how her mother was and she told me she hadn’t been ill. After that it wasn’t hard to find out the rest.’
I broke a piece of toast. ‘Why shouldn’t I go if I want to?’
‘Is that the point? Surely the main question is, why lie to me in the first place?’
‘Because I thought you’d disapprove.’
‘So I do. But only because it’s Terry. Otherwise I try to let you live your own life.’
I was feeling scared. Supposing he’d had me followed to Torquay!
‘Well, it’s Terry. Why shouldn’t I go out with Terry if I want to?’
‘Two reasons. Perhaps they’re both personal and you won’t think they affect you. I think Terry is one of the misfits of this life. I spend one-third of the time feeling sorry for him and two-thirds hating his guts. I feel he’s utterly misplaced and out of his true element as a printer. But there’s no job on earth that I can think of that would be his true element. Can you? He’s – to me – a jumble of ambitions and frustrations that don’t quite add up to a real person. He wants to be a first-rate business man, but he never will be. He wants to be a great lover, and is always trying to be, but I don’t think he is. He teeters around on the edge of things, dressing beautifully, picking up the latest fads and phrases, running his little poker parties and his jam sessions. You see, Marnie, if he was a really tough bad character, perhaps I could make something of that, but he isn’t even big enough to be really bad. And what’s worse, along with his failures – perhaps as a result of them – there’s a sort of slyness that gets under my skin. He has the sort of ingenuity that turns sour everything that it touches.’
‘Perhaps it’s because he’s a misfit that I – get along with him.’
‘Don’t underrate yourself. Look at this business of the Glastonbury Investment Trust – and it’s you I’ve to thank for putting me on to it. I haven’t tackled him yet, but it seems to me perfectly typical of the man. I don’t resent his enmity but I resent his back-door way of showing it.’
‘What are you going to do?’
‘I don’t know. That’s reason number two for your not going to these parties. Just at the moment I don’t think you, as my wife, can possibly, decently, have a foot in both camps. It would be less impossible if the blood-letting were above ground. But it isn’t yet.’
I began to put one or two of the things together on the table.
He said: ‘I hate unpleasantness. And the feeling that all this is going on underneath all the time poisons every day as soon as I get to the works. I told Rex about the Glastonbury Trust, and he has some weird idea of having the Holbrooks and ourselves over to dinner one night to see if they’ll make the friendly move and come out in the open. I’ve told him he’s crazy, but he says it’s a pity if an old family firm is going to have to come to a split for lack of an effort on his part.’
‘When does he want us to go?’
‘I don’t know. I think the week after next. Anyway you see how it is. You see how impossible it is for you to be out until all hours with Terry, don’t you?’
I piled the dirty plates on the dinner wagon. If something was put to me rationally I nearly always saw the point. But I was feeling mulish. I expect I looked mulish, because after watching me he said:
‘Ours is about the oddest sort of life anyone could live, isn’t it. That’s if it can be called a life at all.’
‘I didn’t suggest it.’
‘No, but to some extent you acquiesced.’
‘You know the reason for that.’
He came over and stood beside me. His eyes were very dark. ‘I’ve done what I can to leave you alone, Marnie. It hasn’t been much fun, I can tell you. Sometimes it gets me down. That’s another form of unpleasantness, to feel that you’re being treated as a jailer by your own wife. That, and all the other pressures involved . . . It puts me off balance at my job, it comes between me and my sleep. I’m irritable and short-tempered with things. Sometimes I feel I could kill you. But I don’t. I leave you alone. Except for Roman, you do whatever you want. You go your own way. I hope for better things. I keep on hoping. It’s the only thing that makes the present set-up tolerable at all. But if you start playing fast and loose with Terry I shall have to think again.’
‘I don’t play fast and loose with him! I can’t bear him to touch me!’
‘I know he wouldn’t be Terry if he didn’t try.’
‘I really believe you’re jealous of him.’
He took me by the shoulders and tried to bring me round to face him. I wouldn’t move. He pulled me round.
‘You’re hurting me, Mark.’
He didn’t let go. ‘So I’m jealous, Marnie. I’m jealous of the men you speak to, of the people you go out with, of the hours you spend here alone while I’m at the works. I even have to be jealous of my miserable backdoor sham-smart wise-cracking cousin. More than ever jealous of him because he seems to be the only man you favour. The whole damned feeling is something I’ve never felt before and never need to have felt, because with any sort of proper relationship between us it wouldn’t have arisen.’
‘You’re hurting me.’
He let me go, shrugged. ‘I don’t want to start getting melodramatic . . . I’ve made my own present – and yours too. And for the time being at any rate we’ve got to live in it. I’m trying to let you go your own way and at your own pace. That’s fine – we’ve agreed to it, and if it’s wearing on me that’s my funeral. But the bargain doesn’t include your going out and staying out with Terry. I’m sorry if you thought it did, but it doesn’t. It just doesn’t, Marnie.’
I pulled my arm away and left him there at the door.