ELOISE SHOT MAX a furtive look when he walked into the room, then stared down at the plain white handkerchief in her cuffed hands.
“Eloise? My name is Max Mingus. I’m investigating the kidnapping of Charlie Carver.”
No reply.
“I know you speak English as well as I do,” Max said. She stayed silent, kept her eyes on the handkerchief, her body slightly hunched forward, as if she would have drawn her knees up to her chest if she could.
“Let me paint the picture for you. This is going to go very very badly for you both,” Max kept his voice low and soft, his tone non-threatening, one of shared intimacy. “You know who Vincent Paul is. I’ve seen what he does to people and trust me, it is not pretty.”
She didn’t even move.
“Eloise, I’m not like him. I want to help you. I’ve seen the videotapes of you when you were a little girl. I’ve seen what that man in the next room did to you. If you help me, I promise you that I will talk to Vincent about you. I’ll explain to him that it wasn’t really your fault you got involved in the things you did. You might have a good chance of getting out of this alive.”
Silence.
Then Max heard the unmistakable boom of Vincent Paul’s voice outside the house.
“Eloise. Save yourself. Please,” Max implored. “If you don’t help me, Vincent Paul will kill you. He’s not going to take your past into account. He’s not going to care that you were once a little girl, that that evil bastard out there snatched you from your home and raped you and abused you. He’s just going to see what he’s looking at—a teacher, someone responsible for the lives of young vulnerable children, orphans, who let evil men abuse them and even participated in it. I won’t blame him for his actions, Eloise. Think about it. Think about it hard. I’m offering you a way out. That sack of shit in the next room isn’t worth it.”
Max walked out and saw Paul standing in the corridor. He greeted Max with a half-smile and a slight nod.
“Give her this.” Vincent put something small and wet into Max’s palm.
Max looked at it and went back in to Eloise.
“Recognize this?” he asked her.
Her eyes widened and teared up when she recognized what the bloody gleaming chunk of metal between Max’s fingers was.
“You leave him alone!” she screeched.
“If you don’t tell us what we want to know, Eloise, we are going to take him apart, piece by piece.” He grabbed her hand and pressed her lover’s gold front tooth into her palm.
She stared at Max, her eyes poisoned darts. He knew then that she wasn’t the warped innocent he was almost sure she’d be. She wasn’t any kind of victim at all. She was every bit as guilty as Codada.
“You’re still going to kill us whatever,” she sneered, French accent smothering American inflections.
Paul walked in, dragging Codada behind him by his cuffed legs.
Eloise cried out when she saw him. She tried to stand.
“Sit down!” Max thundered. “You will answer my questions or that child-raping scumbag over there will lose a lot more than his teeth. Understand?”
Max didn’t wait for an answer.
“Charlie Carver? What did you do with him?”
“Nothing. We don’t have him. We never had him. We never would have had him. You’ve come to the wrong people, detective.”
“Have I?” Max got in her face. He’d come back to Charlie later. “Where is Claudette Thodore?”
“I don’t know who she is.”
Max pulled the picture out of his wallet and showed her. She glanced at it for a second.
“She wasn’t one of mine.”
“What do you mean?”
“I didn’t work with her.”
“‘Work with her’? What do you mean?”
“I didn’t groom her.”
“‘Groom her’?”
“Teach her etiquette—table manners—the things you need to know in polite society.”
Max was about to ask her to expand on what she’d said, but Codada gurgled something from the floor.
“He says he’ll talk now,” Paul translated.
“Yeah? Well, I don’t want to listen to him right now. Take him back.”
Vincent dragged Codada out.
Max turned back to Eloise.
“Grooming—go, tell me.”
“You mean you can’t figure it out?” Eloise sniggered.
“Oh, I know what it is,” Max sneered. “I just want to hear it from you.”
“Our clients are all very wealthy men, people who move in high society circles. They like their product to be of a certain standard.”
“Their ‘product’ being these children?”
“Yes. Before selling them we teach them table manners, and the correct way to behave around adults.”
“As in saying ‘please’ and ‘thank you’ when they’re being raped?”
Eloise didn’t answer.
“Answer me.”
“It’s more than just that.” She got defensive.
“Oh?”
“Ill-mannered people get nowhere in life.”
“And you’re what—doing them a favor, teaching them how to hold a knife and fork at some pedophile’s dinner table? Give me a motherfucking break, Eloise!” Max shouted. “Why’d you do it, Eloise? I saw those tapes. I saw what happened to you.”
“You saw, but you didn’t see,” she countered, boring into Max with hard eyes. “You should look again.”
“Why don’t you just fill me in on what I’m missing?”
“Maurice loves me.”
“Bull-shit!” Max spat.
“Why?” she countered calmly. “What did you expect to find? A victim? A helpless, weeping adult-child? Someone right out of your training manual?” She was defiant and angry, her voice falling just outside a shout. Yet, in spite of this, her delivery was completely devoid of passion, as if she had been rehearsing this speech all her life and the words had lost their meaning to her, become a row of audio dots she had to follow until they stopped.
“It’s easy for you to paint us all as innocent, vulnerable little victims, but we’re not all the same. Some of us beat the system. Some of us come out on top.”
“You call this coming out on top?” Max threw his hands around the room. “You’re gonna die and you’re gonna die bad.”
“No one has ever treated me as well as him. Ever. In my whole life. I have no regrets. If I could change anything, I really wouldn’t,” she said calmly.
“Tell me about Maurice. How did he steal you? What was his technique?”
“He didn’t ‘steal me,’” she said impatiently. “He rescued me.”
“Whatever.” Max sighed. “Just tell me how he did it.”
“The first thing I remember about him was his camera—he had a Super 8 then. It covered half his face. I used to see him in the mornings. Me and my friends would wave to him. He’d talk to us, give us things—candy, these little wire figurines he made of us. He paid me the most attention. He made me laugh. My friends were so jealous.” Eloise smiled. “One day he asked me if I wanted to go away with him—go on a trip to a magical place. I said yes. And the next thing I knew, I was sitting next to him in a car. Best decision I ever made.”
Max tried to swallow but his mouth was arid. She was right. She wasn’t what he was expecting. He knew all about Stockholm syndrome, where kidnap victims fall in love with their captors, but he’d never encountered that in a child-abuse case before.
He was deeply confused—and lost and horrified, and the worst part was he couldn’t help himself from showing it, letting her see into him, letting her have the edge on him, the authority.
“But—what about your family?”
She let out a sour laugh, her face rigid, her eyes cold and fixed.
“My family? You mean my ‘apple-pie Mom and Dad,’ like you have in America? Is that what you think when you speak of my ‘family’?”
Max looked at her blankly.
“Well, it wasn’t like that, let me tell you. The little I can remember I’d give anything to forget. Eight to a tiny one-room house, so poor the only thing I had to eat was dirt cake. Do you know what dirt cake is? It’s a little cornmeal and a lot of dirt mixed together with sewer water and left outside to dry into a cake. That’s what I ate every day.”
She stopped and looked at him defiantly, goading him to come back at her with something bigger, to try and net her with some homespun morality.
When she saw he wasn’t going there, something in her changed and became unsure. Then she breathed deeply through her nose, held in the air, closed her eyes, and lowered her head.
She held her breath for well over a minute, her eyeballs squirming back and forth behind her eyelids, her fingers screwing up the corners of her handkerchief, and her lips moving fast but soundlessly, either in prayer or conflict with her conscience. Then, one by one, the neurotic motions timed out: she put the handkerchief down on her lap and rested her hands, palms down. Her lips froze and her eyes rolled to a stop.
Finally, she exhaled through her mouth, opened her eyes, and addressed Max.
“I’ll tell you everything you need to know. I’ll tell you where we keep the children and who we sell them to. I’ll tell you who is involved, and who we work for.”
“Who you work for?”
She opened her eyes and met his.
“You didn’t think Maurice ran this all by himself, did you?” She laughed.
Paul came back in.
“Maurice is many things, but clever isn’t one of them.” She giggled fondly, and then almost immediately flipped into business mode. “I’ll tell you absolutely everything—but on one condition.”
“Try me,” Max said.
“You let Maurice go.”
“What? Absolutely no fucking way!”
“You let Maurice go and I’ll tell you. He was just a cog in a very big wheel. We both were. If you don’t let him go, I won’t talk. You might as well turn your guns on us now.”
“Done,” Paul suddenly interrupted, making Eloise start. “As long as we verify whatever information you give us, I’ll let him go.”
“Give me your word,” Eloise said.
“I give you my word.”
Eloise bowed her head solemnly to indicate they had a deal.
Max didn’t know if he believed Paul would let Codada walk, but he put that to the back of his mind.
Paul put his hand on Max’s shoulder and tapped it, which Max understood as a sign to resume the interrogation.
“Tell me who you’re working for.”
“Can’t you guess?”
“Eloise, you’ve got a deal. We ain’t going to play cat-and-mouse no more. We ain’t going to play clever. I ask you a question, you give me an answer—and you tell me the truth. Simple as that. Understood?”
“Yes.”
“Good. Who are you working for?”
“Gustav Carver,” she said.
“No fucking shit, Eloise!” Max yelled. “I know he’s your fucking boss already! He runs Noah’s Ark. He runs the bank where your motherfucker child-rapist lover works!”
“But you asked who we’re wor—”
“Don’t get fucking cute with me!” Max leaned all the way over to her. “You hold out on me anymore, I swear to God I’m going over and capping Maurice myself.”
“But I’m telling you it’s Gustav Carver! He is our boss. He is behind this. He runs this. He owns this. He started it! He invented it!” Eloise insisted, her voice trembling. “Gustav Carver. It’s him. He’s been doing it for almost forty years. Stealing children, turning them out, selling them for sex. Gustav Carver is Tonton Clarinette.”