AFTER BEZEAL’S DEVASTATING ACCUSATIONS, ARCHER STOOD. He had to make a good impression here. He left the defense table and strode to the witness box. Razz stared at him and shifted uneasily, still perched upon the rail.
“Dreamtreader Keaton.” Chief Justice Michael the Archelion’s expression was an odd combination of curiosity and indignation. “May I ask, what . . . are . . . you . . . doing?”
Archer blinked and found that most everyone in the courtroom was staring at him. “Um, I’m approaching the witness,” Archer said. “I have questions. I think it’s called cross-examination, right? Or—”
“I suppose it would be natural to make such an assumption,” the judge said, “but this court doesn’t work that way. The prosecution has the opportunity to present its full case. Only then may the defense respond.”
If Archer had been back in school talking to a teacher about procedures or some such thing, he might have considered making some kind of polite counterargument. But in the presence of Chief Justice Michael, Archer had seen already this judge was not someone to be trifled with.
“I’m sorry,” Archer said quietly, hurrying to take his seat. “I misunderstood.”
“Thank you, your honor,” Bezeal said. Archer felt like he could hear the sneer in his opponent’s words. The beady-eyed merchant spun on his heel to face the gallery once more. “This is but one case of direct disobedience. There was also the time when Archer, with unmitigated gall, attempted single combat with the Nightmare Lord himself.”
The cylinder screen came to life once more, showing the rampart leading up to No. 6 Rue de La Morte, the Nightmare Lord’s fortress home. And there was Archer somersaulting high over the mounted enemy. Archer’s fiery blue sword flashed as he hewed one of the horns from the Nightmare Lord’s fearsome helm.
“And then,” Bezeal continued, “there was the time Archer refused to take care of the Lucid Walkers, the trespassers to the Dream—even though Archer knew their presence in the Dream caused damage to the fabric. How many times did the Walkers go in and out? That, I cannot say, but this Dreamtreader’s failure to secure the Dream’s borders clearly led to the Rift.”
When Bezeal finished, he had his Cheshire grin cranked up to eleven. He sidled over to the witness stand once more, turned to Razz, and with an arrogant wave of his three-fingered green hand, said, “Witness, you are dismissed.”
Razz crossed her arms and disappeared in a puff of purple smoke and blue sparks. She reappeared next to Archer and whispered heatedly, “I’ll dismiss you, ya little hooded nitwit.”
“Shush, Razz,” Archer warned. “Not now.”
“And so we see, ladies and gentlemen of the jury,” Bezeal addressed the court, “Archer, in direct defiance of his commanding officer, none other than Master Gabriel, the Chief Dreamtreader himself, did travel into Archaia. Against all better judgment, Archer did enter the lair of the Lurker, and he did procure the ancient relic. He placed his own personal ambitions above the expressed command of his superior. This is insubordination in its purest form, repeated often since!”
Bezeal gave the court a long, contemplative pause. Archer felt it: the weight of his own poor choices condemning him. Bezeal was right, in essence, and Archer knew it.
“For my next witness,” Bezeal said, his tone morphing in an instant from triumphant to grim, “I would like to call two former Dreamtreaders. But, alas, I cannot because they are dead.”
The jurors murmured and shifted in their seats. Archer knew what was coming next.
Bezeal waltzed slowly around the courtroom. “Three Dreamtreaders,” he said, “always three, and they are intended to work in concert not against each other. When Archer Keaton was inducted into the Dreamtreader fold, he joined two veteran Dreamtreaders, the seasoned and well-respected Duncan and Mesmeera. This, you’ll note, was during the same time period in which Archer directly disobeyed Master Gabriel. Those events led to this little scene . . .”
Bezeal gestured to the cylindrical screen. The lights dimmed once more. A vast cobblestoned courtyard appeared. On the far side of it, two trees towered, each one occupying its own significant place as if it were an object of great worship. In the foreground, a gigantic hound lay writhing, and Archer dropped to the ground just on the other side.
“Oh, I can’t watch!” Razz squeaked, and then vanished.
Archer didn’t want to watch either, but he couldn’t tear his eyes away. Somehow it felt right to see what he had done; it was the very least he could endure for his wrongs.
The on-screen Archer stood before the first of the two trees, this one similar to a great oak. Fire crackled in Archer’s hands. It seemed to be surging and pulsing . . . growing. The fireballs glowed with increasing ferocity, became great molten globs around Archer’s wrists and hands. Suddenly, Archer screamed and threw up his arms. There was a fearsome red-orange flash. The on-screen Archer was thrown violently backward even as a wall of fire shot forward and engulfed the tree.
In the courtroom, Archer braced himself for what he knew would come next:
The screams.
The agonizing shrieks filled the courtroom. Archer shut his eyes while they endured. He knew all too well the scene that transpired. He’d defeated two more of the colossal hounds, and then torched the second tree in like manner as he had the first. When Archer opened his eyes, the screen went blank. The lights came up.
Bezeal said, “The screams you heard came from Duncan and Mesmeera, Archer’s partners. They were imprisoned within the two trees, yet Archer killed them anyway. He burned Duncan and Mesmeera alive.”
The resulting uproar in the courtroom required four gavel strikes from Chief Justice Michael. When an uncomfortable silence ensued, Bezeal spoke up once more. “The loss of Duncan and Mesmeera is indeed disturbing,” he said, “and while Archer may try and persuade you that he acted in ignorance, I contend there is no excuse for this sort of gross negligence. None of this would have happened if Archer had simply done as Master Gabriel commanded.”
Bezeal again paused, and the horrible truth took its toll on Archer. He was grieved to the point of trembling.
But Bezeal was not finished. “Archer Keaton is guilty of these charges,” he said. “Of that, there can be no doubt. But there is more. And this, perhaps, is the most deplorable of all. A Dreamtreader is sworn to protect the people of the Waking World. He is never to use his powers to harm a human being, especially not one who could not possibly defend himself.”
Bezeal gestured. The room darkened. The screen came alive. There was the medical suite in Rigby’s basement. And there was old Doc Scoville looking frail, sickly, and unconscious. He was hooked up to dozens of machines. The lights in the room blinked, and then Archer was there. He approached Rigby’s uncle and seemed to stare.
Back in the courtroom, Archer remembered the scene all too vividly. He didn’t need Bezeal to narrate, but Bezeal did.
“What you see here,” he said, “is Archer after he had broken into Rigby Thames’s home, and, against Rigby’s expressed wishes, entered this basement laboratory. Why is Archer there you might ask? Why is he doing this?” Bezeal hesitated, leaving the question to hang for several moments, while he strolled to and fro in front of the jury box.
Then, his eyes f lashing, he cried out: “Revenge! Revenge was on Archer’s mind. You see, Rigby Thames had threatened Archer’s little sister. Archer decided he had to take matters into his own hands. Here, watch! Watch as Archer’s hand goes perilously close to that thick black cord—the very cord that supplies the power to keep Doc Scoville alive. He planned to pull that cord, to use attempted murder as a threat against Rigby.”
Archer watched the on-screen Archer reach for the cord, hesitate, and then reach more. The lights in the lab blinked again, and suddenly Doc Scoville was very much awake and standing beside Archer.
Bezeal gestured. The screen went blank. “Fortunately, Doctor Scoville awakened from his catatonic state,” he said. “Just in time to
save his own life. Archer Keaton did not succeed in his murderous plot, but a murderous plot it was. This was premeditated and in complete opposition to the Dreamtreaders’ sacred Creeds.
“Archer Keaton’s actions and thoughts reveal him to be inexperienced, defiant, deceitful, and dangerous . . . for these and many other reasons, you must convict Archer Keaton. The prosecution rests its case.”