Coldcliff Police Station, September 23, 10:16 a.m.
OFFICER OLDMAN: I’ll get right down to it, Thomas. That’s your real name, right? Thomas Becker Rutherford III.
BECK: Nobody calls me that.
OFFICER OLDMAN: We had a warrant to search your phone. You weren’t exactly forthcoming when we asked you if you’d been in contact with Tabitha. There was a flurry of calls made from her to you right around Christmas. Then again a few months later. And over the summer. She hadn’t lost your number.
BECK: So she called me. I don’t see what the big deal is.
OFFICER OLDMAN: The big deal is you picked up. You must have talked about something.
BECK: I told her to stop calling. She did that sometimes. Just wanted to talk. Maybe there was nobody else who would listen.
OFFICER OLDMAN: Did she tell you she was upset with Mark?
BECK: No, because we didn’t talk about him.
OFFICER OLDMAN: Did she want anything from you? When she called? She must have wanted something, if she kept calling.
BECK: Sometimes she’d want to be picked up from a party. She knew I wouldn’t judge.
OFFICER OLDMAN: Judge what?
BECK: Her. For being wasted. Or whatever.
OFFICER OLDMAN: Tabitha drank a lot.
BECK: So do most people at parties.
OFFICER OLDMAN: You picked her up, then. On your motorcycle.
BECK: Yeah.
OFFICER OLDMAN: And what did you talk about, on those rides? Where did you go?
BECK: It was too loud to hear anything. You ever been on a bike before? Can’t hear much, besides the road. I’d drop her at home. Well, a block away, then I’d watch to make sure she got inside okay.
OFFICER OLDMAN: Why not walk her to her door?
BECK: Her folks didn’t like me much.
OFFICER OLDMAN: Why not?
BECK: Do you have a daughter?
OFFICER OLDMAN: Answer the question, please.
BECK: Maybe it wasn’t that they didn’t like me. They just didn’t know me.
OFFICER OLDMAN: Do you feel like a lot of people don’t know you?
BECK: Are you a cop, or a shrink now, too?
OFFICER OLDMAN: (clears throat) Those nights you drove Tabitha home. You never went to Queen Anne’s Woods?
BECK: No. Why would we?
OFFICER OLDMAN: If you and Tabitha—(pauses, is interrupted by another officer coming in) One moment, Thomas. I’ll be back shortly.
BECK: My name’s not Thomas.