Appendix about Postures of Reference

I will now describe a few static positions, used by numerous body psychotherapists as references or positions to use by default. They are compatible with the requirements of orthopedics, physical therapy, and hatha yoga. It is usually asked of the person who is using these postures that he maintains the natural curvature of spine. This requires a tonic balance between the muscular chains that structure the front and back of the body. These are all ideal postures that are promoted by experts.

Some may need to consult a book on anatomy or an online search engine for definitions and illustrations. I do not know of a book that contains all of these notions.

ALIGNMENT OF THE BODY SEGMENTS WHEN A PERSON IS STANDING

The Reading of the Position with
the Plumb-Line Method

The physical therapists often evaluate a static standing posture with the plumb-line method (see figure A.l).1 They ask an individual to stand as straight as possible, knees unlocked, with the nape of the neck elongated. The feet are parallel or in the shape of a V (heels touching). In this posture, all of the muscles that permit this stretching (feet, legs, pelvis, back, nape of the neck, cranium, abdominal muscles, etc.) must be toned but not tense. The muscle tone in the front and in the back of the body is in balance. If the required muscle tone is present, and there is no skeletal deviation, the body segments align themselves automatically to provide the best possible balance. Ensuring a minimum of tension in the muscular system in all of the muscles is the criterion.2

Image

FIGURE A.1. Reading of the posture using the “plumb line” method. (A) An ideal vertical standing position; (B) a restful standing position; (C) a standing-at-attention position. Source: Bonnett and Millet (1971, p. 695).

This ideal alignment places the ear, shoulder, pelvis, and middle of the foot on the same axis. A plumb-line that is held up to the side of the body from the profile ought to pass in front of the ear, the shoulder, the articulation of the pelvis, and arrive somewhat in front of the ankle. With practice, the physical therapist abandons the use of the plumb-line, because he has learned to analyze the alignment of the body as if there were a plumb-line. He will mostly use this device so that patients can learn to analyze their alignment when they are standing in front of a mirror.

Most Europeans are aligned toward the back: the plumb-line passes in front of the pelvis, shoulders, and ears. If you place these individuals in an ideal vertical standing position, they generally have the impression of leaning forward; they are afraid of falling. Yet if you test their balance by lightly pushing the chest backward, or the shoulder blades forward, they discover that they are more solidly anchored to the ground in this position. We thus notice that to align an individual also requires a reeducation of bodily sensations.

The “Inner” Axis

The Hindus and the Egyptians of old were already marvelous architects and had mastered geometry. They used the plumb-line to construct their homes. They imagined that the body balanced itself around an invisible axis that passes through the body’s center of gravity while standing. This center is situated in the middle of the abdomen, under the navel (a bit lower for a woman because, on average, her pelvis is heavier than a man’s). For the standing position, it therefore consists in aligning the perineum, the belly, and the fontanel, as if a perfectly vertical axis traversed the middle of all these body segments, and planted itself into the ground in between the soles of the feet. This imaginary axis of the vertical body that passes through the body’s center of gravity is referred to by the body specialists of almost all cultures, from yoga up to the theories used by the whirling dervishes of Turkey. We encounter this metaphor in several schools of dance that teach the necessity of sensing in oneself an axis that stretches out, in psychomotor schools of scientific inspiration, and in most schools of body-mind aproaches.3 For example, we ask some people to stand up, eyes closed, and imagine roots coming out of their feet and reaching deep into the earth. To regulate the position of the head, it is often suggested to imagine that a thread ties the fontanel to a star above the fontanel, and this thread tugs in such a way as to elongate the nape of the neck and the spine between the shoulder blades, which induces a lowering of the external part of the clavicles.4 Ideally, the clavicles form a straight line. It often happens, when we take a workshop in bodywork, that the instructors suggest that you feel your feet getting heavy around the axis and your head rising toward the star you were asked to imagine.

In this kind of work, it is often asked of the individual carrying out the exercise to sense the lateral distribution of body weight on the soles of the feet. Does the right or left foot carry more of the weight? Is the weight more on the inside or the outside of the feet? In both cases, it is the balance between the feet that is sought, with a weight that anchors itself at the center of each foot.

The Basic Bioenergetic Grounding Position:
Standing with Knees Flexed

With his colleagues, Alexander Lowen established a series of postures that allowed patients to increase their awareness of a series of connections between impressions, breathing and postures (Lowen and Lowen, 1977). The posture that is most often used is called “grounding” (see figure A.2). It was already used in the Chinese martial arts, but Lowen works with it in his own fashion. The basic bioenergetic position is described as follows:

Image

FIGURE A.2. The basic grounding position in bioenergetics.

 

  1. The individual is standing.
  2. Each foot is beneath the corresponding shoulder. The feet are parallel. Sometimes Lowen requests that the toes point slightly toward each other to increase muscular tension. The weight of the body is halfway between the toes and the ankle, the body’s center of gravity is above the space between the feet, in the middle of the right-left axis. To feel the dimension of grounding that Lowen relates to this position, the person who takes up this position is often asked to imagine that roots are coming out of the soles of his feet, travel through everything that separates the feet from the earth, and then sink into the earth.
  3. The knees are bent at about 135°.5
  4. Feet, pelvis, shoulders, and ears aligned according the rule of the plumb-line.
  5. The pelvis is in an orthopedic position. Lowen often asks that the individual move the pelvis forward and backward until he finds the most relaxed position. This movement is often done in coordination with respiration (the lower back is straight in exhaling and arched in inhaling). This position can be taken only if the groin (the junction between the front of the top of the thighs and the lower abdomen, around the genitals) forms a furrow. The mobility of the groin is always an interesting place to work. An image that is currently proposed by some teachers of tai chi chuan and by Lowen is that of the tail of a kangaroo. The virtual tail that extends beyond the coccyx reaches the space between the heels. The individual imagines being able to sit on this tail.
  6. The arms are relaxed.
  7. The bioenergetic therapists use all of the rules described in the preceding sections.

By default, Lowen asks the patient to be as relaxed as possible, let go of his breathing, and breathe with an open mouth. Breathing through the mouth encourages the advent of vegetative reactions and emotional expressions. Breathing from the nose is a way to diminish these reactions when it is necessary. In tai chi chuan, it is often recommended to breathe in from the nose and to breathe out by the mouth.

SITTING PROPERLY ON THE ISCHIA

There are two basic criteria to characterize sitting:

 

  1. From an orthopedic point of view, one can sit in more or less healthy ways. For example, crossing one’s legs is bad for one’s health because it inhibits the venous circulation in the legs.
  2. Sitting is more or less comfortable. Two criteria measure the comfort: (a) a subjective feeling; (b) the time that a person sits before moving. The longer the time spent in the position, the more comfortable the position.

From an orthopedic point of view, there is only one way to sit. It is roughly the one that is automatically set in place by a person who sits comfortably in a lotus position: the person is sitting on the ground, the right foot high up on top of the left thigh, the left foot high up on top of the right thigh, in such a way the heel of the right foot is near the navel.6

The physical therapist7 typically proposes that an individual sit on a horizontal seat, a bit higher than the knees. The “correct” position of the pelvis is to imagine that the base of the pelvis is a three-legged stool that supports the weight of the upper body. The two “back feet” are the ischia, and the third is an imaginary extension of the perineum when it is as close as possible to the seat. The dorsal face of the pelvis8 is roughly at a 90° angle to the support surface. The two bones of the pelvis that frame the lower abdomen and the genital region are leaning slightly forward.9 This position of the pelvis is the best possible base to sustain the flexibility of the spinal column when someone is sitting, and it does not block any ongoing respiratory movements. Furthermore, the vertical position of the hip bone supports the uprightness of the lower back and imposes the necessary curvature. This position also tones up the rectus and obliquus abdominal muscles—just what is needed.

In Europe, many people have difficulty staying in this position for any length of time. In talking with them about their discomfort, it is possible to obtain a lot of information pertaining to their habits and muscular tension. It is sometime useful to recommend an approach to reeducate the relevant muscles and sensory-motor circuits (hatha yoga, the Mathias Alexander technique, Feldenkrais schools, Rolfing, etc.).

THE BASIC REICHIAN POSTURE: LYING ON ONE’S BACK

Going from psychoanalysis to body psychotherapy, Reich kept one constant variable: the patient is, more often than not, lying down on his back on a couch. Yet the therapist is now sitting next to the patient and even sometimes invites a visual contact.

When I speak of the basic Reichian posture (see Figure A.3), I refer to the following position:

 

  1. The patient is stretched out on his back.
  2. The patient has bent his legs so that the feet are flat on the support surface.
  3. The insides of the legs and feet do not touch.
  4. The feet are parallel and separated almost the width of the shoulders.
  5. The “correct” distance between the feet and the pelvis is determined in this way: ask the individual lying down to lift and drop the pelvis several times. A proper placement of the feet is the one that facilitates this movement; an improper one inhibits this movement.
  6. The position does not aim at comfort. It even seeks to render the tensions of the body perceptible to the patient and the therapist. A dialogue on the location of these tensions is sought. Therefore, the therapist does not immediately ask the patient if he wants a cushion or invite him to choose the position he wants. The slight gap between the legs and the parallel position of the feet may make the tensions on the inside of the thighs more tangible. Reich relates these tensions to the fear of sexual pleasure.

I have not found any text in which Reich describes this position. I have reconstructed it from discussions with individuals who worked with Ola Raknes (e.g., Gerda Boyesen, Bjørn Blumenthal), and with Eva Reich. This posture is also compatible with all of the cases described since 1933. This was Reich’s default position; he sometimes observed someone standing or conversed with a patient who was sitting down.

Image

FIGURE A.3. The basic vegetotherapy position.