1 The Road Back to Blackstone: An Overview of the Argument
Model 1: A Substantive Double Jeopardy Clause
Model 2: A Partly Substantive Double Jeopardy Clause
Model 3: A Procedural/Derivative Double Jeopardy Clause
The Court’s View of Legislative Prerogative
Applying Blackstone and the Three Models
Criminal Law Offense Definitions
2 Double Jeopardy Policy and History
Double Jeopardy Paradigm and Policies
Traditional Understanding of Double Jeopardy Policy
The Brief, Unhappy Life of Grady v. Corbin
Double Jeopardy Unity: Rejecting Greater Protection against Successive Prosecutions
An Alternative Double Jeopardy Policy
A Double Jeopardy Principle and Two Presumptions
A Presumption about the End of Jeopardy
A Presumption about “Same Offense”
Double Jeopardy Evolution to 1792
Double Jeopardy Law before Henry II
Henry II and Fraudulent Acquittals
Post–Henry II Statutory Changes
3 Standard Double Jeopardy Approaches
Early Definitions of Same Offense
The Supreme Court’s View of Legislative Intent
Legislative Intent on the End of Jeopardy
Legislative Intent on Same Offense
Double Jeopardy Reform Proposals
4 “Life or Limb” Blameworthiness
The Language of the Double Jeopardy Clause
The Court’s Pre-Hudson “Criminal Punishment” Doctrine
The Civil/Criminal Issue in Broader Context
5 Singular/Distinct Blameworthiness
A Basic Account of Blameworthiness
Action Theory: Act-Types and Act-Tokens
Alternative versus Distinct Blameworthiness
Defining Act-Token Separateness
The Relationship of Act-Tokens to Harms
Counting Act-Tokens: The Act-Type Scope Issue
Counting Act-Tokens: Consuming Blameworthiness
Single Act-Token Blameworthiness
A Procedural Defense of Chapter 5
6 Bringing Coherence to Same-Offense Doctrine
A Summary of Blockburger’s Failure
A Legislative-Prerogative, Blameworthy-Act Alternative to Blockburger
Dual-Sovereignty Same-Offense Presumptions
Rebutting Same-Offense Presumptions
Same-Offense Presumptions Summarized
7 Unifying Same-Offense Theory: A Blameworthiness Test of Collateral Estoppel
Collateral Estoppel Civil/Criminal Blameworthiness
Rethinking Collateral Estoppel
8 Second Jeopardies: A Fresh Look at Blackstone’s Solution
Formal Verdicts as the End of Jeopardy
Convictions Reversed on Appeal
Overview of Acquittal Equivalence
Paradigm Acquittal Equivalence: Dismissals and Appellate Reversals That Resolve Blameworthiness
Acquittal Equivalence in Mistrials
Prosecution-Requested Mistrials
Counterfactual Acquittal Equivalence
Hung-Jury Acquittal Equivalence
Mistrials That Are Not Acquittal Equivalents
9 The Role of Legislative Intent in Determining the End of Jeopardy
Blameworthiness and State Appeals
Pre-Palko Treatment of Acquittals
Current Status of the Legislative Role
When State Appeals Are Authorized