I took the liberty of letting the owner order for us,” Hayden said. “This place has the best tapas.”
Rachel nodded, trying not to seem too distracted. She left the phone on vibrate and willed it to sound. David had been gone for far too long. The fear that he’d been captured—or worse—hardened in her chest. She pushed it away and looked into Hayden’s green eyes. He wore the idle-rich uniform of khaki pants and blue blazer with some kind of crest on the chest. His hair had thinned and was now plastered against his skull. He was still handsome, still boyish, but there was more softness now. His jowls sagged a bit. His complexion had grown ruddier. Hayden was, she thought, transforming into one of those old family portraits they kept at the Payne Museum.
They exchanged pleasantries. Hayden commented on her new hairstyle. He claimed to like it, but that didn’t feel like the truth. She’d told him about her divorce in an email, so they didn’t have to cover that. Hayden had discovered a few years ago that he had a son via a B-movie Italian actress he dated a few years back—a boy named Theo—and was now helping to raise and support him. Hayden had spent most of the last decade overseas, purportedly watching over the family’s European interests, but mostly Rachel figured that he was skiing in St. Moritz and partying on the French Riviera.
Maybe that wasn’t fair.
When they moved on to the story that destroyed her journalism career, Hayden said, “Going after your old enemy.”
“I pushed too hard.”
“Understandable.”
“I know I should have told you…”
He waved it away. Hayden had been there, all those years ago, the night of the Halloween party at Lemhall University during their freshman year. They had, in fact, met that night by the beer keg. They flirted a bit. She knew who Hayden Payne was—everyone on campus knew the scions of wealthy families—and so it had been fun. Hayden had been charming and sweet, but for Rachel, no sparks commenced.
She dressed as Morticia Addams, and she probably drank too much. But that wasn’t the issue. She’d been roofied, she’d later learn, and somewhere, maybe two hours after she met Hayden, her night derailed like a runaway train. She felt stupid, even now, falling for not watching her drink closely after all the warnings.
There was a young humanities professor named Evan Tyler, whose mother was on the board of trustees. He was the one who slipped the drug into her drink. The rest of the night was a blur. She had vague recollections, visions that she saw through internal gauze—her clothes being torn off, his curly hair, his mouth on hers. She could feel the weight of Evan Tyler on top of her, crushing her, suffocating her. Rachel had tried to say no, tried to scream for help, tried to push him away.
That was the image that ended up seared into her brain. Evan Tyler. On top of her. Grinning with maniacal glee. The image still visited her in her sleep, of course, but it popped up when she was awake too, an awful jack-in-the-box, startling her whenever she felt relaxed and at ease. Even now. Even after all the years, that image—that maniacal grin—was always with her, walking a few steps behind her, taunting her, sometimes tapping her on the shoulder when she felt any confidence. It followed Rachel day and night for days, months, years, fueling her anger, urging her to work harder and harder, to do the story, to seek justice, to smother that awful maniacal grin, to pressure everyone and anyone, including Catherine Tullo…
But right then, on this horrible Halloween Night, when she couldn’t breathe, when it might have ended up even worse for her—or maybe, who knows, she would have passed out and forgotten it all—Evan Tyler suddenly vanished from atop her.
The weight was gone from her chest. Just like that. Poof, gone.
Someone had tackled him.
Rachel tried to sit up, but the brain impulses still couldn’t reach the muscles. She just lay there, her head lolling to the side, where she heard Hayden let out a primal scream. Then Hayden punched Tyler and then punched him again and then again. His fists just flew, spraying blood across the room. There was no tiring, no letup, and Rachel was sure that Evan Tyler would have been killed if two other guys hadn’t heard the commotion, burst into the room, and pulled a bloodied Hayden off him.
Evan Tyler was comatose for the next two weeks.
Rachel still wanted to press charges, especially after she heard that she had not been Tyler’s first victim, but the school wanted it swept under the rug. Tyler was in a coma, after all, with facial fractures that would take months to heal. Hadn’t he suffered enough? His mother was an important woman. Did Rachel really also want to drag the school through the dirt? What was the point in that?
Rachel didn’t care about any of that.
She did, however, care about Hayden.
That was the issue. The beating had gone well beyond the act of stopping a crime, and while the Payne fortune would certainly assure a soft landing, Hayden’s family wanted it kept quiet for all the obvious reasons. So that was how it went. Deals were made. Money might have exchanged hands.
Swept away for the greater good. Over. Onward.
Except for those images of Evan Tyler, who would later become president of the college, seared into her brain.
As for Rachel and Hayden, they became close friends. That, she realized, happened often when you are bonded in either tragedy or a secret—or in their case, both.
When David and Cheryl met Hayden during a visit to Lemhall University, David pulled Rachel aside and said, “That guy’s in love with you.”
“No, he’s not.”
“He may be settling for the Friend Zone,” David said. “But you know better.”
She did, but that seemed to be the origin story of ninety percent of boy-girl friendships on campus in those days. The guy likes you, wants to sleep with you, doesn’t get to, settles on being a friend, the tension goes away. Either way, she and Hayden became close confidantes—the kind of close confidantes where you could never really date after all you knew, even if you wanted to.
The waiter came over with a plate. He placed it between them. “Lobster paella,” he said.
Hayden smiled at him. “Thank you, Ken.”
It smelled wonderful.
He picked up his fork. “Wait until you taste this.”
“I didn’t call you about Lemhall or that story,” she said.
“Oh?”
“Do you know if there was a Payne Industries event on May twenty-seventh at Six Flags amusement park?”
He frowned. Hayden still wore the Lemhall University ring, a tacky thing with a purple stone and the school crest, and she never understood why. He was, in fact, fiddling with it now, turning it around his finger like it was some sort of stress reliever. Perhaps it was. Still, the ring seemed too much to her. She wanted to forget the place. She guessed that for some reason he needed to remember.
“May twenty-seventh?” he repeated. “I really don’t know. Why?”
She took out her phone, swiped, showed him a photo of a family standing in front of the backdrop with logos. Hayden took the phone from her hand and studied it.
“I guess there was,” Hayden said. He handed her back the phone. “Why do you ask?”
“It would have been, what, a corporate event?”
“Probably. We buy a bunch of tickets to a theater or a ballpark or an amusement park. It’s a perk for employees and clients. Is this for a story you’re doing?”
She pressed on. “You’d have had photographers on hand, right?”
“I assume so.”
“I mean, like this photo in front of that backdrop. A photographer you guys hired probably took pics like this?”
“Again: I assume so. What the hell is this about, Rachel?”
“Can you get me all the photos?”
Hayden’s eyes flared for a millisecond. “Pardon?”
“I need to go through them.”
“Corporate events like this,” he began, “we sometimes rent half the park. There could have been, I don’t know, five, ten thousand people at it. What are you looking for?”
“You won’t believe me if I told you.”
“Tell me anyway.” Then Hayden added, “I assume this has something to do with your brother-in-law escaping prison.”
“It does.”
“You can’t still have a crush on him, Rachel.”
“What, I never had a crush on David.”
“You talked about him nonstop.”
“You almost sound jealous, Hayden.”
He smiled. “Perhaps I was.”
This was a minefield she didn’t want to wander into. “Do you trust me?” she asked him.
“You know I do.”
“Can you get me the pics?”
He picked up the water glass, took a sip. “Yes.”
“Thank you.”
“So what else?” he asked.
She knew him well. “This favor is trickier.”
The waiter came over with a second dish. “Jamon Iberico with caviar.”
Hayden smiled at him. “Thank you, Ken.”
“Enjoy.”
“You’re going to love these,” Hayden said. He scooped some of the paella onto her plate. It smelled fantastic, but Rachel ignored it for the moment. Hayden took a bite, closed his eyes as though savoring. When he opened them again, he said, “So what’s the favor?”
“One of the logos on that backdrop,” Rachel said, “is for the Berg Reproductive Institute.”
“Makes sense,” Hayden says. “It’s one of our holdings. You know that.”
“I do.”
“So?”
“So ten years ago, I made an appointment at one.”
Hayden stopped midbite. “Pardon?”
“I called Barb.” Barb Matteson was the institute’s manager at the time. “You introduced us.”
“I remember. At the family holiday party.”
“Right.”
“I don’t understand.” Hayden put the fork down. “Why did you make an appointment?”
“I told her I wanted to look into getting pregnant via donor sperm.”
“Are you serious?”
“About making the appointment? Yes. About going through with it? No.”
“I’m not following, Rachel.”
“I made the appointment for Cheryl.”
“Okay,” he said slowly. Then: “I’m still not following.”
“She didn’t want David to know.”
“Ah.”
“Right.”
“So Cheryl made the appointment in your name so her husband wouldn’t find out?”
“Exactly.”
Hayden tilted his head. “You realize that’s probably against the law.”
“It’s not, but I know it’s an ethical breach. Anyway, Rachel checked in under my name. She used my ID. We look enough alike. The bills came to my house.”
“Okay,” he said slowly.
“I even made the appointment for Cheryl at your satellite office in Lowell—in case Barb was around at the Boston one.”
“All to protect your sister from telling her husband?”
“Yes.”
“Interesting,” he said.
“She was going through some stuff. I thought it would be harmless.”
“Doesn’t sound harmless,” Hayden said. “Did David ever find out?”
“Yes.”
“He must have been furious with you.”
“He doesn’t know about my part in it.”
“But he knows Cheryl went to look into donor sperm.”
“Yes.”
“And you never told him your role in this—shall I use the word ‘deception’?”
“I never told him,” Rachel said softly.
The waiter came by and poured some wine. When he left, Hayden asked, “So what do you want now?”
“David doesn’t think it’s a coincidence.”
“Doesn’t think what’s a coincidence?”
“You’re going to think this is insane.”
“We’re past that, Rachel.”
“He thinks…that is, we think…” It sounded so ridiculous that for a moment, Rachel couldn’t finish the thought. Then: “We think Matthew was at the amusement park with your group.”
Hayden rapid-blinked as though he’d been smacked across the face. Then he cleared his throat and asked, “Who is Matthew?”
“My nephew,” she said. “David’s son.”
More blinking. “The one he murdered?”
“That’s the point. We don’t think he’s dead at all.”
Rachel handed Hayden the phone again, this time with the photograph of Maybe-Matthew. “The boy in the background. The one holding the hand.”
Hayden took the phone and held it in front of his face. He used his fingers to try to blow up the image. She waited. He squinted. “It’s so blurry.”
“I know.”
“You can’t really think—”
“I’m not sure.”
He frowned. “Rachel.”
“I know. It’s crazy. It’s all crazy.”
Hayden shook his head. He handed the phone back to her as though it were on fire. “I don’t know what you want me to do here.”
“Can you send me all the pics from Six Flags?”
“Why?”
“So we can scour through them.”
“And what would you be looking for?”
“Any other photos of this boy.”
He shook his head. “This blurry boy who looks like a million other boys?”
“I don’t expect you to understand.”
“You’re right about that.”
“But for my sake, Hayden. Please? Will you help?”
Hayden sighed. Then he said, “Yes, of course.”