If the Shoe Fits1

Will your high hopes get you there

Goal so far and yet so near

You can’t ignore the writing on the wall

Every time you rise you fall

End’s nowhere in sight at all

Why should you pick it up and try again

Chorus:

Give it up, ’cause you can’t win

Let it go while you still can

Gave it all you had, now you’re feelin’ bad

So you’re gone, ready to roam

You come on so strong with that same sad song

Wherever you go

Run along, take your ball and go home2

Promised yet another chance

Forbidden just a single glance

So much rides on what you say and do

Discarded truths and famous myths

Tales that life deceives you with

Certain things you always thought you knew

(Chorus)

Helpful hands that pull you down

Smaller minds turn you around

Friends in need are never really true3

So why should you put trust in this

The bridge above the dark abyss

You never learned you can’t make all the rules

(Chorus)

Run along, take your ball and go home

Take a hike, we ain’t got all night

Take your ball, get out my house, go home

Words by Andrew Charles

Music by Phil Lesh

1 If the shoe fits

The proverb from which the song takes its title is characterized as follows:

If something belongs or pertains to you, accept it. This proverb first appeared as “if the cap fits,” which may have referred to a fool’s cap. The later version has become more common and is associated with the glass slipper in the fairy tale “Cinderella.” (Hirsch)

2 take your ball and go home

A cliché of indeterminate origin that’s often but not always used in an athletic context.

3 Friends in need are never really true

A play on the saying “A friend in need is a friend indeed.”

Notes:

No official recording.

First performance: June 9, 1994, at Cal Expo Amphitheater in Sacramento, California.

Andrew Charles is a self-taught musician born and raised on the island of Barbados, the West Indies. After moving to the Bay Area in 1993, he played with several local Caribbean bands and then expanded his musical talent to songwriting. Jill Lesh introduced Phil to Andrew. Phil listened to a few songs and asked if he could play around with “If the Shoe Fits,” which was originally titled “Give It Up.”