It made her wonder what the other men’s answers would have been if she and Sidney had approached them together. Or maybe that wouldn’t have made any difference in the world.
At the moment, however, it was impossible for Jerry to give any sort of answer to the question they had proposed minutes earlier. That was because Sidney was bouncing up and down on Jerry’s cock while Carly was sitting on his face. She liked how his tongue danced over her clit, then explored the depth of her pussy, then licked her perineum before wandering all the way back to her asshole where it teased her just a little. That made her tense up, but in a delightful way.
But Carly wasn’t able to fully concentrate on Jerry’s tongue. That was because of Sidney’s mouth and fingers. Sidney could multitask easily. She was able to ride his cock while nursing from Carly’s tits, pinching the one her mouth wasn’t on. The two women, by mutual and silent agreement, had mounted Jerry facing each other.
“Oh…oh yes, oh please yes!” Carly burst out. Seeing her girlfriend on the brink of orgasm, Sidney pulled her mouth off Carly’s nipple and then pinched both of the bright pink buds hard, twisting them at the same time. Carly screamed. Sidney pulled her hands away and allowed Carly’s nipple to spout milk that splashed on Sidney’s tits and fell down to Jerry’s body.
“I love watching you cum,” said Sidney, stealing a kiss from Carly.
“I’m…I’m…I’m not sure if…if…if it was you or his tongue,” Carly panted.
“Why not both?”
“Oh fuck!” Carly cried out again as she all but vibrated on Jerry’s cock. Sidney was caressing her tits again so that helped as well. She was getting to the point where it was very easy to make her cum with just a little application of the right stimulation.
She didn’t care who made her cum a second time. It didn’t matter.
“I…I…I want to make you cum,” Carly told Sidney.
But her girlfriend wasn’t paying attention. She had one hand on Carly’s shoulder while she held herself still as Jerry slammed his cock upwards into her. Carly reached down and touched Sid’s clit just as Jerry was cumming. His spunk was forced out of Sid’s pussy by gravity and the vigor of his thrusts.
For all his endurance, Jerry wasn’t superhuman. He used his arms to force Carly off his face. When she fell to the side of the bed, he breathed in deeply.
“Fuck that was good. I know we’re all going to go eventually, but being smothered to death by pussy doesn’t sound like a bad way to go.”
Sidney laughed and leaned down to kiss him, encouraged, perhaps, by the smears of amrita Carly had left behind on his face.
“You say the sweetest things.”
“Is that what it’s going to be like?” he asked.
“What what is going to be like?” replied Carly, slightly worried at the intimate scene between the other two.
“Being the third in your trio,” Jerry answered. “I mean, it’s probably perfect for me, because I’m never around one place very long and I don’t see myself ever getting married. Hell, Sid, this is the longest serious relationship I’ve ever had with anyone, and it’s not terribly serious, is it?”
Sidney frowned. “Are you saying yes…or are you saying that you aren’t man enough to take on two women at once?”
“I’m more than man enough, but how long can I keep this up for?”
“Just until Carly gets pregnant,” Sidney teased.
He glanced back and forth between the two women. “Then we’ll have to switch positions. I’m pretty sure I came in the wrong pussy if Carly wants to get knocked up.”
Jerry stuck around a while longer. Sidney was gracious enough to give him a blowjob so he could get hard again. She then watched as Carly and he got into the classic doggy style position while he fucked her. When he was done, he left.
Carly was frankly glad that she was left alone with Sidney. Jerry was great and all, and maybe he would be the perfect addition to their trio, but she liked her time alone with her girlfriend.
She couldn’t admit that out loud.
“Which of us do you think is going to get pregnant first,” asked Sidney as they settled down together in the bed. It still smelled vaguely of Jerry’s body, but that was fine with Carly. She liked a little masculinity in her bed.
Maybe she’d ask Sid to put on a strapon dildo and fuck her raw tomorrow.
“Probably me.”
“What makes you think that?”
“Because you want to get pregnant so that means I’ll be the one to get knocked up first. Didn’t you pay attention in high school health class? You know, the two days they spent on sex ed?”
“Do you want to get pregnant?” asked Carly.
“No.”
“Then use birth control.”
“I don’t want to lose my milk.”
“Oh. That.”
“Yeah. Oh. That. The only reason the two of us are together.”
“Hey!” Carly objected. “We aren’t together just because of our milk.”
Sidney gave her the eye. “Really? Are you so sure about that?”
“I’d blame the alcohol first.”
“Really? The alcohol?”
Carly kissed Sidney. “Yeah. The alcohol. And your bisexuality. And my…whatever.”
“Let’s call it your unrelenting sexual curiosity.”
“Sure. Let’s not. And after all that…then the milk.”
“I love nursing from you.”
“Thanks. “
Sidney waited expectantly. “Well?”
“Well what?” asked Carly.
“This is where you’re supposed to say you love nursing from my tits.”
“I do,” said Carly. “But I’m still jealous of them. I’m probably the only woman in the world who has incredible milk production, but small boobs.”
“We can get you implants.”
“No.”
“Then what do you want?”
Carly gave that a moment’s thought. “I want…I want…I want your tits.” She rolled over on top of her girlfriend and gave her a kiss.
But she didn’t stop there. She kissed her way down to Sidney’s big breasts and took a nipple between her lips.
Sidney groaned. “You’re such a tease. And a horny little girl. But after Jerry’s big cock…I don’t have anything else in me tonight.”
She was right. Mostly. Carly got only the slightest taste of Sid’s sweet milk. She never had much milk anyway, but that was fine. She wasn’t there to have a feast on Sidney’s breasts. She wanted more.
Staying on hands and knees, she moved her small body, forcing Sidney to move as well. Their bed wasn’t big enough, but once they had Jerry wrapped around their fingers—or nipples—they could get a bigger bed and they’d be able to do all sorts of things that were wrong but felt so wonderful.
Eventually she and Sidney were laying crossways on the queen sized bed. Then Carly dangled her tits in Sidney’s face. Sid knew what to do. She found Carly’s nipple and got to work.
Right away Carly’s milk let down. She always had more milk. Her tits were amazing. Sidney started nursing happily.
Carly ducked her head and found the large nipple that topped Sidney’s big mounds. There wasn’t much milk. But there was enough. There was always enough.
Because there was always more.
END