This Kreutzer is a good dear fellow who gave me much enjoyment when he was here—his modesty and his natural ways appeal to me much more than all the exterieur or inferieur of most virtuosos. Since the Sonata was written for a competent violinist, the dedication to him is all the more appropriate.
—Beethoven to Nikolaus Simrock, Bonn, October 14, 1804
Beethoven does not understand the violin.
—Rudolphe Kreutzer
Not much left to do
but pay your respects
—bow, genuflect?—
to the ochre façades of a city
you’d wanted to conquer . . .
no, make that seduce.
Well, what of it? Turns out
the Grand Old Man
has a temper, plus some
addled idea of honor
that overblown barmaid
wouldn’t have known
what to do with
if it had slapped her
on her extraordinary ass.
Vorsicht: Forget
the Dirndl. She’s a picked bone.
And hadn’t the Old Fart
leapt up from the keyboard
to embrace you
in front of everyone?
Mein lieber Bursch,
everyone listening, isn’t that
what he had called you?
Time to leave
this tiered confection
of a city, this coquette
who pretends to sip
then slings the rest away,
who has spit you out
like coffee dregs. . . .
Why, they’re quit of me—
they’ve rinsed the cup.
As if on cue,
it begins to rain.
Vienna, June 1803
Silver ribbons stripped loose from their implacable
eyelets, fingers stuttering through muffled lace,
skittering from the keyboard in disgrace.
Whimpered accompaniment to a tongued nipple.
Cascade-glimmer of a chromatic scale.
Tiny bone clack against porcelain, roast squab
or dove dripping from china plates; a sweating pail
of ice, kicked over by a horse. Ach, to be robbed
in one’s sleep, robbed between a sip and a laugh!
(Because we’re wading through wreckage, we’re
not even listening to all the crash and clatter—
chords wrenched from their moorings, smashed
etudes, arpeggios glistening as they heave and sink.)
Ciphers, the lot of them. Their money, their perfumed stink.
Then he saith, I will return into my house from whence I came out;
and when he is come, he findeth it empty, swept, and garnished.
—Matthew 12:44
1.
What remains? Not much.
Gilt, and columns he recognizes
as Ionic, cool shafts of white cloud
peeling now, the dark oak rotting
beneath.
(To a boy it was
sheer phantasmagoria,
mystery’s faint perfume;
glimmering gowns, fans set aflutter
by invisible feminine engines,
and the chimney sweep surveying us
from his corner, quiet watchfulness
under a hooded eye.
I saw the gridwork of power
and thought it was Delight.)
Esterháza, the Hungarian Versailles.
2.
Heat, of course. It grew a steady crop of dulling
from May until Guy Fawkes embers cooled;
not pleasant, a heat that declared
Enemy and a foreign occupation in invisible march
sweeping bats up from the hay bales
on the road to Széplak,
a black lace unfurling
against the molten scrim
of day’s end . . .
(The puppet theater was my favorite
hiding place, dark and glimmering,
a cave inside
a treasure chest. I sang to myself.
It was like being buried in jewels.)
3.
Silence where once there were ceaseless
operas, banquets, shooting parties;
fancy-dress balls at the end of which
the aristocracy would repair to assorted terraces
to watch the domestics and villagers
treated to food and drink.
Along the roadside
booths, magicians:
To observe common folk
in their Sunday Best
considered the culmination
of festivities, a welcome
“amusement.”
4.
Steps chipped and sagging where the revelers climbed them.
The footmen in maroon, gloved, bowing.
What a majestic blood bath,
complete with epaulets
adrift in golden froth!
(on the road
dwarf Johann,
weeping,
tiny
under his bulging pack)
5.
Barbiere di Siviglia.
Paisiello’s L’amor contrastato.
Cimarosa’s Il credulo and L’impresario in angustie.
Thwarted Love. The Dupe.
The Manager in Distress.
Who needs a fortune-teller
when there’s a libretto around?
6.
My life in title pages (Gothic script).
July 1803
We have played our concerts here.
(I am finished.) Why drum up
more opportunities to be fawned over?
I am done with this “concertizing.”
(Brother, do not smirk. Gloating does not become you.)
Forgive me, Mother. The trip has addled
my manners. Vienna was . . . exhausting.
(Circles within circles.) Oh, beautiful
too, of course, but rather too falsely animated.
(Arrogant swill, with their Archdukes and sandstone palisades.)
Yes, “pretentious” is the word.
(I am a fool. I have lost it all.)
He was great. Is great.
He hadn’t finished the score and the copyist
nearly lost his wits scribbling madly
the night before.
My part?
Oh, portions were illegible,
but I didn’t mind. I understood him.
I merely listened, and followed.
He frightened me, but I followed.
The concert was a sensation. I was feted.
We went out on the town.
(Weren’t we comrades? True brothers,
who can drink and curse the night through
yet swear loyalty all the more fiercely
come morning?)
Yes, the gardens were splendid.
Being further south, summer was already upon us
and everything brimmed with color; you could say
(yes, brother, say it) the blooms were flamboyant
to the point of insolence, almost unbearable
in their profusion.
Oh, I’m babbling.
Pay me no mind.
Beethoven at Castle Jezeri, Bohemia
A room is safe harbor. No treachery creaks the stair.
I’ve locked the door; I will not hear them knocking.
Anyone come calling can call themselves blue.
There was a time I liked nothing more than walking
the woods above Vienna, tramping forest paths
to find a patch of green laid square and plush.
I’d sit, tucked in a tapestry of birdsong, and wait
for my breath to settle; let the sun burnish my skin until
the winged horn of the post coach summoned me home.
And then everything began to sound like
the distant post horn’s gleaming trail. . . .
I was careless then, I squandered the world’s utterance.
And when my muddy conspirator swayed and quaked
like the tallest poplar tossed by the lightest wind
so that I could read his playing, see my score
transcribed on the air, on the breeze—I breathed
his soul through my own fingers and gave up
trying to listen; I watched him and felt
the music—it was better than listening,
it was the last pure sound . . .
(My emperor, emptied of honor,
has crowned himself with gold.)
Why did that savage say it? Why did I hear
what he said, why did I mind what I heard?
Good days, bad days, screech and whistle:
Sometimes I lay my head on the piano
to feel the wood breathing, the ivory sigh.
I know Lichnowski listens some evenings;
he climbs the four flights and hunkers on
the stoop. Odd: I can hear his wheezing
and not this page as it rips—the splitting
so faint a crackle, it could be the last
embers shifting in the grate. . . .
Style and flattery will get you the life
you deserve: one table setting after another,
beer and cards in the park at Ranelagh,
some lame poet enthusing over
the pale moon under the pricking stars
while Lord Petersham glimpses himself
in the sheen of his boots and smiles
as he pulls out the snuffbox for this very day.
At least the unnamed gentleman who
each evening squires a different doll
from his own bisque collection
knows that’s all he wants.
Does all that powder make them happier?
There’s the Duchess of Devonshire, snooting past
with her lap dog, as big a yawn as ever.
Look at sly little Miss Lady Wilson prattling on;
she’s absolutely smitten with the divertimento!
Smitten: as if this were a love affair
and she needs to be hit between the eyes
to actually feel something. Divertimenti
do not smite: only God does.
Here’s a modest proposal: Shut your eyes
for five minutes and listen. Easy music,
yet it demonstrates respectable employment
of chordal modulation and is utterly
capable of transporting a weary soul
out of this frenzy and onto the plain
of perfect comprehension—and there is
your bliss, flowing beneath all the fretting;
there is your ecstasy & ruin & entitlement,
all the religion you’ll ever need.
The Countess Shares Confidences over Karneval Chocolate
He was a stormy pedagogue,
always interrupting the prettiest airs—
even his own compositions,
which I was given to understand
he did not permit everyone to play.
I pounced upon each chord
with the ignorant ardor of youth;
I was sixteen, after all, and he was already
famous in Vienna, where such
approbations are stingily accorded.
He insisted on a light touch. He himself
was a wild man, ripping the music
from my stumbling fingers
and stomping about as the pages
fluttered sadly earthwards,
like the poor pheasants dropped over
the hunting fields of the Prater.
Rest assured I soon learned to play
more lightly! He was pleased, then,
and a quick soft smile would crimp
that dismal chunk of a face,
a sight just slightly less repugnant
than his rages. He was exceedingly
unlovely, yes, but with a threadbare
elegance—much as a servant,
envisioning gentility, might
avail himself of the scraps and dashes
from the milliner’s basket.
Sometimes I could coax him
to the pianoforte, where
he would bow his head,
eyes closed, and wait—
as if the silence spoke only to him;
before playing without notes
music of such inexpressible beauty,
I thought to breathe and disturb the air
would break his heart. He would not
consent to payment, but accepted the linens
I had sent up to his rooms. Poor man—
he thought I had sewn them myself.
Base level’s this: A day like all others,
blessed with sun, or not . . . the heart’s
in place, for once. Occasionally
the world offers a kindness, and I return
the favor. Ecstasy for these small services—
the proper temperature of tea, the cream introduced
tenderly. Fair enough, that.
So I’m content. As in: comforted by
the mere presence of a heartbeat.
For once not aglow with performance,
nor dingy with standing out.
Var. I.
Sun’s out, and all the tender ladies are in light cloth, frills buoyant
on bosoms, each flippant tit (that’s what they are, you bitches)
an accent or grace note, if you will, to . . . well, I won’t offend.
Not even in thought; I must behave the proper gentleman.
After all, I’ll not forget what I saw at the traveling fair
my companion sought to shield from me: two monkeys
in identical red waistcoats, one with a toy violin . . .
Var. II.
The game is played with the eyes—quick flicks
when the hand is languid, lifting the lady’s
to kiss, but when the arm whips out in the flare of
a proper and deep bowstroke . . . that’s when to look up
and linger. We attend to table, our banter a cover,
storm high in the trees: each delicacy noted, tasted,
eyes bobbing safely above neckline while the words—
ah trippingly, sir, trippingly.
Var. III. Minore
My bed is a curse to me, it reeks of dreams,
darkness complete. The city thuds on—
clangs, bells, whipcrack and whinny,
the swishing grunts of the poor scampering for curfew;
I can hear the straw under their weary limbs.
I can hear this silence, too, silence I’m meant to fill
with chatter, obsequies, and O Lord music . . .
I do think music is a grace but it is as well
the eye of God—baleful,
glittery with his glorious outrage.
Not mine. Not mine. Give me a ball
and I will bounce it before you,
masters. Glorious in my red coat.
Var. IV. Maggiore
I’d pluck an eye out. Let it roll cobble to cobble
like a pebble tumbling, kicked up by a coach run too fast.
I pluck my string instead and it is a light sound, dilettante.
I do not like the tease of a string engaged so curtly.
Picked at. But that long breath of a bow
drawn across it, that feathered sigh swelling to a moan,
to ecstasy—no bird nor mammal utters thus.
Arco. It is a human cry, a susurration that compels the blood
to spill for a sunset or a delicious pair of eyes, an elfin ankle.
Why do I throb so unseemly? I am not a prince
of anything but darkness. I must settle my humors.
When I go for a stroll and happenstance takes me
inevitably to the Thames, there
I can stand and watch the ashen waters
rippling the boaters’ oars, and I feel
for hours afterwards
a sustenance. That is the story
I wish to read, the line of song I’d follow into thin air. . . .
Haydn Serenades the Napoleonic Honor Guard
Vienna, May 1809
When I was a boy, I snipped off
a choirmate’s pigtail
just to see if the scissors were sharp.
I was caned, then expelled.
I had no prospects.
My voice had cracked.
The streets were cold and lacked music.
And now you have arrayed yourselves
into a thorny hedge around my home.
You have been placed in the streets
by a pugnacious little man
who has learned to stomp his foot
until the continent quakes.
I am weary of his chronic percussion.
My emperor has fled; across the city
rooftops are breaking out with white flags
like pustules blotching a beloved face.
I have never been good-looking
but have always dressed carefully.
Now that I am old, your leader
wants to keep me safe. Spare me
your crude fanfare, Honor Guard!
I have starved in these streets with nothing
but a splintered voice
and the angels inside my head,
found Paradise while dozing
before the sparse embers
in an old friend’s only grate,
the warm milk thick on my tongue;
even now it is the grandest
taste I have known.
In the end, it was a good thing
to have had no influences;
every day now for as many days as are given me
I will rise and dress, and go to the clavier
to play my folk song, my final oratorio
so those who need to will hear.
Admit it, toy soldiers
in your fine blue and gold trappings,
your white-strapped chests:
Even your ears are humming,
even your red plumes shake.
1811: The Prince Regent celebrates himself
I have always believed that love is
an overflowing, an abundance one needs
to be rid of, to pour into another. That other
can be a man or a woman, dog or hillock
or headdress of ostrich feathers; it can be
sculpture or shoreline or even a sunless day
seeping its silvery light over the Thames.
It may arrive quietly, a moment between moments
in the river of talk, after the hot soup but before
the mutton; or it can be the mutton, too—
its ginger tang and musky finish.
However it comes, the sensation is
massive, inconvenient, undeniable.
If one were to banish extravagance,
all longing would take on edges. Witness
the general, poised on the smoking field,
as he surveys the strewn body bits
with a ghoulish mix of rue and relish;
he has won another snippet of territory
and is hungry for more. Love is rounder
and less dignified; if love brandished a sword
I would kneel and bare my neck.
Some call me gaudy, capricious; it’s true
that I drool when I drink and cannot walk the path
from bed to breakfast tray without wheezing.
I’m gouty, corseted, flatulent—but it’s all
because I cannot refuse a thing its chance
to shine, to sigh or deliquesce. So let there be
stars in every glass and fireworks over the park,
spun sugar pagodas on mirrored lakes, diamonds,
a footman in ancient armor, crimson drapery;
and down the center of the banquet table
set for two hundred in the Gothic conservatory
an actual stream—pure water cascading
between banks of real moss with tiny flowers—
and fish flashing, gold and silver, down the sluice.
More pineapples, more cherry wine!
Tell the other two thousand guests
gathered in Carlton House
that we are here to show the world
England’s swaggering heart;
and that I intend to celebrate all century,
until something even grander arrives—
more outrageous and beautiful—to swallow me
in its monstrous, invisible embrace.
Cambridge, Great St. Mary’s Church
I kneel, but not in sufferance,
not in faith. There is a fulcrum
beyond which the bow tip wobbles;
no ardency nor forceful wrist
can make it sing. I am there,
at wit’s balancing point. Music
pours through the blackened nave,
hollowing my bones to fit
the space it needs. It needs
so much of me, the soul’s
wicked cartridge emptying
as fast as it fills. I kneel
because even the reed bends
before God’s laughter
splits it, and the storm
moves on.
Carlton House, London, 1812
Music played for the soul is sheer pleasure;
to play merely for pleasure is nothing
but work. Is anyone listening? I am
the First Violinist of the Prince Regent’s
Prized Private Orchestra, playing
for your satisfaction—except
His Mad Majesty’s son is a gluttonous fool,
and I’m as invisible as a statue of a moor.
Laughter drifts between the staves
like sunlight through the iron-black pikes
of Windsor’s Middle Ward, back
when I was beginning: the courtyard
a blazing field of chipped stones
combed into swirls, like the yellow dust
at Esterházy: matted down, awaiting
the guests’ arrival . . . everything
done for the pleasure of others,
so they might exclaim All this
for me? Such extravagance!—
as it unrolled beneath their dainty steps.
Stop bitching: There’s worse work
and crueler wardens. In the end,
each note sent pearling
over their dull heads
is mine—although they believe
they own it all, and for me
to claim even a portion of it
is to be their servant.
was something to be happy about,
wasn’t it? Four days in a short cold month
when even one’s breath, upon exit,
instantly condensed into a shower of snow.
The sky was black. The river shone,
a marble corridor dulled by its awestruck traffic—
charred coal, crushed underfoot and smeared
the length of this vast, dim spine of ice
dubbed City Street by the amused vendors
—as if those walking there, terrified to drop
too bold a footfall, slid booth to booth
instead. Banked fires hurled sooty issue
against the frigid air so that smoke hung
nearly gelatinous, in wreaths of drab warmth
from Blackfriars Bridge to Three Cranes Stairs;
it was difficult to breathe. Games abounded—
skittles for the squeamish, bowling for the bold,
donkey rides for the ladies and dancing for all.
A small sheep was roasted whole on the ice
and plates and knives laid out, with penny loaves;
also an elephant led across the river by rope
just below Blackfriars—wasn’t that
a sign? The Fair began on a Tuesday,
followed by Candlemas, which meant
even if the coaches still weren’t running
the northern roads and yet another man
was found frozen near Dove’s Inn, having
drunk freely there, then fallen into a snowbank—
all the same, winter’s grip was loosening. Soon
there’d be no more sleighs-for-hire come evening,
no more Punch and no Judy duking it out
for the children crowding the makeshift stalls;
and as for the three men propped up
on hay bales when the gin tent broke loose
and skimmed downriver—
before ice water sluiced over their boots
and the sweat broke out, wasn’t it
the best damn drunk ever?
From Temple to Westminster, a curve of soft fire
alive on the ice. Lanterns bobbing. No time
for din and rabble when the King was calling,
when one was nearly a Professor of Music, when . . .
Christ, the night’s bitter.
Move on, before you start to enjoy
freezing to death.