I twist my neck back to face Alex when he asks, “Do the goats always ride in the cab of the truck?” His eyes dart between mine and my dad’s glaring at him in the rearview mirror as he adds on, “I get the chickens—they’re just babies—but this goat appears full grown.”
Before I can assure him he isn't going crazy, my dad butts in, "That's Clancy—Regan's pet goat. When Regan's home, Clancy goes wherever Regan goes." He mumbles a few more words under his breath but they’re quiet enough neither Alex or I can hear them. "Pet him. He's real friendly."
Missing the brisk shake of my head advising him against it, Alex does as instructed. He pays for his trust not even two seconds later. Clancy’s bite isn’t firm enough to draw blood, but I’m reasonably sure Alex’s hand will bear the imprint of his teeth for the next three to four days.
I pat Alex’s knee, enticing his eyes to mine. “He’s a bit of a chewer—”
“That’s not true,” my dad interrupts, hating that I’m soothing the sting to Alex’s ego. “He just doesn’t like strangers moseying in on his turf.” He overemphasizes the word “strangers,” ensuring Alex can’t miss that Clancy isn’t the only animal in this truck harboring some disdain. “We don’t do well with city folk around here.”
Alex braces his chin on his chest to hide his smirk when I roll my eyes at my dad's pompous attitude. I've always loved that my dad is so big and brawny, he didn't just scare boys my age into being gentleman, he also petrified their fathers, but it doesn't have the same effect on me today. Alex doesn't want to hurt me. He wants to save me. Both notions are as frightening as the other.
When I return my eyes front and center to wordlessly warn my dad to quit the larks, a scrap of paper at my feet captures my attention. It's a receipt with flight details scribbled on the back.
After gathering the receipt in my hand, I shift my eyes to my dad. “Who told you I was coming? It was Maisy, wasn’t it? Or Beatrice?”
Heat surfaces on my cheeks as I run through the short list of women over seventy in our home town. They and their belittling ways are the reason Luca could never be who he truly wanted to be. He was too concerned about maintaining an image than pursuing happiness. That's why his depression was so hard to overcome. It fed off their negativity until it combusted in the most horrific way.
“Answer me, Dad! Which one of the know-it-all old biddies yapped in your ear this time?”
My dad keeps his eyes on the road, knowing he can’t look at me and lie. “No one. It was my ears. You know how they twitch when you girls. . .” His words trail off when I yank on his steering wheel, bringing his beloved truck to the very edge of the asphalt. “Rae! Have you gone tooting mad?! You could get us killed!”
Although I love the return of the nickname he hasn’t called me since I was twenty-two, the anger in his tone holds back my joy.
“You lied!” I shout, tossing the crumbled up receipt into his chest. “Those are the exact details of our flight today!”
His lips wobble, but not a word escapes them.
Recalling the strict rules my momma raised me with, I shout, "Out!" I nudge my head to his door, giving him his marching orders. "You lie, you walk. That's what momma always says."
“Rae—”
“Out! What's good for one is good for all,” I quote, using his words against him. “Liars don’t prosper. They also don’t get a free ride, so out you go!”
Alex remains as quiet as a church mouse when my dad throws open his door before clambering onto the roadside. He barely squeaks a peep when I slide into my dad’s spot, slam my foot on the gas pedal, and leave my dad in a pile of dust.
He doesn’t say a word until my dad is nothing but a speck of dirt in the low-hanging sun. “Rae. . .” He articulates my name more sincerely than my dad did. “You can’t leave him. We still have over thirty miles to travel.”
Our eyes meet in the rearview mirror. “So? That will give him plenty of time to cool down.”
"A cold shower is a much better solution for calming down an out-of-control Myers." He aims for his tone to come out cheeky, but all I hear is sexual innuendo. He's amused, but not enough to smile. It’s a pity for him I don’t need to see his grin to know it’s there.
I lower my speed to a less dangerous pace when Alex climbs into the passenger seat. I am as mad as hell, but I don’t want him getting hurt.
The anger blistering my veins simmers when a manly scent engulfs me. Even hours after his last shower, Alex smells clean and fresh. . . and a little bit like Clancy. It doesn’t dampen his appeal in the slightest. It suits him. He should wear country more often.
“Did you just sniff me?” Alex asks, sliding into the empty space next to me.
“No!” I immediately retort, lying through my teeth.
My bones jump out of my skin when Alex shouts, “Out!” He yanks on the steering wheel as abruptly as I did a mile ago. “What's good for one is good for all.”
“But I wasn’t lying,” I lie.
Alex waits for me to pull over before arching a brow. He doesn’t speak. He doesn’t need to. I can read the shit-eating pompousness beaming out of him.
Incapable of ignoring his stern glare for a second longer, my voice wavers, “It was barely a whiff; it doesn’t count!”
“You lied; get on your bike.” He leans across me to yank on the rusty door handle. When the driver’s side door pops open, he nudges me in the shoulder. “You better get a wiggle on; you’ve only got an hour of sunlight left.”
I slam the door shut. "I am not walking. There could be coyotes and rattlesnakes, or god knows what else hiding in the bushes waiting to pounce on me!"
"And honesty?" Alex asks with a twist of his lips. "There could also be that."
I grunt like a wild animal, unappreciative of his underhanded swipe at my integrity. “Who are you to preach?! You’ve done nothing but lie to me since the day we met!”
He says nothing—of course! A liar doesn’t defend himself with lies. He keeps quiet.
Enraged with anger at his continued deceit, I throw open the door I just shut, then slip out of the truck. I barely make it three steps away from the hood when Alex is on my tail.
“When have I lied to you?” his voice roars through both my chest and the deadly quiet afternoon.
I whip around to face him so fast I give myself whiplash. "Oh, I don't know, how about the accountant speech you gave me at the hospital?! Or what about the whole toolbelt incident instead of admitting you were carrying a gun—"
“That was Josie, not me.”
I continue talking as if he never spoke, “—Or the fact that you continuously deny me when I know you want me?! How many more examples do you want, Alex? A hundred? I can give you a hundred just from the number of times you’ve looked at me the past twenty-four hours.” He remains quiet, perplexed and blindsided by my honesty. “A lie doesn’t need to be vocalized to be heard. You just have to think it.”
“What do you see when you look at me, Regan? A man who can’t stop thinking about you? That you’re on my mind from when the sun rises to when it goes down, no matter what's happening in my day? That you are the most beautiful woman I’ve ever fucking seen?! They aren’t lies. Nothing I’ve said or shown you are lies! They are omissions of the truth.”
“They’re still lies!”
“No, they’re not,” he denies, stepping closer to me. “A lie is something you do when you are deceiving someone. An omission of truth is sometimes the only option you have when you’re trying to protect someone you care about. I don’t want to lie to you, Rae, but I sure as fuck don’t want to lose you either.”
I clutch my chest, trying to lessen its leaps from his words. I thought it was just me. The crackling. The fire. I thought it was all my imagination. But he just proved it isn't. He's as deeply invested as me. Just as confused, but definitely devoted.
Even with a hundred theories running through my head, I can’t help but ask, “Who are you, Alex? Really.”
If I were to believe the hunch I’ve been running with since the night we bumped heads in the elevator, he’s either an undercover cop or a spy. I honestly don’t know which scenario I despise the most.
He licks his cracked lips. “I can’t tell you that.”
“Can’t or don’t want to?”
“Can’t,” he answers without pause. “Yet,” he quickly adds on when he spots disappointment in my eyes. “But I will. One day.”
“Just not today?”
He smirks, hoping his heart-fluttering smile will have me feeling no pain when he confirms, “Not today. But soon. I promise you, Rae. When the time is right, you’ll know everything.”
Trusting the honesty beaming out of him, I ask a question I’ve wanted answered since we met. “Why do you call me Rae? There are only two times I’ve been called Rae. By my daddy when I was a child, and by the clients at. . .”
I didn't think this through. From what I've heard via the grapevine, Substanz is still in operation. Jayce is no longer at the helm, but the cabaret dancers and cigar-smoking clientele are still in abundance. Although I doubt Alex would judge me on my past, I like the way he looks at me. I don't want to ruin that for anything.
I raise my eyes to Alex’s. His quirked brow reveals he didn’t miss my fade-to-black comment. “I take it this is what you meant by an omission of the truth?”
With a smile, he nods. “It isn’t that you don’t want to be honest, just sometimes you can’t be. It’s like when my sister asked if her butt looked big in her prom dress, even if it was the size of a submarine, I’d never say it was. An omission of the truth isn’t about harm; it’s about keeping the other person from getting hurt.”
His words impact me more than I can explain. For the past eight years, I’ve felt like I’ve been living one big fat lie. Now it doesn’t feel so bad. I’m not lying to the people I love. I’m stopping them from getting hurt. Those are two entirely different things. So as much as Alex’s inability to be honest frustrates me, until I come clean on the lapses I’ve had the past decade, I can’t preach morality.
“Rae. . .”
I slant my head to the side, confused as to why Alex's voice mixed with my father’s. For the first time in months, my muddled mind gets a moment of reprieve. I didn't imagine two influential voices mixing together. I heard them as one, delivered with the same amount of sorrow. My father's for lying, and Alex's for his ability to read me like no man ever has.
After thanking a local for the lift, my father closes the gap between us with long, brisk strides. Alex also moves closer. His steps are more imposing than my father’s. I should pull away when he lifts his hand to my face, but with his eyes finally free of betrayal, I can’t. I want his touch. I want his hands on me. Even more so since I’ve just realized we’re standing mere feet from a parcel of land I will never forget.
I was so caught up bickering with Alex, I didn’t recognize the landscape we were driving past, but with my dad’s savior whipping past us with his headlights on, the truth is viciously crashing into me. I forgot to turn off at Smith Street, meaning I’ve driven right into the eye of the storm. We are mere feet from the site of Luca’s accident.
“What’s going on, Sweetie? Why did you stop here?” my father asks, catching up to us.
He yanks on Alex’s shoulder so rigidly, his thumb slips from my mouth. The concern in both Alex and my father’s eyes doubles when they scan my ashen cheeks and moisture-filled eyes.
“I. . . uh . . I forgot to turn off,” I reply, my voice as low as my heart rate.
Stunned by the sheer terror in my reply, Alex follows the direction of my gaze. Nearly eight years have passed since I visited this site, but the gap in time hasn’t hindered my observation skills in the slightest. Even if it had, the late afternoon sun illuminating the cross on the tree that claimed Luca’s life quickly floods me with memories.
Although the sun rays bouncing off the white paint appear angelic, the absolute horror tearing at my chest is anything but. I forgot him. It may have only been for a minute, but I still forgot. That's unforgivable.
Upon spotting a rogue tear careening down my cheek, my dad murmurs, "Oh, baby girl." His cracking voice adds to my devastation. "We'll head back to Smith Street; go home via Duke's place. Come on."
Faster than I can blink, he helps me into his truck via the hanging open driver's side door. I bite on the inside of my cheek to stifle a sob when Alex reenters the cab from the opposite side of my father. Instead of sitting where he did earlier, he takes my spot in the passenger seat, squishing me between him and my father's slumped shoulder.
The tension is so high, nothing but the erratic thump of three hearts is heard. After my father executes a U-turn, we quickly slip away from an area responsible for tearing my heart in two, but it comes too late. Nothing can impede the train wreck of memories hammering me: the horrifying words Luca and I screamed at each other as he dangerously careened down the narrow road we are traveling on, the smell when I awoke after twenty minutes of unconsciousness, his low-hanging head. They crash into me like a violent wave, ensuring my eyes have no choice but to release the flood inundating them.
“Don’t,” Alex murmurs when I protest him seizing my wrist to pull me into his lap. “You either let me hold you, or I’m gonna cut down that damn tree with my bare hands.”
My dad’s tightened jaw slackens from Alex’s comment. He has threatened to destroy a certain tree many times the past eight years.
Although I feel utterly ridiculous grieving one man while nuzzling into the chest of another, I can’t help but accept Alex’s comfort. He peers down at me without a single pang of doubt in his eyes. His comfort comes with no strings attached. I won’t owe him a single dime if I accept what he's offering. He's with me because he wants to be, not because he feels obligated.
That was all I ever asked from Luca.
Only now am I realizing it was the one thing he never gave me.