At midday I rented a kayak, bought wire cutters at a hardware store, and studied the map. The pond behind Cabot’s house was accessible from a dirt road on the far side, although I’d have to fight my way through another marshy stand of underbrush.
Toward dusk, I lashed the kayak to the top of my rental car and drove it to the spot I’d pegged as the most convenient drop-off. I shoved the boat and paddle far enough into the brush to hide them from passersby. Then I drove to the nature preserve, where I parked on the shoulder of the dirt road and walked to the lookout spot. I hoped my hunch about Anderson’s habits was correct.
Shortly after six p.m. he emerged from the house, right on schedule. He headed for the Jeep while I headed for the car. I gave him enough time to make the turnoff, then I drove to where the kayak was stashed and parked on the shoulder.
The remnants of an old path offered easier and drier access than I’d expected, and the boat was light enough to drag through the grass and sand. The hard part was climbing into the snug cockpit and casting off without turning the thing over. It tipped alarmingly as I shoved off with the paddle. But it finally eased into the pond, and I quickly reached the buoy. I grabbed the line to stop my progress, then held on for dear life as the boat rocked and wobbled beneath me.
I waited for the waters to calm and took my bearings. The loon from this morning was still on patrol, keeping his distance. A night heron prowling near Cabot’s dock eyed me suspiciously. The only sounds were of bugs and the wind.
Taking a deep breath, I began hauling up the slimy line, a chore that told me just how strong Anderson must be. Every foot was hard-earned, and each great tug threatened to capsize the boat. But my excitement mounted as the line coiled on the deck, and I gasped with joy when the rusting trap finally broke the surface with its treasure inside.
The trickiest part was balancing the trap on the deck while getting the wire cutters out of my pocket. A mosquito buzzed my ear, Cabot’s last line of defense, and I began clipping open the rusted mesh. It snipped easily, and I peeled back a panel large enough to reach in and take hold of the canister. It was bigger than I’d expected, and cumbersome to hold while I shoved the trap back off the deck. Bubbles rose as I watched it disappear into the murk.
I opened the canister and removed the yellow dry bag marked with Cabot’s initials. I put the open canister back in the pond, where it immediately filled with water and sank. The lid floated, so I took it with me and paddled back to shore. Getting out was easier than launching, and within ten minutes I’d tossed the dry bag into the trunk of the car and lashed the kayak to the roof. Only one car passed while I was tying down the boat, and it didn’t even slow down. On my way back into town I saw Anderson’s Jeep, still parked at the natural foods grocery. Enjoy your latte, Kyle. I was giddy with excitement.
I dropped off the boat at the rental place just before closing, then returned to the hotel. As I passed through the lobby, the desk clerk looked at me with even greater curiosity than he’d shown in the morning. I was again wet, with leaves and brambles stuck to my trousers. The yellow dry bag dangled from my hand like the catch of the day at the fisherman’s dock. I held it so that he didn’t see Cabot’s initials, but otherwise I was feeling downright cocky, so I smiled and waved.
“Beautiful day, wasn’t it?”
“Yes, sir.”
Sometimes it was brazen or nothing in this business.
I spread the items across the bed. The size of the archive was astonishing. Cabot’s trove could be roughly divided into four categories, one for each of the plastic bags. The largest was the contents of a fat folder marked “Nethercutt.” Most of its holdings were stamped with an H for Project Honetol, the name Angleton gave to his ruinous mole hunt when he began it in 1964.
Nethercutt, being one of Angleton’s most zealous disciples, had spirited away quite a haul, and I’m sure that if I’d known as much as a historian about all the contacts and ops, then I would have been able to make sense of everything. As it was, the only Nethercutt materials I could put into context pertained to either Lemaster (“Headlight”), his Soviet source Nijinsky, or Headlight’s communications network.
Among the most relevant items was a summary of an interrogation with Yuri Nosenko, the defector whom Angleton and his own Soviet pet, Anatoly Golitsyn, had never believed, and who had therefore been locked away in a bunker. Nosenko named four KGB “traveler” agents with roaming rights to all of Central and Western Europe. One was code-named Dewey, the longtime recipient of all those goodies from Lemaster.
The Nethercutt file also included material on the Soviet agent Leo, or Trefimov, the one Litzi and I knew as Vladimir just before he was murdered. There was a summary of the criminal associations he developed after the collapse of the Soviet Union, which mentioned his relocation to Vienna in the late 1990s. This was the material Cabot must have used to track him down and set up our meeting.
There were also several 1972 Nethercutt memos to Angleton, which outlined Nethercutt’s involvement in quashing the publication of Lothar Heinemann’s novel. Not one of them mentioned the book’s title, or Lothar’s pen name, which helped explain why Cabot hadn’t found it.
The second batch was a collection of Cabot’s own Agency files. The findings of Valerie Humphries’s research were there with regard to the points of intersection for Lemaster and Dewey. There were also records of Cabot’s recent correspondence with Vladimir and with Milan Bobić, my old consular adversary from Belgrade.
At the very back of the Cabot folder was a long list of antiquarian book dealers across Europe. Many had tiny checkmarks by their name. Der Flügel was prominent among them, but obviously when Cabot called he hadn’t known which title to ask for, and I suspected that Lothar had alerted Ziegler to deflect any queries that came in by phone. I’d lucked out.
The third, and smallest, portion of the cache was made up of my own contributions—the negatives of Vladimir’s KGB documents, my one written report, and the copy of Oppenheim’s The Great Impersonation. By the look of it, Cabot had placed the microdot right back on the dust jacket, as if to better preserve it for use in an official proceeding.
The fourth bag was in some ways the most interesting, even though the materials had little or nothing to do with Edwin Lemaster. It was a huge stack of pages from Angleton’s office diary and appointment logs from September 1949 to May 1951, the period when the British mole Kim Philby had been a frequent lunch companion and a regular visitor to his office. Incredible material, in other words, for any CIA historian.
As I flipped through the pages, scanning Angleton’s odd marginalia and notes of his discussions with Philby, all sorts of key operational details jumped out, meaning that he had leaked them directly to the infamous mole, often doing so after a very wet lunch in which he regularly consumed boatloads of martinis. Anything Ed Lemaster would’ve leaked might well have been tiny by comparison. In fact, if Lemaster had truly been a Soviet operative, his main role could have been to help fuel Angleton’s mistrust of people like Nosenko.
I realized then what the CIA desired most from my unofficial mission to Block Island. It was the Angleton stuff—the logbooks, the diaries, and all of the Honetol material that Nethercutt had squirreled away. The more personal game that I’d gotten so caught up in involving Cabot, Lemaster, Preston, Dad, and Litzi was the merest of sidelights, a means to an end.
The idea that a popular author might once have betrayed them was probably worth keeping under wraps, especially if Preston and his new Russian business partner were involved, since Preston still made millions from the government. But in the bigger picture of the Agency’s legacy, the Angleton stuff carried more weight.
It was nearly midnight by the time I finished going through it all, and I was exhausted. I packed everything back into the folders and slipped the dry bag into my luggage for safekeeping. Then I slept soundly, ready to finish the job once and for all.