INDEX
Page numbers refer to the print edition but are hyperlinked to the appropriate location in the e-book.
Abu Simbel temples, 183
Acceleration, of time, 80, 123–24, 178, 190, 231n71
Achilles, 215n8, 215n13; with mourning, 43–44; with perpetual present, 43–45, 54; with time, 218n51
Ages: of humanity, 86; of slavery, 74; of world, 12–13, 74; see also Middle Ages
Aging, 113–14
Alberti, Leon Battista, 164, 165–66
Alcinous (King of the Phaeacians), 42, 47, 49, 58, 216n31
Allen, Woody, 229n48
Allusion, see Art of allusion
Amaterasu (Japanese goddess), 154
America, 82–86; Chateaubriand and, 77–79, 97–98; ruins in, 94–95; Tocqueville and, 93–95, 98; Volney and, 90–92
Anacharsis, 70–72
Anachronism, 53, 88, 101, 224n96
Anaximander (Greek philosopher), 1, 205n1
Ancient City (Fustel de Coulanges), 134
Ancients: imitation of, 74, 92; Indians and, 78, 83–84; moderns and, 67, 76, 86–87, 107; savages and, 67–69, 76, 77; see also Greece; Rome
Annales (Febvre), 4, 13
“Annals of the poor,” 31–32
Anthropology, 56, 69, 112, 121, 186, 195; culture and, 23; with form of temporality, 38–40; historical, 23–28, 36; history and, 9, 36
“Anti-affliction,” 46, 47
Antiquities, 155–56, 162, 165, 166, 171
Antiquities (Varro), 162, 165
Apollinaire, 110
Archaic royalty, 29–32
Archival institutions, 116
Arendt, Hannah, 4–5, 49, 52, 80, 106, 129, 204
Arete (excellence), 30
Ariès, Philippe, 113, 135, 138
Aristotle, 49, 56, 60
Aron, Raymond, 139, 146
Art of allusion, 50
Arts, 170; conservation of, 176; in Greece, 169, 171, 173; historians, 171; pillaging of, 175–79; in Rome, 169, 171; with time and history, 174
Assassins of Memory (Vidal-Naquet), 102
Atala (Chateaubriand), 78
Athens Charter of 1931, 182, 183
Attention, xvi, 57, 58
Auerbach, Erich, 42–43, 57–58
Augé, Marc, 208n28
Augustine (saint), xvi, 12, 56; attention and, 57, 58; distension and, 59, 60; Odysseus compared to, 55–63; with time, 57
Augustus (emperor), 158, 159
Aurelius, Marcus, 109
Autarchic present, 208n28
Bainville, Jacques, 137–38
Bananas (film), 229n48
Bankruptcy: in ancient Greece, xiv; of history, 110, 129
Bards: heroes and, 46–49, 51–52, 55, 216n28; as historians, 48; Muses inspiring, 49, 55; with past and future divinatory knowledge, 44, 55; as seers, 48
Barrès, Maurice, 135, 181
Barthélemy, Jean-Jacques, 69–70
Baschet, Jérôme, 208n28
Bastille, 142, 161
Battle of Bouvines, 37
Baudelaire, Charles, 50, 84
Benjamin, Walter, 4, 129
Benveniste, Émile, 109, 211n57
Berestycki, Henri, 202
Bergson, Henry, 122, 128, 231n80
Berlin, 7–11
Berlin Wall, 3, 102, 106, 146–47, 185, 197
Between Past and Future (Arendt), 5
The Bible, 60–61, 153, 240n65; see also Old Testament, time in
Biondo, Flavio, 164, 165
Biotechnologies, 6, 198
Bloch, Marc, xiv, 110, 137, 138, 233n105
Boas, Franz, 34–35
Boissy d’Anglas, François-Étienne, 174
Boito, Camillo, 236n14
Boniface IV (Pope), 160
Bonnaud, Robert, 210n55
Bossuet, Jacques-Bénigne, xvi, 11, 12
Bourdieu, Pierre, 113
Bousquet, René, 115
Braibant Report, 229n52
Braudel, Fernand, xvi, 103, 133; on capitalism, xiv; longe durée and, 14, 16; as prisoner of war, 140–41
Burguière, André, 141
Camus, Albert, 207n16
Capitalism, xiv
Caractères originaux de l’histoire rurale française (Bloch), 138
Cassiodorus, 160
Castel, Robert, xviii
Catastrophism, 197, 202, 244n10
Caumont, Arcisse de, 180
Certeau, Michel de, xviii, 2, 8
Change, France with societal, 243n119
Charlemagne, 160
Charles X (King of France), 92
Char, René, 4, 5
Chartier, Roger, 121
Chateaubriand, François-René de, xvii, 11, 83, 92, 101, 179, 193; on acceleration of time, 123; America and, 77–79, 97–98; Complete Works, 66–67, 93; historia magistra vitae and, 72–77; Odysseus and, 88; return of, 79; ruins and, 89–95; savages and, 68; time and, 65–66, 79–81, 103, 106, 194; travel and, 66–72; see also Historical Essay; Travels in America
Chirac, Jacques, 118, 245n19, 245n29
Christianity, 179; conversions to, 29–30, 42, 169, 223n84; historia magistra vitae and, 106; orders of time and, 56, 59–63, 153–54; present and, 109–10
Christo, 159
Chronic time, 211n57
Chronosophy, 11, 15
Cicero, 73, 126, 162, 171, 221n30
Cities, 134; city-states in Greece, 28, 54; “Generic City,” xix
The City of God (Augustine), 59
Clio (Péguy), 128, 142
“Cold” societies, 8, 24–26
Coleridge, Samuel Taylor, 202
Collective memory, 121–25, 187
The Collective Memory (Halbwachs), 122
Colonna, Giovanni, 163
Commemorations, 119–20, 141–43, 191
Communism, 7, 208n25
Communist Manifesto, 107
Comte, Auguste, 11
Condorcet, Nicolas de (marquis), xvi
Confessions (Augustine), xvi, 56
Conservation, 115, 118, 151, 157; of art, 176; France and, 161, 173–74; of monuments, 166–67; restoration and, 152, 175
Considerations on the Arts of Design (Quatremère de Quincy), 170
Constant, Benjamin, 86
Constantine the Great, 30, 153, 163, 167
Constructing the Past (Le Goff and Nora), 120–21
Conversions, to Christianity, 29–30, 42, 223n84
Cook, Captain James, 24, 35–36
Cooper, Fenimore, 29
Corruption, 71–72, 75, 76, 84
Cosmic myths, 31, 33
Counter-Muses, 52–53
Crimes, 7, 230n53; against humanity, 8, 117, 171, 200–201; against public instruction, 172
Crises: financial crisis of 2008, xiii, xiv; modern regime’s, 104–7
Croesus (King of Lydia), 2
Cultures: anthropology and, 23; cultural diversity, 14, 26, 187; gaps, 14–15; Greek, 19; heritage, 172–73, 181, 184, 189
Cumulative history, 14, 26, 112
Current events, 7, 33
Customs of the American Indians Compared with the Customs of Primitive Times (Lafitau), 69
Cynics, 72
Cyriacus of Ancona, 164
Dagron, Gilbert, 153
Dangers, of imitation, 75–76
Daniel (prophet), 12
Dates, 88, 104, 105; see also 9/11
Death, 7, 13, 113, 138; life after, 61, 134; mourning and, 43–44, 46, 50, 53, 216n31; as price for listening pleasure, 53–54; with statues uprooted, 171–72
Debord, Guy, 229n43
Debts, xiv, 201–2, 245n29
The Decline of the West (Spengler), 13
Degree zero museum, 188
De la Blache, Vidal, 125
Democracy in America (Tocqueville), 94
Denon, Vivant, 178
Description of Greece (Pausanias), 156–57
Descriptio urbis Romae (Alberti), 166
Despotism, 174–75, 194
d’Estaing, Valéry Giscard, 118
Detienne, Marcel, 9, 42
Development, see Sustainable development; Urban development projects
Dictionary of Architecture (Quatremère de Quincy), 170
Discourse on Inequality (Rousseau), 68
Discourse on Universal History (Bossuet), 12
Disorientation, of time, 3–5, 80
Distension: Augustine and, 59, 60; Odysseus and, 57, 58
Diversity, cultural, 14, 26, 187
Divinatory knowledge, 44–45, 55
Does History Go Faster? (Jeanneney), 123
Dreams, interpretation of, 12
Dreyfus Affair, 128
Droysen, Johann Gustav, 104
Duby, Georges, 37, 138, 233n106
Dumont, Louis, 29
Dupront, Alphonse, 168
Dupuy, Jean-Pierre, 197, 199
Earth, Heaven separated from, 33, 35
Ecclesiastical history, 62
Eclair Film Studios, 182
Ecomuseums, 187–88
“Editorial” (Sartre), 111
Egypt, 90
Einaudi, Jean-Luc, 117
Eliot, T.S., 113
“The End of History” (Fukuyama), 15
Enlightenment, 170–71, 203
“Entering one’s future backwards,” 227n12
“Entropology,” 112
Environment: heritage and natural, 151–52, 187; heritage and time of, 186–91; protection of, 115, 198–200
Epicureanism, 109
Eschaton, 109
Essay on the Acceleration of History (Halévy), 123
Essays (Montaigne), 107, 167
Estrangement, 3; historicity and, xv; from past, present, and future, xvi; self-, 50, 51–52, 55; from time, 42–43
Eternity, 202–3
Eugene IV (Pope), 165
Europe: heritage in, 152–53; identity, 148
Eusebius (bishop of Caesarea), 62
Eventfulness, 26–27
Events: current, 7, 33; from event to myth and working misunderstandings, 34–38; from myth to, 32–34; non-events-based history, 33; as repetitious for Maori, 33; requirements for appearance of, 38–39; rethinking of, 37
Evolutionism, 14
Ewald, François, 199, 200
Excellence, see Arete Exemplum, 107
Existentialism, 111
Expectation, xvi, 9, 73, 119
Experience, 9, 73, 119
Fabian, Johannes, 38–39
Fabre, Daniel, 184
False evolutionism, 14
Fault lines, of present, 114–20
Faust II (Goethe), 203
Fear: of forgetting, 45; heuristics of, 198
Febvre, Lucien, 4, 13, 110, 136, 137, 139; with national consciousness of France, 233n105; on Valéry, 228n31
Fermigier, André, 230n55
Fiji, 28–32, 56; Christianity in, 29–30; as island of history, 36
Financial crisis, of 2008, xiii, xiv
The Flood (painting), 89
Forgetting, 2, 45, 46, 102, 112
Fortune, 164, 165, 168; see also Tukhe
Foucault, Michel, 2
Fourastié, Jean, 108, 227n22
France, 101–3, 115–16, 129, 135; with commemorations, 119–20, 141–43; conservation and, 161, 173–74; heritage in, 149–55, 161–62, 181–83, 235n3; with national consciousness, 233n105; with national history, 131–41; national unity of, 144; with pillaging of art, 175–79; with societal changes, 243n119; universalization and, 180–85; urban development projects in, 117–19, 182; see also French Resistance; French Revolution
Francis I (King of France), 161
Frazer, James George, 29
Frederick the Great, 120
Freedoms, 85–86, 175
French Heritage Foundation Law, 182–83
French Resistance, 4–5
French Revolution, 11, 65, 73, 74, 102, 104, 107; cultural heritage and, 172–73; despotism and, 174–75; with heritage and present, 170–80; museums and, 175–79; Quatremère de Quincy and, 170–72
Freud, Sigmund, 6
Fukuyama, Francis, 15, 146
Furet, François, 3, 131
Fustel de Coulanges, Numa Denis, 18, 133–36, 144
Future, xv; disorientation of, 3–5, 80; divinatory knowledge of, 44–45, 55; “entering one’s future backwards,” 227n12; estrangement from, xvi; forgetting of, 112; gap between past and, 5, 13, 53, 74, 88, 204; historia magistra vitae and, 38, 72–77; Historical Essay and, 73; Maori and, 33, 34; past and, 105, 109, 190, 194, 201–2; with past and present as single concept, 211n57; present threatened by, xviii, 13, 191, 198
Futures Past (Koselleck), 9, 13, 17, 34, 39, 73, 104–5, 214n43
Futurism, xvii, 107–8, 113, 196, 197
Futurist Manifesto (Marinetti), 107, 108, 203
Gaps: between ancients and moderns, 87; culture, 14–15; between past and future, 5, 13, 53, 74, 88, 204; in time, 3–7, 88, 106
“Generic City,” xix
Genius of Christianity (Chateaubriand), 179
German Sites of Memory, 120
Germany, 73, 120, 143; see also Berlin; Berlin Wall
Gide, André, 110
Gluck, Carol, 227n11
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von, 109, 169, 203
Gracq, Julien, 105
Great Britain, 34–36
Greece: art in, 169, 171, 173; bankruptcies in ancient, xiv; city-states in, 28, 54; culture, 19; heritage in, 156–58; legacy of, 174; orders of time in, 1–2; Scythians and, 70–72; statues from, 171; tragedy, 31
Grégoire (Abbé), 175
Grey, George (Sir), 32, 33, 34
Guizot, François, 180, 237n23
Guy, Michel, 118
Gyges (King of Lydia), 2
Habitus, 31, 32
Halbwachs, Maurice, 121–22, 123, 124, 127
Halévy, Daniel, 123–24
Hartog, François, 18, 205n1, 206n26, 206n28, 209n31, 213n21, 213n26, 213n29, 214n1, 217n35, 218n64, 220n9, 221n16, 221n22, 221n23, 221n30, 222n34, 222n90, 227n12, 227n18, 227n19, 227n29, 227n51, 232n94, 233n97, 237n22, 239n64, 241n92; see also The Mirror of Herodotus
Hawaii, 24, 35, 36, 39
Heaven, Earth separated from, 33, 35
Hedda Gabler (Ibsen), 110
Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich, 9, 11, 27, 28, 49
Heidegger, Martin, xv, 9
Helena (Empress), 153
Hélias, Pierre-Jakez, 102
Heritage, 98, 103, 230n55; with ancients and present, 155–62; cultural, 172–73, 181, 184, 189; defined, 152; in Europe, 152–53; in France, 149–55, 161–62, 181–83, 235n3; with French Revolution and present, 170–80; in Greece, 156–58; history of, 151–55; identity and, 119, 151, 182; in Japan, 154–55; memory and, 11; national, 119; with natural environment, 151–52, 187; Rome and, 155–56, 158–70; with time of environment, 186–91; universalization of, 180–86; world, 6, 150, 186–87
Herodotus, 1, 12, 18, 70, 72, 157
Heroes: bards and, 46–49, 51–52, 55, 216n28; with perpetual present, 41–46, 54, 56, 58; see also Achilles; Odysseus
Heroic regimes, history and, 28–32, 36, 38
Hesiod, 44
Heuristics, of fear, 198
Hierarchy, 29, 31
Hiroshima, 124, 196
Historia magistra vitae, 38, 62–63, 72–77, 92; Christianity and, 106; defined, 105; inverted, 95, 98; new interpretation of, 190; repetition and, 91
Historians, 228n32; art, 171; bards as, 48; on capitalism, xiv; history and, 101, 121, 122–23, 139; as last traveler, 82; regimes of historicity constructed by, xvi, 8–9; task of, xv, xvii, 1, 16, 134–36, 144–45, 208n27; time and, 8, 81, 104–5; as witnesses, 115
Historical Essay (Chateaubriand), 66, 67, 68, 71, 220n7, 220n12; freedom in, 85–86; past, present, and future in, 73; time in, 79–81, 83, 90
Historical Studies (Chateaubriand), 80–81, 101
Historicity: approach, 208n28; connotations, xv, 9; divinatory knowledge and, 44–45; estrangement and, xv; self-estrangement and, 52; of societies, 24–28; see also Regimes of historicity
Historic monuments, 158, 161, 165, 180–81, 183
Histories (Herodotus), 70
History, 92; anthropology and, 9, 36; with arts and time, 174; bankruptcy of, 110, 129; “cold” societies and zero historical temperature, 24; cumulative, 14, 26, 112; ecclesiastical, 62; Germany with modern concept of, 73; global historical turning points, 210n55; of heritage concept, 151–55; heroic regimes and, 28–32, 36, 38; historians and, 101, 121, 122–23, 139; historical anthropology, 23–28, 36; islands of, 36, 38–39; justice and link to, 1–2; legend differentiated from, 215n5; memory and, 2, 6–7, 16, 102, 120–31; with modern regime’s crises, 104–7; from myth to event, 32–34; national, 127–28, 131–41; non-events-based, 33; The Odyssey as “first” historical narrative, 45, 49; orders of time and universal, 11–15; of present time, 8; of price, 13; repetition and, 71; scientific, 121, 138; social function of, 207n15; stationary, 26
A History of French Civilization (Duby and Mandrou), 138
History of Art in Antiquity (Winckelmann), 169–70, 177
History of Contemporary France (Lavisse), 125–26, 129, 140, 144
History of France (Bainville), 137–38
History of France (Burguière and Revel), 141
History of France (Lavisse), 136
History of France (Michelet), 120
History of Private Life (Ariès and Duby), 138
History of the Peloponnesian War (Thucydides), 32
History of the Political Institutions of Ancient France (Fustel de Coulanges), 134
The History of the French Population and Its Attitudes to Life Since the Eighteenth Century (Ariès), 138
Hobsbawm, Eric, 226n10
Hocart, Arthur Maurice, 29
Holocaust, 102, 121, 202
Homecomings, 44, 45, 53, 58
Homer, xvi, 11, 71, 82, 215n16; with narrative devices, 50; perpetual present and, 41–46, 54, 56; see also The Iliad; The Odyssey
Hone Heke, 34, 37, 41
Horace, 72, 109
The Horse of Pride (Hélias), 102
“Hot” societies, 8, 24, 27, 112, 127
The Hour of Our Death (Ariès), 138
Humanism, 13, 159, 168–69, 175, 190
Humanity: ages of, 86; crimes against, 8, 117, 171, 200–201
Human spirit, regeneration of, 174
Ibsen, Henrik, 110
Identity: European, 148; heritage and, 119, 151, 182; with memory, heritage, and commemoration, 119; narrative, 52; personal, 217n41
Identity of France (Braudel), 103, 133, 140
The Iliad (Homer), 43, 45, 53, 215n16, 218n49
Imitation, 152, 171, 177, 188; of ancients, 74, 92; dangers of, 75–76; of moderns, 74; proscribed, 104
The Immoralist (Gide), 110
The Imperative of Responsibility: In Search of an Ethics for the Technological Age (Jonas), 197
imprescriptibilité,” 117, 200–1
Indians, 69, 78, 83–84
Injustice, fortune’s, 165, 168
In Search of Lost Time (Proust), 128, 143
Instantaneism, 110
Institutions, archival, 116
Instruction of Year II, 173–74
Interpretation: of dreams, 12; historia magistra and new, 190
Iroquois, 78, 83, 84
Islands of History (Sahlins), 23–24, 28–38
Islands, of history, 36; see also Fiji; Hawaii; Polynesia
Israel, 60, 153
Italy, 107–8
Japan, 124, 154–55, 196
Jaucourt, Louis de, 70, 71
Jeanneney, Jean-Noël, 123, 231n71
Jesus Christ, 12, 61, 62, 153, 189, 240n65
Jetztzeit (presence of now), 129
Jews, 61; Holocaust and, 102, 121, 202; Israel and, 60, 153; with memory of past, 6–7
John the Evangelist, 169
Jonas, Hans, 196, 197–98, 199, 244n18
Julius II (Pope), 166
“Junkspace,” xix
Justice, 201; fortune’s injustice, 165, 168; history and, 1–2
Justin, 71, 72
Kamehameha (king of Hawaii), 36
Kant, Immanuel, 6, 15, 114, 198
Klein, Étienne, 206n5
Kleos (renown), 52, 53, 55
Knowledge, 156; of bards and historians, 48; divinatory, 44–45, 55; not knowing and, 56; sirens with language of, 218n48
Kohl, Helmut, 120
Koolhaas, Rem, xix
Koselleck, Reinhart, xvi, 9, 17, 39, 73, 104; see also Futures Past
Lafitau, Joseph-François, 68–69
Laïdi, Zaki, 208n28
Land treaties, 34–35
Lang, Jack, 181
Language, 24, 84, 89, 147; of knowledge and Sirens, 218n48; Latin, 109, 155, 162, 164; linguistic time, 211n57
Lanzmann, Claude, 6, 102
A Lapse of Memory (Segalen), 84
Latin, 109, 155, 162, 164
Lavisse, Ernest, 102, 125–26, 129, 136, 144
Leaves of Hypnos (Char), 4
Lectures on History (Volney), 92
Lefort, Claude, 27–28, 32, 37, 40, 42
Legacy, 172–75, 178, 198
Legends, 31, 43, 215n5
Le Goff, Jacques, 120–21, 147–48
Lenclud, Gérard, 9
Lenoir, Alexandre, 176–77
Leon X (Pope), 166
Letters to Miranda (Quatremère de Quincy), 170, 171
Levi, Primo, 202
Lévi-Strauss, Claude, 8, 9, 14–15, 37, 40, 67; cultural diversity and, 187; with eventfulness, 26–27; on historicity of societies, 24–26; savages and, 111–12; see also Race and History
Liberty, see Freedoms
Lieux de mémoire (Nora), 98, 102, 103, 106, 123, 126; commemorations and, 141–42; moment of, 143–48
Life, after death, 61, 134
Life of Rancé (Chateaubriand), 89
Linguistic time, 211n57
Listeners, 47, 50, 53–54, 121
Little Red Book (Mao), 5
Lives (Plutarch), 30, 31
Livy, Titus, 164
Logorio, Pirro, 171
Longue durée, 14, 16, 19, 103, 106
Lono (Hawaiian deity), 36
Loschi, Antonio, 164
Louis-Philippe (king of France), 180
Louis XVI (king of France), 161
Luther, Martin, 120
Lycurgus, 75
Magritte, René, 119
Majority, power of, 28
Makahiki rites, 36
Malraux, André, 111, 181, 183–84
Mandelstam, Ossip, 41
Mandrou, Robert, 138
Manifesto of the Futurist Painters, 108
Maoris, 32–35, 56, 195
Mao Tse Tung, 5
Mapping, of monuments, 165–66
Marie Louise of Austria (empress of France), xvii
Marinetti, Filippo Tommaso, 107–8, 110, 172, 203
Marrou, Henri-Irénée, 139
Marx, Karl, 6, 11, 76, 197
Mazon, Paul, 43
Media, 114–15, 124, 142–43, 227n11
Medieval Civilization (Le Goff), 148
Meiji Restoration, 154
Mémoires d’outre-tombe (Chateaubriand), xvii, 11, 66, 67, 106, 193–94
Memorials, 6, 85, 120, 184, 190–91
Memories of Odysseus, 18–19
Memory, 84, 98, 102; collective, 121–25, 187; commemorations and, 119–20, 141–43, 191; communism and, 208n25; heritage and, 11; history and, 2, 6–7, 16, 102, 120–31; Jews and past, 6–7; reconstructed, 119; site of, 6, 10, 85, 120, 125–27, 145–46, 153–54, 184; social thought and, 122; societies based on, 124; time and, xvi, 6; witness and, 7
Memory, History, Forgetting (Ricoeur), 2, 102
“Men of former times,” 46, 53–55, 73–74
Men of nature, 68, 71–72, 78
Mérimée, Prosper, 157, 180
Michaud, Éric, 110
Michelet, Jules, 82, 103, 120, 121, 124; with national histories, 132–33; with thread of tradition, 132, 185
Middle Ages, 13, 132, 148, 154, 157, 168
Millin, Louis Aubin, 161
Mimesis (Auerbach), 42
Mind, 57, 97, 109
The Mirror of Herodotus (Hartog), 18
Misunderstandings: from event to myth with working, 34–38; with Maori and British, 34–35; of present, 130
Mitterand, François, 114–15, 119–20
Modern: concept of history, 73; freedoms, 85–86; with regime’s crises, 104–8
Moderns: ancients and, 74, 76, 86–87, 107; ancients and sagaves, 66–67, 77; imitation and, 74
Momigliano, Arnaldo, 69
Monod, Gabriel, 135, 136, 148
Montaigne, Michel de, 107, 110, 167–68
Monuments: conservation of, 166–67; historic, 158, 161, 165, 180–81, 183; mapping of, 165–66
Moral Considerations on the Destination of Works of Art (Quatremère de Quincy), 176
Mortier, Roland, 156
Mos majorum, 62
Mourning: past and, 43–44, 46, 50, 216n31; Sirens and anti-, 53
Muses: bards inspired by, 49, 55; poets and, 48; with present, past, and future divinatory knowledge, 44; Sirens as counter-, 52–53
Museums, 118–19, 166, 171–73; with art pillaged, 175–79; Berlin Wall as object for, 185; degree zero, 188; eco-, 187–88; Versailles as, 179, 180
Musil, Robert, 123
Myths: cosmic, 31, 33; to event, 32–34; from event to myth, 34–38; Hawaii and political, 36
Nagy, Gregory, 216n33
Napoleon, xvii, 104, 107, 175
Narratives, 2; devices, 50; identity, 52; The Odyssey as “first” historical, 45, 49; utopian, 77
Narrator-poet, 49
Nations: consciousness of, 233n105; heritage of, 119; history of, 127–28, 131–41; society and, 130; unity of, 144
Nature: heritage and natural environment, 151–52, 187; societies compared to, 68, 70; see also Men of nature
Nausea (Sartre), 111
Nebuchadnezzar (King of Babylon), 12
Neufchâteau, François de, 175
New History (Le Goff, Chartier, and Revel), 121
New World, ruins in, 94–95; see also America
Nicholas V (pope), 166, 171
Nietzsche, Friedrich, 110
9/11, 104, 142–43, 150, 227n11
Non-events-based history, 33
Nora, Pierre, 6, 120–21; on acceleration of time, 124; commemorations and, 141–42; on heritage, 150; on historians and history, 123; with past and present, 142; with site of memory, 126–27; time and, 103; see also Lieux de mémoire
Nunism, 110
Oblivion, 52–55, 157, 220n7
Odysseus, xvi, 11, 18–19, 215n13; attention and, 58; Augustine compared to, 55–63; Chateaubriand and, 88; distension and, 57, 58; return of, 58; self-estrangement and, 50, 51–52; with Sirens’ call to oblivion, 52–55; tears of, 46–52, 58; as witness, 48, 55
The Odyssey (Homer): as “first” historical narrative, 45, 49; with The Iliad, 45, 53, 215n16; narrative devices in, 50; with Odysseus’s tears, 46–52, 58; past and present juxtaposed in, 54–55; perpetual present in, 41–46, 54, 56; with Sirens’ call to oblivion, 52–55
Old Testament, time in, 42–43, 224n94
Omnipresent, present as, 8
On the Concept of History (Benjamin), 129
On the Inconstancy of Fortune (Poggio Bracciolini), 164
Ophüls, Marcel, 102
Opinion polls, 115
Order of Discourse (Foucault), 2
Orders of time: Christianity and, 56, 59–63, 153–54; gaps in, 3–7; historical links to, 1–2; Judaism and, 60; from the Pacific to Berlin, 7–11; regimes of historicity and, 11–19; with universal histories and, 11–15
The Order of Time (Pomian), 2
Origins of Totalitarianism (Arendt), 5
Ornamentation, see Urban ornamentation
Ostrogoths, 160
“Other Times, Other Customs: The Anthropology of History” (Sahlins), 23
Othon, 75
Pacific, with orders of time, 7–11
Papon, Maurice, 117, 201, 230n53
Pascal, Blaise, 109–10
Past, xv; disorientation of, 3–5, 80; divinatory knowledge of, 44–45, 55; estrangement from, xvi; future and, 105, 109, 190, 194, 201–2; gap between future and, 5, 13, 53, 74, 88, 204; historia magistra vitae and, 38, 72–77; Jews and memory of, 6–7; Maori and, 33, 34; mourning and, 43–44, 46, 50, 216n31; The Odyssey with present juxtaposed with, 54–55; present and, 121, 142, 156, 194–95, 229n43; with present and future as single concept, 211n57; with presentist and historicist approaches, 208n28; time and objectification of, 2; see also Memory
Patrimony, 154, 236n16; see also Heritage
Paul (Saint), 163
Paul III (Pope), 166
Pausanias, 156–57
Paxton, Robert, 102
Péguy, Charles, 142, 231n80; on historians, 139; on history and memory, 128–29; on present, xvii, 194
Peripety, 30–31
Perpetual present: heroes and, 41–46, 54, 56, 58; ruins and, 208n28
Perrault, Charles, 65, 107
Personal identity, 217n41
Pétain, Philippe, 102
Peter (Saint), 163
Petit-Dutaillis, Charles, 137
Petrarch, Francesco, 163, 164
Philology, 164
Pillaging, of art, 175–79
Pirenne, Henri, xiv
Pius II (Pope), 166
Pleasure, death and listening, 53–54
Plotinus, 202–3
Plutarch, 30, 31, 104
Poets, 48, 49, 53
Poggio Bracciolini, Gian Francesco, 164–65, 166
Politics, 134; of environmental protections, 198–200; Hawaiian political myths, 36; of utopia, 197
Polls, opinion, 115
Polynesia, 32, 38, 106, 195, 213n36
Pomian, Krzysztof, 2, 152
Pommier, Edouard, 172
Pompidou Center, 118
Pompidou, Georges, 117
Poor, see “Annals of the poor”
Poussin, Nicolas, 89
Power: antiquities and, 166; Kamehameha and, 36; of majority, 28; of seers, 55
Praesens, 109
Praesentism, 110
Precautionary principle, 196–200, 245n19
Presence of now, see Jetztzeit
Present: autarchic, 208n28; Christianity and, 109–10; disorientation of, 3–5, 80; divinatory knowledge of, 44–45, 55; estrangement from, xvi; eternity and, 202–3; fault lines of, 114–20; with French Revolution and heritage, 170–80; future as threat to, xviii, 13, 191, 198; with heritage and ancients, 155–62; Historical Essay and, 73; history of present time, 8; misunderstandings of, 130; The Odyssey with past juxtaposed with, 54–55; as omnipresent, 8; past and, 121, 142, 156, 194–95, 229n43; with past and future as single concept, 211n57; perpetual, 41–46, 54, 56, 58, 208n28; presentism distinct from, xvii–xviii; Sirens as muses of anti-mourning in, 53
Presentism, 196; defined, 8, 18; “Generic City” and, xix; present distinct from, xvii–xviii; with presentist approach, 208n28; with regimes of historicity, xv; reign of, 193–204; rise of, 107–14
Preservation, restoration or, 155, 158
Price: history of, 13; listening pleasure with death as, 53–54
Primitive societies, 27, 32
Principles: of eventfulness, 27; precautionary, 196–200, 245n19
Prisoners: Papon and release, 230n53; of war, 140–41
Proscription, of imitation, 104
Protection, of environment, 115, 198–200
Proteus of Egypt, 73–74
Proust, Marcel, 127–28, 143, 180
Pucci, Pietro, 50
Quatremère de Quincy, Antoine-Chrysostome, 170–72, 175, 176, 178
La Querelle des Anciens et des Modernes, 107
Querrien, Max, 187–88, 242n118
Race and History (Lévi-Strauss), 14, 26, 27, 187
Raphael, 166–67
Rational catastrophism, 197, 244n10
Recognition, 39, 42, 45, 51, 54, 217n40
Recollection, 127–29, 222n52
Reconstruction, 5, 37, 119, 154
Record of a Journey from Paris to Jerusalem (Chateaubriand), 83
Reflections on Imitation (Winckelmann), 177
Reflections on the World Today (Valéry), 3
Regeneration, 172, 174–75
Regimes: connotations, xv; heroic, 28–32, 36, 38; modern regime’s crises, 104–7
Regimes of historicity: defined, xvi–xvii, 9, 15–17; gaps in time with, 3–7; heroic, 29; historians constructing, xvi, 8–9; orders of time and, 11–19; from the Pacific to Berlin, 7–11; presentism and, xv; relevancy of, 38; universal histories and, 11–15
Relativity, 14, 26, 27
Relics, 153, 154, 167
Renaissance, 157; historic monument and, 158; humanists and, 159, 168–69, 190; in Rome, 156, 162–68
Renovatio: defined, 168, 196; Enlightenment and, 203; of Rome, 163–65, 171, 190, 196
Renown, see Kleos
Repetition, 73–74, 137; historia magistra and, 91; history and, 71; Maori with events as, 33
Res Gestae (Augustus), 158
Responsibility, 197, 198, 199–201, 244n16
Restitution, 164, 175
Restoration, 176, 190; conservation and, 152, 175; Meiji, 154; preservation or, 155, 158; of Rome, 159, 165–66
Returns, 6, 99, 218n52; of Chateaubriand, 79; homecomings, 44, 45, 53, 58; to life of savage, 77, 111–12; of Odysseus, 58
Revel, Jacques, 121, 141
Revue Historique, 135
Rico, Francisco, 168
Ricoeur, Paul, 2, 60, 102, 217n40, 218n58; on historicity, 9; narrative identity and, 52; on responsibility, 198, 200, 244n16; see also Forgetting; History; Memory; Time and Narrative
Riegl, Alois, 157–58
Risk technology, 202
Rites, of Makahiki, 36
Rodin, Auguste, 180
Roland, Jean-Marie, 173
Rolin, Olivier, 5
Rollin, Charles, 71, 72
Roma instaurata (Rome Restored) (Biondo), 165
Rome: art in, 169, 171; heritage and, 155–56, 158–70; as home of antiquity, 171; Latin and, 164; Renaissance and, 156, 162–68; renovatio of, 163–65, 171, 190, 196; restoration of, 159, 165–66; ruins of, 165, 166–68; statues and, 169–70; as tomb, 168
Rome Restored, see Roma instaurata
Rosenzweig, Franz, 4, 109
Rousseau, Jean-Jacques, 24, 55, 67–68, 71, 76, 86
Rousso, Henry, 102
Royalty, archaic, 29–32
Ruins: in America, 94–95; Chateaubriand and, 89–95; Indian, 83; perpetual present and, 208n28; of Rome, 165, 166–68
Ruins; or, Meditation on the Revolutions of Empires (Volney), 90–91, 130
Rule, see Transfer of rule
Sahlins, Marshall, 8, 9; with anthropology and forms of temporality, 38–40; from event to myth and working misunderstandings, 34–38; heroic regime and, 28–32, 36, 38; with historical anthropology, 23–28, 36; from myth to event, 32–34; see also Islands of History
Saint Augustine and Aristotle, 60
Sartre, Jean-Paul, 23, 111
The Savage Mind (Lévi-Strauss), 24
Savages, 70, 77–79; ancients, and moderns and, 32, 66–69, 76; freedom of, 85–86; as interpretive vantage point, 86; as men of nature, 68, 71–72; return to the life of, 77, 111–12; time and, 82–84
“savage thought,” 112
Scharoun, Hans, 10
Scholem, Gershom, 4
Scientific history, 121, 138
Scott, Walter, 132
Scythians, 70–72, 76, 86
The Scythians (Voltaire), 70
Seers, 74; bards as, 48; power of, 55; with present, past, and future divinatory knowledge, 44–45, 55; as voyeurs, 48
Segal, Charles, 218n48
Segalen, Victor, 56, 84
Self-estrangement, 50, 51–52, 55
Semiophores, 152, 154, 162, 175, 189
Shoah (film), 6, 102
Simiand, François, 130, 146
Simultaneism, 110
Sirens: call to oblivion, 52–55; as counter-Muses, 52–53; with language of knowledge, 218n48; in present as muses of anti-mourning, 53
Site: defined, 126; of memory, 6, 10, 85, 120, 125–27, 145–46, 153–54, 184
Sixtus IV (pope), 166
Slavery, ages of, 74
Social function, of history, 207n15
Social space, 185
The Social Contract (Rousseau), 68
Social thought, 122
Société ‘sans histoire’ et historicité” (“Societies ‘without history’ and historicity”) (Lefort), 27
Societies, 228n32; changes in French, 243n119; “cold,” 8, 24–26; historicity of, 24–28; “hot,” 8, 24, 27, 112, 127; memory-based, 124; nations and, 130; nature compared to, 68, 70; primitive, 27, 32; social forms, 31
“Societies ‘without history’ and historicity”; see Société ‘sans histoire’ et historicité”
Solon, xiv
Some Ideas on the Arts, on the Need to Support Them, on the Institutions Which Can Ensure Their Progress, and on Various Institutions Necessary for Their Teaching, 174
The Sorrow and the Pity (Ophüls), 102
Space: “junkspace,” xix; social, 185
Sparta, 76, 78
Spengler, Oswald, 11, 13
Stationary history, 26
Statues: communist-era, 208n25; death and uprooting of, 171–72; in dreams, 12; Greek, 171; Roman, 169–70
Stocking, George W., 208n28
Stoicism, 109
Strabo, 72
Structuralism, 24, 28, 38, 213n36
Suetonius, 158, 163
Supplement to the Voyage of Cook (Sahlins), 24
Sustainable development, 186–87, 199, 200, 245n21
The Swan (Baudelaire), 50
Syria, 90
Le système de l’histoire (Bonnaud), 210n55
Tableau de la géographie de la France (Vidal de la Blache), 125
Tacitus, 74–75, 79, 89
Tahiti, 223n84
Tane (separator of Earth and Heaven), 35
Tears, of Odysseus, 46–52, 58
Technology, 6, 197, 198, 202
Temporality, anthropology and, 38–40
Testament, 4–5, 75, 174–75
Thakombau (Fijian leader), 29, 42
Theodoric (Ostrogoth king), 160
Theory, of relativity, 14, 26
Thermidorian Reaction, 75
Thiénot, J., 122
Thierry, Augustin, 101, 132, 136
Thomas, Nicholas, 39
Thomas, Yan, 159–60, 166, 201
Thread of tradition, 132, 185
Threat, of future, xviii, 13, 191, 198
Thucydides, 32, 33, 121, 142
Time, 23, 69, 110, 128, 143; acceleration of, 80, 123–24, 178, 190, 231n71; Achilles with, 218n51; with arts and history, 174; attention and, 57; Augustine with, 57; Chateaubriand and, 65–66, 79–81, 103, 106, 194; chronic and linguistic, 211n57; disorientation of, 3–5, 80; of environment with heritage, 186–91; estrangement from, 42–43; experience of, 79–81; gaps in, 3–7, 88, 106; historians and, 8, 81, 104–5; in Historical Essay, 79–81, 83, 90; history of present, 8; Indians and, 83; memory and, xvi, 6; mind and, 57; Nora and, 103, 124; in Old Testament, 42–43, 224n94; with past objectified, 2; of ruins, 208n28; savages and, 83–84; with temporality and anthropology, 38–40; in three modes, xvi; of traveling, 81–89; unanchored, 78–79; see also Future; Orders of time; Past; Present; Presentism
Time and Narrative (Ricoeur), 2, 217
Time: Histories and Ethnologies, 39
Tocqueville, Alexis de, 93–95, 98
Tomb, Rome as, 168; see also Mémoires d’outre-tombe
Tonga, 30
Tourism, 113, 167, 188–89
Touvier, Paul, 117
Toxaris, 70
Toynbee, Arnold J., 11
Tradition, 132, 185
Tragedy, 31, 49, 76
Trajan’s Column, 160
Transfer of rule, 13, 164
Travel: Chateaubriand and, 66–72; historians as last travelers, 82; time of, 81–89
Travel Diary (Montaigne), 167
Travels in America (Chateaubriand), 66, 67–68; ancients and savages in, 77; freedom in, 85–86; time of traveling and time in, 81–89; unanchored time in, 78–79
Travels of Anacharsis the Younger in Greece (Barthélemy), 70
Treaties, land, 34–35
“trente glorieuses,” 108
Tristes tropiques (Lévi-Strauss), 67, 111
Tukhe (Fortune), 30
Unanchored time, 78–79
Unemployment, xiii, 112, 113
UNESCO, 14, 15, 26, 150, 186–87
Unity, national, 144
Untimely Meditations (Nietzsche), 110
Uprisings, of Hone Heke, 34
Urban development projects, 117–19, 182
Urban ornamentation, 159–60, 166
Utopia, 77, 197
Valéry, Paul, 3, 13, 104, 110, 137, 207n11; Febvre on, 228n31; with future, 227n12
Valla, Lorenzo, 164
Varro, Marcus Terentius, 162, 163, 165, 190
Venice Charter of 1964, 182, 183
Versailles, 179, 180
Vespasian, 158
Veyne, Paul, 159
Vichy France: Old Guard and New Order, 1940–1944 (Paxton), 102
The Vichy Syndrome: History and Memory in France Since 1944 (Rousso), 102
Vico, Giambattista, 29, 38, 41, 133
Vidal-Naquet, Pierre, 102
Viewing from afar, 37, 55, 68, 77
View of the Climate and Soil of the United States of America (Volney), 92
Viollet-le-Duc, 180, 236n14
Volney, Constantin-François, 90–92, 130, 225n105
Voltaire, 11, 70
Von Stein, Lorenz, 101
Voyeurs, seers as, 48
Walzer, Michael, 60
War, prisoner of, 140–41
Washington, George, 78
Weber, Max, xvi
Winckelmann, Johann Joachim, 169–70, 171, 177–78
Witnesses, 7, 48, 55, 115, 229n48
World, 3, 4; ages of, 12–13, 74; heritage, 6, 150, 186–87; New, 94–95
The World of Yesterday (Zweig), 4
Yerushalmi, Yosef, 6–7
Zakhor (Yerushalmi), 6–7
Zalmoxis, 70
Zero: “cold” societies and historical temperature of, 24; degree zero museum, 188; growth, 5
Zweig, Stefan, 4