Love doesn’t have to be complicated.
—Excerpt from Finding Mr. Right-for-You by Dr. Kate
“It shouldn’t be too long.” Lucas opened the door for Sydney. “I’ll call you when it’s finished.”
“Feel free to call before then if you have any questions.” Sydney’s smile indicated a call would be welcome, questions or not.
With nothing more than a polite nod, Lucas let the door close and wiped his hands on his jeans. He appreciated the business—she was giving him plenty—but the woman had the subtlety of a shark in a fish pool. He had little respect for a woman who ignored a man’s wedding band. Did she even care that he belonged to someone else?
You’re only a name on a wedding certificate, man.
His eyes wandered up the staircase to Kate’s office. Would she mind if he interrupted her work? He hated to admit it, but he’d missed having lunch with her. Missed the way she wiped her lips after every bite. Missed the way she separated the food on her plate so nothing touched.
Mostly, he missed listening to her talk about her work. At first glance, some might think Kate’s career was self-serving. But if they heard her talk about people—heard the excitement in her voice when she helped someone—they’d know differently.
It was quiet upstairs, not even the clacking of her computer keys. Maybe she was taking a break. Lucas took the stairs, glad for the opportunity to shake the cloying cloud of Sydney’s perfume.
When he reached the second floor, her office chair was empty. A colorful screensaver danced on the computer, indicating she hadn’t been typing for some time. Strange—he knew she was there; her car was out front.
He was about to call for her when he saw movement at the back of the building, through her old apartment doorway. He walked the length of the rug—and stopped. Beyond the coffee table, Kate lay flat as a mat on the floor. Her head faced the wall, ear to the floor—or was that the vent? One hand clutched the hair at her nape, pulling her cream-colored suit coat up at the waist. Her pants hugged the curve of her derrière, and the tops of her feet skimmed the floor.
What in the world? Why would she be lying over the—
Realization washed over him, cool and refreshing, and his lips slowly curved into a smile.
Oh yeah. This was going to be good.
Lucas leaned against the door frame, crossing his arms, biding his time. Finally, when she didn’t budge, he cleared his throat.
Kate jumped, turned toward him, letting loose of her hair. The air must have kicked on because a blast blew a strand across her face.
“Looking for something?” He almost felt sorry for her as she scrambled into a sitting position. But the look on her face was too comical, and the feelings her jealousy inspired, too heartening.
“Lucas. I was just—” She dusted her suit coat, working her flattened fingers down the length of her arm in short swipes. “My earring.” She held out a circular piece of jewelry lying in her palm. “I was getting my earring.”
Who was she kidding? She’d been lying flat on the floor, her ear against the register. She was caught. Nailed. Busted.
“Did it fall down the vent?” He held back a smile, barely.
Her cheeks bloomed with color as she attempted to put the earring in. Even across the room he could see her hand shaking. “Of course not. It just—” Kate tried again to poke the earring through the hole and failed. She gave up and looked at him like a butterfly caught in a net.
He raised his brows, waiting.
At that, her shoulders drew back, her chin tipped. “All right, all right,” she snapped. “You made your point.”
Lucas approached her, feeling sorry for her now that she knew she was caught. Still, there was that whole jealousy thing that tugged the corners of his mouth.
Kate set her earring on the coffee table and struggled to stand. When he extended his hand, she smacked it away, her eyes narrowing as she straightened. Her crisp white shirt had come loose from her waistband, and her hair was tousled like she’d just awakened. She smoothed it and tucked it behind her ears with quick hands.
“I saw you after lunch with that . . . woman,” Kate said. “I was worried about how it might look to other people.” She crossed her arms over her chest. “We have an image to maintain, and it’s not proper for you to be gallivanting all over the island with someone else.”
Her words were so ridiculous he didn’t know where to begin. “Gallivanting?”
She looked him in the eye. “You know what I mean. People will notice when you’re eating with another woman. It’s a small island—”
“I didn’t eat with Sydney.” Was that really what was bugging Kate? What everyone else thought? The notion sucked some of the air from his sails.
“Well, whatever. It’s not proper for you to be seen with someone like that.” Her lips, free of artificial color, pressed together.
Was she only concerned about her reputation, or was she hiding her jealousy behind its mask? “Someone like what?” he asked, curious to hear her answer.
“Someone like—You know what I mean. She isn’t exactly unattractive, and she’s . . . clingy.”
“Clingy?”
“Like socks out of the dryer,” she retorted. She tilted her head. “You know exactly what I mean.”
Lucas lost the tug-of-war with his smile. “You’re jealous,” he said.
Kate turned away, tucking in her shirt before grabbing the earring off the table and walking toward a mirror that hung over the armchair. “I’m concerned about my reputation.” She took the back off the earring and put it in.
“And that’s why you were spying through the vent?” It didn’t wash. If she were concerned about gossip, she would confront him, not eavesdrop.
Her eyes met his in the mirror. “I’m just trying to protect my career.” He walked closer until he was behind her. “Is that what you’re telling yourself?”
Her hands fell slowly to her sides. In the light of the window to the side of the mirror, her eyes sparkled. He wanted to get lost in there. Better yet, he wanted to climb behind those eyes and see what was holding her back.
Did she love Bryan still? He reviewed their kiss for the hundredth time and felt his confidence climb. A woman didn’t kiss a man like that when she was in love with someone else. Maybe she’d never been in love with Bryan.
All Lucas knew was she had some kind of feelings for him.
“Why are you so afraid to be honest with yourself?” he asked.
Kate stared back. “I’m not afraid.”
Her bravado seemed to have shrunk two sizes. He wanted to reach out and wrap his arms around her, pull her against him as he had on the sailboat. But he had a feeling he didn’t dare move or she’d run.
“Why can’t you admit you’re jealous? It’s not a crime.” He found the courage to open up. Someone had to. “When Bryan called last week, I was jealous.”
Something in her face softened. Her lips parted to speak. Then, as if she thought better of it, they sealed again.
Why was it so hard to admit something was happening between them? They had almost ten more months together. Would it hurt to explore the feelings?
“There’s something here, and you know it,” he said.
She blinked, her eyes fastened on his for just a split second before she walked away. “Stop it, Lucas. Leave things as they are.” She stopped behind the barrier of the sofa.
Heaven forbid she let her guard down. “All neat and tidy, you mean?”
“What’s wrong with neat and tidy? Neat and tidy is simple and clear-cut, and nobody gets hurt.”
“Is that what’s got you worried?” Was she still nursing wounds Bryan had inflicted? Couldn’t she see he’d never forsake her as Bryan had? He always wanted to be there for her. To protect her. To cherish her. To love her.
“Nobody likes to get hurt.”
He held the image of her on their wedding night. Remembered the sound of her sobbing in that big empty bed. “I’m not the one who left you at the altar,” he said gently.
Kate wrapped her arms around her stomach. “Look, it just—It just won’t work between us. We’re too different. Completely incompatible, for heaven’s sake. I’ve seen what happens too many times.”
Did she think feelings were planned? Scheduled and carried out like entries on her color-coded calendar? “There’s never been another you and me. You can’t compare us to some couple you counseled in your office.”
“I don’t have to look any further than my parents to strike a comparison.”
Something in her tone alerted him. “What about your parents?”
“They argued constantly. Good grief, they were like hot and cold, hard and soft, and whatever other opposites you can think of. I can still close my eyes at night and hear their bickering.”
It was starting to make sense now. Her passion for helping others find a compatible mate. Her parents had divorced, possibly damaging her greatly, and now she was out to save the world. “Is that why you do it?”
“Do what?”
“Counsel others. Help people find their soul mate.”
She rolled her eyes. “Huh. I don’t believe in soul mates. I believe in helping women find a compatible mate whose values and personality line up with hers.”
“All neat and tidy.”
“We can’t all live a messy, jumbled life.”
Is that the way she saw his life? Like a chaotic heap of garbage?
“It might not be pretty to look at, but I found love nonetheless.”
It was out before he could stop it. His heart skipped a beat.
The look on Kate’s face made him glad he’d risked it. The way her eyes widened ever so slightly before she looked down at her fingers curled around the sofa’s cushion. Was it awe or joy he’d seen before she looked away?
“I didn’t mean to disregard what you had with Emily. I’m sorry.”
Emily. She thought he was talking about Emily. The disappointment was keen. Hadn’t he shown her his feelings these weeks they’d had together? Even if he hadn’t said them. Apparently, he’d been too subtle. Or she just didn’t want to see the truth.
She was waiting for his response. “Don’t worry about it,” he said, feeling like a fool. She didn’t want anything between them; she’d made that clear. Maybe he wasn’t the kind of man she wanted. Maybe she was waiting to be with Bryan.
For the first time he wondered if he’d ever be able to change her mind.