As he filed the rough edges of a new trigger he’d made for a cavalry carbine, Duncan McPherson gloomily supposed he should feel fortunate. His skill as a gunsmith had won him the unofficial post of armorer for two of the cavalry companies stationed at Chihuahua. He was treated as a competent craftsman by most of the officers and men, and he earned enough money to support himself. That was well and good, but he still wasn’t free to leave, and he was virtually alone. His friend, Tom House, had died and he rarely saw any of the other Nolan men—most had married or moved to other towns.
Things could be worse, Duncan mused, but here I am nearly twenty-six, and it looks like I’ll be here till I die. He wore the typical white cotton shirt, loose-fitting pantaloons, and juaraches, or sandals. But for his height, his blue eyes, his long blond hair streaked with brown, and his reddish beard, he looked like any Mexican artisan.
He did have one trusted friend, mestizo Sergeant Francisco Munóz, who was about the same age but half a head shorter. He was stocky and powerful, with a bushy mustache and twinkling, mischievous eyes, at least when off duty. Like others of mixed Spanish-Indian ancestry, his skin was swarthy. He was, Duncan knew, an excellent cavaliyman, or he’d never have made sergeant.
In the late fall of 1810, Spanish Major Franco, the only officer who was consistently hostile to Duncan, stalked into his shop, a small room off the cavalry barracks. From the lingering aroma, Duncan suspected that it had been a place where drunken soldiers forsook their sins and recovered their wits. Scowling, Franco thrust a pistol toward Duncan, who took it without looking up. He saw the hammer was bent.
“Fix it, peón," Franco snapped. Duncan laid it on his work-table, while Franco stood there still scowling, his trim mustache twitching.
“When do you need it?” Duncan asked, resisting the temptation to shove it down his throat.
“Immediately, you ass. Why do you think I brought it here myself?”
Duncan rubbed his finger along the bent hammer. “It’s cracked,” he said. “I’ll have to replace it.”
“All you need to do is put it in your vise and straighten it,” Franco growled.
Duncan shrugged and put the hammer in his vise. When he tightened it, the hammer snapped. “I told you it was cracked,” he said.
“You clumsy fool! You did that on purpose,” Franco snarled. He stepped forward to slap him, but the look in Duncan’s eyes stopped him. “I’ll send for it tomorrow,” he muttered. “See that you have it ready.” He spun around and left.
Duncan was standing by his bench, still cursing in both Spanish and English when Muñoz entered a short time later, his eyes wide, his face animated. He looked at Duncan in surprise. “What’s the matter?” he asked. “You look mad enough to kill.”
“I am. That son of a bitch Franco was just here,” he replied. Muñoz swore.
“That Gachupin!” he spat. “He hates all Americans. Of course he hates all Mexicans, too. But forget about him. We’ve had big news from the south. A padre named Hidalgo started an Indian tumulto in September, the biggest ever. They say it’s spreading to the rest of the country,” he said, extending his arms.
“What do they want?” Duncan asked, sitting again on his rough bench. Muñoz straddled it and sat facing him, unbuttoning his cavalry jacket to scratch his ribs.
“They say it started as a creole plot to declare independence at the annual fair, when so many people would be there they could overwhelm the Gachupines. But someone betrayed the plotters, and the viceroy ordered them arrested. One, an army officer named Allende, got wind of the arrests and rode to Dolores to warn Hidalgo. Instead of fleeing, Hidalgo called out the Indians. Although they had only clubs and machetes at first, they won several victories. Their war cry is ‘Independence and death to the Gachupines,' but to them Gachupines are creoles as well as Spaniards from Spain.” He paused to catch his breath, while Duncan stared at him and waited to hear more.
“What it means,” Muñoz continued more calmly, his expression solemn, “is that what started as a creole movement for independence is now a war of Indians against the rest of the people. Creoles, even those who hoped for independence, now may have no choice but to fight for the Spaniards just to save their own skins, although some are still with Hidalgo.”
“That’s bad news,” Duncan said, shaking his head. “Mexico should be independent. It’s been a colony too long.”
“We will be independent one day,” Muñoz said, lowering his voice. “Maybe not this time, but the idea won’t die.” He went on to say that Hidalgo had sent Mariano Jiménez, a young creole mining engineer who’d proved a capable commander, to spread the revolution into Coahuila and Texas. “That means among settlers, not Indians. If he succeeds, it will be a different kind of war after that,” he added, “and it just might succeed.” Duncan shrugged, for he couldn’t see how it might affect him.
The next news Muñoz brought was that royalist General Calleja had crushed and scattered Hidalgo’s Indian horde at Calderón. Hidalgo, Allende, and the rest of the officers were retreating northward with what was left of the army, but the disaster at Calderón discouraged the insurgents, and many had given up the fight.
“It probably will be easy for the royalists to stamp out the little fires before they can revive and spread,” Muñoz said somberly. “I expect that General Salcedo will send some of us to Coahuila to help. Any change from garrison duty is usually welcome, but not this time. I don’t like the idea of killing my countrymen for the Gachupines."
“I don’t blame you. I’d be glad to fight for your people, but not against them.”
A few days later Muñoz came again to see Duncan. “Both of our companies will march to Coahuila shortly to support Colonel Cordero,” he told Duncan. “Since my troop is not at full strength, I have permission to take any of the Nolan men who are willing to serve, and of course, I want you. It may be the best chance you’ll ever have to leave Chihuahua. What do you say?”
Duncan thought about it, his forehead wrinkled. If he served in the army, there’d be no excuse for holding him when the fighting was over. And once away from Chihuahua, he’d have a better chance to escape. The only drawback was the prospect of having to fight Mexican patriots, but that was a risk he’d have to take.
“I’m with you, amigo," he told the smiling Muñoz. “But I know nothing about fighting on horseback. Where I come from, we fight behind trees.”
Muñoz chuckled at that. “It will take nearly a month to reach Saltillo,” he replied, “and in that time I can teach you enough to get by, then we can go on from there. Let’s see the quartermaster and get you a uniform.”
The quartermaster’s clerk looked Duncan up and down and shook his head. “I don’t know what I have that will fit you,” he said. He went into a storeroom and returned with a blue shirt, jacket, and pants, as well as boots and a black hat. “These are the largest I could find,” he said apologetically.
Duncan tried the pants first, and all three laughed when he pulled them up as far as he could, which wasn’t nearly far enough. He got the shirt on with difficulty, but he couldn’t move his arms forward, and the sleeves reached only to the middle of his forearms. He managed to button the jacket partway. He got the boots on after a struggle, and figured they’d stretch. Only the hat fit perfectly.
“I’ve never seen a soldier wearing only hat and boots,” he said. “What can we do?”
Muñoz laughed, “That would make everyone notice you,” he said, “but bring it along. I know a seamstress who can add inserts and make it fit. Then let’s cut your hair.”
The uniform was ready shortly before they marched a few days later, in mid-December. Duncan felt strange wearing a Spanish uniform and riding in a cavalry troop. Major Franco was in command, but if he recognized Duncan, he gave no sign. Duncan thought of the long ride from Saltillo to Chihuahua years ago, when Nolan’s men were prisoners. All he remembered was crossing a desert that had seemed endless. The trail led across open sandy places, through rocky arroyos, and around or between hills and buttes, on and on, with more of the same. The vegetation was cactus and scraggly, oily bushes, but cottonwoods and willows flourished along streams and around waterholes. The only living creatures Duncan saw were occasional coyotes, jack rabbits, and scrawny buzzards watching the troops in hope that some of them would provide a feast.
When they were only a few days from Saltillo, a Spanish captain rode up at a trot, and the column halted while he reported to Franco. Muñoz’ troop was first in line that day, close enough for Duncan to overhear most of what the captain said.
“Colonel Cordero’s militia and a company of us regulars marched to meet the rebel Jiménez at Aguanueva,” he explained. “The rebels had infected the militia with their lies, and Captain Elizondo and the lot of them defected to Jiménez. I was fortunate to escape, but they captured Colonel Cordero and then entered Saltillo. Hidalgo and Allende probably have joined them by now. Other rebels under Aranda control Monclova. Only Presidio Río Grande still holds out.”
Duncan wiped the dust from around his eyes with a handkerchief, wondering what he’d gotten into. The officers talked among themselves for a few minutes, then Franco ordered the troops to march to Presidio Río Grande. There was no trail, so they strung out in a single file to avoid getting speared by cactus. A long cloud of dust hung over them.
Nearly a week later, the nervous presidio commander welcomed them, for he expected a rebel attack any day and was greatly relieved to have reinforcements. Riders passing from one town to another frequently stopped at the presidio to tell the latest news or rumors. With little to do except occasional patrols, Muñoz taught Duncan how to use a lance effectively.
At the end of January 1811, a party of royalist fugitives from San Antonio brought the bad news that a militia captain named Las Casas had arrested the governor—Colonel Salcedo—and Colonel Herrera, and sent them as prisoners to the rebel chieftains in Coahuila. Men from Saltillo reported that Jiménez had promoted Elizondo from captain to lieutenant colonel, but when Elizondo petitioned Allende to promote him to brigadier general, he had been refused. Although he was sulking over his rejection, they said, Jiménez had sent him to guard Salcedo and Herrera on a hacienda near San Fernando.
Duncan was thrilled to know that all of Texas was in rebel hands. If he could elude the royalists and get to San Antonio, he could ride on to Natchitoches without difficulty. “What do you think?” he asked Munñz. “Any chance I could make it to San Antonio?”
Muñoz shook his head. “I’m sure the Major would send both companies after you, and they’d overtake you and shoot you on sight. And if you ran into patriots while in a Spanish uniform, you can guess what they’d do. Those aren’t very good choices,” he added, his eyes twinkling.
“You’re probably right as usual,” Duncan admitted, frowning, “but....”
“Be patient, my friend,” Muñoz advised him. “Don’t risk leaving until you’re absolutely sure your way is clear. You’re safe here, and there’s no sense in getting yourself killed. Right now things are changing too fast.”
Early in March, a courier from San Antonio brought word that royalists there had arrested Las Casas and restored control over Texas. “You sure gave me good advice,” Duncan told Munñz. “If I’d gotten to San Antonio, I’d have landed right in the middle of it.” He drew his finger across his throat and grimaced.
Royalists from Saltillo reported that Hidalgo, Allende, and Jiménez had held a council of war and then turned over what was left of the army to Ignacio Rayón. It was rumored, they said, that the three were planning to head for the United States with about four hundred men to guard a pack train canying silver bars for purchasing arms and recruiting men.
A messenger from San Fernando brought more startling news. Piqued at Allende’s refusal to promote him, Elizondo had allowed Salcedo to win him back to the royalist side. He raised a militia company and at night, surprised rebel governor Aranda in Monclova, capturing him along with dispatches from Jiménez detailing plans for the expedition to the United States. Franco and the two cavalry companies hastened to Monclova. I’m on the wrong side, Duncan glumly thought, but what can I do about it?
In Monclova they joined Elizondo’s militia, and Munñz soon learned Elizondo’s plans. “Jiménez doesn’t know, of course, that Elizondo has changed sides again,” he explained to Duncan. “He wrote Jiménez that he’d meet them with an honor guard at the Wells of Baján on March 21. That’s the only water between Saltillo and Monclova. Elizondo is a slimy one. He recommended that they arrive in separate groups, not all at once, so there’ll be enough water. If they do that, they haven’t a chance.”
“I don’t like the smell of it,” Duncan said, clenching his fists. “It’s the lowest kind of treachery. Isn’t there any way we can warn them?”
“No,” Muñoz replied, “Elizondo has men watching the trail. There’s nothing we can do, unfortunately. I wish there was.”
On March 20 Elizondo, who was obviously gloating in anticipation, marched them along the desert trail to the Wells of Baján to set his trap. The trail from Saltillo wound around a low hill to the wells. In the morning, Elizondo posted fifty mounted militiamen in two lines to act as the honor guard, while the rest of the militia and the troops under Franco waited out of sight, ready to seize and disarm the unsuspecting rebels after they passed between the lines.
At mid-morning, the rebels began arriving in small groups. Duncan watched, feeling sick as they were easily disarmed. Hidalgo, who was riding in a carriage, looked shocked, as if he couldn’t believe Elizondo was capable of such treachery. At dark, Colonel Salcedo arrived with several hundred more militiamen. There was now no possibility that the rebels could make a break with the slightest hope of success.
In the morning they herded the disconsolate prisoners back over the desert trail to Monclova. Then, leaving Herrera in command, Salcedo and the two cavalry companies set out with the rebel officers on the long journey to Chihuahua. As he rode with Muñoz and his troop, Duncan sadly observed the white-haired Hidalgo, whose pale countenance remained serene. Allende and Jiménez, both young men, were surely aware of the fate that awaited them, but they appeared to regret failing in their fight for independence more than having to face a firing squad. They wouldn’t actually face it, Duncan knew, for they’d be forced to kneel facing a wall to be shot in the back as traitors. Duncan greatly admired them, and wished the rebels would come to their rescue. His own prospects weren’t promising, for if the cavalry remained at Chihuahua, his chances of escaping were gone.
When they finally reached Chihuahua with the prisoners, General Salcedo smiled in grim satisfaction. He named his nephew, Colonel Salcedo, president of the military court that would try the culprits. The trials of the lower ranking officers began within two weeks. They were speedily found guilty, and executions immediately followed. In June, Allende and Jiménez were tried and shot, and on July 29 Hidalgo shared their fate. Duncan felt nauseated every time he heard the firing squad. The royalists called these men traitors and worse, but to Duncan they were patriots who deserved a better fate.
Duncan was greatly relieved when the two cavalry companies under Franco were ordered to escort Colonel Salcedo back to Monclova and then march to Saltillo, where Colonel Cordero was again in command. Saltillo was high enough that the nights were pleasantly cool, and although it was surrounded by desert, wherever there were irrigated farms Duncan saw flourishing orchards and green fields.
After the execution of Hidalgo and Allende, the royalists celebrated the end of the revolution, but rebels still controlled most of Nuevo León and Nuevo Santander to the east of Coahuila. In the south Morelos and other rebel leaders were winning victories. The revolution was not yet dead, but Elizondo had struck it a near-fatal blow.
Colonel Cordero, who was in his early fifties, was fairly tall and well-built, with a fair complexion and blue eyes. He was, Duncan learned, an ideal cavalryman and widely respected as a gallant and generous officer. His devotion to Spain and its monarch was obvious. Duncan had to admire him even though he was a staunch royalist who considered the rebels vile traitors to their king, not the heroic patriots their people regarded them.
No organized rebels remained in Coahuila, but since they still controlled most of Nuevo León and Neuvo Santander to the east, the cavalry patrolled the border to prevent them from infecting Coahuila again. Texas was still under royalist domination. Duncan glumly wondered if he’d ever have an opportunity to reach the States.
In the fall of 1812, a courier from Colonel Salcedo brought word that a long-expected invasion of Texas from the United States had begun, and the news caused a flurry of excitement. Four or five hundred Americans and Tejanos under the Mexican rebel, Bernardo Gutiérrez, and the former American army officer, Augustus William Magee, were besieged at La Bahía, and Salcedo called on other provinces for support. Only Colonel Cordero responded—he sent his best militia company and several barrels of gunpowder. Duncan was elated to learn of the invasion. If Americans conquered Texas, he had only to watch for a safe opportunity to join them. In the meantime he rode on cavalry patrols, and under Muñoz’ tutelage, became a competent cavalryman.
Duncan was relieved, in fact, whenever the troop was sent on patrol. News that Americans had joined Gutiérrez in the invasion of Texas had infuriated the Spanish officers, especially Major Franco. Once afternoon when Duncan walked past the Major and other officers on his way to the barracks, Franco loudly proclaimed, “All Americanos in Mexico should be shot like the dogs they are! ” Duncan knew the words were meant for him, but he kept walking as if he’d heard nothing.
Muñoz, who had also heard Franco, was troubled. “Watch your step around that Gachupin, amigo,” he warned Duncan. “He wouldn’t need much of an excuse to have you shot.”
“I know,” Duncan replied, slapping his hat against his leg to remove the dust. “I’m not goin’ to give him an excuse, but I figure he won’t be satisfied until he finds some way to do me in. I’ve got to get away somehow.” But that was impossible.
In late April 1813, fugitives from San Antonio brought dire news for the royalists. Salcedo and Herrera had been forced to lift the siege of La Bahia and withdraw to San Antonio. The Gutiérrez-Magee army had followed and routed them, and it now controlled all of Texas. Resentful Tejanos, whose fathers or brothers Salcedo had executed simply because they had received rebel broadsides and admitted favoring independence, had seized Salcedo, Herrera, and a dozen other royalist officers and assassinated them. Later, other royalist fugitives from San Antonio reported that the Americans and Tejanos had fallen out over the killing of the prisoners, and that many Americans had left Texas in disgust. There goes my chance to escape, Duncan thought.
All of the officers were greatly aroused over the brutal murders, and Duncan shivered when he saw Franco glaring at him like he’d been responsible. A short time later, two infantrymen entered the barracks and marched up to Duncan.
“You must come with us,” one said.
“Why?” Muñoz demanded to know. “He’s in my troop.”
“He’s under arrest.”
“What for and on whose orders?”
The soldier shrugged. “Who knows what for? Major Franco’s orders.”
Apprehensive over what the Major might have in store for him, Duncan walked between the two soldiers to the guardhouse, where he was thrown in with several sullen prisoners. They were fed a little gruel mornings and evenings, and given water. They could either stand or lie on filthy mats, for there were no benches. Duncan recalled the dungeon in San Luis Potosi and shuddered at the thought of being imprisoned and forgotten again. As the next few days passed, prisoners were released and others took their places. Munñz came to see Duncan one afternoon, but there was no way they could speak in private.
“Courage, amigo,” Muñoz said. “I’m doing what I can.” Duncan shrugged. What could a mestizo sergeant do against a major from Spain? I’m doomed, he thought.
Nevertheless, a few days later, Duncan was released and allowed to return to the barracks. Overwhelmed by a feeling of relief, he bathed and washed his shirt in a nearby stream. Late in the afternoon, while he waited for his shirt to dry, Muñoz returned from a patrol.
“You did it,” Duncan said, crushing his hand. “I never thought you could. Tell me how.”
Muñoz looked up at him, but his eyes weren’t twinkling. “Major Franco had you locked up for no stated reason,” he said. “I suspect he was trying to drum up some charge that would have gotten you put away for good. It wasn’t easy, but through Sergeant Castillos of headquarters company, I got word to one of Cordero’s creole aides who dislikes the Major. Cordero called the Major in and told him all soldiers are needed, and none was to be punished for frivolous reasons.” He paused and looked thoughtful. “Sooner or later the Major will figure out that I had something to do with it. Then we’ll both have to watch out for him, but at least he’ll leave you alone for the present.”
Duncan put on his shirt, which was nearly dry. “We need to get to San Antonio,” he said. Let’s make a run for it while we can.”
Muñoz’ eyes opened wide. “Don’t even consider it,” he said. “The Major would like nothing better than to run us down and hang us. Besides, Arredondo has sent Colonel Elizondo with seven hundred militia to the Frío to watch the Americans, and we’d never get through. Arredondo has finished mopping up the patriots east of us, and he’s preparing to march to Texas. And from what I hear, he doesn’t take prisoners.” Duncan frowned. He was almost willing to risk everything just to get away.
“Wait till you hear this!” Muñoz exclaimed a few days later. “Arredondo ordered Elizondo not to cross the Frío or to engage in battle for any reason, but fugitives from San Antonio told him the Americans had all left and the people would welcome him. So he disobeyed Arredondo and marched to San Antonio, then ordered the rebels to surrender Gutiérrez and other leaders. A few hundred royalists joined him, so he felt confident. But the Americans and Tejanos came out and thrashed him. He abandoned his artillery and everything else. I hear he wasn’t so cocky when Arredondo got through with him.” Remembering Elizondo’s treachery to Hidalgo and the others, Duncan smiled grimly.
In August, they learned, Arredondo had marched into Texas with a large force that included a battalion or more of veteran troops from Spain. At the Medina he had prepared a strong position and waited. The Americans and Tejanos, after a gruelling march in sweltering heat that left them exhausted, had unwisely attacked him and been routed. As usual, Arredondo took no prisoners. His orders were to bayonet the wounded and shoot all who surrendered. Less than one hundred Americans escaped.
Duncan groaned on hearing of Arredondo’s decisive victory and its consequences. In San Antonio he sent Elizondo and his cavalry after the families that had fled, while his own men rounded up all suspected rebels. Then, forcing their families to watch, he had more than three hundred shot without trials. Elizondo’s troops had killed most of the men they overtook, but he forced a few of the prominent ones, along with the women and children, to walk back to San Antonio so Arredondo could have the pleasure of executing the men. A Spanish officer, maddened by the callous brutality, had fatally wounded Elizondo. Leaving San Antonio destitute and nearly depopulated, Arredondo had retired to Monterrey to establish his headquarters as commander of the Eastern Interior Provinces.
Arredondo’s merciless sweep through Nuevo Santander and Nuevo León hadn’t totally quenched the desire for independence in the two provinces. In mid-1814, an armed band under a mestizo named Valeriano captured an army pack train carrying guns and ammunition. Alarmed at the possibility of a revival of the revolution in the north, Cordero ordered Major Franco and the two cavalry companies to stamp out the uprising before it became dangerous.
The cavalry rode eastward to the region where the band had been reported, and circled the area. They made camp at the westernmost of two springs they saw, while scouts searched for the enemy. When they reported finding the rebel camp, Franco met with his officers. After he dismissed them, he sent an orderly for Muñoz and Duncan. Puzzled, they walked to where the Major waited and saluted him.
“I have an important mission for you,” the Major said pleasantly, as if they were two of his most trusted men. “I want to arrange a meeting with the rebel leaders at the other spring we saw, so I can try to persuade them to disband. I want you to take them a letter under a flag of truce.” He smiled. “I’m sure they know what a flag of truce is. Report to me after breakfast tomorrow.” He dismissed them, and they returned to where the troop was bivouacked. They walked in silence, both thinking hard about the Major’s orders.
“I doubt he’d have chosen us unless he thinks we’re likely to be killed,” Duncan said at last. “I can’t see any other reason.”
“You mean unless he’s certain we’ll be killed,” Muñoz corrected him. “I’m going to talk to Sergeant Castillos; he’s usually told, or figures out what’s planned. But I can’t let the Major see me talking to him.” He didn’t return until after dark; Duncan had already rolled up in his blankets, but he had difficulty sleeping. He listened to owls hooting mournfully in the cottonwoods, tossing restlessly and wishing he knew what Muñoz had learned.