NOTES

ABBREVIATIONS:

CCAP: The Cambridge Companion to Arabic Philosophy, ed. Adamson and Taylor

DSB: Dictionary of Scientific Biography, 16 vols, ed. Gillespie

EHAS: Encyclopedia of the History of Arabic Science, 3 vols, ed. Rashed

TTT: Tradition, Transmission, Transformation..., ed. Ragep et al

CHAPTER 1

1 ‘knowledge of the sundial...’, Herodotus, II, 109

1 ‘The Egyptians by their...’, Ibid., II, 4

1 ‘The invention of geometry...’, Ibid., II, 109

1 ‘in the modern sense...’, Neugebauer, p. 80

2 ‘Egyptian astronomy had...’, Ibid., p. 80

2 ‘The Egyptian calendar became...’, Ibid., p. 80

2 ‘survived and are often...’, Ibid., p. 81

4 ‘No astronomical texts...’, Ibid., p. 14

4 ‘The only essential...’ Ibid., p. 29

4 ‘has furnished us ...’, Ibid., p. 14

4 ‘tables of square...’, Ibid., p. 34

4 ‘the calculation of...’, Hodgkin, p. 28

5 ‘this method became...’, Neugebauer, p. 20

5 ‘can in many respects...’, Ibid., p. 48

6 ‘the first signs ...’, Ibid., p. 100

6 ‘If on the 21st...’, Sarton, A History of Science, vol. 1, p. 77

6 ‘The data on...’, Neugebauer, p. 101

7 ‘All that we can safely...’, Ibid., p. 147

8 ‘the terminology as ...’, Ibid., p. 166

8 ‘it seems reasonable...’, Ibid., p. 167

8 ‘Babylonian influence is...’, Ibid., p. 156

CHAPTER 2

9 ‘the land of the Greeks’, Anawati, DSB, vol. 15, p. 230

10 ‘supposed the elements of...’, Kirk and Raven, p. 237

11 ‘Nothing occurs at random...’, Ibid., p. 413

12 ‘he was the first...’, Plutarch, Pericles, iv, 4

12 ‘The sun, the moon...’, Kirk and Raven, p. 391

12 ‘saw that the...’, Plato, Phaedo, 98c

12 ‘Let’s study astronomy...’, Plato, Republic, VII, 530 b-c

13 ‘on what hypotheses the...’, Guthrie, V, p. 450

14 ‘Now intelligent action is...’, Aristotle, Physics, II, 8: 12–15

14 ‘a distinguished man who...’, Diogenes Laertius, v. 58

15 ‘For if one observes...’, quoted by Lloyd, Greek Science After Aristotle, p. 16

15 ‘had at his disposal...’, Mostafa El-Abbadi, ‘The Alexandria Library in History’, in Alexandria, Real and Imagined, by Anthony Hirst and Michael Silk, p. 171

17 ‘a volume equal to...’, Dijksterhuis, p. 362

17 ‘Aristarchus of Samos has, however,...’, Ibid., p. 362–63

17 ‘that he was disturbing...’, Plutarch, Moralia, xii, 923

19 ‘things on land and...’, Strabo, 1.1.1

20 ‘we see here...’, Neugebauer, p. 226

CHAPTER 3

25 ‘Though I am a...’, quoted by Freely, Istanbul, the Imperial City, p. 78

26 ‘a man eloquent and...’, Clagett, Greek Science in Antiquity, p. 181

26 ‘admirable introduction to the...’, O’Leary, How Greek Science Passed to the Arabs, p. 69

27 ‘These texts are based...’ Morelon, in EHAS, vol. 1, p. 9

27 ‘their valuable methods of...’, Boyer, p. 238

27 ‘I only wish to...’, Ibid, p. 238

28 ‘books by Aristotle...’, Gutas, Greek Thought, Arabic Culture, p. 30

28 ‘motivated by the belief...’, Ibid., p. 25

28 ‘He had in his retinue...’, Ibid. p. 30

29 ‘he mingled elements from...’, quoted by Gutas, Greek Thought, Arabic Culture, p. 114

29 ‘over the centuries...’, Gutas, Greek Thought, Arabic Culture, p. 114

29 ‘That his text survived...’, Saliba, A History of Arabic Astronomy, p. 72

30 ‘The people of every age...’, Gutas, Greek Thought, Arabic Culture, p. 46

30 ‘mistress of all sciences’, Ibid., p. 108

30 ‘to renew this useful science...’, Ibid., pp. 180–81

30 ‘Stephanus brought with him...’, Ibid., p. 181

30 ‘after a hiatus of ...’, Ibid., p. 181

31 ‘as an expression of...’, Ibid., p. 185

32 ‘This was the reason...’, Ibid., p. 115

32 ‘And fire which burns...’, Al-Hassan and Hill, p. 141

33 ‘one of the centres...’, O’Leary, How Greek Science Passed to the Arabs, p. 156

33 ‘From Marw came...’, Ibid., p. 156

33 ‘Some of the astronomical...’, Ibid., p. 157

33 ‘the varying lengths...’, Gutas, Greek Thought, Arabic Culture, p. 111

34 ‘The ancient city...’, Pingree, DSB, vol. 1, p. 32

34 ‘In this effort ...’, Ibid., DSB, vol. 1, p. 33

34 ‘to restore to mankind...’, Ibid., DSB, vol. 1, p. 32

34 ‘In these writings ...’, Ibid., DSB, vol. 1, p. 35

35 ‘And Harun, amid the pomp...’, Clot, p. 35

CHAPTER 4

36 ‘he translated from Persian...’, Gutas, Greek Thought, Arabic Culture, p. 55

36 ‘It was a library...’, Ibid., p. 58

36 ‘Under al-Ma’mun it seemed...’, Ibid., p. 58–9

36 ‘was certainly not a center...’, Ibid., p. 59

37 ‘caliphal authority at the ...’, Ibid., p. 99

37 ‘Al Ma’mun dreamed that...’, Ibid., p. 98

37 ‘was employed full-time...’, Ibid., p. 58

38 ‘encouraged me to compose...’, Ibid., p. 113

38 ‘The first thing which...’, Boyer, p. 253

38 ‘We have said enough...’, Ibid., p. 254

38 ‘It may be that mathematics...’ O’Leary, How Greek Science Passed to the Arabs, p. 154

38 ‘Certainly the earliest Arab...’, Ibid., p. 154

40 ‘for full-time translation’, Gutas, Greek Thought, Arabic Culture, 133

40 ‘What makes the people...’, Anawati, DSB, vol. 15, p. 230

41 ‘He went to the bath...’, Hugh Kennedy, The Court of the Caliphs, p. 255

41 ‘I sought for it...’, Anawati, DSB, vol. 15, p. 230

41 ‘I translated it when ...’, Ibid., DSB, vol. 15, p. 230

42 ‘These are the books...’, Iskandar, DSB, vol. 15, p. 235

43 ‘advised them to claim...’ O’Leary, How Greek Science Passed to the Arabs, p. 177–78

43 ‘The story is obviously apocryphal ...,’ Ibid., p. 173

43 ‘how the Harranites came...’, Ibid., p. 173

43 ‘was originally a money-changer...’, Ibid., p. 173

43 ‘the supreme philosopher among...’ Thorndike, vol. I, p. 661

44 ‘As well as the error...’, Morelon, EHAS, vol. I, p. 29

45 ‘Handbook for manufacturing...’, Ibid., p. 55

46 ‘We are the heirs and offspring...’, Rozenfeld and Ihsanoğlu, p. 56

46 ‘a certain great noble...’, Thorndike, vol. I, p. 65

47 ‘the world’s greatest city...’, Clot, p. 197

47 ‘For you must know...’, Ibid., p. 216

47 ‘See you not how...’, Hugh Kennedy, The Court of the Caliphs, p. 63

CHAPTER 5

49 ‘Knowledge of the first...’, Klein-Franke, in Nasr and Leaman, p. 169

49 ‘We should not be...’, Walzer, p. 12

49 ‘My principle is first ...’, Ibid., p. 13

50 ‘The philosopher may intend...’, Adamson, in Adamson and Taylor, p. 46

51 ‘It is impossible for...’, Ibid., p. 41

51 ‘The sages’, he writes, ‘have proved...’, Thorndike, I, p. 65

52 ‘The mosquitoes go out...’, Egerton, p. 143

52 ‘The best gift from Allah...’, Turner, p. 131

52 ‘In his youth, he played...’, Arberry, The Spiritual Physick of Rhazes, p. 1

53 ‘The unsurpassed physician...’, Goodman in Nasr and Leaman, p. 198

55 ‘When shall it be...’, Nasr, Science and Civilization in Islam, p. 206

55 ‘I have never gone...’, Ibid., p. 200

55 ‘He used to sit ...’, Ibid., p. 201

55 ‘Truly I know not...’, Arberry, The Spiritual Physick of Rhazes, p. 7

56 ‘After this’, according to...’, Mahdi, DSB, vol. 4, p. 523

57 ‘The book can be...’, Ibid., p. 55

57 ‘Some men need...’, Reisman, in Adamson and Taylor, pp. 63–4

58 ‘Have you any proficiency...’, Netton, p. 6

58 ‘He then drew...’, Ibid., p. 6

CHAPTER 6

59 ‘Verily, in the creation...’, Sayılı, The Observatory in Islam, p. 16

59 ‘the senior of the ...’, Ibid., p. 53

60 ‘Al Ma’mun ordered him [Khalid] to...’, Ibid., p. 53

61 ‘composed an important...’, Hartner, DSB, vol. 1, pp. 507–8

61 ‘We have observed it ...’, Sayıı, The Observatory in Islam, p.97

61 ‘al-Battani the Harranite’, Copernicus, p. 21

62 ‘It is impossible...’, Singh, p. 66

62 ‘I have a truly...’, Ibid., p. 66

63 ‘Pleurisy is an inflamation...’, Hamarneh, DSB, vol. 9, p. 40

65 ‘After I had barely...’, Kennedy, DSB, vol. 2, 148

68 ‘will be sufficient for any one...’, Sachau, vol. 2, p. 246

69 ‘And now Islam has appeared...’, Chelkowski, p. 113

CHAPTER 7

70 ‘when I reached the age...’, Gutas, Avicenna and the Aristotelian Tradition, p. 23

70 ‘sent me for a while...’, Ibid., p. 24

70 ‘who claimed to be...’, Ibid., p. 24

70 ‘took leave of me’, Ibid., p. 27

70 ‘I occupied myself...’, Ibid., p. 27

70 ‘Next I desired [to learn] medicine...’, Ibid., p. 27

71 ‘The next year and a half...’, Ibid., pp. 27–8

71 ‘but did not understand...’, Ibid., p. 28

71 ‘I rejoiced at this ...’, Ibid., p. 28

71 ‘So that by...’, Ibid., p. 29

71 ‘As a matter of fact, ...’, Ibid., p. 82

71 ‘by means of which..., Ibid., pp. 16–17

71 ‘This faculty... does not...’, Ibid., p. 17

71 ‘divine inspiration... as in...’, Ibid., p. 17

71 ‘through syllogisms and...’, Ibid., p. 17

72 ‘None shall gain...’, Ibid., p. 19

72 ‘all the sciences...’, Goodman, Avicenna, p. 18

72 ‘asked me to comment...’, Gutas, Avicenna and the Aristotelian Tradition, p. 94

72 ‘Then my father died...’, Ibid., pp. 29–30

72 ‘From this point...’, Afnan, pp. 64–5

72 ‘amateur of these sciences’, Ibid., p. 98

73 ‘he introduced ten new...’, Ibid., p. 71

73 ‘One of the glories...’, Ibid., p. 66

73 ‘contains the marrow...’, Gutas, Avicenna and the Aristotelian Tradition, p. 99

73 ‘loaded with many costly...’, Afnan, p. 66

73 ‘fearing for themselves...’, Ibid., p. 67

73 ‘if you agree that ...’, Ibid., p. 68

74 ‘Aristotle’s oeuvre as a...’, Gutas, Avicenna and the Aristotelian Tradition, p. 205

74 ‘will help remove...’, Ibid., p. 205

74 ‘I would read the Shifa...,, Afnan, p. 68

74 ‘That I go in...’, Goodman, Avicenna, p. 29

74 ‘without having any book...’, Arberry, ‘Avicenna: His Life and Times’, in Wickens, pp. 22–3

74 ‘Each day he wrote...’, Ibid. pp. 22–3

75 ‘All three are highly...’, Hughes, pp. 2–3

76 ‘because he saw that...’, Goodman, Avicenna, p. 33

76 ‘If the year were 1900...’, Urquhart, John, ‘How Islam changed medicine...’, in British Medical Journal 332 (14 January 2006), p. 120

76 ‘At court he...’, Arberry, ‘Avicenna: His Life and Times’, in Wickens, pp. 23–4

76 ‘He used to sit...’, Afnan, p. 77

76 ‘So he finished the...’, Arberry, ‘Avicenna: His Life and Times’, in Wickens, p. 24

77 ‘I then concluded...’, Ibid., pp. 54–5

77 ‘petrified in the course...’, Crombie, ‘Avicenna’s Influence on the Medieval Scientific Tradition’, in Wickens, p. 97

77 ‘that in many places...’, Ibid., p 97

78 ‘to attain salvation...’, Gutas, Avicenna and the Aristotelian Tradition, p.112

78 ‘the leader of the wise...’, Morewedge, p. 76

78 ‘O you who are anxious...’, Gutas, Avicenna and the Aristotelian Tradition, p. 140

78 ‘Then I thought it...’, Ibid., p. 142

78 ‘He once more attended...’, Arberry, ‘Avicenna: His Life and Times’, in Wickens, p. 26

79 ‘a quality by which...’, Crombie, ‘Avicenna’s Influence on the Medieval Scientific Tradition’, in Wickens, p. 100

79 ‘impressed force’, Ibid., p. 100

79 ‘borrowed power,’ Crombie, Medieval and Early Modern Science, vol. 2, p. 53

79impetus impressus’, ‘impeto’, momento’, Crombie, ‘Avicenna’s Influence on the Medieval Scientific Tradition’, in Wickens, p. 101

80 ‘I think we can agree...’, Ibid., p. 101

80 ‘among the sublimest...’, Arberry, ‘Avicenna: His Life and Times’, in Wickens, p. 26

80 ‘Out of her lofty...’, Ibid., p. 140

CHAPTER 8

82 ‘And often a latter-day...’, ‘Ahmad, DSB, vol. 9, p. 171

83 ‘good fortune or a divine...’, Sabra, DSB, vol. 6, p. 190

84 ‘doctrines whose matter...’, Ibid., DSB, vol. 6, p. 190

84 ‘views on the nature...’, Sabra, The Optics of Ibn al-Haytham, vol. I, p. 3

84 ‘recommencing the inquiry...’, Ibid., p. 5

84 ‘ascend in the inquiry...’, Ibid., pp. 5–6

85 ‘visual rays’, Sabra, DSB, vol. 6, p. 192

85 ‘distinct form’, Ibid., p. 193

85 ‘primary’, ‘secondary’, Ibid., p. 191

85 ‘in the form of...’, Sabra, DSB, vol. 6, p. 191

85 ‘We shall now show...’, Sabra, The Optics of Ibn al-Haytham, vol. I, p. 113

85 ‘When the beholder fixes...’, Ibid., p. 229

86 ‘In the final analysis,...’, Lindberg, Theories of Vision from Al-Kindi to Kepler, p. 205

87 ‘learned investigators’, ‘the ancients’, Sabra, Optics of Ibn al-Haytham, vol. II, p. xl

87 ‘thick and moist air’, Sabra, DSB, vol. 6, p. 195

88 ‘Archimedes and Anthemius and...’, Ibid., DSB, vol. 6, p. 195

88 ‘certain philosophers’, Sabra, Optics of Ibn al-Haytham, vol. II, p. xli

88 ‘opacity’, Ibid., vol. II p. xli

89 ‘more truly descriptive’, Sabra, DSB, vol. 6, p. 198

89 ‘Commentary and Summary of...’, Sabra, Optics of Ibn al-Haytham, vol. II, p. xxxv

89 ‘just as objects placed ...’, Ibid., vol. II, p. xxxv

89 ‘deeper...and therefore it ...’, Ibid., vol. II, p. xxxv

90 ‘scientific intuition’, Sabra, DSB, vol. 6, p. 203

CHAPTER 9

92 ‘I have acquired a high...’, Johnson, p. 187

92 ‘My duties to...’, Ibid., p. 187

92 ‘ill for about...’, Davidson, p 73.

92 ‘I can no more...’, Ibid., p. 73

92 ‘From Moses [the prophet]...’, Frank and Leaman, p. 138

93 ‘interpretative comments on three...’, Ibid., p. 141

93 ‘because of the great...’, Roth, p. 22

93 ‘as the [Babylonian] Talmud...’, Davidson, p. 149

93 ‘in exile and wandering...’, Roth, p. 26

93 ‘laboured day and night...’, Davidson, p. 205

93 ‘assembles the entire Oral...’, Ibid., p. 208

93 ‘all the commandments that...’, Ibid., p. 232

94 ‘to the extent, ...’, Ibid., p. 246

94 ‘the celestial sphere rotates...’, Ibid., p. 235

94 ‘I guarantee that...’, Davidson, p. 429

94 ‘In my larger work,...’, Maimonides, The Guide for the Perplexed, pp. 5, 9

95 ‘Having acquired this knowledge...’, Ibid., p. 397

95 ‘The hearts of the people...’, Johnson, p. 193

96 ‘Life is short,...’, Davidson, p. 440

96 ‘from Galen’s words’ in ‘all ...’, Ibid., p. 444

96 ‘The indulgence in sexual...’, Maimonides, The Medical Aphorisms, vol. 2, p. 42

96 ‘The brain of a camel ...’, Ibid., vol. 2, pp. 113, 114, 119

97 ‘art of medicine’... ‘experience and reasoning...’, Davidson, p. 475

98 ‘medication... beneficial for...’, Ibid., p. 467

98 ‘electuary of Mithridates’, Ibid., p. 469

98 ‘concedes that one select...’, Ibid., p. 463

99 ‘Know, my masters, that...’, Freudenthal, p. 384 (III)

99 ‘to make his body healthy and...’, Davidson, p. 233

99 ‘Galen’s medicine is only...’, Johnson, p. 186

100 ‘second Ibn Sina’, Nasr, Islamic Science, An Illustrated Study, p. 190

100 ‘When the blood has...’, Nasr, Science and Civilization in Islam, p. 213–14

101 ‘The heart has four...’, quoted by Huff, p. 177

CHAPTER 10

103 ‘I was unable to...’, Youschkevitch, DSB, vol. 7, p. 325

104 ‘One of the mathematical...’, Rashed and Vahabzadeh, p. 11

104 ‘Whoever thinks algebra is...’, Boyer, p. 265

105 ‘I have written a book...’, Youschkevitch, DSB, vol. 7, p. 325

106 ‘Ah, but my Computations,...’, Khayyam, p. 101

106 ‘One of the most...’, Al-Hassan and Hill, p. 27

106 ‘This just balance is ...’, Hall, DSB, vol. 7, p. 340

107 ‘In design and operation...’, Al-Jazari, p. 9

108 ‘I was in his presence...’, Ibid., p. 15

108 ‘followed the method...’, Ibid., p. 17

108 ‘Above the door...’, Ibid., p. 18

109 ‘and the sound is...’, Ibid., p. 18

109 ‘This happens at the end...’, Ibid., p. 18

109 ‘I have never come...’, Ibid., p. 83

109 ‘Near its foot is ...’, Ibid., p. 83

110 ‘The wick is lit ...’, Ibid., p. 83

110 ‘A goblet that arbitrates ...’, Ibid., p. 94

110 ‘If a mere 5 dirhams ...’, Ibid., p. 94

111 ‘And so on up...’, Ibid., p. 137

111 ‘It is a fountain in a...’, Ibid., p 157

111 ‘It is an instrument ...’, Ibid., p. 170

111 ‘The ropes go over...’, Ibid., p. 182

111 ‘is beautiful to behold, ...’, Ibid., p. 182

112 ‘A lock for locking a chest...’, Ibid., p. 199

112 ‘It is interesting to observe...’, Ibid., p. 274

112 ‘If the observer forgets ...’, Ibid., p. 204

112 ‘one of the earliest manuals...’, Ibid., p. 279

112 ‘He was a master craftsman,...’, Ibid., p. 279

CHAPTER 11

113 ‘historians have acknowledged the...’, Al-Hassan and Hill, p. 280

113 ‘When people speak of ...’, Ibid., p. 280

114 ‘It is still in ...’, Ibid., p. 40

114 ‘To cite but a ...’, Ibid., p. 30

114 ‘Although the machine is...’, Ibid., p. 40

115 ‘that it was invented...’, Hill, Islamic Science and Engineering, p. 97

115 ‘Tidal mills were in...’, Al-Hassan and Hill, p. 53

115 ‘in every province of...’, Ibid., p. 54

115 ‘Paper mills were introduced...’, Ibid., p. 54

115 ‘the history of windmills...’, Needham, vol. 4, part 2, p. 556

115 ‘are commonly used by...’, Al-Hassan and Hill, p. 54

115 ‘this must surely have...’, Needham, vol. 4, part 2, p. 561

116 ‘Al-Jazari’s clocks are...’, Al-Hassan and Hill, p. 58

116 ‘...he described the construction...’, Ibid., p. 59

117 ‘To convert mercury into...’, Nasr, Science and Civilization in Islam, p. 267

117 ‘vessels carrying trade sail...’, Al-Hassan and Hill, p. 145

117 ‘wells were dug in...’, Ibid., p. 145

118 ‘On present evidence it...’, Ibid., p. 138

118 ‘In the same way...’, Ibid., p. 140

118 ‘Take equal parts of...’, Ibid., p. 149

118 ‘Soap manufacture became an...’, Ibid., p. 150

118 ‘...the secrets of Syrian ...’, Ibid., p. 153

119 ‘The geographical distribution of...’, Smith, p. 14

119 ‘an interesting anticipation of...’, Ibid., p. 33

120 ‘installed siege engines...’, Al-Hassan and Hill, p. 112

121 ‘Arabic sources report that...’, Ibid., p. 191

121 ‘factories for paper-making...’, Ibid., p. 191

121 ‘Only later did paper-making...’, Ibid., p. 191

CHAPTER 12

123 ‘the bride of al-Andalus’, Hillenbrand, ‘The Ornament of the World’, in Jayussi, The Legacy of Muslim Spain, p. 118

123 ‘in four things Cordoba’, Ibid., p. 118

126 ‘one of the books of the Christians,’ Vernet and Samso, ‘Development of Arabic Science in Andalusia’, in EHAS, vol. 1, p. 246

126 ‘Too much branching and...’, Hamarneh, DSB, vol. 14, p. 584

126 ‘Only by repeated visits,’ Ibid., p. 585

127 ‘the bringer of joy and...’, Ibid., p. 585

127 ‘applied himself...’, Vernet and Samso, ‘Development of Arabic Science in Andalusia’, in EHAS, vol. 1, p. 254

127 ‘the author of...’, Ibid., vol. 1, p. 254

127 ‘very wise... philosopher...’, Thorndike, vol. II, p. 813

127 ‘a compendium of magic,...’, Vernet, DSB, vol. 9, pp. 39–40

127 ‘confused compilation of extracts’, Thorndike, vol. II, p. 815

128 ‘The virtue of the stone...’, Dunlop, pp. 78–9

128 ‘a serious illness’, Menocal, The Ornament of the World, p. 112

128 ‘Love, may God honor you...’, Ibid., p. 112

128 ‘I have observed women’, Menocal, The Literature of Al-Andalus, p. 238

128 ‘women taught me...’, Ibid., p. 238

128 ‘first sources of all...’, Pavlin, ‘Sunni kalam and theological controversies’, Nasr and Leaman, History of Islamic Philosophy, p. 108

129 ‘the reality of things ...’, Ibid., p. 108

129 ‘In this book I...’, Hernandez, ‘Islamic Thought in the Iberian Peninsula’, in Jayussi, The Legacy of Modern Spain, p. 783

129 ‘to explain what’, Dold-Samplonius and Hermelink, DSB, vol. 7, p. 82

129 ‘There is no method...’, Ibid., DSB, vol. 7, p. 83

130 ‘which systematized trigonometry...’, R. P. Lorch, DSB, vol. 7, p. 38

130 ‘egregious calumniator of...’, R. P. Lorch, DSB, vol. 7, p. 39

131 ‘His tables Toletanes...’, Chaucer, Canterbury Tales, ‘The Franklin’s Tale’, 545–56

CHAPTER 13

134 ‘was so preoccupied with...’, Goodman, in Nasr and Leaman, History of Islamic Philosophy, p. 297

135 ‘combined the songs of...’, Monroe, ‘Zajal and Muwashshaha: Hispano-Arabic Poetry and the Romance Tradition’, in Jayussi, The Legacy of Muslim Spain, p. 412

135 ‘Wise Men of India’, Tony Levy, in Ragep, F. Jamil, and Sally P. Ragep with Steven Livesey (eds.) Tradition, Transmission, Transformation, p. 75

136 ‘long period of study...’, Crombie, Medieval and Early Modern Science, vol. 1, p. 10

136 ‘something new from...’, Ibid.

136 ‘better to attribute all ...’, Ibid., vol. 1, p. 26

136 ‘I do not detract...’, Ibid., vol. 1, p. 26

136 ‘the opinions of the...’, Haskins, p. 41

137 ‘this pearl of philosophy...’, Thorndike, vol. II, p. 270

139 ‘there, seeing the abundance...’, Lemay, DSB, vol. 15, p. 174

139 ‘wiser philosophers of the...’, Haskins, p. 127

142 ‘If you live among...’, Ahmad, DSB, vol. 7, p. 8

142 ‘the wonder of the world’, Kantorowicz’, p. 356

142 ‘baptised sultans’, Haskins, p. 243

143 ‘classified in order,...’, Masson, Frederich II of Hohenstaufen: A Life, London, 1957, p. 224

143 ‘We have followed Aristotle...’, Ibid., p. 216

143 ‘I have heard from...’, Ibid., p. 112

143 ‘with the new Indian...’, Vogel, DSB, vol. 4, p. 604

144 ‘How many pairs...’, Boyer, p. 287

144 ‘the late Theodore...’, Haskins, p. 247

CHAPTER 14

146 ‘By my solitary reading...’, Watt, The Faith and Practice of Al-Ghazali, pp. 29–30

146 ‘We must therefore reckon...’, Ibid., p. 32

147 ‘philosophical sciences’, Ibid., p. 32

147 ‘connected with religious matters,...’, Ibid., p. 33

147 ‘The basis of all these...’, Ibid., pp. 36–7

147 ‘most of the errors...’, Ibid., p. 37

147 ‘They are unable to...’, Ibid., pp. 37–8

147 ‘By the time I...’, Ibid., pp. 43–4

147 ‘I knew that the...’, Ibid., p. 54

147 ‘Everything which God apportions...’, Campanini, in Nasr and Leaman, p. 267

149 ‘the examination of the...’, Fakhry, A History of Islamic Philosophy, p. 289

149 ‘without which the faith...’, Ibid., p. 289

150 ‘At one moment the...’, Leaman, Averroes and His Philosophy, p. 16

150 ‘Why do you deny...’, Ibid., p. 16

150 ‘In the same way...’, Ibid., p. 17

151 ‘he explained that the...’, Arnaldez, DSB, vol. 12, p. 7b

151 ‘We affirm definitely that...’, Taylor, ‘Averroes...’, in Adamson and Taylor, p. 186

152 ‘In my youth I...’, Arnaldez, DSB, vol. 12, p. 3

152 ‘As to a profound...’ Ibid., DSB, vol. 12, p. 3

152 ‘the rate at which...’, Moody, ‘Galileo and Avempace: The Dynamics of the Leaning Tower Experiment’, Journal of the History of Ideas 12, no. 3 (June 1951), p. 375

152 ‘that the effect and ...’, Ibid., p. 380

152 ‘We maintain that the...’, Lindberg, Theories of Vision from al-Kindi to Kepler, p. 53

153 ‘The innermost of the coats...’, Ibid., p. 54

153 ‘What the laws existing...’, Leaman, Averroes and His Philosophy, p. 124

153 ‘the reception of forms...’, Lindberg, Theories of Vision from al-Kindi to Kepler, p. 54

153 ‘And you know that...’, Ibid., p. 54

154 ‘Our society allows no scope’, Robert Hillenbrand, ‘The Ornament of the World,’ in Jayussi, The Legacy of Muslim Spain, p. 122

CHAPTER 15

155 ‘undoubtedly the greatest work...’, Ibn Khaldun, Muqaddimah, p. viii

155 ‘The various kinds of science...’, Ibid., p. 333

155 ‘God distinguished man...’, Ibid., p. 333

155 ‘These cities have never...’, Ibid., p. 341

157 ‘But when the center of the...’, Saliba, A History of Arabic Astronomy, p. 123

158 ‘he expounds a philosophical...’, Nasr, DSB, vol. 13, p. 511

158 ‘one of the most...’, Ibid., 509

158 ‘the first in history...’, Ibid., p. 510

158 ‘one of the major...’, Ibid., p. 511

158 ‘Al Tusi’s view of medicine...’, Ibid., p. 511

159 ‘one of the learned...’, Saliba, ‘Arabic planetary theories after the eleventh century AD,’ in EHAS, vol. 1, p. 97

160 ‘All this being so,...’, Lindberg, Theories of Vision from al-Kindi to Kepler, p. 241

160 ‘If there are a...’, Pingree, DSB, vol. 7, p. 217

163 ‘...al-Shirwani...attests to...’, Saliba, A History of Arabic Astronomy, pp. 45–6

CHAPTER 16

164 ‘metaphysics of light’, Crombie, Robert Grosseteste and the Origins of Experimental Science, p. 128

165 ‘multiplication of species’, Ibid., pp. 109–10

165 ‘...An optics book...’, Lorris and Meun, The Romance of the Rose, p. 183

166 ‘even though the natural...’, Lindberg, The Beginnings of Western Science, p. 232

166 ‘in spite of the...’, Minio-Paluello, DSB, vol. 9, p. 435

167 ‘in the things of...’, Thorndike, vol. II, p. 144

167 ‘Every multiplication is either...’, Ibid., vol. II, p. 144

167 ‘cars can be made...’, Crombie, Medieval and Early Modern Science, vol. 1, p. 55

169 ‘It would be futile ...’, Crombie, Robert Grosseteste and the Origins of European Science, p. 216

169 ‘of corporeal influences sensible...’, Ibid., p. 214

169 ‘there is something wonderful...’, Minio-Paluello, DSB, vol. 9, p. 435

169 ‘that a globe of...’, Wallace, DSB, vol. 4, p. 93

171 ‘the rebirth of trigonometry’, Boyer, p. 308

CHAPTER 17

172 ‘this remote corner of...’, Copernicus, Preface, p. 5

173 ‘a manuscript of six...’, Gassendi, p. 140

173 ‘to the meridian of...’, Rosen, DSB, vol. 3, 402

173 ‘the apparent motion of...’, Rosen, Commentariolus, in Three Copernican Treatises, p. 57

173 ‘unable to account for...’, Ibid., p. 57

173 ‘eccentrics and epicycles, ...’, Ibid., p. 57

173 ‘in which everything would...’, Ibid., pp. 57–8

173 ‘this very difficult and ...’, Ibid., p. 58

173 ‘fewer and much simpler...’, Ibid., p. 58

174 ‘imperceptible in comparison to...’, Ibid., p. 58

174 ‘the apparent retrograde and...’, Ibid., p. 59

174 ‘the motion of the...’, Ibid, p. 58

174 ‘The celestial spheres are...’, Ibid., pp. 59–60

174 ‘Then Mercury runs on...’, Ibid., p. 90

174 ‘my teacher’, Rosen, Narratio Prima, in Three Copernican Treatises, p. 109

175 ‘by having the sun...’, Ibid., pp. 135–36

176 ‘He had lost his...’, Armitage, Sun Stand Thou Still, p. 127

176 ‘The sun stood still...’, Joshua X, 12–14

176 ‘People give ear to...’, Kuhn, p. 191

176 ‘I can reckon easily...’, Copernicus, p. 2

177 ‘I myself think that...’, Ibid., pp. 19–20

177 ‘In the center of...’, Ibid., pp. 25–6

178 ‘assuming that the heavens...’, Thomas W. Africa, ‘Copernicus’ Relation to Aristarchus and Pythagoras’, Isis, vol. 52, No. 3 (Sept. 1961), p. 406

178 ‘spins and turns, which...’, Ibid., p. 406

179 ‘the distance from the...’, Rosen, Commentariolus, in Three Copernican Treatises, p. 90

179 ‘How exceedingly fine...’, Copernicus, p. 27

179 ‘In essence, these astronomers...’, Ragep, ‘Copernicus and His Islamic Predecessors: Some Historical Remarks’, Filizofski vestnik, XXV, No. 2 (2004), p. 128

180 ‘The planetary models for...’, Ibid., p. 130

180 ‘How Copernicus learned of ...’, Ibid., p. 130

180 ‘All that someone ...’, Saliba, Islamic Science and the Making of the European Renaissance, p. 193

CHAPTER 18

189 ‘Copernicus...affirmeth...’, Kuhn, p. 186

183 ‘a still unexhausted treasure...’, Caspar, p. 64

184 ‘Have faith, Galilii...’, Koestler, p. 364

184 ‘although he knew...’, Ferguson, p. 284

185 ‘Medicean Stars’, Galileo, The Starry Messenger, in Discoveries and Opinions of Galileio, translated by Stillman Drake, p. 21

186 ‘necessary for the contemplation...’, Caspar, p. 296

188 ‘foolish and absurd...’, Armitage, Copernicus and Modern Astronomy, p. 189

188 ‘it would still be ...’, Galileo, Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems, Ptolemaic and Copernican, p. 464

188 ‘Your Galileo has ventured...’, De Santillana, p. 191

188 ‘had altogether given rise...’, Koestler, p. 503

189 ‘All this was in...’, Westfall, p. 143

190 ‘rays which make blue...’, Ibid., p. 160

190 ‘extremely well pleased to...’, Manuel, p. 144

191 ‘What Descartes did was...’, Westfall, p. 274

191 ‘what he thought the...’, Ibid., p. 403

192 ‘Law 1: Every body perseveres...’, Newton, Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy, pp. 416–17

192 ‘corrected by the author’s...’, Newton, Opticks, p. lxxvii

192 ‘My design in this...’, Ibid., p. 1

193 ‘the oldest and most...’, Ibid., p. 369

193 ‘Light is propagated...’, Ibid., p. 277

193 ‘He lived honoured by...’, Voltaire, p. 69

CHAPTER 19

194 ‘By standing on the...’, Westfall, p. 274

195 ‘passing through the nine...’, Sayılı, The Observatory in Islam, p. 290

195 ‘The King of Kings...’, Ibid., p. 293

195 ‘Seeing that very important...’, Ibid., p. 360

196 ‘After examining the work...’ Ihsanoğlu, ‘Introduction of Western Science to the Ottoman World...’, in Transfer of Modern Science to the Muslim World, p. 67

196 ‘absorption of Arabic knowledge...’, Dampier, p. 82

197 ‘some of the most...’, Huff, p. 208

197 ‘The problem was not ...’, Ibid., p. 212

197 ‘Islamic law does not...’, Ibid., p. 79

198 ‘The prevalence of a general ...’, Sayılı, The Observatory in Islam..., p. 84

198 ‘that what we see ...’, Sabra, ‘The Appropriation and Subsequent Naturalization of Greek Science in Medieval Islam: A Preliminary Statement’, in TTT, pp. 3–19

198 ‘three-stage development...’, Ibid., p. 19

198 ‘The acquisition of ancient,...’, Ibid., p. 19

198 ‘of a large number...’, Ibid., p. 19

198 ‘The carriers of scientific...’, Ibid., p. 20

198 ‘I do not possess...’, Ibid., p. 22

198 ‘the knowledge man has ...’, Ibid., p. 22

198 ‘not only that religious ...’, Ibid., p. 23

199 ‘The doctrines of natural...’, Ibid. p. 23

199 ‘is not intended...’, Ibid., p. 24

199 ‘it should be noted...’, Ibid., p. 25

199 ‘easily understandable why...’, Goldhizer, p. 190

199 ‘Allegorical interpretations ought...’, Huff, p. 223

200 ‘Let it be known...’, Ihsanoğlu, ‘Introduction of Western Science to the Ottoman World...’, in Transfer of Modern Science to the Muslim World, p. 67

202 ‘scientific thought is the common...’, Lundquist, p. 513