Here’s a logic puzzle for you: there are four people, named Grant, Bill, Marci, and April. Each one has a different eye color: blue, brown, green, and hazel. Each one has a different role: girlfriend, neighbor, therapist, and mother. Each one died in a different way: a stabbing, a slit throat, slit wrists, and fire. One of the women died alone. The other woman died without a blade. One of the men killed the other one and then he, in turn, was killed by a child. All of them loved the child, but the child didn’t save any of them. Can you solve the puzzle and find the answer?
Do you even know what answer you’re looking for?
“Good morning, John.” Dr. Trujillo was an older man, short and squat, his white hair making a stark contrast with his bronze skin. Him I’d probably poison, though there were other options depending on the circumstance. His shirt was wrinkled enough that I assumed he must have spent the night on the cot in the room next to Brooke’s—we’d paid Whiteflower extra to get a second room, and Trujillo slept there more often than not. He stood when I walked toward him. “I heard about the project yesterday; I’m glad it went well.”
We always called them “projects” in public. “Job” felt too crass, “mission” attracted too much attention, and “government authorized murder of a supernatural monster” just didn’t have that sassy ring to it.
“It pays the bills,” I said. He tilted his head analytically, and I rolled my eyes. “Is she awake?”
“Let me ask you a question first,” he said, as if my permission had anything to do with it. “When you say that our work ‘pays the bills,’ what do you mean? Obviously it’s true, but it’s not a way you’ve ever characterized our work before.”
“Do we have to do this right now?”
“I’m your psychologist, John, assigned to this unit specifically to help keep you and Brooke on an even keel. The reasons why you do the work you do are every bit as important as the work itself, and if you’ve begun to think—”
“Is she awake yet?”
“If you’ve begun to think of yourself less as a protector of human life and more as a contract killer, that’s exactly the kind of thing I need to be watching out for.”
Trujillo was the most zealous therapist I’d ever had, but on the plus side, having a lot of therapists meant I’d gotten really good at pissing them off. “Actually I prefer to swing as far as I can in the opposite direction,” I said. “I have a full-on messiah complex now. I don’t just protect people, I’m the outright savior of mankind.” I spread my arms beatifically.
“Now you’re just being belligerent,” said Trujillo. “That’s a deflection tactic, and we’ve talked about this before.”
“I don’t need to deflect anything,” I said, “I’m impervious to harm. Try it—you packing? I’m sure there’s a zip gun or a shiv somewhere in this place, it’s a psych ward. Of course, if you try to harm me you’ll be damned for eternity and live forever without My grace.”
Trujillo put his fingers on the bridge of his nose, sighing or pressing down on a headache. “Why do you do this, John?”
“If I tell you, it’s cheating. You’re supposed to figure it out on your own.”
“I’m here to help you.”
“I’m here to see Brooke,” I said. “Is she awake yet?”
He stared at me a moment, exasperated. I got to see his exasperated face a lot. “If not now, can we at least talk about this later?”
“Does it matter if I say no?”
“You can always say no,” he said, “but you know what will happen if you do. I can’t sign off on your psychiatric readiness to perform your job unless you open up to me.”
“In your defense,” I said, “the illusion of freedom is one of my favorite illusions. Also that one where you can pull a quarter out of someone’s ear; I love that one.”
“This does not have to be a confrontational relationship, John.”
“Then why do I have to ask you four times if my friend is awake yet?”
He blew out a rough sigh, throwing one hand in the air and then pointing it at Brooke’s door. “Yes, she’s awake.” He turned and walked back toward the side room, talking over his shoulder. “You’re not likely to get much out of her today, but you’re welcome to try. And we will talk about this later.”
“Bless you, my son.”
He grunted and disappeared into the second room. I walked to Brooke’s door and peeked in the window. She was sitting up on the bed, cross-legged, her long blond hair hanging like a tangled curtain around her shoulders. Her face was turned up, her eyes staring blankly at the ceiling, and her left hand was tracing intricate patterns in the bedspread. I opened the door—it was only locked from the inside—and she turned toward me.
“Bunâ ziua.” Her left hand, unattended, was still drawing on the blanket.
“What language is that?”
“I don’t know,” she said, “what language is this?”
“English,” I told her.
She didn’t say anything, but simply stared.
Brooke had always been thin, but a year of mental incapacitation had left her gaunt, her blue eyes sunken deep in her pale, white face. Trujillo said some of that was the drugs they had her on—they made food taste bad, so she never ate unless they forced her. Protein shakes when she was in a good mood, restraints and IV drips when she wasn’t. Her entire room had been cleared of anything dangerous, partly for our safety but mostly for hers: there were no cords, no glass, no sharp edges. Even the power outlets were nailed into the wall, because screws were too easy to extract and misuse.
“Do you remember me?” I asked.
“Of course I remember you,” said Brooke, and her eyes focused on me suddenly. “I love you.”
I sighed. “No you don’t,” I said. “You’re Brooke Watson, remember? You’re not Nobody.”
“My name is Hulla.”
We’d known the Withered as Nobody back when I was hunting it, but in her more lucid moments Brooke could remember the thing’s real name. Hulla was, according to Nathan, an old Sumerian name, but that didn’t tell us much; we already knew the Withered were ancient. Did Hulla come from Sumer, or just borrow a name when she got there?
“Do you love me back, Ghita?”
“I’m John,” I said. “You’re Brooke and I’m John.”
Her hand was still drawing, all by itself, like it wasn’t even a part of her at all.
“I saw Meshara last night.”
“These are not real people,” I said. “Not anymore. You live in Whiteflower Assisted Living Center in a town called Fort Bruce. My name is John Wayne Cleaver. Do you remember any of this?” I couldn’t tell how much of her was Brooke and how much was Hulla; how much was crazy and how much was drugs designed to control the crazy. I could only imagine how much worse it was for her.
“Of course I remember you,” she said again. “You lived on my street. We were friends. I married you and I died the next day.”
“I’m not Ghita,” I said, “I don’t even know who that is. My name is John, and this is—”
“This is the Whiteflower Assisted Living Center,” said Brooke. “My name is Nobody and I was born ten thousand years ago in a shepherd’s hut on the slopes of the great mountain. And Meshara was there and now he’s here.”
I sat up straighter; this was different than her usual ranting. She called me by old names occasionally, thinking I was someone from her past, but she’d never referred to anyone else that way except for the actual Withered: the two we’d known in Clayton were named Mkhai and Kanta, just like Nobody was named Hulla. These were their old names, the names they used for each other; to hear her use such a name for someone she’d seen last night, and to connect it with something so deep in the past, was troubling, to say the least. Who was this Meshara? “You saw somebody here?” I asked. “You recognized him?”
“In the lobby downstairs,” she said. “The doctor took me for a walk. I almost didn’t recognize him, it’s been so long. Maybe a hundred years.”
We thought there were only two Withered in Fort Bruce. If there were three … “Did you tell Trujillo who you saw?”
“I don’t like Dr. Trujillo.” Brooke scowled. “He never lets me cut my own food.”
“Can you describe Meshara to me?”
“He’s sad.”
“What does he look like?”
“He looks sad.”
I stood up and walked to the door; I needed to talk to Trujillo. “Could you point him out to me if you saw him again?”
Her voice changed suddenly, losing the odd, disconnected tone she always seemed to use when she was remembering things and becoming suddenly sharp and pained. “Please don’t leave me.”
“I’m coming back, I just need to—”
“No one ever comes back.”
“I promise,” I said, and knocked on the door. “Just try to remember everything you can about Meshara, okay? Can you do that?”
“He’s here,” said Brooke.
“I know, and I need you to remember everything you can about him—”
“Not Meshara,” said Brooke. “The doctor.”
Half a second later Trujillo stepped into view through the window and did a visual check of the room before opening the door. “Is everything okay?”
I shot one last look at Brooke; she had tears on her cheeks and look of abject despair in her pale, haunted eyes. I turned away, stepped into the hall, and closed the door firmly behind me.
“Did you take her on a walk last night?”
“Yes, down to the lobby and back. We bought some candy from the vending machine.”
“She’s found another Withered, here in Whiteflower.”
His brow furrowed in worry. “There were only supposed to be two in the city.”
“Exactly,” I said. “And if there’s an extra one, and if he’s here, right under our noses, it only means one thing: the Withered are hunting us now.”
* * *
“Ghita is a Romanian name,” said Nathan. “Her greeting was also Romanian: ‘bunâ ziua’ means ‘good morning.’ That’s all in line with the kind of flashbacks we tend to see from Brooke: she woke up with the wrong memories on the surface of her consciousness, and so she thought she was a Romanian villager. Not exactly the worst-case scenario for her, all things considered.”
“And Meshara?” asked Agent Ostler. The entire team was gathered around a table in our office, a rented space across the street from Whiteflower. I could tell by the way they were fidgeting—drumming their fingers on the table, glancing at the windows, shifting their weight from foot to foot without bothering to sit down—that they were just as tense as I was.
“That one’s not Romanian,” said Nathan. “I haven’t had time to look into it too deeply, but my preliminary research suggests that Meshara is Sumerian, like Hulla, which suggests in turn that this is another Withered. Kudos to John for spotting it.”
I ignored the compliment, taking as it a bald attempt to get back on my good side after yesterday’s argument. The joke was on him for thinking I had a good side. “How do we track him down?” I asked.
“I was able to pull last night’s security footage from the lobby cameras,” said Kelly, laying a stack of low-res photos on the table, hastily printed on plain white office paper. She pointed at the top photo and tapped her finger on an average-looking man in a loose jacket. “I took these to Brooke and she identified this man as Meshara.”
Potash pulled the photo toward his side of the table, rotating it for a better look at the image. “Is this our best shot of him?”
Kelly nodded. “This isn’t a convenience store, where the cameras are positioned to get clear face shots of the customers at the counter. Whiteflower’s main security risk is patients leaving unaccompanied, so their lobby camera is a wide-angle pointed at the front door. The image you’re looking at comes from a hallway camera and offers a slightly better look at his face than the one in the lobby.”
I dug through the pile of photos, looking for the lobby image. It was just a few photos down, marked with a red circle from Kelly’s meeting with Brooke. The jacket looked the same as the hallway image, but the face was hard to discern—dark hair, no beard or mustache, paunchy. An incredibly average-looking man.
“Do we have a name yet?” asked Ostler.
“I’ve sent it back to headquarters for facial recognition,” said Kelly, “but without a better image the computer’s not likely to find anything. This is one we’re probably going to end up doing by hand, so I hope you’re all excited to sit down with old case binders and start flipping.”
“There’s got to be a better way,” said Nathan. “Are there traffic cameras outside? I haven’t noticed.”
“In Fort Bruce?” asked Diana. “Come back in five years.”
“There’s a camera in the parking lot,” said Kelly, “but it’s out of order. I can try going to the other businesses in the area and hope we get lucky, but unless he stopped at a gas station immediately before or after his visit that’s almost guaranteed to be a dead end.”
“Brooke said nothing to me,” said Trujillo, “so if I had no idea she saw anything, this Withered might not know either. Our best hope for now is that he still thinks we don’t know about him.”
“He?” asked Potash. “Or they? This could be a sign of a much larger counterattack than we’re imagining.” The group started grumbling, but I ignored them and studied the photo. There was something about it …
“Don’t jump to conclusions,” said Ostler, trying to regain control. “The last thing we need is a panic.”
“The last thing we need is to get murdered,” said Nathan. “It could be weeks before we figure out who this guy is, and by then we could all be—”
“Did you ask at the front desk?” I asked. Kelly looked at me, and I turned the photo to face her. “Look at his position there—he’s either just changed directions for no reason in the middle of the room, or he’s walking away from the receptionist.”
The room went quiet, and Kelly studied the image a moment before closing her eyes. “I’m trying to remember the layout of the lobby. Leaving the front desk at that angle would take him toward…”
“The dining room,” I said, and looked at Trujillo. “Did you walk through there?”
“We never do,” said Trujillo. “Too many knives.”
I looked at Ostler. “The dining room is for residents and their guests only; unless he’s accompanying somebody, he wouldn’t even be allowed in.”
“Why does this matter?” asked Nathan.
“Because it means Meshara has a cover story,” said Ostler, picking up my line of thought. “If he was just walking around watching people the nurses would get suspicious, so he’s made friends with a resident. That’s his excuse for being there. And that means he’s been there more than once, which means the people at the front desk might recognize him.”
“It’ll be an Alzheimer’s patient,” I said. “Someone who doesn’t remember anyone, so no one will think it’s weird that he doesn’t remember this guy.”
“How do you know that?” asked Diana.
“I don’t know for sure,” I said. “But that’s the way I’d do it.”
Ostler looked at Kelly. “Ms. Ishida?”
Kelly stood up, taking the better of the two photos with her. “I’ll check it out. Potash, come with me—nobody should be alone now that we know we’re being followed.” The two of them left, and the rest of us looked at each other.
“What does this mean?” asked Trujillo. “Practically, I mean? I’ve worked on serial-killer cases, but never one where the investigators were being hunted. Has this ever happened before?”
“Nobody was hunting John,” said Nathan. “I mean, the Withered named Nobody was hunting John.”
“That’s a weird name for a Withered,” I said. “Is ‘Nobody was hunting John’ also Sumerian?”
“This is serious,” said Diana. “Can you please stop making jokes for five damn minutes?”
“Let me fill in some gaps for you,” said Ostler. “In the process of hunting John, the Withered named Nobody killed four girls John knew, including his girlfriend, then tried to kill Brooke, then burned John’s mother alive. So maybe humor is a defense mechanism, and you need to cut him a little slack.”
So now they knew my history. Judging by their silence, it kind of freaked them out.
Trujillo was the first to speak. “So I take it the answer to my question is ‘yes, we’re in incredible danger.’”
“All I knew about Nobody was her name,” I said. “We know Meshara’s name, face, and location, and we have a good lead on finding more, plus anything else we can get out of Brooke. We can do this.”
“And how many of us die in the process?” asked Nathan.
“Better us than civilians,” said Diana.
“I am a civilian!” Nathan shouted.
“We knew the risks when we got into this,” said Ostler. “Even you, civilian or not. If they want to make this a war, we have the tools, the experience, and the weapons to fight it.”
“Our first step needs to be Mary Gardner,” said Trujillo. “If there’s more than one Withered working together, we have to assume she’s a part of it. If we take her out as fast as we can, we remove one enemy soldier before they have a chance to hit us. That could throw their whole plan into disarray and buy us the time we need to track down this Meshara.”
“We’re not ready to move on Mary,” I said. “I haven’t figured out her weakness yet.”
“She passed the speed-bump test,” said Nathan, “so we know it’s going to be tricky.”
“Maybe the speed-bump test is part of our problem,” said Diana. “If the Withered talk to each other at all, and this suggests that they do, then the fact that each one of them’s been in a major, unexplained car accident recently can’t help but look like a clue.”
“So we don’t speed bump Meshara,” I said. “Make them think we don’t know about him yet.”
“All that does is deny us information,” said Nathan. “Even if it denies them information, too, it’s still a wash at best, and a needless precaution if Brooke has communicated with him in any way. Dammit!” He smacked the table with his hands, like he’d just remembered something terrible. “She’s thinks she’s one of them! For all we know she’s been talking to him all along!”
“She wouldn’t do that,” I said, though I knew it was a hollow assurance. We could never be sure what Brooke would do. I shook my head. “All we have to do is the same thing we always do: get to know them, make a plan, and strike. And we’ve already made good progress, despite barely knowing about this guy for three hours. We know he’s hunting us, we know he’s using a patient as a cover, and we know he can’t shape shift the way some of the others can.”
“How do we know that?” asked Ostler.
“Because Brooke recognized him,” I said, “after what she claimed to be a hundred years. If he could shape shift in that time, he would have. So unless the receptionist throws Kelly some insane curveball down there, we’ve got a good head start on figuring out what he does, and how, and how to stop him.” Ostler’s phone rang. “Speak of the devil.”
Ostler set her phone in the middle of the table. “Ms. Ishida, you’re on speaker.”
“His name is Elijah Sexton,” said Kelly. “The receptionist knew him immediately. He visits a man named Merrill Evans—an Alzheimer’s patient, just like John guessed.”
“Nice one!” Nathan held up his hand for a high five, but I ignored him.
“Now get ready for the weird part,” said Kelly. “He’s been visiting here ever since Merrill Evans checked in. That was almost twenty years ago.” She sighed. “Either that’s a really deep cover story, or we don’t have any idea what’s really going on here.”