In Loving Memory

E. M. BUTLER1

1

‘Goodbye’ – the number of times each day one says it!

But the goodbyes that matter we seldom say,

Being elsewhere – preoccupied, on a visit,

Somehow off guard – when the dear friend slips away

Tactfully, for ever. And had we known him

So near departure, would we have shut our eyes

To the leaving look in his? tried to detain him

On the doorstep with bouquets of goodbyes?

I think of one, so constant a life-enhancer

That I can hardly yet imagine her dead;

Who seems, in her Irish courtesy, to answer

Even now the farewell I left unsaid.

Remembering her threefold self – a scholar,

A white witch, a small girl, fused into one –

Though all the love they lit will never recall her,

I warm my heart still at her cordial sun.

2

There was the small-boned witch who would accost us

In Notting Hill Gate, white shoes and hairnet on,

Having just flown out of a dream of Doctor Faustus,

Vanished from Cambridge or Ceylon,

Or merely passed intact under the wheels

Of several buses. And instantly her spells

Worked on us – we were young, a drab day shone.

Then the attentive scholar, listening for clues

To meaning, like a bird with its head inclined

Earthward: one in whose presence to misuse

Truth was hazardous – she would find

You gently out. But her own truth sang and tingled

With a Mozartian gaiety that mingled

Wise innocence and pure elegance of mind.

But I think I loved in her most the original Alice –

The round blue gaze ready for wonderland,

The mien, polite, inquisitive, without malice,

Of one who nevertheless would stand

No nonsense from cardboard kings or tinpot knights –

A little girl who reached spectacular heights

By chewing on whatever came to hand …

Child, with a scholar’s cool, precise discerning:

Scholar, unfeigned in her bewitching glee:

White witch, whose subtle essences were burning

With a child’s candour. Now all three

Are in one grave. But still her nature glows

Through earth and night, and like trefoil there grows

On us the sweetness of her memory.

1 E. M. Butler: former Professor of German at Cambridge, and author.