Fall 2012, the Krause family farm
The next day, Kate stood in the apple orchard and surveyed the damage to the house. Thanks to Will arriving when he did and his 911 call before Trudy had tossed the match, the destruction was minimal compared to what it might have been. The kitchen and Trudy’s bedroom had fared the worst, and the rest of the house had water and smoke damage.
Kate shook her head at the irony. The room where Jacob had been murdered was now nothing more than charred timbers.
“What are you going to do now?” Will asked from where he stood next to her.
“I spent most of the night thinking about it,” she replied, kicking at the leaves at her feet. “A crew’s coming in today to rip out the burned areas, then they’ll board it up. I guess after that I’ll start cleaning it out. Most of the antiques were saved, so I’ll get them ready for the estate sale.”
“Are you sure you want to sell them all?”
“Yes, I am.” She stuck her hands in her pockets as her attention roamed over what was left of the old house. “Then the house will be torn down.”
“No more Krause family home?”
She turned to face him. “This never was a home. From what I’ve learned, the families who spent their lives here knew nothing but misery.” She glanced back at the house and the blackened shell of Jacob’s bedroom. “If Trudy was right, and fire does cleanse, maybe now those restless spirits will be free.”
“You finally believe in all the stuff about curses and ghosts?”
Kate thought for a moment. “I don’t know. Last night, I could’ve sworn I heard the music box.” She shook her head. “But that’s impossible. I checked this morning, and it’s still lying in pieces on Joe’s desk.”
“Maybe Hannah was looking out for you.”
“If so, then I owe her my life. Hearing the music box was what got me out of bed.” She smiled up at him. “I also owe you a debt of gratitude. What made you drive out here so late last night?”
“I couldn’t sleep. I kept replaying our conversations over and over in my mind, and I wasn’t proud of the way I acted.” He rocked back on his heels. “I wanted to set things straight, so I took the chance you’d still be up and drove out here. That was when I saw the light in the kitchen and went around to the back—”
“And saw Trudy with her can of gasoline and box of matches,” she finished for him with a shiver.
“Where are you going to live?”
“Not out here—I’m not going to rebuild. I still plan on managing the farm, but I’m going to get a place in town. And I want to keep working at Doc’s and serving as a volunteer at Essie’s House. In fact, the proceeds from the estate sale are going there.”
“You’re not keeping it?”
“No, I don’t need the money.” She gazed back at the house. “After the violence that Hannah must’ve suffered, there’s a certain amount of justice in giving the proceeds from the Krause family heirlooms to Essie’s House. The money will help other abused women.” She gave him a half-smile. “I think Hannah would’ve approved.”
“Hey,” Will said abruptly, “you want to go for a ride? I want to show you something.”
“Now?” she asked with a lift of her eyebrow.
“Yeah, come on,” he said, grabbing her hand and leading her to his car.
Once in the car, Kate turned to him. “I have a confession to make.” She picked at the hem of her shirt. “I . . . well . . . I thought you might have killed Joe.”
The car swerved toward the shoulder. “What?” he asked as he regained control.
“Yeah. Look, I know you and Rose are hiding something—”
“But—” he interrupted.
She held up her hand, stopping him. “I know it’s crazy, but I got the wild idea that maybe Willie had killed Jacob, that Joe knew about it, and you were trying to protect Willie’s reputation. I even wondered if Joe had tried to blackmail you over it.” She finished with a nervous laugh.
“You were right about one thing—”
“Not Joe?” she blurted out.
“No, not that or,” he said, shooting her a sideways glance, “about Willie killing Jacob. But we were protecting someone’s reputation.” He paused. “Johan Bennett.”
“Essie’s mentor? I looked that name up yesterday while I was at the library.”
“Then you must have noticed that there isn’t much written about Johan.”
“Right. The articles referred to him as reclusive.”
“That’s true. Johan lived in Chicago and worked hard to improve conditions for families, specifically women.”
“I read where his writing contributed to changes in the child-labor laws.”
“They did. That book of essays? It’s one of Johan’s earliest works and not as well-known as his later writings.”
“How did a Krause get a copy?”
“My guess is that someone mailed it to Joseph. You saw that the essay, ‘The Sins of the Father,’ had been ripped out?”
“Yes,” Kate answered slowly.
“That essay is about how violence in families can be perpetuating and passed down to the children.”
“The victim grows up to become the abuser.”
“Yeah.”
Kate stared out the window before returning her attention to Will. “That was true in Joe’s family. I don’t know about his grandfather, but his father abused Trudy throughout their marriage. Joe talked about it in counseling.”
“By all accounts he was an abuser and so was Joseph.”
Kate counted on her fingers. “Four generations. That’s where the ‘sins of the father’ comes in.”
Will nodded.
“So who carved those words in the music box?”
“My guess is Joseph. We’ve always believed he was the one who really killed Jacob.”
“Why?”
“We’ll never know. My grandfather once mentioned rumors concerning the death of Jacob’s first wife and Joseph’s mother. She died under mysterious circumstances, but nothing was ever proved.”
“Revenge?”
“Maybe, or maybe he got tired of waiting around for his inheritance. I figure that carving is the closest thing to a confession that Joseph ever made.”
“Johan knew the Krauses?”
“Yeah. Here we are,” he said, turning into the cemetery.
Kate’s eyes widened. “You brought me to the cemetery?”
“I told you that I wanted to show you something.”
Will drove past the rows of headstones, their polished surface gleaming in the morning light. When he reached a corner of the cemetery, he stopped and got out, motioning for Kate to follow.
A slight breeze whispered through the pines and stirred the leaves littering the graves. Artificial wreaths and flowers marked a few of them. Some had bright banners waving next to them that seemed out of place in such a somber space.
Finally, Will stopped at a headstone made of gray granite.
Smiling, Will pointed to it. “Kate, meet Johan Bennett.”
Kate’s chin dropped as she stared at Will. “Hannah? Hannah was Johan Bennett?” She shook her head. “But how? I don’t understand—I thought Hannah spent her life in an insane asylum?”
“She spent ten years,” he answered grimly. “Her sister and brother-in-law worked for her release, but it wasn’t until Willie became an adult that they managed to get her out.” He wiped a dead leaf off the top of the stone. “They both moved to Chicago where Willie went to medical school and Hannah found a job as a secretary.”
“When did she start writing?”
“Right away, but she did it under her pen name.” He chuckled. “When her essays started causing a stir, she quit and wrote full-time.”
“No one ever made the connection?”
“No, not even when she became successful. She was always very careful to keep her past, and the fact that she was a woman, secret. She didn’t believe that she’d be taken seriously if it got out she’d spent ten years in an insane asylum.”
“She was probably right. I take it Rose and her family knew?”
“Yeah, in fact Hannah helped Essie get established.”
“And both families have kept her secret all these years?”
A look of sadness crossed his face. “Hannah went through hell and back, first with Jacob then in the asylum. We’ve always felt that the least we could do was respect her wish for anonymity, even after she’d passed away.”
Kate knelt by the granite stone and traced the lettering of Hannah’s epitaph.
A VOICE NOT SILENCED