Chapter 4
IN THIS CHAPTER
Linking feeding and housetraining
Selecting the right food for your dog
Making the treat decision
Giving your dog a drink
You can’t discuss the art of housetraining a dog — much less practice that art successfully — without also discussing what you’re going to feed that dog.
The reason is simple: What comes out of your dog in the form of pee or poop is directly related to what you put into him. Consequently, if you control what you feed your four-legged friend, you also exert some control over his bathroom behavior. In this chapter, I explain how that relationship works — and how to take advantage of that relationship as you teach your canine companion proper potty deportment.
That what-goes-in-eventually-comes-out principle of housetraining manifests itself in countless ways. Here are just a few examples:
What you feed: This affects the size and consistency of your dog’s poop, as well as how often he may need to do the doo. For example, if your dog eats a lot of vegetables, he’ll probably need to poop more often than the pooch who prefers more basic canine fare. Vegetables contain relatively high amounts of fiber, and fiber acts as a laxative.
Also, food that’s high in salt is likely to make your dog thirsty. Ingesting goodies that have a lot of salt in them, such as many table scraps, may send your pooch to his water dish more often. And the more times your dog tanks up, the more often he’s going to need to empty his tank (his bladder).
Even different types of dog food affect your dog’s bathroom output. A dog who eats a raw food diet tends to have firmer, more compact stools than a pooch whose diet consists of other fare.
When you feed: Timing directly affects when your dog needs to potty. A canine housetrainee who eats his dinner at 5 p.m. needs a post-dinner pit stop earlier in the evening than the dog who sups at 7 p.m.
Experts explain that the very act of eating can activate a dog’s gastrocolic reflex: In layman’s terms, that means the act of chowing down triggers your dog’s urge to go.
Just like you, dogs need certain basic nutrients to survive, much less thrive. Those nutrients include proteins, fats, vitamins, and minerals. This section explains why they’re necessary and how your dog can obtain them.
Much more info about dog food and nutrition is in Dog Health and Nutrition For Dummies, by M. Christine Zink (Wiley). For up-to-date information, consider subscribing to the Whole Dog Journal (www.whole-dog-journal.com
), which ranks commercial foods every year and accepts no advertising.
Proteins enable the body to convert food into energy. They also promote healthy growth and cell repair and affect both metabolism and nervous system function. Commercial dog foods contain several types of protein:
Not all proteins are created equal. A dog can digest meat or animal proteins more easily than she can digest grain proteins. The more digestible the protein, the better it is for the dog.
Proteins are made up of amino acids, ten of which a dog has to get through diet. If proteins don’t contain all ten essential amino acids, those proteins are considered incomplete.
The amount of protein a dog needs varies throughout a dog’s life. For example, puppies need more protein than adult dogs do, because puppies are still growing and need extra energy. Protein requirements also vary between dogs with different activity levels. A Border Collie who spends her days herding livestock needs more protein in her diet than a Bulldog whose fastest pace is likely to be a leisurely amble.
Fats are essential to maintaining healthy hair and skin. They also help keep a dog’s body temperature stable and promote healthy digestion. And because they contain more calories than protein, fats are sources of energy. Of course, too much fat in a diet — particularly when coupled with a lack of exercise — leads to extra poundage on both pooches and people. Fats are in many foods and in supplements such as fatty acid capsules.
Vitamins and minerals enable the body to properly process proteins and fats (as well as carbohydrates; see the nearby sidebar for more on this topic). They also help sustain a dog’s immune system, maintain coat quality, and prevent disorders ranging from bone problems to behavioral difficulties.
Vitamins and minerals may be incorporated into a commercial food or dispensed as a supplement in the form of pills or caplets. To be fully effective, vitamins and minerals must be balanced properly. For example, calcium supplements aren’t fully effective unless they’re combined with magnesium.
Your dog food choices depend mainly on your dog: her preferences, her age, and her lifestyle. For example, you may go for a higher protein food if your canine companion is a growing puppy and/or is very active. Foods that are lower in protein content may be better for adult dogs, particularly if they spend most of their time being couch potatoes. And if your dog doesn’t like the brand you’re currently feeding her, trying another makes sense. No food, no matter how nutritious it is, will do your dog much good if she refuses to eat it.
In the following subsections, I discuss some of your feeding choices, including commercial, home-cooked, and raw foods.
Years ago, dogs ate whatever people didn’t feel like eating: table scraps, unwanted leftovers, and stuff otherwise destined for the garbage can. Many dogs also procured their own protein sources by killing animals such as barnyard rodents or rabbits who strayed into the fields where the dogs liked to roam. But just as life on the farm became a thing of the past for many people and their pooches, interest in breeding prize-winning dogs burgeoned. So at the same time that dogs could no longer scrounge up their own grub, their increasingly busy owners began demanding better fare than those table scraps, leftovers, and killed vermin for their canine companions.
Enter the livestock feed industry, which began to expand its market beyond cattle, hog, and poultry producers to also include dog owners. The industry developed different combinations of grains and meat products into dog foods that were convenient to buy and easy to prepare. As time passed and nutritional knowledge accumulated, the quality of some manufactured foods improved. This section discusses dry and canned commercial foods as well as some special diets.
Today’s dog owner has a huge variety of commercial foods from which to choose for her dog, but commercial dog foods are generally dry or canned. Table 4-1 shows how they compare.
TABLE 4-1 Comparing Dry and Canned Food
Category |
Dry Food (Kibble) |
Canned Food |
Spoilage time |
Can last for weeks if kept in an airtight container |
After you open the can, you have to keep it in the fridge and use it up within 7 days |
Dental effects |
Can keep your dog’s teeth clean |
May cling to teeth |
Nutritional value |
If properly formulated, can be a viable option; sometimes contains too many carbs and not nearly enough proteins from meat |
More likely to have higher content from meat and less from grain |
Cost |
Relatively inexpensive |
More expensive because of shipping costs |
Dog enjoyment |
Dogs don’t always enjoy total kibble diets and may find such regimens too dull |
The moisture and aroma are generally more pleasing to pooch palates than dry food |
Effects on poop |
Poop is compact, dry, and easy to clean up |
Poop is bigger and wetter than that of dogs who stick to kibble |
Pet food manufacturers have also come up with all kinds of other options for feeding your four-legged friends, including freeze-dried foods; semi-moist foods that come in tubes (and make great treats); and base-type foods that, when mixed with meat, provide a complete meal.
Although the same types of ingredients appear in virtually every commercial dog food, the amounts of each vary. Many of these variances are deliberate. Pet food manufacturers combine these ingredients in different ways to create foods designed to address a wide range of conditions and life stages. These special diets include the following:
Condition diets: Several pet food companies have developed a wide range of dog foods designed to aid in the treatment of a dizzying array of conditions. For example, one company has developed a food that’s been proven to help extend the lives of dogs who have cancer, and other companies are finding that high-carbohydrate, lower-protein diets may be a potent weapon in combating these dreaded diseases.
Meanwhile, several companies have developed product lines that aim to help pooches with food allergies. Such diets frequently eliminate corn, soybeans, or wheat from their foods, because some dogs are allergic to these ingredients. These foods may substitute lamb or chicken or really exotic proteins (would you believe bison or kangaroo?) for beef and also include novel carbohydrates such as potatoes or yams.
Other diets aim to aid in the treatment of conditions that range from accident recovery to weight management.
Giving your dog home-prepped foods may take more work, but you have more control over what goes into your dog’s diet. In this section, I discuss cooking meals for your dog and following the BARF diet, which is the cornerstone of the raw-foods movement.
Sooner or later, no matter how committed you are to giving your dog commercial food, you’re probably going to have to fix a doggie dinner yourself. A common reason to give your dog a homemade meal is that your four-legged friend has a bout of diarrhea (and diarrhea is pretty common among dogs, so this possibility is more than likely). Among the remedies your veterinarian probably will suggest is to put your dog on a bland diet. This regimen consists of gentle, easy-to-digest foods, such as ground beef and rice, that are guaranteed to soothe your pooch’s tender tummy and put him well along on the road to recovery.
If you decide to find out more about canine feeding options, you’ll probably come across the BARF diet. Rest assured that this food plan won’t induce bulimia in your dog or anyone else. BARF is an acronym for biologically appropriate raw food, and it’s just what it sounds like: a food plan in which you feed raw bones, raw meat, and fresh vegetables to your canine companion.
Dog owners who favor going raw contend the following:
Many breeders, dog show enthusiasts, and owners of performance dogs enthusiastically endorse the BARF diet, as do many veterinarians who practice alternative veterinary medicine.
Feeding a raw diet is not for every dog or for every owner. If the idea of handling raw food makes your stomach queasy, bag the idea of BARFing and don’t feel guilty about it. And if your dog has a compromised immune system or a lot of chronic illnesses, a BARF diet probably is not a good choice.
Before you make your decision about BARFing your dog, consult some expert sources. A fine book to start with is The Holistic Dog Book: Canine Care for the 21st Century, by Denise Flaim (Howell Book House).
The way you serve your dog can affect his digestion (and thus, what he produces) almost as much as what you serve him does. This section covers the where, when, and how of feeding your dog, plus it includes some dishing about dishes.
Choosing where to feed your dog depends mostly on what works for you. The most convenient canine dining room is one that’s located close to where you prepare meals, if not actually in the same place. In most households, that place is the kitchen, which has a couple of advantages:
You can also feed your dog in her crate — in fact, doing so can help your dog learn her basic bathroom manners more quickly. That’s because crate-based dining gives your four-legged friend another reason to like this makeshift doggie den. In addition, eating in the crate helps a pooch learn to refrain from pooping or peeing as soon she’s finished a meal. The reason, of course, is that she doesn’t want to soil her den. Many plastic crates include small dishes that you can attach to the inside doors.
What sort of dining atmosphere do you prefer? Do you like a noisy, hectic, Grand-Central-Station eating experience? Or do you prefer a quieter, more low-key dining environment? Do you like eating with a crowd? With one or two other people? Alone? Of course, those questions don’t have any one correct answer. Every response simply reflects the responder’s personal preference. And that’s exactly the point. You may have definite ideas about the ideal dining experience — and your dog may, too (see the nearby sidebar “Doggie dining preferences” for some examples).
I truly believe that decoding a dog’s dining desires can make for better bathroom behavior. A dog who’s happy with his dining environment will eat more regularly — and a dog who eats more regularly will probably eliminate more regularly than a dog who’s too distracted to attend to what’s in her dish. Any way you look at it, what goes in eventually comes out — but what doesn’t go in ultimately goes nowhere except to the garbage disposal.
No discussion of how to feed a dog is complete without a little dishing about dishes. They come in a wide range of sizes and shapes. Your best bet is to choose the one that best fits your dog’s size, age, and appetite:
Next, consider the material. Experts give a unanimous thumbs-up to stainless steel dishes because they’re easy to clean and can’t be demolished by a teething puppy.
Ceramic dishes are easy to clean and impervious to chewing. They also have the added advantage of weight, which keeps them from being knocked over.
Plastic dishes are convenient, cheap, and easy to clean but may cause some dogs to lose their nose pigment. In addition, plastic dishes aren’t as durable as stainless steel or ceramic.
By making Fido’s mealtimes predictable, you go a long way toward making his potty times equally predictable. You want your dog to do his bathroom business at regular, predictable intervals, which is why putting your canine housetrainee on a regular potty schedule — at least until Fido masters his bathroom basics — is a good idea. To be fully effective, that potty schedule needs to cover feeding times, because most pooches want to potty soon after they eat.
A generation ago, many people simply scooped a couple of piles of kibble into their dogs’ dishes and left those dishes out all day for Fido to feast on whenever his stomach growled. Some people still do that in a practice experts call free feeding.
Without a doubt, free feeding is a far more convenient way to give your dog his grub than remembering to feed Fido at the same times every day. However, free feeding carries three major disadvantages, at least two of which directly affect a dog’s bathroom behavior:
Frequent meals will help keep your dog in the best of health — especially if he’s a young puppy. A juvenile canine needs to eat more often than an adult dog does, but even an adult dog may need to dine more often than you may suspect. Here are some various feeding schedules:
The morning-and-evening regimen can also help prevent physical problems. Some, such as flatulence, usually aren’t serious. But one deadly condition, bloat, can result if a dog scarfs down a very large meal. Large dogs are more likely to be stricken with bloat (also known as gastric tortion) than smaller breeds are. For more on bloat, see Chapter 10.
Some people find that feeding Fido before they eat works well. They find that a dog with a full tummy is less likely to try scoring table scraps from the human family members while they eat.
Still others favor simultaneous dining: Letting the dog eat at the same time that his people do. One undeniable advantage to this option is that the dog is too busy eating her own food to worry about eating yours, at least for the first few minutes of your meal. However, the logistics of preparing human and canine cuisine at the same time can prove to be a challenge to people like me, whose multitasking ability is somewhat limited!
And some people suggest feeding your dog after the people in the house have their meals. They believe that making a dog wait for her meals underscores the fact that people outrank the pooches in the family pack. They also point out that among wolves observed in captivity, the alpha wolf generally eats before the rest of the pack does. Consequently, feed-the-dog-last advocates believe that alpha people should follow suit when feeding their canine pack members.
I don’t advocate any one of these three dining options over the others. The right answer varies with each dog and each family. I generally feed my dog, Allie, before the rest of my family eats — not because she begs for table goodies (we don’t permit such behavior in our house) but because the humans in our house tend to dine late. For that reason, I give my Golden girl her grub around 7:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m.
Dogs love to snack and eat treats just as much as people do — but the question of whether to give a pooch any treats in housetraining can be difficult to answer. Certainly, you can make a good case for using treats to train your dog. They’re a great learning incentive; I use them liberally when training my own dog and working with other people’s pooches. You can use a treat to actually lure a dog into sitting or lying down on command (see Figure 4-1). A treat makes a great reward for the dog who’s learning to come on command and can spark your dog’s learning process in countless other ways.
FIGURE 4-1: Treats can be a great teaching tool.
In this section, I name some treats that may be appropriate for your dog, including some low-calorie options.
People who decide to add treats to a dog’s diet find an incredible assortment of goodies to choose from. Regular supermarket aisles, pet boutique floor space, print catalog pages, and online pet store bandwidth are clogged with culinary offerings designed to please the most discriminating canine palate. Here are some of the more common types of commercial treats:
Biscuits and cookies: From the been-around-forever offerings of Del Monte’s Milk-Bones to the gourmet fare of Three Dog Bakery, biscuits and cookies jump-start the appetites of countless canines. The fact that most dogs love scarfing down biscuits and cookies gives these products a big advantage. Another is that their small sizes make them easy for dogs to chew and digest. In addition, their crunchy textures provide good chewing exercise for dogs and can even help clean a canine’s canines (as well as her other teeth).
The downside? Many biscuits and cookies are loaded with calories. In addition, some treats can upset the nutritional balance that commercial dog foods offer.
If you’re worried about upsetting the nutritional balance offered by your dog’s commercial food, try a treat that carries the same product name as the main food product. Science Diet (by Hills) and California Natural (by Innova) are just two product lines that include treats designed to dovetail with their regular dog foods.
Chew treats: Most dogs adore chomping on chew treats made of rawhide, pigs’ ears, cows’ hooves, and other animal parts.
Some dogs may adore chew treats a little too much. These chewing maniacs may gnaw off and swallow big chunks of such treats, and those chunks can cause internal injuries. For that reason, don’t feed chew treats unless you can directly supervise your dog. If she has a sensitive stomach, don’t offer them at all.
If you enjoy making treats for yourself and the other people in your household, you may also enjoy making treats for your canine family member. Homemade treats offer several advantages over commercial fare, the biggest being that you have much more control. When you make treats yourself, you know which ingredients (and how much of each) go into the treat — an important consideration if, for example, your canine companion suffers from food allergies. You can also control the size of the treat so that it’s just right for your particular dog.
Yes, you can give your dog treats without necessarily causing him to put on excess poundage. Here are some possibilities:
Fruits and vegetables: Many dogs adore raw or frozen fruits and vegetables, and because they’re so low in calories, they make a terrific treat for the plumper pooch. Good veggies to try are carrots, Brussels sprouts, broccoli, and green beans. For fruits, consider apples.
Make sure that you offer small pieces of veggies and fruits so your four-legged friend can digest those greens and yellows easily. And be aware that vegetables contain fiber, which acts as a laxative. If you give your pooch too many veggies, he’ll need to poop a lot more often.
Don’t feed your dog grapes, raisins, or onions. They contain compounds that are toxic to dogs in sufficient quantities. Besides, who wants a dog with onion breath?
Dogs need water for the same reasons that people do: to regulate their body temperature, to shuttle nutrients via the bloodstream from the digestive system to anywhere else the body needs them, and to transport waste products in the form of urine outside the body via urination. But although all dogs need water for the same reasons, the amount of water they need varies from pooch to pooch. Dogs who are very active and/or eat a lot of food — especially dry food — need to drink more water than more sedentary canines, those who eat less, and/or those whose diets include some canned or moist fare.
Healthy, housetrained dogs can regulate their water intake all by themselves. They drink when they’re thirsty and don’t drink when they’re not. Meeting the water needs of these dogs is simple: Keep water available at all times.
That said, 24/7 access to water can pose a problem for the canine housetrainee. To anticipate when your dog may need to let some water out — in other words, to pee — you need to have some idea of when he took that water in. The best way to acquire that knowledge is to control his access to the water bowl. Make no mistake: The dog who’s just learning basic bathroom manners needs frequent opportunities to drink. But you need to know when he takes advantage of those opportunities — and the best way to gain that knowledge is to give him a full dish of clean water several times a day — at the very least, at the same time as every meal — at the same times each and every day.